Hutson v Australian Securities and Investments Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hutson v Australian Securities and Investments Commission & Anor [2023] QCA 167

PARTIES:

JENNIFER JOAN HUTSON
(appellant)
v
AUSTRALIAN SECURITIES AND INVESTMENTS COMMISSION
(first respondent)
JUDGE FARR SC
(second respondent)

FILE NO/S:

Appeal No 15498 of 2022
SC No 14915 of 2021

DIVISION:

Court of Appeal

PROCEEDING:

General Civil Appeal

ORIGINATING COURT:


Supreme Court at Brisbane – [2022] QSC 243 (Crowley J)

DELIVERED ON:

22 August 2023

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

17 April 2023; 18 April 2023

JUDGES:

Mullins P, Dalton JA and Henry J

ORDERS:

1.   Appeal dismissed.

2.    The appellant must pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

PROCEDURE – STATE AND TERRITORY COURTS: JURISDICTION, POWERS AND GENERALLY – DECLARATIONS – CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS – GENERALLY – where the appellant was charged on two indictments in the District Court alleging contraventions of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) and counts contrary to the Criminal Code (Qld) – where the second indictment contains counts of giving false or misleading information in compulsory examinations of the appellant by ASIC contrary to the Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth) (the ASIC Act) – where the appellant applied to the District Court for a pre-trial ruling under s 590AA of the Code for a permanent stay of both indictments on the basis that ASIC’s purported exercise of power under s 19 of the ASIC Act to compulsorily examine the appellant was unlawful – where the District Court dismissed the stay application – where the appellant applied to the Supreme Court for declaratory relief that the compulsory examinations were unlawful and that the pre-trial ruling erred in concluding the compulsory examinations were lawful and in the construction of s 49(1) of the ASIC Act – where the Supreme Court exercised its supervisory jurisdiction by determining issues of law and fact including the construction and application of s 19 and s 49(1) of the ASIC Act – whether it is in the interests of justice that issues of law and fact should be determined by means of declaratory relief in the exercise of the Supreme Court’s supervisory jurisdiction over criminal proceedings where like issues were the subject of the pre-trial ruling

Australian Securities and Investments Commission Act 2001 (Cth), s 19, s 49, s 63, s 68
Criminal Code (Qld), s 590AA, s 668A, s 669A

Anderson v Attorney-General (NSW) (1987) 10 NSWLR 198, considered
Emanuel Exports Pty Ltd v Department of Primary Industries and Regional Development [2023] WASCA 36, cited
Gedeon v Commissioner of the New South Wales Crime Commission (2008) 236 CLR 120; [2008] HCA 43, cited
Grierson v The King (1938) 60 CLR 431; [1938] HCA 45, cited
Lacey v Attorney-General (Qld) (2011) 242 CLR 573; [2011] HCA 10, cited
Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs v B (2004) 219 CLR 365; [2004] HCA 20, cited
R v Chardon [2017] 1 Qd R 148; [2016] QCA 50, cited
R v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hutson v Australian Securities and Investments Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QCA 167
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hutson v Australian Securities and Investments Commission, the appellant, who was charged on two indictments in the District Court, sought a permanent stay of proceedings on the basis that ASIC's exercise of power under the ASIC Act to compulsorily examine her was unlawful. The appellant applied for declaratory relief in the Supreme Court, arguing that the compulsory examinations were unlawful and that the pre-trial ruling erred in concluding the examinations were lawful and in the construction of s 49(1) of the ASIC Act. The legal issues before the court were whether it was in the interests of justice for the Supreme Court to determine the issues of law and fact raised by the application for declaratory relief in the exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction over criminal proceedings, and whether the compulsory examinations were unlawful.

The court found that the primary judge should not have embarked on a consideration of the construction and application of s 49 of the ASIC Act. The strongest factor in support of the Supreme Court’s embarking on the substantive issues of law and fact raised on the application for declaratory relief was that, if the Court concluded that the compulsory examinations of the appellant were unlawful and allowed the appeal, it would be untenable for the CDPP to proceed with the charges on the second indictment. There is a significant public interest in obtaining a definitive construction of s 49(1) of the ASIC Act.

