Humphrey v Police No. Scgrg-00-920

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

HUMPHREY v POLICE
[2000] SASC 391

Magistrates Appeal (Criminal)

1................ OLSSON J....... This is an appeal against sentence.  Consequent upon the appellant pleading guilty to two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, the appellant was sentenced to 15 months’ imprisonment, with a non parole period of 10 months.  The learned Chief Magistrate declined to accede to a submission by counsel for the appellant that the custodial sentence ought to be suspended.  The appellant complains, in his notice of appeal, both that the sentence imposed was manifestly excessive and also that it ought to have been suspended.

  1. Having heard detailed submissions on behalf of the appellant and a co‑offender, the learned Chief Magistrate published detailed remarks on penalty, in which he recorded his findings of fact. What follows is a brief summary of them.  Certain of the findings are under challenge.

  2. The appellant had been married to Cheryl Ann Bickley for a period of some 12 years, up to about the end of 1999.  There were two young children of that relationship, now aged eight and seven years respectively.

  3. The appellant and Ms Bickley were the co-owners of a car wrecking business conducted in Port Lincoln.  They also jointly owned a home in which Ms Bickley was living with the children at the time of the commission of the offences.

  4. The relationship came to an end in about January 2000.  This occurred at the instance of Ms Bickley, following an argument which had occurred between the two partners.  Ms Bickley thereupon moved out of what had been the matrimonial home located on the business premises to the other jointly owned house property where the offences occurred.  However, the appellant and Ms Bickley continued to co-operate in relation to the conduct of the business and the appellant having access to the children.

  5. A medical certificate which was placed before the learned Chief Magistrate indicates that the appellant had sought medical treatment in late November 1999, at which time he was complaining of increasing aggression and violent mood swings - a condition which had progressively worsened over the previous two years.  The doctor commenced treating him in relation to a diagnosis of clinical depression.  He was referred for supportive psychotherapy.  This background may provide some explanation for the somewhat bizarre behaviour of the appellant on the night in question, although the learned Chief Magistrate does not appear to have given great weight to it.

  6. A pre-sentence report prepared for the learned Chief Magistrate indicated the appellant regularly drank a fair quantity of beer, although it is not clear as to when this habit commenced.

  7. Following her separation from the appellant Ms Bickley formed a relationship with a man named Dendunnen.  There is some doubt as to when the appellant first became aware of that relationship.  The learned Chief Magistrate was content to proceed on the footing that the appellant was unaware of it prior to the night of the offences.  Be that as it may, at about midnight on the night of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Humphrey v Police No. Scgrg-00-920 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 391
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Humphrey v Police is an appeal against sentence, where the appellant pleaded guilty to two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. The appellant was sentenced to 15 months’ imprisonment, with a non-parole period of 10 months. The appeal was lodged against the sentence, claiming it was manifestly excessive and ought to have been suspended. The legal issues that the court was required to decide included whether the sentence was manifestly excessive, whether it should have been suspended, and whether the learned Chief Magistrate appropriately considered the relevant factors in imposing the sentence.

The court found that the appeal must be allowed due to a combination of errors made by the learned Chief Magistrate, including the inappropriate importation of policy considerations relevant to another offence, and a misunderstanding of the appellant’s antecedents. The court also found that the appellant’s background, including his guilty plea, lack of serious offending in the past 15 years, and the likely devastating effect of imprisonment on his business and family, pointed to the desirability of a suspended sentence. The court was persuaded that the considerations mentioned constituted very powerful reasons for suspending the custodial sentence in this case.

The court concluded that the custodial sentence and non-parole period were confirmed; however, the sentence would be suspended, on entry by the appellant into a bond of $500 to be of good behaviour for a period of two years. The terms of the bond include being subject to the supervision of a probation officer and undergoing or participating in rehabilitative, medical, and psychological programs as directed by the probation officer.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Humphrey v Police revolves around the events leading to the assault of Cheryl Ann Bickley and her companion, Dendunnen, by the appellant, Humphrey, and his co-offender, Stephens. Humphrey and Bickley were married for twelve years and co-owned a car wrecking business in Port Lincoln. Their relationship ended in January 2000, when Bickley separated from Humphrey and moved out of their shared home, although they continued to co-operate in managing their business and maintaining access to their children. Humphrey had been experiencing increasing aggression and violent mood swings, for which he sought medical treatment and a diagnosis of clinical depression.

In the early hours of the morning, Humphrey and Stephens, both intoxicated, went to Bickley's house where she and Dendunnen were sleeping. They attacked the couple, dragging them out of bed and severely assaulting them. The attack was witnessed by the couple's two young children, causing significant trauma to all involved. The Chief Magistrate found that the assault was unprovoked and occurred due to a spontaneous emotional reaction triggered by Humphrey's discovery of Bickley with another man.

Humphrey pleaded guilty to two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm and was sentenced to 15 months’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of 10 months. The Chief Magistrate rejected a submission to suspend the sentence. Humphrey appealed the sentence, arguing that it was excessive and should have been suspended. The appeal court found errors in the sentencing process and decided to exercise the sentencing discretion afresh, ultimately allowing the appeal and suspending the sentence.

