IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master: Civil)

IML P/L & ORS v INTERNATIONAL VINEYARDS P/L & ORS

[2006] SASC 310

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

25 October 2006

PROCEDURE - SUPREME COURT PROCEDURE - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - PROCEDURE UNDER RULES OF COURT - JUDGMENTS AND ORDERS

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - POWERS, DUTIES, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF TRUSTEES

STANDING TO INSTITUTE AND CONTINUE PROCEEDINGS

Appeal from a decision of a Master - defence struck out and judgment entered against defendants - further defence and counterclaim filed subsequently purporting to be in response to consolidated statement of claim in respect of which judgment had already been entered - further defence and counterclaim struck out - whether further defence and counterclaim should have been struck out - whether second defendant has standing to represent the other defendants - whether second defendant has any standing to represent himself - Held: appeal dismissed, second defendant does not have standing in any capacity, defence and counterclaim struck out properly in accordance with Rules of Court, appeal incompetent.

Supreme Court Act 1935 (SA) s50(2); Supreme Court Rules r3.04, r30.01, r59.06; Bankruptcy Act 1966 (Cth) s58(1)(a), s134(1)(j), referred to.
Bailey v Marinoff (1971) 125 CLR 529; Shanks & Co Pty Ltd v Hohne [1963] VR 198; Cummings & Fuller v Claremont Petroleum NL & Anor (1996) 185 CLR 124; Evans v HiFert Pty Ltd [2003] SASC 186, applied.

IML P/L & ORS v INTERNATIONAL VINEYARDS P/L & ORS
[2006] SASC 310

Civil: Appeal from a Master

  1. ANDERSON J      Andrew Morton Garrett has filed a notice of appeal from a decision of a Master dated 4 May 2006.  The Master struck out Mr Garrett’s defence and counterclaim because a default judgment had already been entered against him.  That was a final judgment and the Master ruled that no counterclaim could be filed because the proceedings had been brought to an end.

  2. The issues to be decided are:

    1Does Mr Garrett have any standing in this matter to represent himself and, or, any entities related to his former business; and

    2If so, should the subsequent defence and counterclaim have been struck out by the Master.

    Standing

  3. Mr Garrett asserted that he appeared as a trustee of a trust, and as agent for the appellants, International Vineyards P/L, and in his own personal capacity.  Mr Garrett is presently an undischarged bankrupt.  None of the defendants are legally represented.  Mr Garrett has previously attempted to represent the corporate defendants, other natural persons and himself.  A Master has earlier refused him leave to do so on the basis that he could not represent the companies as he was not a director and not shown to be duly authorised.  He was also refused leave to represent the other natural defendants. This refusal was on 21 April 2005.

  4. Mr Garrett asserted that since that time there had been “a significant shift in (his) capacity to stand before this court.”  I do not believe that to be…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] SASC 310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of IML P/L v International Vineyards P/L involved a dispute between the plaintiffs, IML P/L, and the defendants, International Vineyards P/L and Andrew Morton Garrett. The matter came before the court as an appeal against a decision by a Master to strike out the defence and counterclaim filed by Mr Garrett. The appeal raised issues of procedural fairness and the proper application of the rules of court.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the Master correctly exercised his discretion to strike out the defence and counterclaim, and whether the appeal was properly before the court. The court also had to consider whether Mr Garrett had standing to appeal and whether there were any substantive issues that warranted further consideration.

The court found that the appeal was procedural in nature and that the Master had correctly exercised his discretion to strike out the defence and counterclaim. The court held that the Master's decision was made on a procedural basis and was not subject to the same standards of review as a decision on the merits. The court also found that Mr Garrett did not have standing to appeal, as the order striking out the defence and counterclaim had already been finalising the proceedings against him. The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the respondents be awarded costs.

The final orders of the court were that the appeal was dismissed and that the respondents be awarded costs of the appeal. The court found that the Master's decision to strike out the defence and counterclaim was procedurally sound and that there were no substantive issues that warranted further consideration. The court also held that Mr Garrett did not have standing to appeal and that the appeal was without merit.

Background

Background to the litigation

However, if I am wrong and Mr Garrett does have valid standing, I now turn to consider the merits.Background Facts The history preceding the Master’s decision to strike out the defence and counterclaim is as follows:(a)On 18 November 2004 actions 247, 253 and 321 of 2004 were consolidated by an order made by Gray J.(b)On 9 December 2004 the plaintiffs filed a consolidated statement of claim (FDN 54). (c)On 24 January 2005 the second defendant (Mr Garrett) filed his defence (FDN 56).(d)On 19 May 2005 the plaintiffs filed a notice for specific directions (FDN 76) seeking an order that the defence be struck out pursuant to Supreme Court r 59.06, on the basis that the second defendant had failed to fulfil his discovery obligation pursuant to the orders made by Gray J on 18 November 2005.(e)On 6 July 2005 Master Bowen Pain ordered that the defence be struck out for failure to comply with previous orders in particular, Mr Garrett’s failure to adequately discharge his discovery obligations pursuant to Supreme Court r 59.06. (f)On 20 July 2005 the plaintiffs filed a subsequent notice for specific directions (FDN 94) seeking, in particular, judgment in default of defence against two defendants, International Vineyards P/L and Andrew Morton Garrett. It should be noted that the plaintiffs’ application for judgment against Mr Garrett was made pursuant to Supreme Court r 59.06(1)(b) on the basis that the defence should be struck out for failure to give adequate discovery. The plaintiffs also sought judgment in default of filing a notice of address for service against the defendants Averil Gay Garrett, Garrett International Investments P/L and Evajade P/L.(g)On 5 September 2005 Master Burley heard the plaintiffs’ application to enter judgment in default of defence. That application was dealt with in open court.(h)On 13 October 2005 Master Burley gave judgment in favour of the respondents. The order was formalised and sealed on 19 October 2005. In the judgment given, Master Burley granted declaratory and injunctive relief in favour of the respondents dealing with, amongst other things, the identity of the participants in the joint venture, the identity of the shareholders, directors and secretaries of the ninth plaintiff, International Vintners Australia P/L, the validity of a purported extraordinary general meeting of International Vintners held on 18 March 2004, of resolutions purportedly passed at that meeting, and injunctive relief in respect of Mr Garrett’s dealings with the joint venture. The relief disposed of most of the orders sought in the plaintiffs’ consolidated amended inter partes summons (FDN 54).(i)On 17 November Mr Garrett filed a notice of appeal (FDN 120) in respect of that judgment. Vanstone J heard this appeal on 17 January 2006. Her Honour dismissed the appeal as incompetent and published her reasons on 19 January 2006. Her Honour found that the notice of appeal was so defective that it was not susceptible to amendments, and that further, there was no application to amend and that in any event it would be inappropriate to exercise the power given in r 3.04 to validate the notice. On this basis she dismissed Mr Garrett’s appeal as incompetent and ordered the respondents to have the costs of this appeal. The proceedings by the present respondents against the Garrett Group were thereby finalised as a result of that judgment. (j)On 24 November 2005 Mr Garrett filed a defence and counterclaim (FDN 127), purporting to be a new defence and counterclaim to the consolidated statement of claim in respect of which judgment had been given against him. The plaintiffs then filed a notice for specific directions seeking to have the defence and counterclaim struck out (FDN 152). This matter was listed for hearing before Master Lunn on 10 April 2006 but, at the request of Mr Garrett, was adjourned to 4 May 2006. On 4 May 2006 Mr Garrett did not attend the hearing, and in his absence Master Lunn ordered that the defence and counterclaim be struck out. Was the Master correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim?

