New South Wales
Medical Tribunal
CITATION: In Re Dr Jonathan Bentley and the Medical Practice Act 1992 [2005] NSWMT 10 TRIBUNAL: Medical Tribunal PARTIES: FILE NUMBER(S): 40015 of 2003 CORAM: Graham, DCJ - Spark, Dr R - Houen, Ms J CATCHWORDS: LEGISLATION CITED: Medical Practice Act 1992
(Commonwealth) Health Insurance Act 1973CASES CITED: Health Care Complaints Commission v Litchfield (1997) 41 NSWLR 630;
Richter v Walton, Court of Appeal (15 Sept 1993);
Health Care Complaints Commission v Abou Hatoum and another [2004] NSWCA 30;
Zaidi v Health Care Complaints Commission (1998) 44 NSWLR 82;
Ohn v Walton Court of Appeal (28 Feb 1995)DATES OF HEARING: DATE OF JUDGMENT: 26 May 2005 ORDERS: 1. (a) A declaration that order 2 made by the tribunal on 21 June 1996, that is, an order relating to psychiatric treatment, is no longer appropriate.; (b) An order revoking that order.; 2. An order deleting all remaining conditions to which the practitioner is subject.; 3. No order as to the costs of either the applicant or the respondent.
JUDGMENT:
40001/5
MEDICAL TRIBUNAL OF NEW SOUTH WALES
DEPUTY CHAIRPERSON: JUDGE GRAHAM
MEMBERS: DR J KENDRICK
- DR R SPARK
MS J HOUEN
THURSDAY 26 MAY 2005
IN RE DR JONATHAN BENTLEY AND THE MEDICAL PRACTICE ACT
JUDGMENT
1 This is an application for relief Under section 92 of the Medical Practice Act 1992. The application relates to an order and what remains of two of the conditions imposed upon the applicant at the conclusion of a hearing in the medical tribunal on 21 June 1996, in relation to a number of matters of complaint, then before the tribunal.
ORDER 2
2. The application, in the first instance, relates to order 2 made on that occasion.
3 . Having made findings of both professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct in relation to different aspects of the complaints, the tribunal suspended the practitioner for a period of six months commencing on 1 July 1996.
4. That was an order which the tribunal was empowered to make under section 64(1)(b). In reaching that conclusion, the tribunal took into account not only the professional misconduct which it then found, but also, the unsatisfactory professional conduct. The latter would not, of itself, have enlivened the power under section 64 subsection (1).
5. The second order was in these terms:
"We direct that the respondent promptly seek and accept treatment at his own expense, from a psychiatrist approved by the Medical Board of New South Wales, such psychiatrist to report forthwith to the board, any adverse finding regarding the respondent."
Although couched as a direction, it is clear that the intention of the tribunal was not to treat that direction as constituting a condition under section 61(1)(c). Rather, it should be treated as having been intended to constitute an order,
"that the person seek and undergo medical or psychiatric treatment or counselling",
pursuant to section 61 subsection (1) paragraph (b).
6. The next order set out in the findings…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read In Re Dr Jonathan Bentley and the Medical Practice Act 1992 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2005] NSWMT 10
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the court was whether the 1996 order concerning psychiatric treatment remained appropriate in light of the circumstances and evidence presented. This included examining the medical and professional conduct of Dr Bentley since the order was made, as well as the evolving standards and expectations within the medical profession regarding such conditions. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the remaining conditions placed on Dr Bentley's practice were still necessary or had served their purpose.
The court found that the psychiatric treatment order was no longer appropriate, given the significant changes in Dr Bentley's practice and the evidence of his professional conduct since the order was made. The court acknowledged that while the initial order was made in the interest of public protection and professional standards, the circumstances had evolved to the point where the order was no longer necessary. The court also concluded that the remaining conditions on Dr Bentley's practice were no longer required. Consequently, the court issued a declaration that the psychiatric treatment order was no longer appropriate and revoked it. Furthermore, the court ordered the deletion of all remaining conditions imposed on Dr Bentley's practice. The court declined to make any order regarding the costs of either party.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. (a) A declaration that order 2 made by the tribunal on 21 June 1996, that is, an order relating to psychiatric treatment, is no longer appropriate.; (b) An order revoking that order.; 2. An order deleting all remaining conditions to which the practitioner is subject.; 3. No order as to the costs of either the applicant or the respondent.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi