IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

IML P/L & ORS v INTERNATIONAL VINEYARDS P/L & ORS

Judgment of Judge Burley a Master of the Supreme Court

13 October 2005

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PRACTICE UNDER RULES OF COURT - DEFAULT OF PLEADING

Application by plaintiffs for judgment in default of defence against two defendants, in the case of one defendant pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 59.06(1)(b) on basis that defence struck out for failure to give adequate discovery, and judgment in default of filing a notice of address for service against three other defendants - orders made for hearing of the application in open Court by a Master pursuant to SCR 75.19 and 75.01(1)(b) - no requirement to serve application - plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief only - hearing ex parte - dispute arose out of operation of a joint venture established to develop and manage vineyards - property of joint venture included contracts to supply grapes to several major wine producers - one defendant, either personally or through companies under his control, challenged authority of participants in the joint venture and interfered with the operation of the joint venture through its corporate structure - declarations sought related to questions about identity of participants in joint venture, manner in which property of joint venture held, identity of shareholders, directors and secretaries of companies involved with joint venture, validity of certain purported general meetings of members and general meetings of directors of those companies, and whether certain agreements entered into void - injunctive relief sought to restrain defendants from dealing with assets of joint venture, including drawing cheques on bank account of company trustee of joint venture assets, purporting to act as manager of the joint venture, purporting to terminate existing management agreement, carrying on business of the joint venture or acting in respect of any such business other than on written instructions of Vintners, and in case of one defendant, holding himself out as director of certain companies - declaratory and injunctive relief granted.

Supreme Court Rules 1987 (SA) r 59.06, r 75.01, r 75.19, r 23; Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s 60; Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ., referred to.
Stewart Chartering Ltd v S & O Management [1980] 1 All ER 718; Trossman v Trossman (1960) 80 Am LR (2d) 933; The Russian Commercial and Industrial Bank v British Bank for Foreign Trade [1921] 1 AC 438, applied.
Austin v Wildig [1969] 1 All ER 99, considered.

IML P/L & ORS v INTERNATIONAL VINEYARDS P/L & ORS
[2005] SASC 396

  1. JUDGE BURLEY:            The plaintiffs seek judgment in default of defence against the defendants, International Vineyards Pty Ltd (“Vineyards”) and Andrew Morton Garrett (“Garrett”) and judgment in default of filing a notice of address for service against the defendants Averil Gay Garrett (“Mrs Garrett”), Garrett International Investments Pty Ltd (“GII”) and Evajade Pty Ltd (“Evajade”).  The hearing of the application for judgment was ordered to be listed in open Court pursuant to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] SASC 396
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiffs, IML P/L, applied for judgment in default of defence against two defendants, International Vineyards P/L and others, following a dispute arising from the operation of a joint venture established to develop and manage vineyards. The dispute involved issues concerning the authority of participants in the joint venture, interference with its operation, and the validity of certain agreements. The plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief, including declarations regarding the identity of participants in the joint venture, the manner in which property was held, and the validity of certain agreements. They also sought injunctive relief to restrain the defendants from dealing with assets of the joint venture.

The court was required to determine whether the plaintiffs were entitled to the relief sought, including declarations and injunctions, in light of the defendants' failure to plead or provide adequate discovery. The primary issue was whether the defendants' conduct justified the grant of the relief sought by the plaintiffs. The court also needed to address the procedural aspects of the application, including the appropriate method for hearing the application and whether the application could proceed ex parte.

The court granted the plaintiffs' application for judgment in default of defence and provided detailed declarations and injunctive relief as sought. The court found that the defendants had failed to provide adequate discovery, justifying the grant of judgment in default. The court also held that the plaintiffs were entitled to the relief sought, including declarations regarding the nature of the joint venture's property and the invalidity of certain agreements. The court issued comprehensive orders to protect the plaintiffs' interests, including restraining the defendants from dealing with the joint venture's assets and interfering with its operation.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L involves a legal dispute arising from the operation of a joint venture established to develop and manage vineyards. The property of the joint venture includes contracts to supply grapes to several major wine producers. One defendant, either personally or through companies under his control, challenged the authority of the participants in the joint venture and interfered with the operation of the joint venture through its corporate structure. The plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief, including declarations about the identity of participants in the joint venture, the manner in which the property of the joint venture is held, the identity of shareholders, directors, and secretaries of companies involved with the joint venture, and the validity of certain purported general meetings of members and directors of those companies. The plaintiffs also sought injunctive relief to restrain the defendants from dealing with the assets of the joint venture, including drawing cheques on the bank account of the company trustee of the joint venture assets, purporting to act as manager of the joint venture, purporting to terminate existing management agreements, carrying on the business of the joint venture, or acting in respect of any such business other than on written instructions of Vintners.

The dispute originated when the defendant either personally or through companies under his control interfered with the operation of the joint venture. He challenged the authority of the participants in the joint venture and attempted to deal with the assets of the joint venture, including the receivables under the Grape Supply Agreements, without proper authority. The plaintiffs sought declarations to clarify the legal position, including the validity of the purported agreement between Vineyards and GII assigning the receivables under the Grape Supply Agreements. The plaintiffs also sought injunctive relief to prevent the defendants from continuing to interfere with the operation of the joint venture and to restrain them from dealing with the assets of the joint venture. The case was heard ex parte, and the orders were made for a hearing of the application in open Court by a Master pursuant to SCR 75.19 and 75.01(1)(b). The plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief only, and there was no requirement to serve the application.

The matter of IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L came before the Supreme Court of South Australia in the context of an application by the plaintiffs for judgment in default of defence against two defendants, with the basis for one of the defendants being the striking out of their defence for failure to provide adequate discovery. The plaintiffs sought declaratory and injunctive relief in relation to a joint venture involving the development and management of vineyards, including contracts for the supply of grapes to major wine producers. The dispute centred around the identity of the participants in the joint venture, the validity of certain agreements, and the management of the joint venture’s assets. The application was made under Supreme Court Rule 59.06(1)(b) and required a hearing by a Master in open Court, as per SCR 75.19 and 75.01(1)(b), with no requirement to serve the application on the defendants. The hearing was conducted ex parte due to the plaintiffs seeking only declaratory and injunctive relief. The relief sought included declarations regarding the identity of shareholders, directors, and secretaries of the companies involved, the validity of certain general meetings, and the voidness of agreements assigning receivables under grape supply agreements. Injunctive relief was also sought to restrain defendants from dealing with joint venture assets and acting on behalf of the joint venture without proper authorisation.

Procedurally, the matter involved multiple defendants, with the plaintiffs filing an application for judgment in default of defence against two defendants, while seeking judgment in default of filing a notice of address for service against three other defendants. The application was processed under Supreme Court Rules, with specific focus on the failure of the defendants to provide adequate discovery, leading to the striking out of their defence. The Supreme Court ordered the hearing of the application in open Court by a Master, reflecting the complexity and significance of the issues at hand. The ex parte nature of the hearing underscores the urgency and necessity of the relief sought by the plaintiffs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should grant a judgment in default of defence against the defendants for their failure to provide adequate discovery.
2. Whether the court should declare that International Vineyards P/L is a bare trustee in relation to the property of the joint venture and has no beneficial interest in the property.
3. Whether the court should declare that any agreement between International Vineyards P/L and GII assigning the receivables under the Grape Supply Agreements is void and of no effect.
4. Whether the court should grant injunctive relief to restrain the defendants from dealing with the assets of the joint venture, including drawing cheques on the bank account of the company trustee, purporting to act as manager of the joint venture, purporting to terminate existing management agreements, carrying on the business of the joint venture, or acting in respect of any such business other than on written instructions of Vintners.
5. Whether the court should declare that certain individuals are the shareholders, directors, and secretaries of the companies involved in the joint venture.
6. Whether the court should declare the validity of certain purported general meetings of members and general meetings of directors of the companies involved in the joint venture.
7. Whether the court should declare the validity of certain agreements entered into by the parties involved in the joint venture.

Held
1. The court granted a judgment in default of defence against the defendants for their failure to provide adequate discovery, resulting in the appeal allowed in favor of the plaintiffs.
2. The court declared that International Vineyards P/L is a bare trustee in relation to the property of the joint venture and has no beneficial interest in the property.
3. The court declared that any agreement between International Vineyards P/L and GII assigning the receivables under the Grape Supply Agreements is void and of no effect.
4. The court granted injunctive relief to restrain the defendants from dealing with the assets of the joint venture, including drawing cheques on the bank account of the company trustee, purporting to act as manager of the joint venture, purporting to terminate existing management agreements, carrying on the business of the joint venture, or acting in respect of any such business other than on written instructions of Vintners.
5. The court did not make any declaration regarding the identity of the shareholders, directors, and secretaries of the companies involved in the joint venture.
6. The court did not make any declaration regarding the validity of certain purported general meetings of members and general meetings of directors of the companies involved in the joint venture.
7. The court did not make any declaration regarding the validity of certain agreements entered into by the parties involved in the joint venture.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Blue also put an argument that, in any event, the participants in the joint venture had not agreed to GII becoming a participant and that such agreement was necessary pursuant to clause 3.9 of the JVA. In the absence of the production of the loan agreement referred to in paragraph 14.1 of the JVA, it is not possible to adjudicate in respect of this argument because it is based on the contention that clause 3.9 governs clause 14.1. However, it may be said that GII did not become a participant pursuant to clause 3.9 because none of the other participants consented to such an appointment.Declarations relating to Vineyards (paragraphs 3 and 15 of the minutes) The plaintiffs seeks a declaration that Vineyards is a bare trustee in relation to the property of the joint venture, that it has no beneficial interest in the property and that the property includes certain land and monies receivable under the Grape Supply Agreements. I think it is preferable to alter the proposed paragraph 3 so that it reads as follows:3.International Vineyards Pty Ltd (ACN 074 023 671) (“Vineyards”) is a bare trustee in relation to the joint venture and has no beneficial interest in the joint venture and the assets thereof which include:3.1 The whole of the land (“the land”) comprised in Victorian Certificates of Title Register Book:3.1.1Volume 10288 Folio 345;3.1.2Volume 10444 Folio 407;3.1.3Volume 10533 Folio 032;3.1.4Volume 10579 Folio 755; and3.2 Monies receivable under Grape Supply Agreements (“the Grape Supply Agreements”) referred to in the joint venture agreement dated 25 June 1997 (“the JVA”). Paragraph 3 of the minutes refers to two types of property: the real property and the Grape Supply Agreements. Mr Blue’s submissions were directed primarily to the Grape Supply Agreements. The only basis upon which the reference to real property in the proposed declaration can be supported is that if, as was contended by the plaintiffs, Garrett either individually or through one of his companies attempted to deal with the Grape Supply Agreements contrary to the terms of the joint venture, it was necessary also to make reference to the real property because it was the source of the grapes which were the subject of the Grape Supply Agreements. Paragraph 3 of the minutes is linked with paragraph 15 of the minutes which seeks a declaration as follows:15.Any agreement between Vineyards and GII assigning the receivables under the Grape Supply Agreements referred to in the JVA is void and of no effect. Oliver refers to such a purported agreement at paragraph 174 et seq of his affidavit. A copy of the agreement is in book 5 of exhibit P1 at pages 359 to 375. The purported agreement is dated 12 July 2004. It purports to be between Vineyards as vendor and GII as a purchaser. The document has been executed by Garrett purportedly as sole director of Vineyards and by Garrett again as sole director of GII. It is abundantly clear from the affidavit evidence that whatever authority Garrett may have had from GII to enter into such agreement, he had no authority to execute the agreement on behalf of Vineyards. Although the agreement only relates to the “receivables” (as defined) from the 2004 vintage, a declaration is sought in more general terms both as to the basis upon which Vineyards holds the assets of the joint venture (paragraph 3.2 of the minutes) and also as to the absence of entitlement of GII to such proceeds (paragraph 15 of the minutes).