The court dismissed the appeal and ordered that the appellant must pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal dismissed.

2. The appellant must pay the first respondent’s costs of the appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Judge Farr SC was excused from appearing in the appeal except as to the question of costs.Factual background The primary judge adopted (at [18] of the reasons) ASIC’s investigative chronology set out at [20]-[34] of the pre-trial ruling (with footnotes omitted) as follows:“[20] From July 2015 ASIC began to monitor, and then investigate, the circumstances of a takeover bid for Affinity by G8. The applicant was a director and chairperson of G8. Shares in Affinity were purchased in tranches between 13 and 28 July 2015 by a third company, West Bridge Holdings Pty Ltd (West Bridge).[21]The substantive charges, representing Counts 1 – 13 on Indictment 156/21, in substance allege that between 13 July 2015 and 2 September 2015 the applicant breached provisions of the Corporations Act and Criminal Code (Qld) when she acquired a sum of money from G8 to fund West Bridge’s purchase of Affinity shares, authorised the transfer of other funds, authorised the purchase of shares with surplus funds, and, in a number of documents lodged with the Australian Stock Exchange, failed to accurately disclose G8’s ‘relevant interest’ in Affinity. The applicant denies each of those allegations.[22]Although an investigation was not formally ‘commenced’ under s. 13 of the ASIC Act until 12 January 2016, ASIC began monitoring the applicant’s activities in around July 2015 as part of a Takeovers Panel investigation. Her actions were referred for criminal investigation within ASIC in November 2015.[23]From August 2015, ASIC issued numerous statutory notices compelling relevant persons and entities to provide information, personal and company records and to furnish written statements, and, in turn, filed this material with the Takeovers Panel in support of its submissions. By September 2015, those statutory notices referred to ASIC’s allegations of contraventions of the Corporations Act. And by 9 October 2015, ASIC set out the extensive nature of its ‘investigative effort’ in its submissions on costs to the Takeovers Panel.[24]The Takeovers Panel made its decision on 5 October 2015 and delivered written findings shortly thereafter. Following the release of the Takeovers Panel draft written reasons, members of ASIC’s Markets Enforcement Team referred the matter to the Corporations and Corporate Governance Enforcement Team (CCG). That referral, dated 2 November 2015, alleged that, on the basis of ‘useful and relevant evidence from relevant parties’ that ASIC had already acquired, the ‘key documents’ returned under statutory notices issued by ASIC, and the ‘key assessments of the facts relevant to this referral’ in the Takeovers Panel’s draft reasons, G8 and its directors had, respectively, contravened ss. 606 and 184(2)(a) of the Corporations Act.[25]On 13 November 2015, Ms Kelly Rogers, senior lawyer within the CCG, recommended the acceptance of the referral. In support of that recommendation she noted that,ASIC has the benefit of the Panel’s decision and legal analysis and the evidence and submissions put to the Panel by the parties, which reduces the extent of the ‘fact finding’ that needs to be undertaken.[26]On 12 January 2016 a s.13 file note signed by a Mr Brendan Caridi (Caridi), as delegate of ASIC, recorded the formal ‘commencement’ of an investigation ‘re trading in the securities of Affinity Education Group between 2 July and 21 October 2015’. In the days and weeks that followed, ASIC issued dozens more statutory notices. Between 26 February 2016 and 24 March 2016, ASIC compulsorily examined six different people.[27]By 5 April 2016, ASIC investigators noted in email correspondence that they had commenced drafting witness statements for inclusion in a brief of evidence to the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP). In affidavit evidence now filed in this Court, investigators state that these witness statements were prepared for the purpose of ‘the commencement of criminal proceedings against the defendant’ and ‘were not created for any other purpose’.[28]On 29 April 2016, ASIC investigators wrote to the applicant offering her a cautioned record of interview. On 5 May 2016, the applicant exercised her common law right to decline to participate in that interview.[29]On 6 May 2016, ASIC officers Matthew Bastianon (Bastianon), Peter Paleologos (Paleologos) and Caridi issued a notice to the applicant, pursuant to s. 19 of the ASIC Act (the s. 19 notice) requiring her to attend and participate at a compulsory examination. ASIC informed the applicant that a failure to comply with the s. 19 notice constituted a criminal offence.[30]On 25 May 2016, the examination took place (the May examination). At the conclusion of the May examination, the examiner adjourned the examination to a date to be fixed.[31]On 6 June 2016, by email, ASIC notified the applicant, via her lawyers, that ASIC sought to resume the previously adjourned examination. The examination was resumed on 22 June 2016 and concluded that day (the June examination).[32]Following these examinations, ASIC continued to exercise what Bastianon described as its investigative powers. Those powers included ASIC engaging in the following:(a)interviewing three prospective witnesses pursuant to s.19 (interviewed between 21 June 2017 and 12 March 2019);(b)interviewing numerous other prospective witnesses voluntarily;(c)issuing 16 notices requiring the production of documents (issued between 8 July 2016 and 27 March 2018);(d)obtaining signed witness statements from 27 witnesses (obtained between 15 July 2016 and 12 March 2019);(e)obtaining and executing seven s.3A Crimes Act search warrants (executed on 18 August 2016 on the residences and vehicles of the applicant and another and on the business premises of Wellington Capital Limited);(f)reviewing, collating, copying and considering the documents produced as a result of each of the above steps; and(g)preparing the brief of evidence for submission to the CDPP.[33]ASIC referred the brief of evidence to the CDPP on 22 November 2016 to enable the Director to determine whether the applicant should be charged, and, if so, what charges should be laid.[34]The applicant was charged in February 2018.”

