SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA
(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction: Application)
In the Estate of BENJAMIN (DECEASED)
[2016] SASC 84
Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley
9 June 2016
SUCCESSION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - JURISDICTION AND DISCRETION OF COURT - SOUTH AUSTRALIA
SUCCESSION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - ALTERATION AND REVOCATION OF GRANTS - CIRCUMSTANCES
SUCCESSION - PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - GRANTS OF PROBATE AND LETTERS OF ADMINISTRATION - GRANTS OF ADMINISTRATION GENERALLY - PUBLIC TRUSTEES AND CURATORS
Laurence Gwynfryn Benjamin (the deceased) died on 27 August 2015. He was survived by his sons Leigh Benjamin and Grant Benjamin. He had made a will dated 17 September 2013. On 17 November 2015 a grant of probate was made in favour of James Cavalier Douglas and Shona Hoskins, the executors and trustees appointed by the deceased in his will. The executors were the deceased’s solicitors. They are the plaintiffs on this application.
The deceased’s will left one half of his estate to his son Leigh Benjamin and gave a life interest in the other half, to be held on trust, for his son Grant Benjamin. The executors and trustees appointed by the deceased are required by the terms of his will, in their absolute discretion, to apply the income and capital of that half of the estate for the general maintenance, comfort or wellbeing of Grant Benjamin. The remainder interest is to vest in Leigh Benjamin in the event he survives his brother.
The plaintiffs apply to the court for a revocation of the grant of probate made on 17 November 2015. They do so on the basis that they have encountered difficulties in administering the estate due to the behaviour of Grant Benjamin.
Mr Leigh Benjamin supports the plaintiffs’ application for a revocation of the grant of probate.
Held:
1. Circumstances in which a grant of probate may be revoked is a matter for the discretion of the court to be exercised where the court is satisfied that there is a good or convenient reason to do so. In the exercise of that discretion the court must consider all the circumstances of the particular case. In exercising the discretion the court must look to the interests of the beneficiaries under the will or on an intestacy (at [14]).
2. The grant of probate of the will of the late Laurence Gwynfryn Benjamin late of 18 Margaret Avenue, Somerton Park in the State of South Australia, deceased, bearing date 17 September 2013 which was granted by this Honourable Court to Shona Hoskins and James Cavalier Douglas on 17 November 2015 be declared and the same being null and void for all intents and purposes in law, and that probate of the will of the deceased be revoked (at [25]).
3. Administration of the estate of the late Laurence Gwynfryn Benjamin late of 18 Margaret Avenue, Somerton Park in the State of South Australia, deceased, be granted to the Public Trustee pursuant to s 9 of the
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In the Estate of BENJAMIN (DECEASED) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] SASC 84
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the Public Trustee should be appointed as the administrator of the estate. The judge concluded that Leigh Benjamin, one of the beneficiaries, was not suitable for the role due to potential conflicts of interest and familial disputes. The terms of the will, which granted a life interest to Grant Benjamin and a remainder interest to Leigh Benjamin, further complicated the situation. The judge emphasised that this decision was not a reflection on Leigh Benjamin's character but a necessary measure to ensure the proper administration of the estate and protect the interests of all beneficiaries.
The court ordered the revocation of the earlier grant of probate to Shona Hoskins and James Cavalier Douglas and appointed the Public Trustee as the administrator of the estate. The decision was based on the provisions of the Public Trustee Act 1995 (SA), which allows the court to revoke a grant of probate and appoint the Public Trustee under certain conditions, including when a person desires to retire from the office of executor or administrator. The court also noted that the revocation would not prejudice any proceedings taken or acts done under the original grant.
The final orders included the revocation of the earlier grant of probate and the appointment of the Public Trustee as the administrator of the estate. The court reserved the matter for further hearing regarding the costs of the application.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
I am prepared to relieve them of their office because I am satisfied that the due administration of the estate will not be impaired by a revocation of the grant in circumstances where I propose to appoint the Public Trustee as administrator pursuant to the provisions of s 9 of the Public Trustee Act. Section 9 provides:9—Administration of deceased estate(1) The Court may make an order (an administration order) granting administration of the estate of a deceased person to the Public Trustee, or authorising the Public Trustee to administer the estate of a deceased person—(a) if, in the opinion of the Court—(i) the deceased has died bankrupt or insolvent; or(ii) a creditor would be entitled to obtain administration of the estate or to institute an action for the administration of the estate, (and if, in such a case, probate or administration has been granted to a person other than the Public Trustee, the Court may revoke the probate or administration without prejudice to any proceedings taken or act done under it); or(b) if the deceased has died wholly or partially intestate, leaving property within this State, but not leaving a spouse, domestic partner or next of kin resident in the State who is of or above 18 years of age; or(c) if—(i) the deceased has made a will without leaving an executor resident in this State willing to act and capable of acting in the execution of the will; and(ii) there is no person of or above 18 years of age in this State entitled to obtain administration with the will annexed; or(d) if the deceased has made a will and appointed an executor but probate of the will has not been obtained within four months from the death of the deceased; or(e) if no person entitled to obtain administration (with or without a will annexed) obtains it within three months after the death of the deceased; or(f) if probate or administration has been granted to a person who desires to retire from the office of executor or administrator (and, in such a case, the Court may revoke the probate or administration without prejudice to any proceedings taken or act done under it); or(g) if—(i) the estate or portion of it is liable to waste, of a perishable nature or in danger of being lost or destroyed, or great loss or expense may be incurred by reason of delay; and(ii) the executor, person entitled to administration (with the will annexed), spouse, domestic partner or next of kin—(A) is absent from the locality of the estate; or(B) is not known; or(C) has not been found; or(D) is unfit or incapable; or(h) if an executor, or person entitled to administration, requests the Public Trustee, in writing, to apply for an order under this section; or(i) if part of an estate, already partly administered, is unadministered owing to the death, incapacity, insolvency, disappearance or absence from the State of the executor or administrator.(2) If it appears to the Court—(a) that there is reasonable ground to suppose that a person has died leaving property within this State; and(b) that the person died intestate or without a will duly proved within a reasonable time after death, the Court may, without requiring strict proof of death, make an administration order authorising the Public Trustee to administer the person's estate for the benefit of the person's creditors and for the discharge of the person's liabilities as if the person were dead.(3) An application for an administration order may be made by—(a) the Public Trustee; or(b) a person interested in the estate (including a creditor); or(c) a guardian or blood relation of a person under 18 years of age interested in the estate.(4) An administration order may be obtained either without notice or after notice has been given as directed by the Court.(5) The Court may revoke an administration order and order—(a) that probate be granted to an executor entitled to probate of the will of the deceased, or that letters of administration with the will annexed be granted to any person entitled to them;(b) that property from a deceased person's estate vested in or under the control of the Public Trustee be transferred or delivered to a person or persons entitled to it, whether in trust or beneficially.(6) Revocation of an administration order is without prejudice to any proceedings taken or act done under it.(7) An administration order of a kind referred to in subsection (2) may not be revoked unless the Court is satisfied that special circumstances of the case and lapse of time since the making of the order justify the revocation.(8) If an order is made authorising the Public Trustee to administer the estate of a deceased person, the Public Trustee will be taken to be the administrator of the estate for the purposes of any other Act but subject to the provisions of the other Act.