Hungerford v Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
44 CLR 450

HUNGERFORD AND ANOTHER

THE INSPECTOR-GENERAL IN BANKRUPTCY RESPONDENT.

IN RE NORMAN AND ANOTHER.

APPEAL FROM THE COURT OF BANKRUPTOY. Bankruptcy-Deed of inspectorshipInspector's remuneration-Immp sum or com-

mission according to scale prescribed in Bankruptcy Rules-Provision in deed Amount allowable-Resolution of creditors-Costs-Bankruptcy Act 1924-1930 SYDNEY,

(No. 37 of 1924-No. 17 of 1930), Parts VIII., XI., XII., secs. 133 (2), 184, April 13, 14,

199 (3), 203, 223-Bankruptcy Rules 1928 (S.R. 1928, No. 8), rr. 7, 356 Sched. 6.

Rule 356 of the Bankruptcy Rules 1928, which provides that 44 where the creditors resolve that the remuneration of the trustee shall be a sum of money, the sum of money shall be fixed in accordance with the scale in the Sixth Schedule," does not apply to the remuneration of inspectors under deeds of inspectorship, or of trustees under deeds of arrangement, because it is inconsis- tent with the provisions of secs. 184 and 203 of the Bankruptcy Act 1924-1930, which, respectively, deal expressly with the matter. Those sections, unlike sec. 133 of the Act, impose no limitations upon the sum of money, as distinguished from the commission, which the creditors may fix.

44 CLR 451

A clause in a deed of inspectorship provided that the inspectors thereunder should receive "such sums by way of remuneration as the creditors may from time to time authorize not exceeding the rates provided by section 203 of the Bankruptcy Act 1924-1928."

Held, that it meant no more than that the creditors might authorize a remuneration, subject to the restrictions imposed by sec. 203, and did not operate to prevent remuneration being paid by way of a lump sum if the

Decision of Judge Lukin reversed.

APPEAL from the Court of Bankruptcy, District of New South Wales and Territory for the Seat of Government.

Cyril Hungerford and Eric Sydney Spooner, chartered accountants and members of the firm of Hungerford, Spooner &Co., were appointed inspectors under a deed of inspectorship, dated 30th April 1929, for the purpose of supervising, on behalf of creditors, the carrying on of the business of Alfred Harold Norman and Thomas Brown Norman, trading as Norman &Son, storekeepers, Portland. The deed was registered on 22nd May 1929 as a deed of arrangement under Part XII. of the Bankruptcy Act 1924-1928. The portion of the deed material to this report was clause 18, which provided that "The inspectors shall pay and apply all such moneys as may be received by them under the foregoing provisions as follows (a) in payment of all current expenses necessarily incurred in the carrying on of the said business including therein all rents

and other necessary outgoings, (b) in payment of all expenses of and incidental to the carrying out of these presents and of the exercise of any of the powers thereof including the out-of-pocket expenses of the inspectors and such sums by way of remuneration as the creditors may from time to time authorize not exceeding the rates provided by section 203 of the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hungerford v Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1931] HCA 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellants, Cyril Hungerford and Eric Sydney Spooner, sought to appeal a decision of the Court of Bankruptcy, District of New South Wales and Territory for the Seat of Government. The dispute concerned the remuneration claimed by the appellants as inspectors under a deed of inspectorship, which had been registered as a deed of arrangement under Part XII of the *Bankruptcy Act 1924-1930*. The Registrar in Bankruptcy, having audited the appellants' accounts, referred the matter to the Federal Judge in Bankruptcy due to doubts regarding the allowability of certain remuneration payments.

The primary legal issue before the High Court was whether Rule 356 of the *Bankruptcy Rules 1928*, which stipulates that a sum of money fixed by creditors for a trustee's remuneration must be in accordance with the scale in the Sixth Schedule, applied to the remuneration of inspectors under a deed of inspectorship or trustees under a deed of arrangement. A secondary issue concerned the interpretation of a clause within the deed of inspectorship that limited the inspectors' remuneration to sums authorized by creditors, not exceeding the rates provided by section 203 of the *Bankruptcy Act 1924-1930*.

The High Court held that Rule 356 of the *Bankruptcy Rules 1928* did not apply to the remuneration of inspectors under deeds of inspectorship or trustees under deeds of arrangement. This was because the rule was inconsistent with sections 184 and 203 of the *Bankruptcy Act 1924-1930*, which specifically address the remuneration in such cases and do not impose limitations on lump sums fixed by creditors, unlike section 133 which the rule was designed to support. The Court further reasoned that the clause in the deed of inspectorship meant that creditors could authorize remuneration subject to the restrictions in section 203, and that these restrictions applied only to commission-based remuneration, not to lump sums.

Consequently, the High Court allowed the appeal, discharged the order of Judge Lukin, and remitted the matter to the Court of Bankruptcy to be dealt with as just. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.