Hutinel v Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Hutinel v Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd [2023] QIRC 085

PARTIES:

Hutinel, Tatiana
(Complainant)

v

Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

AD/2020/85

PROCEEDING:

Applications in existing proceedings

DELIVERED ON:

20 March 2023

HEARING DATE: 

16 August 2022

MEMBER:

HEARD AT:

O'Connor VP

Brisbane

ORDER:

1.    Pursuant to r 231(6) of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) AD/2020/85 is struck out.

CATCHWORDS:

HUMAN RIGHTS - DISCRIMINATION LEGISLATION - GENERALLY - where complaint from Queensland Human Rights Commission relates to work or the work‑related area - where complainant alleges impairment discrimination - where complainant failed to comply with the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) - where Industrial Registry issued notice to show cause as no action taken by the complainant for over one year - where matter may be struck out if no action taken for at least one year - where complainant sought complaint be held in abeyance - where respondent filed application to dismiss proceedings - where complainant shows no intention of prosecuting her complaint - whether further proceedings necessary or desirable in the public interest - whether respondent will be prejudiced if the proceedings are not dismissed - determined complaint be struck out.

LEGISLATION:

CASES:

APPEARANCES:

Industrial Relations Act 2016, s 3, s 451
Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld), r 5, r 6, r 45, r 230, r 231
Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, s 166

Campbell v State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney-General) [2019] ICQ 18
Gambaro v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2017] ICQ 005
Quaedvlieg and Ors v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Ltd (2005) 180 QGIG 1209
Quinlan v Rothwell [2002] 1 Qd R 647; [2001] QCA 176
Robertson v Hollings [2009] QCA 303

Ms T. Hutinel representing herself.

Ms S. Casey, Ashurst Australia, Solicitors for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

  1. Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd ('the Respondent')[1] in this matter filed an Application in existing proceedings to dismiss AD/2020/85 (the Discrimination Proceedings) on 13 September 2022.

    [1] The Respondent's Solicitors advised in their Outline of Argument filed on 18 October 2022 that GardenHouse Australia Pty Ltd, ACN 151 192 602 changed its business name on 7 August 2020 to 'Actor Pharmaceuticals Pty Ltd', [48].

  2. On 30 September 2022 Ms Tatiana Hutinel, ('the Complainant') filed an Application in existing proceedings enclosing two schedules: one in relation to the workers' compensation appeal proceedings (WC/2020/144) and one in relation to the Discrimination Proceedings (AD/2020/85).

  3. This decision refers to the Respondent's Application to dismiss in the first instance.  It is noted the Complainant's Application in existing proceedings was filed after the Respondent's Application to dismiss.  The following sets out the relevant circumstances of this matter.

    Background

  4. The Complainant made a complaint to the Queensland Human Rights Commission ('the QHRC') on 8 May 2020 ('the Complaint') and this was referred to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission ('the Commission') on 2 September 2020 under s 166(1)(a) of the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991 ('the AD Act').

  5. The Industrial Registry provided the parties with a copy…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hutinel v Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] QIRC 85
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Hutinel v Gardenhouse Australia Pty Ltd, the Respondent sought to dismiss the discrimination complaint filed by the Complainant, asserting that the proceedings had been unduly delayed. The case was heard by the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission, which has the authority to dismiss proceedings if it deems them to be trivial or unnecessary in the public interest. The primary legal issue before the Commission was whether the prolonged delay in the Complainant's proceedings justified the dismissal of the complaint under Rule 231 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld).

The Commission found that the Complainant had not adequately explained the delay or the merits of continuing with the proceedings. The Complainant had requested that the discrimination proceedings be held in abeyance pending the outcome of a related workers' compensation appeal, which was ultimately discontinued. The Commission noted that the Complainant's response to the Notice to Show Cause did not provide a satisfactory explanation for the delay and failed to address the requirements set out in Rule 231 of the IR (Tribunals) Rules. The Commission concluded that the Complainant's actions demonstrated a lack of commitment to pursuing the complaint and that the public interest was best served by dismissing the proceedings.

In light of the Complainant's failure to adequately address the delay and the merits of the proceedings, the Commission ordered that the discrimination complaint be struck out under Rule 231(6) of the IR (Tribunals) Rules. This decision underscores the importance of timely and diligent pursuit of claims and the Commission's role in ensuring the efficient use of its resources.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Pursuant to r 231(6) of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) AD/2020/85 is struck out.

