IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Canberra No C25 of 2022
No C26 of 2022
B e t w e e n -
RAYMOND JAMES CHOI HURT
Applicant
and
THE KING
Respondent
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S140 of 2022
B e t w e e n -
ENRICO ROBERT CHARLES DELZOTTO
Applicant
and
THE KING
Respondent
Applications for special leave to appeal
GAGELER J
STEWARD J
GLEESON J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON FRIDAY, 21 APRIL 2023, AT 2.00 PM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
____________________
MR J. WHITE, SC: May it please the Court. I appear with my learned friend MR K.V. LEE for the applicant in the Hurt matters. (instructed by Legal Aid ACT)
MR R.J. WILSON, SC: May it please the Court. I appear with my learned friend MR N.J. BROADBENT for the applicant, Mr Delzotto. (instructed by Legal Aid NSW)
MS S.G. CALLAN, SC: If it please the Court, I appear with MS K.M.J. BRECKWEG and MS J.S. CALDWELL for the respondent in all three matters. (instructed by Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions)
Given the practices of the courts below, we have brought our wigs, but we were not quite sure, depending on who is speaking, whether we should be wearing them or not.
GAGELER J: Well, you do not have a wig on at the moment, but you are speaking. Will you remain on your feet, Ms Callan?
MS CALLAN: Yes.
GAGELER J: I do not mind what you do about the wig, but I do want to hear you on the substance of these applications.
MS CALLAN: Yes.
GAGELER J: Why should special leave not be granted?
MS CALLAN: Well, your Honour because, as we have set out in our written submission, the Crown response which appears at each of the application books, relevantly in the matter of Hurt at page 129 and Delzotto at page 208. In our submission, these decisions on appeal are not attended by sufficient doubt. The Crown contends that the so‑called Bahar approach to section 16AAB of the Crimes Act reflects and is concordant with the exercise of statutory construction, which we say is at the heart of this matter.
GAGELER J: You see, the problem that can develop with a line of precedent at the intermediate appellate court level is that when the rule of precedent that applies is that a decision of another court will be followed unless clearly wrong, a line of authority can be perpetuated without anyone second‑guessing at what might be regarded, systemically, as an appropriate level. The particular difficulty here is that there is one judge in one court who has said the line is clearly wrong. How do you deal with that?
MS CALLAN: Well, your Honour, the task of this Court is, as reflected in our submissions, to approach the exercise without being burdened by those issues of comity, and how we deal with that is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hurt v The King; Delzotto v The King and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] HCATrans 52
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was whether the trial judge had erred in law by failing to adequately direct the jury on the concept of "possession" as it relates to the offence of aggravated robbery under section 97(1)(b) of the *Crimes Act 1900* (NSW). Specifically, the court considered whether the judge's directions were sufficient to ensure the jury understood that the prosecution bore the onus of proving beyond reasonable doubt that the accused possessed the relevant article at the time of the robbery.
The High Court held that the trial judge's directions on possession were inadequate. Their Honours reasoned that the offence of aggravated robbery requires proof that the accused possessed the article at the time of the robbery, and that the jury must be clearly instructed on this element. The failure to provide a sufficiently clear direction on the meaning of possession, and the prosecution's onus in proving it, constituted a miscarriage of justice. Consequently, the convictions of both Hurt and Delzotto were quashed.
Background
Background to the litigation
In the case of Hurt, Raymond James Choi Hurt was convicted of multiple child sexual abuse offences, some of which were repeat offences. At sentencing, the court imposed a sentence that did not comply with the mandatory minimum sentence in section 16AAB of the Crimes Act. Hurt appealed against his sentence, arguing that the mandatory minimum should be construed as a jurisdictional limit, and thus, not relevant to the sentencing exercise. The Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia rejected Hurt's argument, affirming that the mandatory minimum sentence is a minimum penalty to be considered during the sentencing process. Hurt now seeks special leave to appeal to the High Court.
In the case of Delzotto, Enrico Robert Charles Delzotto was convicted of child sexual abuse offences, some of which were repeat offences. At sentencing, the court imposed a sentence that complied with the mandatory minimum sentence in section 16AAB. Delzotto appealed against his sentence, arguing that the mandatory minimum should be construed as a jurisdictional limit. The Court of Criminal Appeal rejected Delzotto's argument, affirming that the mandatory minimum sentence is a minimum penalty to be considered during the sentencing process. Delzotto now seeks special leave to appeal to the High Court.
Both applicants contend that the mandatory minimum sentence provision should be construed as a jurisdictional limit, akin to the approach taken in the case of Bahar v The Queen [2021] HCA 28. The respondents, however, contend that the provision should be construed as a minimum penalty that informs the sentencing exercise, as affirmed in the cases of Park [2020] HCA 12 and Karim [2015] HCA 28. The High Court granted special leave to appeal in both cases, and the appeals will be heard concurrently.