The case of Humphrey v Police [2000] SASC 391 is an appeal against sentence arising from a Magistrates Appeal (Criminal) hearing. The appellant, who had pleaded guilty to two counts of assault occasioning actual bodily harm, was originally sentenced to 15 months’ imprisonment with a non-parole period of 10 months by the Chief Magistrate. The appellant's challenge to this sentence focused on its severity and the decision not to suspend the custodial term. The appeal was heard by Olsson J, who reviewed the procedural history, examined the arguments presented, and ultimately allowed the appeal, modifying the sentence. Prior to this appeal, the case had been through the Magistrates Court, where the appellant was found guilty following a guilty plea. The Chief Magistrate delivered detailed remarks on penalty, considering various factors including the nature of the offences, the vulnerability of the victims, and the appellant's background. The appellant's legal team argued that the sentence was excessive, should have been suspended, and that several errors were made during the sentencing process. These included the Chief Magistrate's alleged inappropriate consideration of policy factors relevant to a more serious offence, misinterpretation of the appellant's criminal history, and incorrect assumptions about prior custodial sentences served. The Supreme Court of South Australia, in allowing the appeal, noted that while the original sentence and non-parole period were appropriate given the gravity of the offences, the decision not to suspend the sentence required reconsideration in light of the identified errors and other mitigating factors. Olsson J ultimately decided to suspend the sentence, imposing a bond of $500 with conditions for good behaviour over two years, subject to probation officer supervision and participation in rehabilitative programs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the sentence imposed by the learned Chief Magistrate manifestly excessive?
2. Should the custodial sentence have been suspended?
3. Did the learned Chief Magistrate appropriately consider the policy considerations relevant to s 40 offences, or were considerations relevant to s 170 offences impermissibly imported into the sentencing process?
4. Did the learned Chief Magistrate make errors in his findings regarding the appellant's antecedents, specifically whether he had previously served a significant custodial sentence?
5. Was there sufficient evidence to support the finding that the victims were kicked with steel capped boots?
6. Did the combination of errors made by the learned Chief Magistrate vitiated the sentencing process, necessitating a fresh exercise of sentencing discretion?

Held
1. Was the sentence imposed by the learned Chief Magistrate manifestly excessive?
The court concluded that the head sentence and non-parole period were entirely appropriate to mark the seriousness of the offending.

2. Should the custodial sentence have been suspended?
The court concluded that the custodial sentence should be suspended, given the unique circumstances of the case and the significant factors pointing to the desirability of a suspended sentence.

3. Did the learned Chief Magistrate appropriately consider the policy considerations relevant to s 40 offences, or were considerations relevant to s 170 offences impermissibly imported into the sentencing process?
The court concluded that the learned Chief Magistrate inappropriately imported policy considerations relevant to s 170 offences, which are not necessarily applicable to offences under s 40.

4. Did the learned Chief Magistrate make errors in his findings regarding the appellant's antecedents, specifically whether he had previously served a significant custodial sentence?
The court concluded that the learned Chief Magistrate made errors in his findings regarding the appellant's antecedents, particularly in overstating the significance of his criminal record and incorrectly stating that the appellant had previously served a significant custodial sentence.

5. Was there sufficient evidence to support the finding that the victims were kicked with steel capped boots?
The court concluded that there was no sufficient evidence to support the finding that the victims were kicked with steel capped boots.

6. Did the combination of errors made by the learned Chief Magistrate vitiated the sentencing process, necessitating a fresh exercise of sentencing discretion?
The court concluded that the combination of errors made by the learned Chief Magistrate vitiated the sentencing process, necessitating a fresh exercise of sentencing discretion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal against sentence in the case of Humphrey v Police centred on the appropriateness of the 15-month custodial sentence imposed by the Chief Magistrate, and the decision not to suspend the sentence. The appellant argued that the sentence was manifestly excessive and that it should have been suspended. The court found that while the sentence was appropriate given the gravity of the assault, the decision not to suspend it was flawed due to several errors in the learned Chief Magistrate's reasoning.

Firstly, the court addressed the argument that the sentence was manifestly excessive. The appellant's counsel conceded that the head sentence and non-parole period were appropriate, recognizing the seriousness of the assault. The court agreed, emphasizing the gravity of the offence, which involved the violent assault of two victims in their own home, while they were asleep and vulnerable. The court underscored the importance of a substantial custodial sentence to reflect the community's outrage and to maintain the perceived ability of the law to protect citizens.

Secondly, the court scrutinized the decision not to suspend the custodial sentence. It found that the learned Chief Magistrate erred by not adequately considering several compelling factors that pointed to the desirability of a suspended sentence. The court noted the appellant's timely plea of guilty, his lack of serious offending in the 15 years prior to the incident, his industriousness in running a successful business, and the potential devastating effect of imprisonment on his business and family. The pre-sentence report highlighted the appellant's contrition and insight, suggesting that immediate imprisonment would achieve little and that he was unlikely to reoffend.

Thirdly, the court identified that the learned Chief Magistrate may have inappropriately imported considerations relevant to more serious offences into the sentencing process for the lesser offences of assault occasioning actual bodily harm. While the court acknowledged the seriousness of the offences, it found that the Chief Magistrate's focus on policy considerations pertinent to more severe offences was distracting and potentially prejudicial.

Additionally, the court found that the learned Chief Magistrate made errors in assessing the appellant's antecedents. The Chief Magistrate had characterized the appellant's criminal history as extensive, which the court found misleading. The appellant had not served a significant custodial sentence in the past 15 years and had a relatively good record. This distinction is crucial in determining whether a custodial sentence should be suspended.

Lastly, the court found that the learned Chief Magistrate erred in his finding regarding whether the victims were kicked with steel-capped boots. The court concluded that there was insufficient evidence to support this finding, which was significant given the appellant's intoxication and emotional state at the time of the offence.

Given these errors, the court determined that the sentencing process was vitiated. It exercised its discretion afresh, considering all the relevant factors. The court concluded that the custodial sentence and non-parole period were appropriate, but the sentence should be suspended. The appellant was required to enter a bond to be of good behaviour for two years, under the supervision of a probation officer and with participation in rehabilitative programs. The court emphasized the importance of general deterrence and the community interest in the appellant’s rehabilitation. The appeal was thus allowed, and the sentence was suspended with specific conditions.