HYHY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 21 min read

HYHY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2024] AATA 3226 (29 August 2024)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2023/7261

Re:HYHY  

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndNQZM

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:Member L M Gallagher

Date:29 August 2024

Place:Perth

The Reviewable Decision, being the decision of the AAT1 dated 1 September 2023, that there was no change in the care of the child from 23 May 2022, is affirmed.

......................[Sgd].........................

Member L M Gallagher

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988.
CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – actual care – date of effect – evidence – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) ss 87AA(1), 95N(1), 95N(2)
Child Support (Assessment) Act 1989 (Cth) ss 49, 49(1)(a), 49(1)(b), 50, 50(1)(a), 50(1)(b), 50(3), 51, 54A(1), 54A(3), 54B, 54F, 54G, 54G(2), 54H, 54F(3), 54H(3), 55C
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 43(6)

CASES
Minister for Home Affairs v G and Another [2019] FCAFC 79
Polec & Staker & Anor [2011] FMCAfam 959
P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312
P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98
Parent 1 and Child Support Registrar and Parent 2 [2013] AATA 562
Beadle and Director-General of Social Security (1984) 6 ALD 1, 3; [1984] AATA 176; (1985) 7 ALD 670)
Groth v Secretary, Department of Social Security [1995] FCA 1708; (1995) 40 ALD 541, 545
Boscolo v Secretary, Department of Social Security [1999] FCA 106 1999) 90 FCR 531 [18]
Dranichnikov v Centrelink [2003] FCAFC 133 [66] [2003] FCAFC 133; (2003) 75 ALD 134, 148;
Angelakos and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations [2007] FCA 25
Davy and Secretary, Department of Employment and Workplace Relations [2007] AATA 1114
Afghani and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2017] AATA 410
Shanhun and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2016] AATA 675
Singleton and Secretary, Department of Social Services [2019] AATA 766

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member L M Gallagher

29 August 2024

THE APPLICATION

  1. The Applicant seeks review of a decision of the Social Services & Child Support Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal, (AAT1) dated 1 September 2023 (the Reviewable Decision).[1]  The Reviewable Decision: [2]

    (a)Set aside a decision of an objections officer on behalf of the Respondent (objections officer) dated 24 April 2023, which had the effect of reflecting that the Applicant had 0% care and the Other Party had 0% care of the child from 23 May 2022.

    (b)In substitution, decided that:

    (i)There was no change of care of the child from 23 May 2022.

    (ii)The Other Party retained 100% care.

    [1]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HYHY and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] AATA 3226
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding a child support case between the Applicant and the Other Party, the separated parents of a 16-year-old child. The dispute centred on the percentage of care each parent had for the child, specifically whether there had been a change in care from 23 May 2022. An existing determination stipulated that the Other Party had 100% care and the Applicant 0% care from 26 November 2018. The Applicant notified Services Australia on 23 November 2022 that the child had been living with her grandparents 100% of the time since 23 May 2022. A delegate of the Child Support Registrar subsequently revoked the existing determination and made a new one stating both parties had 0% care from 23 May 2022. The Other Party objected to this decision, asserting she had maintained 100% care throughout.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether there had been a change in the child's care arrangements between 23 May 2022 and 13 January 2023, and if so, the date from which any such change took effect. The Applicant contended that neither parent had care during this period, with the child staying with friends and family. Conversely, the Other Party maintained that she retained 100% care, even when the child stayed with friends, her boyfriend, or her grandmother.