Background

Background to the litigation

This decision refers to the Respondent's Application to dismiss in the first instance. It is noted the Complainant's Application in existing proceedings was filed after the Respondent's Application to dismiss. The following sets out the relevant circumstances of this matter.Background The Complainant made a complaint to the Queensland Human Rights Commission ('the QHRC') on 8 May 2020 ('the Complaint') and this was referred to the Queensland Industrial Relations Commission ('the Commission') on 2 September 2020 under s 166(1)(a) of the Anti‑Discrimination Act 1991 ('the AD Act'). The Industrial Registry provided the parties with a copy of the Referral made by the QHRC and issued Directions on 2 September 2020 for the parties to file and serve an application for leave to be represented. On 1 September 2020 the Complainant emailed the Industrial Registry (not through her solicitor), updating her contact details and advising, "I decided not to have the representation of Maurice Blackburn Lawyers in the second step of the process".The Complainant emailed the Industrial Registry on 3 September 2020 requesting that the Discrimination Proceedings be held in abeyance for the following reasons:a. in or about June 2020 the Complainant was too unwell to provide the Workers' Compensation Regulator ('the Regulator') with relevant documentation and comply with procedures; andb. the application for workers' compensation and the QHRC Complaint relate to the same employer and the 'same ownership group of companies'. Following the Complainant's email, the Industrial Registry on 3 September 2020 issued a Directions Order vacating the orders dated 2 September 2020 and advising the matter will be placed in abeyance until notified otherwise by the Complainant that she is ready to proceed. The Respondent submits they were not afforded an opportunity to respond to the Complainant's request before the matter was placed in abeyance by the Industrial Registry.[2][2] Respondent's outline of argument filed 18 October 2022, [11]. On 29 October 2020 the Complainant filed an appeal of the decision by the Regulator to reject her application for workers' compensation (WC/2020/144) ('the Workers' Compensation Claim') in the Commission. On 16 December 2020 the Industrial Registry emailed the Complainant seeking an update in relation to the Discrimination Proceedings. The Complainant responded on 17 December 2020 seeking the Discrimination Proceedings continue 'on hold in abeyance' until the finalisation of the Workcover appeal. On 7 March 2022, approximately 15 months after the last communication, the Respondent emailed the Industrial Registry noting that the matter had lapsed pursuant to r 230 of the Industrial Relations (Tribunals) Rules 2011 (Qld) ('the IR (Tribunals) Rules' and seeking that the Registrar take action under r 231(1) of the IR (Tribunals) Rules to strike the matter out. Rule 230 of the IR (Tribunals) Rules apply where no action has been taken by an applicant for at least one year and provides as follows:230 Lapse of proceeding after at least 1 year's delay(1) This rule applies if -(a) an application starting a proceeding has been filed; and(b)no action has been taken by the applicant in relation to the application for at least 1 year since the last action was taken by the applicant in the application.(2)A party may only take further action on the application with an order of the court, commission or registrar.(3)An application for an order under subrule (2) must be in the approved form and state the following -(a)the steps taken in the proceeding;(b)an explanation for the circumstances of the delay;(c)the steps (including a timetable) proposed to be taken to progress the proceeding;(d)any prejudice suffered or likely to be suffered by another party to the proceeding if the application starting the proceeding is not struck out;(e)the merits of the proceeding;(f)why the court, commission or registrar should make the order despite the delay.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commission has the power to dismiss the Complaint under s 541 of the IR Act which provides:541 Decisions generallyThe court or commission may, in an industrial cause do any of the following -(a)make a decision it considers just, and include provision for preventing or settling the industrial dispute or dealing with the industrial matter to which the cause relates, without being restricted to any specific relief claimed by the parties to the cause;(b)dismiss the cause, or refrain from hearing, further hearing, or deciding the cause, if the court or commission considers -(i) the cause is trivial; or(ii)further proceedings by the court or commission are not necessary or desirable in the public interest;(c)order a party to the cause to pay another party the expenses, including witness expenses, it considers appropriate. The Respondent submits the phrase "in the public interest" imports a discretionary value judgement and this is confined to the objects of the relevant legislation.