Serial No 17/1992
List “A”
CITATION: In re the Will of W A G Luck [1992] TASSC 71; A17/1992
PARTIES: IN RE THE WILL OF W A G LUCK
COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
FILE NO/S: M45/1991
DELIVERED ON: 15 April 1992
JUDGMENT OF: Wright J
Judgment Number: A17/1992
Number of paragraphs: 48
Serial No 17/1992
List "A"
File No M45/1991
IN RE THE WILL OF W A G LUCK
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT WRIGHT J
15 April 1992
By his will dated 15th March 1990 William Archibald Geddes Luck left the whole of his real estate and the residue of his personal estate to Thomas G Chaplin upon trust, after conversion thereof into money and payment of debts expenses and duties "for 20th Thaxted Pty Ltd, as Trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust."
Mr W A G Luck died on 15 August 1990. His executor and trustee Mr T G Chaplin has filed an originating application seeking answers to the following questions:
"1Whether upon the true construction of the said will of the Testator and in the events which have happened:
(a)The trust in respect of the residue of the estate referred to in Clause 3 of the said will is a valid and complete trust,
(b)If the answer to question (a) is yes, whether the said residue is to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty. Ltd. as trustee of the G.A.W. Luck Family Trust: –
(i)upon the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement relating to the G.A.W. Luck Family Trust dated the 2nd day of March 1990, or
(ii) upon any other, and if so what, trust or trusts,
(c)If the answer to question (a) is no, whether there is a partial intestacy in respect of the said residue."
Several affidavits were filed on behalf of the applicant.
The respondents, Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd, Maxwell Arthur Luck, the surviving son of the testator and Jason Anthony Luck and Cassandra Joy Luck, the children of Anthony Geddes Luck deceased who was the other son of the testator and who predeceased him, did not file affidavits.
Objection has been taken by the third and fourth named respondents to substantial portions of each of the applicants afffidavits but for the purposes of the argument before me I was invited to admit the evidence objected to de bene esse and to rule upon its admissibility before resolving the questions raised in the originating application.
I will rule upon those objections now.
(a) As to the affidavit of Thomas Geoffrey Chaplin.
Paragraph 9
Mr Chaplin exhibits a copy of the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990 "relating to the trusts known as the GAW Luck Family Trust". Mr Chaplin did not prepare or witness the execution of this document which was supplied to him by a firm of Victorian solicitors. It is objected that the document cannot be incorporated into the will of the deceased testator so as to amplify or explain his dispositions as it was not identified by him…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In Re the Will of W a G Luck and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1992] TASSC 71
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered several affidavits and objections, primarily focusing on the admissibility of evidence regarding the testator's intent and the relevance of a Deed of Settlement. The court admitted evidence showing that the testator and his son had discussed establishing a family trust and that the testator was aware of its basic structure. The court held that the testator's reference to the GAW Luck Family Trust in the will sufficiently identified the trusts under which the residue was to be held, allowing reference to the Deed of Settlement to understand the trust's terms.
The court concluded that the trust in the will was valid and complete, and that the residue was to be held under the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement of 2 March 1990. The court found that Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd was clearly identified as the trustee and that the beneficiaries were identifiable as per the Deed of Settlement. The court's decision affirmed the validity of the trust and the terms under which the estate's residue was to be held.
Background
Background to the litigation
The testator's son, Maxwell Arthur Luck, began experiencing financial difficulties in 1989, which continued until the testator made his will. In February 1990, Maxwell discussed his financial problems and his father's will with the testator. They deliberated on forming a family trust and appointing a company as the trustee. Maxwell arranged for this through his Victorian solicitor, Lindsay George Tipping. On March 2, 1990, Maxwell informed his father that the trust and company had been established. The Deed of Settlement, dated March 2, 1990, created the GAW Luck Family Trust with Mr Peter Tyler, a solicitor and Mr Tipping’s partner, as the settlor. Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd was the trustee of the settlement. The trust fund was defined as a nominal amount of $20.00 and all money, investments, and property transferred to or accepted by the trustees. A new will was prepared by Ray Bailey, a Launceston solicitor, and executed by the testator on March 15, 1990.
Several affidavits were filed, including those from Thomas G Chaplin, Ray Bailey, Lindsay George Tipping, and Maxwell Arthur Luck. Objections were raised to various parts of these affidavits on grounds of relevance, hearsay, and inadmissible opinion. After reviewing the objections, Wright J admitted certain portions of the affidavits while excluding others. The admissible evidence established that the testator and his son had discussed the family trust and the testator was aware of its basic structure. The will referred to the GAW Luck Family Trust, and by referring to the beneficial object of his bounty, the testator identified the trust. The court held that the testator had a manifest intention to impress his residuary estate with a trust, the trustee had been sufficiently identified as Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd, and the intended beneficiaries were identifiable through the Deed of Settlement.