The Tribunal considered the oral and documentary evidence presented by both parties. It found the Other Party's account of her care arrangements to be consistent and internally coherent, supported by documentary evidence. The Tribunal considered the Other Party to be a credible witness who provided a clear historical account of her care responsibilities. While acknowledging that the child sometimes stayed with friends, the child's boyfriend, or her grandmother, the Tribunal accepted that the Other Party remained the child's primary carer and was responsible for her during these absences. The Tribunal was satisfied that the Other Party had 100% care of the child during the period in question.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the existing care percentage determination, finding that the Other Party had 100% care of the child and the Applicant had 0% care.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal also notes at the outset that there are no date of effect issues in this matter, as both the objection and the application for review to the AAT1 were both lodged within time. BACKGROUND The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of the child, who is currently 16 years old. A child support case has been in place for the child since 10 August 2010.[7][7] R1, T64, p 238. On 6 August 2018, a child support case recommenced in relation to the child.[8] The Applicant was the paying parent and the Other Party was the receiving parent.[9][8] R1, T64, p 238.[9] R1, T64, p 237. The existing care determination was that the Other Party had 100% care of the child, and the Applicant had 0% care of the child, from 26 November 2018[10] (existing care percentage determination).[10] R1, T64, p 234. On 23 November 2022, the Applicant notified Services Australia (Agency) that from 23 May 2022 the child had been living with her grandparents 100% of the time.[11] The Applicant also advised the Agency on this date that he was unsure if the child is financially dependent on the Other Party.[12][11] R1, T14, p 136.[12] R1, T14, p 136. The Agency’s three attempts to contact the Other Party for a response were unsuccessful.[13][13] R1, T24, p 148. On 6 December 2022, a delegate of the Registrar revoked the existing care percentage determination and determined that the Applicant had 0% care and the Other Party had 0% care of the children from 23 May 2022[14] (original decision).[14] R1, T25 and T26. On 17 December 2022, the Other Party objected to the original decision on the basis that she had 100% care of the child from and prior to 23 May 2022.[15] The Other Party lodged the following documents with her objection:[15] R1, T32, pp 168 and 169. The objection was lodged within the 28 day time frame for doing so: R1, T25, p 150.(a)Affidavit of SJ (recorded on the affidavit as the child’s stepfather), attesting the child lived at the Other Party’s address since 25 May 2022.[16][16] R1, T32, p 170.(b)Affidavit of NT (recorded on the affidavit as the child’s uncle), attesting the same.[17][17] R1, T32, p 171.(c)Correspondence from a distance education provider, confirming the child was offered enrolment in their school and for the child to attend their distance education programme in Term 4 of 2022.[18][18] R1, T32, p 173.(d)On 23 January 2023, the Other Party advised the objections officer that there was no change of care from 23 May 2022, that she continues to be the child’s primary carer and that she had no idea why the Applicant advised this change.[19] The Other Party also advised the objections officer that the child was attending formal home-schooling with a college.[20][19] R1, T38, p 182.[20] R1, T38, p 182.(e)On 24 January 2023, the Applicant advised the objections officer that:(i)His wife was advised by his sister in law that the child left the Other Party’s care on 23 May 2022.[21](ii)The child stays with her maternal grandmother and her sister, MG.[22](iii)He did not have evidence of these matters at that stage as he does not have contact with the Other Party of her family.[23](f)Later on 24 January 2023, the Other Party advised the Objections Officer that:(i)The child has not left her care.[24](ii)During the school holidays, the child stays at friend’s houses.[25][21] R1, T40, p 185.[22] R1, T40, p 186.[23] R1, T40, p 185. As at the date of the Applicant’s call to the objections officer, the child was 15 years old and was able to speak to what was going on. The objections officer advised the Applicant that she was unable to accept evidence from a person under 18 (R1, T40, p 186).[24] R1, T41, p 187.[25] R1, T41, p 187.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal is satisfied that all the relevant evidence was before the Tribunal and that the parties were provided an opportunity to address it, either orally or in writing.The parties’ evidence The Applicant and the Other Party gave evidence and made submissions in support of their respective positions, in writing and orally at hearing. [50][50] See within R1 and transcript, pp 6 to 24.The Applicant As to what led the Applicant to advise the Agency on 23 November 2022 that the child had been living with her grandmother 100% of the time since 23 May 2022, the Applicant said around Christmas 2022, the child had told him that:(a)she did not live with her mother; (b)had not lived with her mother “for ages”;(c)she just lived with friends “and stuff like that”; and(d)her mother did not provide her with any money “for stuff.” The Applicant also said his sister in law had vouched for the same when he had spoken to her prior on the telephone. As to who had care of the child during the period 23 May 2022 to 13 January 2023, the Applicant said the child was just “couch-surfing” between friends, as well as staying with his friend, NT. When asked if he was in contact with the child during this period (23 May 2022 to 13 January 2023), the Applicant said he had spoken with her on the phone every now and then. The Applicant said that the child had told him during these discussions that she was living with her boyfriend 24 hours a day, seven days a week. When asked, the Applicant said that during the period 22 May 2022 to 12 January 2023, he did not have any care of the child. The Applicant said that during the period 22 May 2022 to 12 January 2023, the child was making her own decisions regarding her health, education, personal behaviours and responsibilities, and her recreational and social activities. As to who was providing emotional support to the child during this period, the Applicant said “probably just her boyfriend and friends, I suppose.”[51][51] Transcript, p 11. As to meeting the costs of the child’s health care, clothing and food, the Applicant said that the child’s sister MG and her grandmother were probably paying for these things. The Other Party When asked, the Other Party said she disagreed with the proposition put by the Applicant on 23 November 2022 that the child had been living with her grandparents 100% of the time since 23 May 2022 and said that rather, during the period 23 May 2022 to 13 January 2023, she had 100% care of the child. The Other Party added that during this period, the child was living with her in a caravan at a caravan park in [regional Western Australia]. The Other Party explained that when the caravan park closed on approximately the 29th or 30th November 2022, she moved in with her partner. At that time, the child moved in with her and her partner, where the child would stay for three or four nights of the week and stay at one of her good friend’s houses on the other nights. The Other Party said that during this period, the child stayed with her grandmother for two or three nights at a maximum and also sometimes with NT, although the Other Party would be present for the overnight stays with NT. The Other Party said that during the time when the child was living with her at her partner’s house and also “cruising around,” she was the child’s primary carer the whole time.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 6 December 2022, a delegate of the Registrar revoked the existing care percentage determination and determined that the Applicant had 0% care and the Other Party had 0% care of the children from 23 May 2022[14] (original decision).[14] R1, T25 and T26. On 17 December 2022, the Other Party objected to the original decision on the basis that she had 100% care of the child from and prior to 23 May 2022.[15] The Other Party lodged the following documents with her objection:[15] R1, T32, pp 168 and 169. The objection was lodged within the 28 day time frame for doing so: R1, T25, p 150.(a)Affidavit of SJ (recorded on the affidavit as the child’s stepfather), attesting the child lived at the Other Party’s address since 25 May 2022.[16][16] R1, T32, p 170.(b)Affidavit of NT (recorded on the affidavit as the child’s uncle), attesting the same.[17][17] R1, T32, p 171.(c)Correspondence from a distance education provider, confirming the child was offered enrolment in their school and for the child to attend their distance education programme in Term 4 of 2022.[18][18] R1, T32, p 173.(d)On 23 January 2023, the Other Party advised the objections officer that there was no change of care from 23 May 2022, that she continues to be the child’s primary carer and that she had no idea why the Applicant advised this change.[19] The Other Party also advised the objections officer that the child was attending formal home-schooling with a college.[20][19] R1, T38, p 182.[20] R1, T38, p 182.(e)On 24 January 2023, the Applicant advised the objections officer that:(i)His wife was advised by his sister in law that the child left the Other Party’s care on 23 May 2022.[21](ii)The child stays with her maternal grandmother and her sister, MG.[22](iii)He did not have evidence of these matters at that stage as he does not have contact with the Other Party of her family.[23](f)Later on 24 January 2023, the Other Party advised the Objections Officer that:(i)The child has not left her care.[24](ii)During the school holidays, the child stays at friend’s houses.[25][21] R1, T40, p 185.[22] R1, T40, p 186.[23] R1, T40, p 185. As at the date of the Applicant’s call to the objections officer, the child was 15 years old and was able to speak to what was going on. The objections officer advised the Applicant that she was unable to accept evidence from a person under 18 (R1, T40, p 186).[24] R1, T41, p 187.[25] R1, T41, p 187. On 24 January 2023, the Other Party provided a statement with her mother’s details, stating that the child does not live with her maternal grandmother and rather, lives with her (the Other Party).[26][26] R1, T43, p 189. On 27 February 2023, the Applicant advised the Agency by email that:[27](a)He spoke to the child at Christmas time, at which time the child told him she lives between family and friends and rarely sees the Other Party.(b)SJ is not the child’s step father and is no relative to the child.(c)The child is now with her elder sister MG.[27] R1, T51, p 201.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to the child’s schooling arrangements in 2022, the Other Party explained she was enrolled at a high school during terms 1, 2 and 3 of 2022 where she was bullied daily and moved to formal home schooling by distance education in term 4 of 2022. The Other Party gave evidence to the effect that at this time, decisions regarding the child’s schooling, healthcare, behaviour, recreational or social activities and meeting the costs of her care (food, accommodation, clothing) were exclusively met by her.CONSIDERATIONWhether the existing care percentage determination should be revoked and replaced The first matter for the Tribunal’s consideration is whether the existing care percentage determination that the Other Party had 100% care of the child, and the Applicant had 0% care of the child, with effect from 26 November 2018, should be revoked and replaced. If not, then the existing percentage of care determination remains in place and that ends the Tribunal’s consideration of the matter. This requires the Tribunal to determine what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party each had of the child during the care period, and, if there was a change in care, from what date that change in care occurred.Was there a change in care? If so, on what date did the change in care occur and what is the date of effect? The Tribunal is of the view that the relevant period for consideration is the period between 23 May 2022 (the Applicant’s nominated date that he claims the actual care of the child changed) and 13 January 2023 (the day before the new care percentage determination came into effect, which is not in dispute) (the care period). The Applicant and the Other Party disagree as to whether a change in care occurred:· The Other Party maintains that she had 100% care of the child during the care period, in accordance with the existing care percentage determination.· The Applicant maintains that during the care period, both he and the Other Party each had 0% care of the child and that rather, the child was in the care of others at this time. The Tribunal has considered the documentary evidence before the Tribunal in the present matter as to the amount of care. In particular, the Tribunal relies upon the Applicant’s and the Other Party’s oral accounts at hearing and supporting documentary evidence referred to in this decision. The Tribunal is satisfied that the Other Party has been consistent over time regarding her claimed actual care that she had during the care period and that her documentary evidence is internally consistent with her oral claims. The Tribunal also considered the Other Party to be a credible witness, who gave a clear historical account of her own recollection of her care of the child during the care period, without seeking to conceal the arrangements whereby the child was staying with friends, her boyfriend or her grandmother instead of herself. The Tribunal accepts that at these times of absence from the Other Party’s and her partner’s home, the Other Party was still responsible for, and the primary carer of, the child.