IN THE ESTATE OF BADGER (DECEASED)

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction)

IN THE ESTATE OF BADGER (DECEASED)

[2021] SASC 25

Judgment of the Honourable Justice Bampton  

12 March 2021

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPLICATIONS TO COURT FOR ADVICE AND AUTHORITY

SUCCESSION - ADMINISTRATION OF ESTATE - OTHER MATTERS

Application for advice or directions regarding the proper construction of a will and distribution of the deceased’s estate – where will appointed a sole executor and trustee and by clause 1 gave the whole of the deceased’s estate to the executor to “distribute the same as he shall know to be in accordance with my wishes” – executor died one month after the deceased without having obtained probate – the executor is survived by his widow who is executor of his will and sole beneficiary of his estate – the widow did not obtain a grant of probate in her husband’s estate and did not apply for a grant in the deceased’s estate – the Public Trustee obtained a grant of letters of administration with the will annexed in the deceased’s estate – whether the deceased’s estate was given to the executor beneficially or merely as trustee – if given to the executor as trustee, was the trust a fully secret or half secret trust – if given to the executor as trustee, are the identities of the beneficial objects able to be identified – if the beneficial objects are identified as being the subject of wishes rather than specific gifts, how should the estate be distributed – where the widow of the executor makes application for joinder to make submissions on the Public Trustee’s application for advice or directions.

HELD:  The application for joinder is dismissed as the executor’s widow has no interest in the estate – on the proper construction of the will, the deceased gave her estate to the executor as trustee of a half secret trust – the beneficial objects of the trust are identified as the subjects of wishes contained in a letter of expression of wishes – the Public Trustee is advised and directed that she would be justified in distributing the deceased’s estate as proposed in the originating application.

Administration and Probate Act 1919 (SA) s 69; Public Trustee Act 1995 (SA) s 9(1)(h), referred to.

King & Ors v Perpetual Trustee Company Ltd & Ors (1955) 94 CLR 70; Marley v Rawlings [2014] 2 WLR 213; Ledgerwood v Perpetual Trustee Co Ltd (1997) 41 NSWLR 540; Gregory v Hudson (1997) 41 NSWLR 573, applied.

In re Pugh’s Will Trusts; Marten v Pugh & Anor [1967] 1 WLR 1262, discussed.

IN THE ESTATE OF BADGER (DECEASED)
[2021] SASC 25

Testamentary Causes Jurisdiction

  1. BAMPTON J: Lady Edith Maud Badger OAM (“Edith”) died at the age of 100, a widow with no children or grandchildren, on 24 November 2016.  She left a will dated 16 July 2012 (“the 2012 will”) which appoints “my friend Richard Burke” her sole executor and trustee and by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IN THE ESTATE OF BADGER (DECEASED) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] SASC 25
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of the Estate of Badger (Deceased) involves Edith Badger, who passed away, and her estate, which is the subject of a dispute. The primary parties in this case are the Public Trustee, the executor, and Mrs. Burke, who is the widow of the deceased executor. The dispute centers around the interpretation of Edith’s 2012 will and the subsequent administration of her estate. The court was tasked with determining whether the estate should be distributed according to the terms of the will, which suggests a half secret trust, or whether it should follow a different course as proposed by the Public Trustee. This case was heard and decided by the court, which issued its decision on February 25, 2021.

The legal issues that the court had to address included the proper interpretation of the 2012 will, specifically clause 1, and whether it established a half secret trust. The court also had to decide if Mrs. Burke, as the widow of the deceased executor, had any interest in the estate and whether she was entitled to join the proceedings. Furthermore, the court needed to determine the identity of the beneficial objects of the trust as outlined in Edith’s letter of expression of wishes dated August 15, 2008, and whether the Public Trustee should be directed to distribute the estate as proposed in the originating application.