[4] Section 3 of the IR Act provides the main purpose of the legislation is:[4] Campbell v State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney-General) [2019] ICQ 18, [24].3 Main purpose of ActThe main purpose of this Act is to provide for a framework for cooperative industrial relations that -(a) is fair and balanced; and(b)supports the delivery of high quality services, economic prosperity and social justice for Queenslanders. To the extent it may confine the exercise of the Commission's discretion under s 541 of the IR Act, the purpose of the Anti-Discrimination Act 1991 (Qld) ('the AD Act') relevant to the Complaint is:… is to promote equality of opportunity for everyone by protecting them from unfair discrimination in certain areas of activity, including work, education and accommodation.[5][5] Anti-Discrimination Act 1991, s 6. The public interest lies in the balancing of interests and is a question of fact and degree.[6] In Quaedvlieg and Ors v Boral Resources (Qld) Pty Ltd,[7] his Honour President Hall, in dealing with an application to strike out for want of prosecution, cited with approval the reasoning of Thomas JA in Quinlan v Rothwell[8] as follows:There is now a consciousness of the need for some level of efficiency in the use of the courts as a public resource. That, of course, must not displace the need for reasonable access to the courts and the provision of justice according to law in each matter, but it highlights the fact that the former laissez faire attitude by courts towards the leisurely conduct of actions at the will of the parties has ended. At the same time the rules of court are not an end in themselves. They do not exist for the discipline of practitioners or clients, or for the protection of courts from inefficient litigants, but rather as a means of ensuring that issues will be defined in an orderly way and that parties have the opportunity of full preparation of their case before the trial commences. The rules also afford defendants the means of bringing to an end actions in which the other party will not abide by the rules.[9][6] Campbell v State of Queensland (Department of Justice and Attorney-General) [2019] ICQ 18, [28].[7] (2005) 180 QGIG 1209.[8] [2002] 1 Qd R 647; [2001] QCA 176.[9] Ibid, [29].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clearly r 6 recognises the obligation placed, in this instance, on the Commission and implicitly on the parties to ensure the expeditious disposition of matters in the Commission.Consideration The Notice to Show Cause of 25 March 2022 required the Complainant to provide a response within 21 days. In particular, the Complainant was required pursuant to r 231(2) of the IR (Tribunals) Rules to address the following:· the steps taken in the proceedings;· the explanation for the circumstances of the delay;· the steps (including a timetable) proposed to be taken to progress the proceedings;· any prejudice suffered or likely to be suffered by another party to the proceedings if the application is not struck out;· the merits of the proceedings; and· why the Court, Commission or Registrar should not strike out the application despite the delay. On 13 April 2022, the Complainant responded in the following terms:This letter has been presented to you as a response of the NOTICE TO SHOW CAUSE received on the 25th March 2022.I am requesting to hold in abeyance the AD/2020/85 on the Queensland Industrial Relation Commission (QIRC).The reason are:a. The Work Cover QLD Claim ... was rejected on the 1St October 2020 by Review Officer QIRC Report Ref ... The Reason for decision Ref .... includes important information with errors in content, form and time; presented by Respondent. I disagreed with the decision of the Regulator and I contracted Lawyers.The appeal process has been managed by Lawyer representing the complaint in Queensland Industrial Relation Commission - Brisbane2. During the Appeal process WC/2020/144. The Regulator has been reviewing all the information presented on the claim and requesting medical reports regarding to the General Practitioner Diagnosis: Burnout at work / Work related mental trauma diagnosis on the 10th Feb 2020.This extra information has been created a delay during the process plus the extensive documents to support the Appeal.3. The merit of proceeding with both claims is to reach out Respect, Justice and Fair treatment during the presentation of a Medical Certificate in a work place in Australia and "To do the right thing" under Australian Values" by Respecting The Fair Work Act 2009", as well.I respectfully request the matter be held abeyance pending the outcome of the QIRC Appeal which I expect to prospect [sic] Hearing in the next months. The explanation (if it can be properly described as such) provided by the Complainant does not reasonably explain why the matter ought not to be struck out. Critically, the Complainant has failed to explain the merits of the current proceedings. The Complainant filed on 30 September 2022 an Application in Existing Proceedings. The application sought no relief but was filed, it was said, to provide 'Clarification about Form 4 sent by Garden House Australia related to No. WC/2020/144'. That matter was unrelated to these proceedings but involved a workers' compensation appeal which was discontinued on 31 August 2022.