| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL | [1995] QCA 043 |
| SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND |
Appeal No. 203 of 1994
Brisbane
[Igarashi v. Registrar of Titles]
[Ozaki v. Registrar of Titles]
BETWEEN:
MICHIKO IGARASHI and
KAZUYOSHI IGARASHI
(Plaintiffs) Respondent
AND:
APC INTERNATIONAL PTY. LTD.
(Defendant)
AND:
THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES
(Respondent) Appellant
Appeal No. 204 of 1994
BETWEEN:
NORIHIOR OZAKI and
KAZUKO OZAKI
(Plaintiffs) Respondents
AND:
APC INTERNATIONAL PTY. LTD.
(Defendant)
AND:
THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES
(Respondent) Appellant FITZGERALD P.
DAVIES J.A.THOMAS J.
Judgment delivered 28/02/1995
Reasons for judgment of the Court.
BOTH APPEALS DISMISSED WITH COSTS.
CATCHWORDS: LAND - FRAUD - fraudulent procurement of
mortgage under Real Property Act 1861 so as to deprive registered proprietor of land, of estate or interest; whether an action under s.126 Real Property Act can only be brought against a person who becomes registered by reason of their fraud; whether benefit obtained by reason of fraud
Real Property Act 1861 ss.126 and 127
Beardsley v. Registrar of Titles [1993] 2
Qd.R. 117
Registrar of Titles (W.A.) v. Franzon (1975)
132 C.L.R. 611
Sekiya v. APC International Ltd. (No. 287 of1994, 6 May 1994, unreported).
| Counsel: | Mr. C. Hampson Q.C. with him Mr. D. Campbell for the applicant |
| Mr. J. McGill Q.C. for the respondent | |
Solicitors: | Crown Law for the applicant Steindls for the respondent |
Hearing Date: 16 February 1995
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL
SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND
Appeal No. 203 of 1994
Brisbane
| Before | Fitzgerald P. Davies J.A. Thomas J. |
[Igarashi v. Registrar of Titles]
[Ozaki v. Registrar of Titles]
BETWEEN:
MICHIKO IGARASHI and
KAZUYOSHI IGARASHI
(Plaintiffs) Respondent
AND:
APC INTERNATIONAL PTY. LTD.
(Defendant)
AND:
THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES
(Respondent) Appellant
Appeal No. 204 of 1994
BETWEEN:
NORIHIOR OZAKI and
KAZUKO OZAKI
(Plaintiffs) Respondents
AND:
APC INTERNATIONAL PTY. LTD.
(Defendant)
AND:
THE REGISTRAR OF TITLES
(Respondent) Appellant
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT - THE COURT
Judgment delivered the 28th day of February 1995
These are two appeals by the Registrar of Titles against judgments in the Trial Division of this Court in favour of the respondents in separate actions by them against, in each case, APC International Pty. Ltd. ("APC").
The actions were each for damages pursuant to s.126 of the Real Property Act 1861. APC did not take part in the proceedings below, which were motions for judgment in lieu of defence, or in these appeals. Although the Registrar was not a party to either action he was allowed to take part in the proceedings below and no point was taken about his right to appeal against each of the judgments.
The facts were similar in each case. The respondents were registered proprietors of land. By the fraud of, including several forgeries by, APC their land was mortgaged to a financier Arkway Pty. Ltd. ("Arkway") who, ignorant of and itself deceived by the fraud, advanced money which APC then misappropriated. When the respondents discovered the fraud…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Igarashi v APC International Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1995] QCA 43
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court of Appeal held that the phrase "the person who derived benefit by such fraud" in section 126 of the Real Property Act was not limited to a person who became registered by reason of their fraud. The court reasoned that there was nothing in the section or the context that required such a limitation. Furthermore, implying such a limitation would be inconsistent with the purpose of the section, which was to provide a remedy for losses caused by fraud. The court emphasised that the purpose of sections 126 and 127 was to compensate those deprived of their land by fraud and that there was no authority supporting the limitation proposed by the Registrar of Titles. Consequently, the appeals were dismissed with costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi