Ici Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Commercial Polymers Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

official notice

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Application  :          No. 606285 in the name of ICI AUSTRALIA OPERATIONS PTY LTD

Title:          Cable

Action: Opposition under section 59 by COMMERCIAL POLYMERS PTY LTD.

Decision:          Issued            .

Abstract: Opposition under section 59 successful in part

All of the claims are prior published or lack novelty with respect to one of the references supplied.
The opponent has not established that any of the claims are obvious.
The specification has section 40 deficiencies. Invention not fully described, claims not fairly based. Applicant given time to amend.

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Patent Application No. 606285 by ICI AUSTRALIA OPERATIONS PTY LTD and opposition thereto under section 59 of the Patents Act 1952 by COMMERCIAL POLYMERS PTY LTD

background

Application 606285 was filed on 15 June 1989 by ICI Operations Ltd (hereafter referred to as “ICI) and opposed by Commercial Polymers Pty Ltd (hereafter referred to as “COMPOL”).  The evidence stages were completed on 16 December 1994 and a hearing set down for 20 March 1995. However on 3 February 1995 ICI sought leave to serve further evidence.  COMPOL objected and a delegate of the Commissioner issued a decision in which special leave was refused.  The opposition has therefore proceeded only on the basis  of evidence filed prior to 16 December 1994.

As the acceptance of the application was advertised accepted before the commencement of the Patents Act 1990, the opposition falls under section 59 of the Patents Act 1952.

The grounds of opposition are those specified in paragraphs (c) through (i) of Section 59 of the Patents Act 1952.

The substantive opposition was heard on 26 and 27 September 1995 in Melbourne. The applicant was represented by Mr J McCormack, patent attorney for Griffith Hack & Co, and the opponent was represented by Mr G Chambers, patent attorney accompanied by Mr C Schlicht, patent attorney, both of Phillips Ormonde and Fitzpatrick.

THE EVIDENCE

The evidence-in-support of the opposition consisted of statutory declarations by: Kim Elizabeth Parker, Hayden Lomas, Glenn Dawes, Quentin Cooke, Gregory Morris Chambers, Gordon Angus Wishart and Dr Ezzelino Leonardi.

The evidence-in-answer consisted of statutory declarations by: John McCormack, Maria Ann Styzinski and Ian Johnson.

The evidence in reply consisted of statutory declarations by: Dr Ezzelino Leonardi, Quentin Cooke and Kathleen Boys.

I will consider the submissions made at the hearing, on behalf of ICI and COMPOL, in relation to specific issues as they arise.

The matters that have to be decided in this opposition are the following

  • section 40 matters

  • prior publication

  • obviousness

THE SPECIFICATION

The specification states that:

“The invention relates to cables and particularly those which are to be laid underground”.

The specification then goes on to describe how such cables are usually coated with a protective sheath or jacket commonly of plastics material, typically polyethylene, which is easily applied by extrusion. It then states how this prior art coating is susceptible to termite…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ici Australia Operations Pty Ltd v Commercial Polymers Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] APO 24
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The opposition to the patent application was heard by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents. The applicant, ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd, had applied for a patent for a process of manufacturing a cable coated with two concentric layers of polymeric material. The opponent, Commercial Polymers Pty Ltd, argued that the claims were ambiguous, the specification was insufficient, and the invention was obvious and anticipated. The delegate found that the claims were clear but not fairly based on the specification. The specification was also found to be insufficient as it did not fully describe the invention and did not disclose the essential features of the claims. The opposition was successful on the grounds of failure to comply with section 40 of the Patents Act and prior publication. The invention was not found to be obvious. The applicant was given 60 days to propose amendments to the specification.

The opposition was successful in part. The applicant was given 60 days to propose amendments to the specification. Costs were awarded against the applicant.

Background

Background to the litigation

Patent application number 606285, filed by ICI Australia Operations Pty Ltd, was opposed by Commercial Polymers Pty Ltd. The invention relates to a process for manufacturing cables with a protective sheath, specifically a process of co-extrusion of modified polyolefin and nylon over the cable. The claims of the patent include processes and the resulting cables with at least two concentric layers of polymeric material, where the outer layer is polyamide and the inner layer is modified polyolefin. The opposition presented arguments on the novelty and obviousness of the claims, as well as on the sufficiency of the specification and the fair basis of the claims.

The opposition to the patent application was filed under Section 59 of the Patents Act 1952. The opposition was based on the grounds of prior publication, lack of novelty, and obviousness. The opposition hearing took place on 26 and 27 September 1995 in Melbourne, with both parties represented by patent attorneys. The applicant sought to serve further evidence but was refused special leave to do so. The decision was made based on the evidence submitted prior to 16 December 1994.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the claims are clear and have a fair basis in the specification.
2. Whether the invention has been fully described in the specification.
3. Whether the invention is obvious to a person skilled in the art.
4. Whether the invention has been anticipated by prior publications.
5. Whether the invention constitutes a manner of manufacture.

Held
1. The opposition to the patent application was successful in part.
2. All of the claims were either prior published or lacked novelty with respect to one of the references supplied.
3. The opponent did not establish that any of the claims were obvious.
4. The specification had Section 40 deficiencies; it did not fully describe the invention and the claims were not fairly based on the description.
5. The applicant was given 60 days to propose amendments to the specification to overcome the identified problems.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the claims and specification of the patent application in light of the evidence and submissions presented by both parties. The court concluded that while the invention was novel and not obvious, the claims were not clear and fairly based on the specification. The specification did not fully describe the invention as it failed to limit the process to simultaneous coextrusion, which was considered essential to the invention. The court found that the claims were not limited to the essential features of the invention, such as the simultaneous coextrusion process, and therefore were not fairly based on the specification. The court also found that the specification included the possibility of more than two polymeric layers and the use of the modified polyolefin as a tie layer, which contradicted the opponent's argument that the invention was limited to two layers. The court concluded that the invention could be amended to overcome these deficiencies and granted the applicant 60 days to propose amendments. The court found that some of the claims were anticipated by prior publications, specifically US Patent Specification 4,675,471. However, the court found insufficient evidence to establish that the invention was obvious to a person skilled in the art. The court awarded costs to the opponent in line with the convention that costs follow the event.