Ikin v The Danish Club "Danebrog" Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA

COURT OF APPEAL

No. 5959 of 2000

PAUL GERARD IKIN

Appellant

v.

THE DANISH CLUB "DANNEBROG" INC.

Respondent

THE DANISH CLUB "DANNEBROG" INC.

Cross-Appellant

v.

PAUL GERARD IKIN

Cross-Respondent

---

JUDGES:

BROOKING, BATT and BUCHANAN, JJ.A.

WHERE HELD:

MELBOURNE

DATE OF HEARING:

1 August 2001

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

1 August 2001

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2001] VSCA 123

---

EMPLOYMENT - Wrongful dismissal - Written contract of employment for fixed term - Express provisions for determination of employment in certain events - Additional term not to be implied - Measure of damages.

APPEARANCES: Counsel Solicitors
For the Appellant/
Cross-Respondent
Mrs S.L. Marks Howie & Maher
For the Respondent/
Cross-Appellant
Mr C.R. Northrop Goldsmiths

BROOKING, J.A. (delivering the judgment of the Court):

1  An action for damages for wrongful dismissal and other monetary relief was brought by the former manager of the Danish Club against the company which had been his employer.  The facts need not be rehearsed.

2  The judge found that the plaintiff had been wrongfully dismissed and awarded $46,000 to the plaintiff, together with $9,000 damages in the nature of interest, a total of $55,000.  The plaintiff appealed on the ground that the amount awarded was too low.

3  There was a cross-appeal by the defendant.  Ground 1 of that challenged the finding of wrongful dismissal, but that finding, which, we may say, we regard as impregnable, is not now challenged.

4  There was a written contract of employment.  By clause 2:

"2.       Office and Term of Appointment

The Club shall employ the Executive in the capacity specified in Schedule 2 ("the Job Title") for a period specified in Schedule 2 ("Term of Employment") from the date specified in Schedule 2 ("Commencement Date") and the Executive hereby agrees to and accepts such employment from that date until the earliest of the following dates:-

(a)the expiration of the Term of Employment specified in Schedule 2;

(b)at any time after the expiration of the term specified in the schedule where either party gives the other party notice in writing of its intention to terminate the agreement, such notice being reasonable notice having regard to the circumstances of the Executive's employment, but in no event being less than the period specified in Schedule 2 ("the Notice Period");

(c) the Club terminates the Executive's employment under Clause 11 or 12 herein."

We refer to Schedule 2 mentioned in that clause which specified as the term of employment, 3 years and as the commencement date, 1 July 1996.  It fixed a salary of $60,000 and a car allowance of $7,500 per annum.

5  Clauses 11 and 12 of the agreement were as follows: 

"11.    None (sic) Performance

Notwithstanding the terms of this agreement, the Club may terminate the Executive at any time by giving notice in writing of its intention to do so if:-

(a) regular performance review - at least every six months -has shown that the performance of the Executive, given due consideration to previous financial results, directions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ikin v The Danish Club "Danebrog" Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] VSCA 123
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ikin v The Danish Club "Danebrog" Inc involved an appeal against a decision of the Supreme Court of Victoria which found that the plaintiff was wrongfully dismissed from his position as manager of the defendant company, awarding him $46,000 in damages. The defendant cross-appealed the decision. The central issue in the appeal was whether the trial judge was correct in implying a term into the contract of employment that would allow for termination by either party if the employment relationship became unworkable. The Court of Appeal held that such a term could not be implied as it was inconsistent with the express terms of the contract and did not meet the criteria set out in BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v. Shire of Hastings.

The Court of Appeal found that the trial judge's assessment of damages was based on a fundamentally erroneous premise and remitted the case to the County Court for reassessment. The Court noted that the judge should consider factors such as unpaid leave accrued to the date of dismissal, the present value of the plaintiff's superannuation benefits, and the impact of the plaintiff's summary dismissal on his ability to obtain other employment. The Court also determined that the defendant should bear the costs of both the appeal and the cross-appeal.

The final orders of the Court of Appeal were to allow the plaintiff's appeal, set aside certain paragraphs of the trial judge's judgment, remit the case for reassessment of the amount of monetary relief, and order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs of the appeal. The Court also refused the defendant's application for an order that the plaintiff disgorge the proceeds of the judgment and the costs paid.

Background

Background to the litigation

Paul Gerard Ikin was the former manager of the Danish Club "Danebrog" Inc. He brought an action for damages for wrongful dismissal against the club. The club denied the wrongful dismissal and alleged that Ikin had constructively resigned. Ikin's contract of employment was for a fixed term of three years from 1 July 1996. The contract specified the conditions under which the employment could be terminated, including non-performance, inability to perform duties due to illness or accident, bankruptcy, unsoundness of mind, conviction of certain offences, serious breach of the agreement, and failure to comply with lawful directions. The contract also allowed for summary dismissal under certain circumstances, such as serious breach or default of any of the covenants and conditions in the agreement. The judge found that Ikin had been wrongfully dismissed and awarded him $46,000 in damages, plus $9,000 in interest, totaling $55,000.

The matter was appealed by Ikin, the appellant, on the ground that the amount awarded was too low. The Danish Club "Danebrog" Inc, the respondent, filed a cross-appeal challenging the finding of wrongful dismissal. The case was heard by Brooking, Batt, and Buchanan, JJ.A. at the Supreme Court of Victoria Court of Appeal on 1 August 2001, and judgment was delivered on the same day.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the amount of damages awarded to the appellant for wrongful dismissal too low?
2. Was the implied term regarding the termination of employment consistent with the express terms of the written agreement?
3. Should the case be remitted for redetermination of the amount of monetary relief to which the appellant is entitled?

Held
1. The appeal was allowed as the damages awarded for wrongful dismissal were too low.
2. The implied term regarding the termination of employment was not consistent with the express terms of the written agreement.
3. The case was remitted for redetermination of the amount of monetary relief to which the appellant is entitled.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge's assessment of damages for wrongful dismissal was based on an implied term that was inconsistent with the express terms of the employment contract. Clauses 2, 11, and 12 of the written agreement provided specific circumstances under which the employment could be terminated and did not allow for termination on the basis of loss of confidence by the employer. The implied term suggested by the primary judge, which allowed for termination by either party if the employment relationship became unworkable, contradicted these express terms and did not meet the requirements set out in BP Refinery (Westernport) Pty Ltd v. Shire of Hastings. The Court held that the term was not reasonable and equitable, was not necessary to give efficacy to the contract, and was not so obvious that it went without saying. As a result, the damages awarded were assessed on a fundamentally erroneous basis.

The Court of Appeal also considered the cross-appeal by the respondent, which challenged the finding of wrongful dismissal. However, this finding was regarded as impregnable, and the Court did not need to address this issue further.

The Court remitted the case to the County Court for the redetermination of the amount of monetary relief to which the appellant is entitled. The redetermination was to be made by the same judge, without the reception of further evidence, but after hearing further submissions. The Court provided guidance on factors to be considered in the reassessment of damages, such as unpaid leave accrued to the date of dismissal, the quantification of superannuation loss, and the relevance of the plaintiff's summary dismissal to the assessment of damages.