IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S231 of 2008
B e t w e e n -
ICETV PTY LTD
First Applicant
ICETV HOLDINGS LIMITED
Second Applicant
and
NINE NETWORK AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED
Respondent
Application for special leave to appeal
GUMMOW J
KIRBY J
KIEFEL J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT SYDNEY ON TUESDAY, 26 AUGUST 2008, AT 10.16 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR J.M. IRELAND, QC: May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friends, MR S.C.G. BURLEY, SC and MR J.S. COOKE, on behalf of the applicant. (instructed by Bartier Perry)
MR A.J.L. BANNON, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friend, MR J.M. HENNESSY, for the respondent (instructed by Gilbert & Tobin Lawyers)
GUMMOW J: Yes, Mr Bannon, we will hear from you first. Are we right in thinking that there is a recent further judgment on some costs questions in this litigation on 20 August?
MR BANNON: Yes, there is a recent further judgment in relation to a matter as to whether something was left for remitter for the trial judge, but it does not affect any of the issues which are before this Court.
GUMMOW J: No. Would the orders in any way be caught up in this Court on a grant of special leave?
MR BANNON: If there was a grant of special leave, the orders could be dealt with on the papers readily.
GUMMOW J: All right. I will not say any more about it now. Yes, go on.
MR BANNON: Your Honours, Ice conceded at the trial, correctly, that the originality of Nine’s weekly schedules lay, at least in part, in the skill and labour invested in the decision to screen particular programs at particular times. That is something which is recorded in the Full Court judgment. The Full Court found that the skill and labour which had been invested in the determination of which programs would screen at which times was relevant to the originality of the weekly schedules. That finding is consistent with a line of authority which was reflected in the House of Lords decision in Ladbroke. It has been consistently applied ‑ ‑ ‑
GUMMOW J: Yes, on the question of Ladbroke, actually, the House of Lords endorsed the majority of the Court of Appeal but Lord Diplock dissented, did he not?
MR BANNON: In the Court of Appeal?
GUMMOW J: Yes.
MR BANNON: Yes, I think that might be right.
GUMMOW J: One can unearth it in [1980] RPC 539. The Court of Appeal had reversed Mr Justice Lloyd Jacob, did they not?
MR BANNON: I think that is right, your Honour, yes.
GUMMOW J: What I am putting to you is that do not think that in this Court William Hill is the end of a rainbow.
MR BANNON: No. It depends on which issue it is which the applicant seeks to…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read IceTV Pty Ltd & Anor v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] HCATrans 308
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The High Court was required to determine whether the program schedule data, as presented by IceTV, constituted a literary work or a dramatic work in which copyright subsisted. Further, the court had to consider whether Nine Network's use of this data, in creating its own electronic program guide, amounted to an infringement of any copyright held by IceTV. The central question was whether the compilation of program information, including titles, descriptions, and broadcast times, was sufficiently original to attract copyright protection and, if so, whether Nine Network's actions constituted unlawful copying.
The High Court, by majority, held that the program schedule data, as compiled and presented by IceTV, did not possess the requisite originality to be protected as a literary work under the Copyright Act 1968 (Cth). The court reasoned that the information contained within the schedules was largely factual and descriptive, and the arrangement and expression of this information did not demonstrate sufficient intellectual creativity or labour to meet the threshold for originality. While acknowledging that compilations can attract copyright, the court found that the degree of skill and labour involved in IceTV's schedules was not sufficient to elevate them to the status of a copyrightable work. Consequently, Nine Network's use of the data did not constitute copyright infringement.
Background
Background to the litigation
The weekly schedules created by Nine Network were the result of significant skill, labour, and decision-making processes. These schedules were not mere listings of program titles but involved the association of specific programs with particular broadcast times, a process that Nine Network argued was original and protected under copyright law. The schedules were prepared as a step-by-step process, taking into account statutory obligations, viewer entertainment, and advertising revenue considerations. The schedules were eventually compiled into a written document, available in both paper and computer formats.
IceTV contended that the weekly schedules were not original enough to warrant copyright protection. They argued that the schedules were simply collections of known facts and did not meet the originality threshold required for copyright protection. Additionally, IceTV claimed that even if the schedules were original, their use of the time and title information did not constitute a substantial reproduction because they did not replicate the form or arrangement of the schedules.
The legal dispute centred on whether the skill and labour invested in creating the weekly schedules endowed them with originality and whether IceTV's use of the time and title information amounted to a substantial reproduction of Nine Network's work. The case highlighted the complexities of determining originality and substantial reproduction in the context of compilations and literary works in the digital age.