The matter came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania in the form of an originating application seeking answers to questions regarding the true construction of the will of the deceased, William Archibald Geddes Luck. The executor and trustee, Mr Thomas Geoffrey Chaplin, filed the application to clarify the disposition of the residue of the estate as outlined in the will dated 15 March 1990. The questions posed in the application sought to determine whether the trust in respect of the residue of the estate was valid and complete, and if so, the terms upon which it was to be held. Several affidavits were filed in support of the application by the applicant, while the respondents, including Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd and the surviving and deceased sons of the testator, did not file affidavits. Objections were raised by the third and fourth named respondents to substantial portions of the applicant's affidavits, which were subsequently considered by Wright J. The court admitted certain evidence de bene esse and ruled on its admissibility before addressing the substantive questions raised in the originating application. The case involved the interpretation of the will and the identification of the intended trusts and beneficiaries, drawing on relevant prior decisions and legal principles.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the trust in respect of the residue of the estate referred to in Clause 3 of the will is a valid and complete trust.
2. If the trust is valid and complete, whether the residue is to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust:
(a) upon the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement relating to the GAW Luck Family Trust dated 2 March 1990, or
(b) upon any other trusts, and if so, what those trusts are.
3. If the trust is not valid and complete, whether there is a partial intestacy in respect of the said residue.
4. Whether the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990 can be referred to in the will to give effect to the trusts intended by the testator.
5. Whether the intended beneficiaries of the trust are identifiable.
Held
1. Whether the trust in respect of the residue of the estate referred to in Clause 3 of the will is a valid and complete trust.
The court concluded that the trust is valid and complete.
2. If the trust is valid and complete, whether the residue is to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust:
(a) upon the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement relating to the GAW Luck Family Trust dated 2 March 1990, or
(b) upon any other trusts, and if so, what those trusts are.
The court concluded that the residue is to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd upon the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990.
3. If the trust is not valid and complete, whether there is a partial intestacy in respect of the said residue.
This issue was found unnecessary to answer as the court determined the trust to be valid and complete.
4. Whether the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990 can be referred to in the will to give effect to the trusts intended by the testator.
The court concluded that the Deed of Settlement can be referred to in the will to give effect to the trusts intended by the testator.
5. Whether the intended beneficiaries of the trust are identifiable.
The court concluded that the intended beneficiaries of the trust are identifiable.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court was required to determine whether the trust in respect of the residue of William Archibald Geddes Luck's estate, as mentioned in Clause 3 of his will, was valid and complete. The court held that the trust was valid and complete, establishing that the residue of the estate was intended to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust. The court reasoned that the will clearly identified the trust and the trustee, and the intended beneficiaries could be identified through the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990.
The court applied the legal principle that for a testamentary disposition to be valid and complete, the trust and the trustee must be sufficiently identified. The will explicitly named Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as the trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust, and the Deed of Settlement provided details about the trust's structure and beneficiaries. The court held that the testator's intention to establish a trust with Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as trustee was manifest and clear. This aligns with the principle established in cases like Tatham v Huxtable, where the court emphasized the necessity for a definite criterion for ascertaining beneficiaries.
Furthermore, the court determined that the residue of the estate was to be held upon the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990. The Deed of Settlement outlined the trusts and beneficiaries, making it clear that the residue of the estate was to form part of the trust fund and be administered according to the Deed for the same beneficiaries designated therein. This interpretation was supported by the testator's discussions with his son and his solicitor regarding the establishment of the family trust.
The court also addressed whether the Deed of Settlement could be referred to in the will to give effect to the trusts intended by the testator. The court ruled that by referring to the GAW Luck Family Trust in the will, the testator effectively identified the Deed of Settlement, allowing it to be considered in understanding the intended disposition. This interpretation was supported by the reasoning in Re Edward's Will Trusts, where it was held that the testator's clear intention and direction to refer to a specific document rendered it permissible to identify and consider that document.
In conclusion, the court established that the trust in respect of the residue of the estate was valid and complete, and the residue was to be held by Twentieth Thaxted Pty Ltd as trustee of the GAW Luck Family Trust under the trusts created by the Deed of Settlement dated 2 March 1990. This decision reinforces the principle that a testator's intent to establish a trust can be sufficiently clear even if not perfectly articulated in the will, provided it is supported by external documents and the context of the testator's actions and discussions.