Re: ROBERT CHARLES MOSTYN HURT
And: TERENCE RICHARD ROSSALL; DAVID FREDERICK BRUCE; JOHN ARTHUR CAPORN;
ROBERT WILLIAM COLE; ROBERT JOHN YOUNG; JOHN VINCENT MONAGHAN; CHRISTOPHER
EDMUND JEFFREY SUMMERS GODWIN (added by leave as a respondent to the appeal)
No. ACT G75 of 1982
Administrative Law
COURT
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY DISTRICT REGISTRY
GENERAL DIVISION
Sweeney(1), Kelly(2) and Neaves(3) JJ.
CATCHWORDS
Administrative Law - Judicial Review of Administrative Decisions - Public Service Promotions Appeal on the ground of superior efficienty - failure of the Promotions Appeal Committee to supply the appellant with a copy of material which the Committee had before it resulting in misunderstanding between the Committee and the appellant - failure of Committee to supply the appellant with the substance of the matters put forward by the other contender for the position - failure of Committee to supply the appellant with the identity of the referees of the other contender for the position - whether a breach of the rules of natural justice
Public Service Act 1922;
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977; s5, 16
Ansell v. Wells & Ors (1983) 43 ALR 41
Dawes v Gesling (1982) 4 ALN No 129
R v Wells (1982) 41 ACTR 31
Hamblin v Duffy (No. 2) (1981) 37 ALR 297
Administrative Law - Natural justice - Promotions Appeal Committee - Appeal against promotion - Duty of Committee - Failure to supply copy of duty statement - Failure to disclose case of applicant - Failure to supply identity of referees of applicant - Public Service Act 1922 (Cth), s 50(6).
HEADNOTE
Held: (1) On the hearing of an appeal to the Promotions Appeal Committee under the Public Service Act 1922, s 50(6) the parties are entitled to the benefit of the appropriate principles of natural justice which are flexible and will vary from case to case.
Ansell v Wells (1982) 63 FLR 127, followed.
(2) Per Sweeney and Kelly JJ, Neaves J dissenting - Where the Committee failed to supply one of the parties with a copy of the duty statement of the new position in the same form as that acted upon by the Committee, that failure amounted to a denial of natural justice and it materially affected that party's chance of success before the Committee.
(3) Per Sweeney and Kelly JJ - A party is entitled to be informed of the substance of matters put forward by the other party in support of a claim to superior efficiency and failure to do so amounts to a denial of natural justice.
(4) Per Sweeney and Neaves JJ - In general the Committee is not obliged to advise the parties of what is said by referees and the same principles should apply when a party seeks disclosure of the names of referees.
R v Wells; Ex parte Ansell (1982) 55 FLR 281; Ansell v Wells (1982) 63 FLR 127, applied.
HEARING
Canberra, 1983, March 24; July 20. #DATE 20:7:1983
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hurt, Robert Charles Mostyn v Rossall, Terence Richard and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1983] FCA 148
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue that the court had to address was whether the appellant's failure to provide the respondent with essential information regarding the appeal and the other contender constituted a breach of the rules of natural justice. Specifically, the court examined whether the appellant's failure to provide the respondent with a copy of the material before the Committee, the substance of the matters put forward by the other contender, and the identity of the other contender's referees amounted to a denial of procedural fairness. The court also needed to consider whether these failures warranted the quashing of the appellant's decision and the subsequent promotion of Mr. Godwin.
The court held that the appellant's failure to provide the respondent with the necessary information did indeed amount to a breach of natural justice. The court found that the appellant's actions led to a misunderstanding between the parties and prevented the respondent from properly responding to the appeal. Furthermore, the court determined that the appellant's failure to provide the respondent with the identity of the other contender's referees was particularly significant, as it prevented the respondent from understanding the basis on which the other contender's appeal was being considered. The court concluded that these failures were serious enough to warrant the quashing of the appellant's decision and the subsequent promotion of Mr. Godwin. The court also ordered that Mr. Godwin's appeal be dealt with by a differently constituted Promotions Appeal Committee.
The court ordered that the appeal be upheld and the order of the court from 29 September 1982 be set aside. The decision of the first respondents from 10 September 1981 allowing Mr. Godwin's appeal against the provisional promotion of the respondent to Position No 3015 was quashed, as was the cancelling of that provisional promotion and the promotion of Mr. Godwin to that position. The court further ordered that Mr. Godwin's appeal be dealt with according to law by a Promotions Appeal Committee constituted by persons other than the first respondents. The court also ruled that the taxed costs of and incidental to the application for an order of review and to the appeal to the Full Court, including the notice of motion to add Mr. Godwin as a respondent, be paid by the second respondents. Additionally, the court ordered that the taxed costs of Mr. Godwin of and incidental to the notice of motion be paid by the appellant, with an order over, in respect of such costs, in favour of the appellant against the second respondents.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. the appeal be upheld and the order of the court of 29 September 1982 be set aside.
2. the decision of the first respondents of 10 September 1981 allowing Mr Godwin's appeal against the provisional promotion of the appellant to Position No 3015 be quashed.
3. the cancelling of that provisional promotion and the promotion of Mr Godwin to that position be quashed.
4. Mr Godwin's appeal be dealt with according to law by a Promotions Appeal Committee constituted by persons other than the first respondents.
5. the taxed costs of and incidental to the application for an order of review and to the appeal to the Full Court including the notice of motion that Mr Godwin be added as a respondent be paid by the second respondents.
6. the taxed cots of Mr Godwin of and incidental to the notice of motion be paid by the appellant, with an order over, in respect of such costs, in favour of the appellant against the second respondents.
Appeal allowed
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.