The matter of IceTV Pty Ltd & Anor v Nine Network Australia Pty Limited came before the High Court of Australia as an application for special leave to appeal. This application followed the decision of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia, which had upheld the judgment of the primary judge, Justice Bennett, who found that IceTV had not infringed Nine Network's copyright in their weekly program schedules. The primary judge's decision was overturned by the Full Court, leading to IceTV's appeal. The case revolves around whether IceTV's aggregation of program guides, which included time and title information from Nine Network's schedules, constituted a substantial reproduction of Nine Network's copyright work. The Full Court held that it did, but this was contested by IceTV, leading to the current application for special leave to appeal to the High Court. The application was heard by Gummow, Kirby, and Kiefel JJ, who ultimately granted the special leave to appeal, allowing the case to proceed to a full hearing in the High Court.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the skill and labour invested in the decision to screen particular programs at particular times can be considered as originality in the context of copyright law.
2. Whether the weekly schedules prepared by Nine Network Australia Pty Limited are considered a literary work under Australian copyright law.
3. Whether the IceTV Guide involves or contains a substantial reproduction of the weekly schedules, considering the importance and originality of the parts taken.
4. How the concept of originality should be interpreted in the context of digital and electronic works under Australian copyright law.
5. Whether the Full Court's decision correctly applied the principles of copyright law in assessing the infringement of Nine Network Australia Pty Limited's weekly schedules by IceTV Pty Ltd.
Held
1. The court concluded that the skill and labour invested in the decision to screen particular programs at particular times can indeed be considered as originality in the context of copyright law. The result was that this finding supported the originality of Nine Network Australia Pty Limited's weekly schedules.
2. The court found that the weekly schedules prepared by Nine Network Australia Pty Limited are considered a literary work under Australian copyright law. The result was the affirmation of the literary nature of these schedules.
3. The court determined that the IceTV Guide involved or contained a substantial reproduction of the weekly schedules. The court found the importance and originality of the parts taken satisfied the test for substantial reproduction. The result was a finding of copyright infringement by IceTV Pty Ltd.
4. The court interpreted the concept of originality in the context of digital and electronic works under Australian copyright law, emphasizing that the originality of a work is not negated by its electronic format. The result was that the form of the work (electronic or otherwise) does not affect its originality.
5. The court concluded that the Full Court's decision correctly applied the principles of copyright law in assessing the infringement of Nine Network Australia Pty Limited's weekly schedules by IceTV Pty Ltd. The result was the affirmation of the Full Court's decision and the allowance of special leave to appeal.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court's reasoning in this case revolves around the principles of originality, substantiality, and the nature of copyright works, particularly in the context of television broadcast schedules. The key issue was whether the weekly schedules prepared by Nine Network Australia Pty Limited constituted a literary work under Australian copyright law, and if so, whether IceTV Pty Ltd's reproduction of substantial parts of these schedules constituted copyright infringement.
First, the court examined the originality of Nine Network's weekly schedules. The Full Court had found that the skill and labour invested in determining which programs would be screened at particular times contributed to the schedules' originality. The court agreed with the respondent that this was consistent with established authority, including the House of Lords decision in Ladbroke. The court emphasized that the originality in question did not stem from the mere collection of known facts but rather from the creative decisions involved in the scheduling process. This included considerations such as statutory obligations, viewer entertainment, and advertising revenue generation. The court held that the schedules, though in a digital format, were essentially a literary work in the form of a compilation.
Second, the court considered whether the IceTV Guide involved or contained a substantial reproduction of Nine Network's weekly schedules. The Full Court had found that the IceTV Guide took more than half of the time and title information each day, which the court deemed to be the critical information. The importance and originality of the parts taken were central to the court's assessment. The court noted that the parts copied by IceTV were those that they could not predict, reflecting changes to the ongoing schedule and embodying the highest degree of originality. The court rejected the argument that the parts taken were merely preparatory work not contributing to the final copyright work.
Third, the court discussed the interpretation of originality in the context of digital and electronic works. The court observed that while there were similarities with the approach in the United States, particularly the Feist decision, this case did not involve commonplace information but rather the original creation of a schedule that functioned as a "game plan" or "menu" for the station. The court distinguished the case from Feist, emphasizing that the schedules were not a mere collection of known facts but an original creation.
Fourth, the court assessed how the Full Court had applied the principles of copyright law. The court acknowledged that the trial judge had reached a different conclusion, but it found that the Full Court correctly identified errors in the trial judge's reasoning. The Full Court rightly rejected the trial judge's dismissal of the preparatory work as non-contributory to the final copyright work and her misunderstanding of the test for substantial reproduction.
Finally, the court considered the concept of "causal connection" and the notion of "look, feel, and content" in the context of copyright infringement. The court noted that while these terms were not found in the Copyright Act, they were used in the advertising industry. The court emphasized that the critical factor was the substantial reproduction of original parts of the schedules, regardless of whether the reproduction bore significant similarities in look, feel, and content. The court concluded that the Full Court's focus on the importance and originality of the parts taken, rather than the form or appearance of the reproduction, was correct.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that the skill and labour invested in the decision to screen particular programs at particular times can contribute to the originality of weekly television schedules, which can be considered literary works under Australian copyright law. Substantial reproduction of the time and title information, which embodies the highest degree of originality, constitutes copyright infringement. The court's approach to originality in the digital age emphasizes the creative decisions involved in the production process, rather than the mere collection of known facts.