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court in Emanuel noted (at [41]) that a determination of the constitutional question would likely create further delay in the trial of the charges and jeopardise the hearing of the trial on the listed dates in November and December 2023, particularly if the dissatisfied party were inclined to apply for special leave to appeal to the High Court. The Court therefore concluded (at [42]) that the interests of justice favoured allowing the trial to proceed on its ordinary course and leaving the constitutional question to be resolved on any appeal against a decision to convict or acquit Emanuel.Should the primary judge have embarked on a consideration of the construction and application of s 49 of the ASIC Act? The focus of the appellant’s submissions on the appeal was the proper construction of s 49 of the ASIC Act and its application to the appellant and ASIC in the circumstances that applied to the appellant when the s 19 examinations took place. No doubt the fact that the second indictment only alleges offences arising out of the answers that the appellant gave in the compulsory examinations gave impetus to the appellant’s pursuit of the declaratory relief after the unsuccessful pre-trial ruling. In the circumstances applicable to this case, the threshold question for the primary judge was whether it was in the interests of justice that the issues of law and fact agitated by the appellant in seeking declaratory relief from the Supreme Court should be determined in the exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction of criminal proceedings rather than allowing the criminal proceedings to follow the usual course. The strongest factor in support of the Supreme Court’s embarking on the substantive issues of law and fact raised on the application for declaratory relief is that, if this Court concluded that the compulsory examinations of the appellant were unlawful and allowed the appeal, that would in practical terms make it untenable for the CDPP to proceed with the charges on the second indictment and consideration would need to be given by the CDPP whether it was possible to pursue any of the charges on the first indictment. There is a mass of evidence that has been gathered in relation to the charges on the first indictment and the effect of unlawful compulsory examinations of the appellant would need to be evaluated in relation to the continuation of the criminal proceeding for those charges. Another factor in support of the Supreme Court’s exercising its supervisory jurisdiction to determine substantive issues raised by the application for declaratory relief is that there is a significant public interest in obtaining a definitive construction of s 49(1) of the ASIC Act. It is relevant that any trial on the second indictment can proceed only after there has been a trial on the first indictment where the trial may give rise to an opportunity to reopen the pre-trial ruling but, if not, and the appellant were to be convicted of any of the charges on the first indictment, there would be the opportunity, if the appellant were so advised, to appeal against conviction on the basis the pre-trial ruling was in error. That is another course open to address the significant public interest in the construction of s 49(1) of the ASIC Act.