Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: IAG Limited t/as NRMA Insurance v McBlane [2019] NSWSC 1789 Hearing dates: 6 November 2019 Date of orders: 13 December 2019 Decision date: 13 December 2019 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Lonergan J Decision: (1) The decision of Assessor Robert Foggo dated 23 April 2019 is set aside.
(2) The matter is remitted to the second defendant for determination by a different claims assessor according to law.
(3) The first defendant is to pay the plaintiff’s costs.Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – judicial review – assessment of damages under Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW) – adequacy of reasons – reasons inadequate Legislation Cited: Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW), s 69, 94, 95, 106, 122, 123, 126 Cases Cited: Allianz Australia Insurance Limited v Sprod [2012] NSWCA 281
Allianz Australia Limited v Kerr (2012) 83 NSWLR 302
IAG Limited v Priestly [2019] NSWSC 1185
Minister for Immigration v Li (2013) 249 CLR 332; [2013] HCA 18
Nominal Defendant v Livaja [2011] NSWCA 121
Zahed v IAG Limited trading as NRMA Insurance and Ors (2016) 75 MVR 1Category: Principal judgment Parties: IAG Limited t/as NRMA Insurance (Plaintiff)
Kaycee Lee McBlane (First Defendant)
State Insurance Regulatory Authority (Second Defendant)
Robert Foggo, in his capacity as a Claims Assessor of SIRA (Third Defendant)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
M Robinson SC/J Gumbert (Plaintiff)
E Romaniuk SC/G Young (First Defendant)
Submitting appearances (Second and Third Defendants)
Hall & Wilcox (Plaintiff)
Schreuders Lawyers (First Defendant)
Crown Solicitor’s Office (Second and Third Defendants)
File Number(s): 2019/226963 Publication restriction: Nil
Judgment
-
The plaintiff is a compulsory third party liability insurer under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW) (“the Act”). It seeks judicial review of a decision of a claims assessor of the State Insurance Regulatory Authority of NSW (“SIRA”) dated 23 April 2019.
-
The decision in question is titled “Reasons for Decision – General Assessment” (“the Reasons”) and is stated to be issued in accordance with s 94(5) of the Act. It assesses damages under specific heads of damage said to have arisen from injuries said to have been sustained by the first defendant, Ms McBlane (“the claimant”), in a motor accident on 21 October 2015.
-
Liability for damages was admitted but, as stated in paragraph [2] of the Reasons, “the insurer disputes the damages sought by the claimant”.
-
Ultimately an award of damages was assessed in the sum of $160,326.65. One component of that award was a “buffer” of $85,000 for loss of future earning capacity inclusive of loss of superannuation.
-
In the Summons filed on 22 July 2019 the plaintiff seeks:
An order in the nature of certiorari, or a declaration, setting aside or declaring invalid the decision of the claims assessor;
An order in the nature of prohibition or an injunction preventing the defendants or any of their agents or officers from taking any active step in reliance on the decision; and
An order in the nature of mandamus remitting the matter to the second defendant…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read IAG Limited t/as NRMA Insurance v McBlane and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NSWSC 1789
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether the reasons provided by the insurer were adequate in the context of judicial review and whether they sufficiently addressed the factors relevant to the assessment of damages under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW). The court was required to determine if the reasons met the legal standard of being adequate, comprehensible, and sufficient to enable the insurer's decision-making process to be reviewed.
The court found that the insurer's reasons for its assessment of damages were inadequate. It held that the reasons did not adequately address the relevant factors and did not provide sufficient information for the court to review the decision. The reasons were deemed not to meet the standard required for judicial review, as they failed to demonstrate a clear and reasoned approach to the assessment of damages. Consequently, the court concluded that the insurer's reasons were inadequate and did not provide the necessary basis for judicial review. The decision was made in favour of McBlane, the policyholder.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court as an application for judicial review. The application was brought by IAG Limited to challenge the decision of the MAA regarding the assessment of damages under the Motor Accidents Compensation Act 1999 (NSW). The court had to consider whether the reasons provided by the MAA were adequate. Prior to this application, the MAA had conducted a hearing and issued a decision, which IAG Limited sought to overturn on the basis of inadequate reasoning. The primary focus of the judicial review was on the procedural fairness and the adequacy of the reasons provided by the MAA for their assessment of damages awarded to Ms McBlane.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the reasons provided by the Motor Accidents Authority for their assessment of damages were adequate.
2. Whether the decision of the Motor Accidents Authority was subject to judicial review on the basis of inadequate reasons.
Held
1. The reasons provided by the Motor Accidents Authority for their assessment of damages were not adequate. The Court concluded that the reasons given by the Authority did not sufficiently explain how they reached their conclusion on the assessment of damages.
2. The decision of the Motor Accidents Authority was subject to judicial review on the basis of inadequate reasons. The Court found that the inadequacy of the reasons provided by the Authority was a sufficient ground for judicial review.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Court held that the reasons provided by the Motor Accidents Authority for their assessment of damages were inadequate. The reasons were criticised for being brief and lacking in detail. The Court noted that the reasons did not provide sufficient insight into the Authority's decision-making process, including how the Authority evaluated the evidence and applied the relevant legal principles. The Court emphasised that when assessing damages, the Authority must provide clear and sufficient reasons that justify the outcome reached. The Court referred to prior cases which established the necessity for detailed reasons in administrative decision-making to ensure transparency and accountability.
The Court further determined that the inadequacy of the reasons provided by the Authority was a valid ground for judicial review. The Court reiterated that judicial review is available to ensure that administrative decisions are made in accordance with the law and that reasons for decisions are adequate. The Court noted that while the threshold for judicial review in administrative law is generally high, where reasons are so inadequate as to render the decision-making process opaque, this can be a sufficient ground for review. The Court's decision was consistent with established principles of administrative law in Australia, which require decision-makers to provide adequate reasons for their decisions to enable effective scrutiny and accountability.