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
Mr Garrett requested that I read the proposed counterclaim to see the injustice of the situation. Having read the counterclaim, I can see that it comprises a history of the Andrew Garrett Group of Trusts including, a history of Andrew Garrett himself, his involvement in the wine industry and his involvement in some of the plaintiff group of companies. It was therefore to be used as a proposed launching pad for what Mr Garrett wants to argue is the injustice brought upon him and his group, by virtue of the impecuniosity of the group, caused by the actions taken by persons and entities owed money and seeking to enforce their legal rights. The matters raised in the counterclaim are irrelevant to the present appeal. Conclusion The Master did not publish any reasons. There was no need to publish reasons, in my view. It is a very simple matter. The order was made on a procedural basis pursuant to the rules of this Court. In my view the appeal in this matter is without any merit at all. Reference to the alleged injustices in the proposed counterclaim do not advance the matter. Mr Garrett did not put forward any valid submissions in relation to the merits of the appeal, but rather attempted to re-agitate issues which were irrelevant to the issues at hand. The present appeal, as I have indicated, involves a very simple procedural matter. It is my view that the appeal should be dismissed. I will hear the parties as to costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J

The court began by addressing whether the Master was correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim filed by Mr Garrett on 4 May 2006. The court noted that the Master ordered the defence and counterclaim to be struck out because Mr Garrett did not attend the hearing. The court held that the Master was correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim because Mr Garrett failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the court. The court emphasised that the order was made on a procedural basis pursuant to the rules of the court and that there was no need for the Master to publish reasons for the order.

The court then considered whether Mr Garrett had valid standing to file the defence and counterclaim, and if so, were there any other grounds upon which the Master could have struck them out. The court found that Mr Garrett had valid standing to file the defence and counterclaim because he was a party to the proceedings. However, the court held that the Master was correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim because Mr Garrett failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the court. The court noted that Mr Garrett did not attend the hearing, and therefore, he failed to comply with the rules of the court.

The court then addressed whether the Master was correct in not publishing reasons for striking out the defence and counterclaim. The court held that the Master was correct in not publishing reasons because the order was made on a procedural basis pursuant to the rules of the court. The court emphasised that the order was a simple procedural matter, and there was no need to publish reasons.

The court then considered whether the matters raised in Mr Garrett’s proposed counterclaim were relevant to the issues at hand, and did they provide any basis to advance the appeal. The court held that the matters raised in the proposed counterclaim were irrelevant to the present appeal. The court noted that the appeal involved a very simple procedural matter, and reference to the alleged injustices in the proposed counterclaim did not advance the matter. The court found that Mr Garrett did not put forward any valid submissions in relation to the merits of the appeal, but rather attempted to re-agitate issues which were irrelevant to the issues at hand.

The court then addressed whether Mr Garrett’s appeal was devoid of merit, and should it be dismissed as a result. The court held that the appeal was devoid of merit and should be dismissed. The court noted that the appeal involved a very simple procedural matter, and Mr Garrett did not put forward any valid submissions in relation to the merits of the appeal.

Finally, the court considered whether the respondents should be awarded costs in relation to this appeal. The court noted that the appeal was devoid of merit, and the respondents had to bear the costs of the appeal. The court held that the respondents should be awarded costs in relation to this appeal.

In summary, the court held that the Master was correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim filed by Mr Garrett on 4 May 2006 because Mr Garrett failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the court. The court held that Mr Garrett had valid standing to file the defence and counterclaim, but the Master was correct in striking them out because Mr Garrett failed to comply with the rules of the court. The court held that the Master was correct in not publishing reasons for the order because it was a simple procedural matter. The court held that the matters raised in Mr Garrett’s proposed counterclaim were irrelevant to the issues at hand, and the appeal was devoid of merit. The court held that the respondents should be awarded costs in relation to this appeal. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the Master was correct in striking out the defence and counterclaim filed by Mr Garrett on 4 May 2006 because Mr Garrett failed to comply with the procedural requirements of the court.