In its decision, the court found that the 2012 will did indeed establish a half secret trust, as it disclosed the existence of the trust but not the identities of the beneficiaries. The court dismissed Mrs. Burke’s application for joinder, concluding that she had no interest in the estate or the Public Trustee’s application. The court also determined that the beneficial objects of the trust were identified as the subjects of wishes contained in Edith’s letter of expression of wishes. Consequently, the court advised and directed the Public Trustee that she would be justified in distributing the deceased’s estate as proposed in the originating application. The court’s decision was based on the proper construction of the will and the lack of any interest held by Mrs. Burke in the estate.

The final orders of the court were that the application for joinder by Mrs. Burke was dismissed. The court found that the deceased had given her estate to the executor as trustee of a half secret trust, and the beneficial objects of the trust were identified in Edith’s letter of expression of wishes. The court further directed the Public Trustee to proceed with the distribution of the estate as proposed in the originating application. This decision ensured that the estate would be administered according to the terms of the will, with the court’s guidance on the interpretation and execution of the half secret trust.

Orders

Orders of the court

HELD: The application for joinder is dismissed as the executor’s widow has no interest in the estate – on the proper construction of the will, the deceased gave her estate to the executor as trustee of a half secret trust – the beneficial objects of the trust are identified as the subjects of wishes contained in a letter of expression of wishes – the Public Trustee is advised and directed that she would be justified in distributing the deceased’s estate as proposed in the originating application.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Mr Jappe’s affidavits affirmed 8 February 2021 and 10 February 2021 were filed in response to Mrs Burke’s application for joinder.My ex tempore decision Following the hearing regarding Mrs Burke’s application for joinder on 25 February 2021, I recorded my decision that, on the proper construction of the 2012 will, Edith’s estate was given to Mr Burke legally as trustee of a half secret trust. I also recorded that clause 1 of the 2012 will creates a half secret trust as it discloses the existence of the trust but not the identities of the beneficial objects. I dismissed Mrs Burke’s application finding she had no interest in the proper construction of the 2012 will or the Public Trustee’s application. These are my reasons and my reasons for determining that the beneficial objects of the half secret trust are identified as the subjects of wishes contained in a letter of expression of wishes (“LOEW”) executed by Edith on 15 August 2008.Edith’s testamentary documents and the deed packet held by Finlaysons By way of background I will set out, by reference to the documents obtained from Finlaysons and exhibited to Mr Jappe’s affidavits, Edith’s association with Mr Burke. Having regard to documents obtained from Finlaysons exhibited to Mr Jappe’s affidavit affirmed 23 July 2020, it is clear Edith had a long history of will-making with Finlaysons and Mr Burke. It appears Mr Burke managed Edith’s personal trust account which included managing her money market account, her gifting programme, paying accounts, and providing and arranging “comforts”. On 11 July 2012, a Finlaysons internal memorandum requested the deposit of the following documents into an existing deed packet number SC000352 for Finlaysons’ client name “Badger, Edith Maud”:[8](1)Will of Edith Maud Badger dated 24 November 2005, appointing Steven Alexander Tarca (“Mr Tarca”) and Mr Burke executors.(2)An Enduring Power of Attorney of Edith Maud Badger dated 17 May 2001, appointing Mr Tarca and Mr Burke donees.(3)A Letter of Expression of Wishes of Lady Edith Maud Badger dated 15 August 2008.[9][8] The deed packet is also referred to by Mr Burke in a letter dated 11 July 2012 as “safe custody packet number 000352”. Mr Tarca refers in a letter dated 11 October 2018 to documents executed by Edith being placed in Finlaysons’ “deed safe”. [9] Exhibit MPJ4 to the affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe affirmed 23 July 2020 at p 44. By letter dated 11 July 2012, Mr Burke, “Manager – Private Client Services” with Finlaysons,[10] wrote to Edith on Finlaysons letterhead enclosing “as requested, your safe custody packet number 000352”. Mr Burke asked Edith to “acknowledge receipt of your packet by signing the enclosed Security Acknowledgement Advice...”. The letter bears a stamp with the words “Posted/Delivered” with the initials “RDB” next to the word “By” and “16/7/12” next to the word “Date”.[11][10] Mr Burke described himself as Manager – Private Client Services and Consultant Private Services in correspondence and Estates Manager in the 2012 will. Mrs Burke deposed in her affidavit affirmed on 11 December 2020 that Mr Burke was employed by Finlaysons as a Manager of Wills and Estates. [11] Exhibit MPJ4 to the affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe affirmed 23 July 2020 at p 44.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Jappe concluded his affidavit saying he did not know who made the transfers from Edith’s accounts, that the accounts ending in 8705 and 6690 appearing in the bank statements are not accounts belonging to Edith, and he did not otherwise know the identity of the owner of those accounts. The administration of Edith’s estate Following Edith’s death, it appears Mr Burke sent an email to Finlaysons on 24 November 2016 asking that a file be opened.[25] He stated that he was the client and the matter was a probate application in Edith’s estate. As stated above, Mr Burke died before obtaining probate in Edith’s estate. [25] Exhibit TA3 to the affidavit of Thomas Lewis Abbott sworn 19 February 2021. It is asserted in a letter from Mr Tarca to the Public Trustee dated 1 March 2017 that Mrs Burke had:[26]… advised Finalysons that she does not wish to seek a grant of probate in Lady Edith’s estate in favour of herself as executor once she has obtained a grant of probate in her husband’s Richard Burke’s estate. … We seek the agreement of the Public Trustee to accept and undertake the role of executor of Lady Edith’s estate in place of the deceased executor appointed under Lady Edith’s will, namely Richard Burke.[26] Exhibit MPJ8 to the affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe affirmed 8 February 2021. Thereafter, according to the Public Trustee’s records, Mrs Burke requested the Public Trustee to make application for an order pursuant to s 9(1)(h) of the Public Trustee Act1995 (SA) in respect of Edith’s estate on 28 June 2017. Section 9(1)(h) of the Public Trustee Act1995 (SA), provides that the Court may make an administration order “if an executor or person entitled to administration requests the Public Trustee to apply for an order under this section”. Upon making application, the Public Trustee was informed by the Registrar of Probates that the affidavit in support of the application for an administration order must recite the fact and date of the grant of probate in Mr Burke’s estate to Mrs Burke.[27] However, Mrs Burke had not obtained a grant of probate in her husband’s estate. I note the only asset in the affidavit of assets and liabilities in respect of Mr Burke’s estate is Edith’s estate. In a letter to the Registrar of Probates, the Public Trustee stated that all Mr Burke’s other assets were held in joint names.[28] Again, according to the Public Trustee’s records, Mrs Burke on 8 January 2018 requested the Public Trustee pursuant to s 9(1)(h) to make application for an administration order in respect of Mr Burke’s estate. [27] Exhibit TA10 to the affidavit of Thomas Lewis Abbott sworn 19 February 2021.[28] Exhibit TA23 to the affidavit of Thomas Lewis Abbott sworn 19 February 2021. The Public Trustee obtained a grant of letters of administration with the will annexed in Mr Burke’s estate on 7 June 2018 and a grant of letters of administration with the will annexed in Edith’s estate on 9 August 2018. In a letter to Mr Paterson of the Public Trustee dated 11 October 2018,[29] Mr Tarca stated that in Finlaysons’ view the wording of clause 1 of the 2012 will required the location of evidence of Edith’s wishes, or the directions of the Court in relation to the meaning of the words, prior to any decision and action in relation to distribution. Mr Tarca stated that Finlaysons had not been provided with any information or evidence nor found anything to indicate Edith’s wishes as referred to in the 2012 will. [29] Exhibit MJP9 to the affidavit of Mark Peter Jappe affirmed 10 February 2021.