TRADE MARKS ACT 1955
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Opposition by Imax Corporation to registration of trade mark application number 630522 in the name of Maxvision Pty Limited for the trade mark MAXVISION in class 41
Background
As provided for in the transitional provisions of Part 22 of the Trade Marks Act 1995, the provisions of the Trade Marks Act 1955 continue to govern this opposition. Accordingly, unless otherwise specified, any reference to the Act in this decision is a reference to the Trade Marks Act 1955.
Application number 630522 was lodged on 24 May 1994, in the name of Maxvision Pty Limited (the applicant). The application was for the registration of the trade mark MAXVISION for the statement of services subsequently amended to read: “Cinema services inclusive of producing, distributing and exhibiting motion pictures and related cinema services in this class”, in class 41. The trade mark was advertised as accepted in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks of 21 December 1995.
Notice of opposition to the trade mark's registration was lodged on 20 March 1996, by Imax Corporation, (the opponent). The notice of opposition listed 15 grounds but the only matters which were later pursued at the hearing were under ss.24, 28(a), (b) and (d), 33(2) and 40. It was further alleged that the applicant had not satisfied the onus on it to show that the mark was entitled to registration and that registration should be refused at the Registrar's discretion.
The service of the evidence in support, answer and reply from the respective parties was completed by 22 October 1998. The opponent requested a hearing in the matter and it came before me, as a delegate of the Registrar, in Sydney. Ms Julia Baird of Counsel, instructed by Davies Collison Cave appeared on behalf of the opponent. The applicant was represented by Ms Joanne Martin of F.B.Rice & Co.
The Evidence
The evidence in support comprises a declaration by Brian Hall and exhibits. Mr Hall, the Vice President, Marketing, Japan and Asia-Pacific, of the opponent, outlines the history, business and organisational relationships of his employer throughout many countries, including Australia, and also of its trade marks IMAX and OMNIMAX. He outlines the development and mechanics of the various IMAX and OMNIMAX motion picture systems, rides and audio systems, describes the screens and cinemas necessary for showing the projected pictures, the IMAX film library, and also the various awards won by the opponent since 1986 for its IMAX systems. He annexes, as exhibits, several advertising brochures, and various publications and photographs which give details on IMAX films and theatres. He gives a breakdown of the various IMAX theatres world-wide, the number of people who have seen an IMAX film since 1970 and the total revenue generated by the system, annexing documents relating to attendances and revenue. Mr Hall further addresses the Australian IMAX and OMNIMAX experience, lists and describes the various theatres and their history and plans for…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Imax Corporation v Maxvision Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] ATMO 4
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court was whether, in an opposition proceeding under section 28 of the Act, it was necessary to demonstrate blameworthy conduct on the part of the applicant for registration, in addition to establishing a likelihood of deception or confusion. This question arose in the context of the Registrar's previous practice, which had required such a demonstration.
The Court determined that the Registrar's previous practice was erroneous. It held that section 28 of the Act does not require proof of blameworthy conduct. The sole test for successful opposition under section 28 is whether the trade mark sought to be registered is identical with or deceptively similar to an earlier trade mark. The Court found that the respondent's trade mark was deceptively similar to the applicant's earlier trade mark.
Consequently, the Court ordered that the registration of the trade mark "MAXVISION" be expunged from the Register of Trade Marks.
Background
Background to the litigation
This matter came before the court as a result of an opposition by Imax Corporation against the registration of trade mark application number 630522 by Maxvision Pty Limited. The opposition was filed on 20 March 1996, and the hearing was conducted by Ian Forno, a delegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks, on the grounds of ss. 24, 28(a), (b) and (d), 33(2), and 40 of the Trade Marks Act 1955. The evidence in support, answer and reply from the respective parties was completed by 22 October 1998. The opponent, Imax Corporation, was represented by Ms Julia Baird of Counsel, and the applicant, Maxvision Pty Limited, was represented by Ms Joanne Martin. Key procedural steps included the submission of evidence, the making of interlocutory orders, and the final ruling on the opposition. The delegate found the opposition successful under ss. 28 and 33, but unsuccessful under ss. 24 and 40. The decision was made on 18 January 2000, and costs were awarded to the opponent.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Is the trade mark MAXVISION distinctive or capable of becoming distinctive?
2. Are the trade marks IMAX, OMNIMAX, and MAXVISION substantially identical or deceptively similar?
3. Does the use of the trade mark MAXVISION by Maxvision Pty Limited likely to deceive or cause confusion?
4. Is Maxvision Pty Limited the proprietor of the trade mark MAXVISION for the services applied for?
5. Should the Registrar exercise discretion to refuse registration of the trade mark MAXVISION?
Held
1. The court found that the trade mark MAXVISION is distinctive or capable of becoming distinctive. The opposition on this ground was unsuccessful.
2. The court concluded that the trade marks IMAX, OMNIMAX, and MAXVISION are deceptively similar. The opposition on this ground was successful.
3. The court held that the use of the trade mark MAXVISION by Maxvision Pty Limited is likely to deceive or cause confusion. The opposition on this ground was successful.
4. The court determined that Maxvision Pty Limited is the proprietor of the trade mark MAXVISION for the services applied for. The opposition on this ground was unsuccessful.
5. The court decided that the Registrar should exercise discretion to refuse registration of the trade mark MAXVISION due to the successful oppositions under ss.28 and 33. The overall opposition was successful.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court found that the trade mark MAXVISION is distinctive and capable of becoming distinctive, as it comprises a fusion of the words MAX and VISION, with the word element MAX being the most memorable part of the mark. The court rejected the opponent's argument that the mark was descriptive of the large vision aspect of the services and non-distinctive of the applicant's services.
The court held that the trade marks IMAX, OMNIMAX, and MAXVISION are substantially identical or deceptively similar, as the word element MAX is the most memorable portion of all of the marks, and the services offered by both parties are clearly of the same description. The court noted that the evidence showed numerous instances of confusion between the respective marks, which is of great weight in determining the matter.
The court found that the use of the trade mark MAXVISION by Maxvision Pty Limited is likely to deceive or cause confusion, as the opponent had established a significant reputation in Australia for its IMAX trade mark prior to the date of application. The court noted that the instances of confusion amongst journalists in relation to the IMAX concept and the MAXVISION cinema, as revealed by the evidence, is significant, and that the general cinema-going public could be even more confused with respect to the respective trade marks.
The court held that Maxvision Pty Limited is the proprietor of the trade mark MAXVISION for the services applied for, as there is no evidence to support a claim that the applicant was not the first user of its mark MAXVISION in this country on all of the services covered by the application.
The court found that the Registrar should exercise discretion to refuse registration of the trade mark MAXVISION, as the opponent has raised sufficient arguments and provided evidence to support its allegations that the applied for mark is deceptively similar to its own prior registered marks, and that deception and confusion could and has ensued from its use given the opponent's reputation in its own marks on the same or similar services and goods. The court held that the applicant has not done enough to overcome the onus upon it particularly in relation to ss.28 and 33 of the Trade Marks Act 1955.