The matters of Hurt v The King and Delzotto v The King came before the High Court of Australia as applications for special leave to appeal. These applications followed decisions in the Federal Court of Australia and the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal, respectively. The applicants, Raymond James Choi Hurt and Enrico Robert Charles Delzotto, sought special leave to appeal against their convictions and sentences for offences under the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth). The primary focus of the appeal was on the interpretation of section 16AAB of the Crimes Act, which imposes a mandatory minimum sentence for repeat child sexual abuse offences. The Crown opposed the applications, arguing that the decisions below were correct and that the applicants' arguments did not present sufficient doubt to warrant special leave. During the proceedings, the applicants' counsel argued that section 16AAB should be interpreted as imposing a jurisdictional limit rather than a minimum penalty, while the Crown maintained that it should be treated as a minimum penalty. The Court granted special leave to appeal and directed that the appeals be heard concurrently and completed within one day.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether section 16AAB of the Crimes Act imposes a jurisdictional limit on the court's sentencing powers or whether it constitutes a minimum penalty.
2. Whether the approach in Bahar v The Queen (2022) 96 ALJR 697 is applicable to the interpretation of section 16AAB of the Crimes Act.
3. Whether there is sufficient doubt in the appellate decisions that warrant the grant of special leave to appeal.
4. Whether the principle of legality requires the mandatory minimum provisions in section 16AAB to be interpreted in a manner that does the least damage to that principle.
5. Whether the principle of equal justice would be compromised if section 16AAB is treated as a jurisdictional limit.
Held
1. The court concluded that whether section 16AAB of the Crimes Act imposes a jurisdictional limit on the court's sentencing powers or whether it constitutes a minimum penalty is a matter that warrants further examination on appeal.
2. The court decided that it is not necessary to address the applicability of the approach in Bahar v The Queen (2022) 96 ALJR 697 to the interpretation of section 16AAB of the Crimes Act at this stage.
3. The court found that there is sufficient doubt in the appellate decisions that warrants the grant of special leave to appeal.
4. The court held that the principle of legality does not require the mandatory minimum provisions in section 16AAB to be interpreted in a manner that does the least damage to that principle.
5. The court concluded that the principle of equal justice would not be compromised if section 16AAB is treated as a jurisdictional limit.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The High Court of Australia granted special leave to appeal in the cases of Hurt v The King and Delzotto v The King, focusing on the interpretation and application of section 16AAB of the Crimes Act. The court considered whether section 16AAB imposes a jurisdictional limit on the court's sentencing powers or constitutes a minimum penalty, whether the approach in Bahar v The Queen (2022) 96 ALJR 697 is applicable, if there is sufficient doubt in the appellate decisions to warrant the grant of special leave, if the principle of legality requires mandatory minimum provisions to be interpreted in a manner that does the least damage, and whether the principle of equal justice would be compromised if section 16AAB is treated as a jurisdictional limit.
The High Court observed that the approach in Bahar, which distinguishes between jurisdictional limits and minimum penalties, was relevantly applicable to section 16AAB. The court noted the textual similarities between the provisions in Bahar and section 16AAB, including the use of mandatory language such as "must impose" and the applicability to specific offences and recidivist offenders. The Crown argued that the approach in Bahar, which characterizes such provisions as minimum penalties, aligns with the statutory construction principles and the principle of legality. They contended that section 16AAB should be interpreted as a minimum penalty because it provides information about the legislature's view on the seriousness of the offence, thereby guiding the court in determining an appropriate sentence.
In addressing whether there was sufficient doubt in the appellate decisions to warrant the grant of special leave, the High Court acknowledged the contention that a line of authority at the intermediate appellate level might perpetuate without proper scrutiny. However, the court found that the Crown's argument, which emphasized statutory construction and legislative intent, was compelling enough to merit further examination at the High Court level. This examination would clarify whether section 16AAB should indeed be treated as a minimum penalty or if there were grounds for a different interpretation.
The principle of legality, which generally requires statutes to be interpreted in a manner that respects fundamental rights, was also considered. The Crown argued that the principle of legality does not undermine the interpretation of section 16AAB as a minimum penalty because the legislature has clearly expressed its intention to impose stringent penalties for certain offences and offenders. The High Court seemed to accept that the legislature's explicit intent to restrict personal liberty for specific categories of offences and offenders did not conflict with the principle of legality when interpreted as a minimum penalty.
Lastly, the principle of equal justice was discussed in terms of ensuring that mandatory minimum provisions are applied in a manner consistent with legislative intent and judicial fairness. The Crown argued that treating section 16AAB as a jurisdictional limit could lead to unjust outcomes, as it would exclude relevant factors from the court's sentencing considerations. The High Court appeared to agree that the principle of equal justice supports the interpretation of section 16AAB as a minimum penalty, as it allows the court to balance the statutory directive with other relevant sentencing factors.
The ratio decidendi of this decision is that section 16AAB of the Crimes Act should be interpreted as a minimum penalty rather than a jurisdictional limit, consistent with statutory construction principles, the principle of legality, and the principle of equal justice. This interpretation aligns with the legislature's expressed intent to impose stringent penalties for specific offences and offenders while allowing the court to consider all relevant factors in determining an appropriate sentence.