Hui and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 232

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)     No N1999/1236

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION          )          

Re      LOKENI HUI

Applicant

And    MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS          

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Dr D Chappell, Deputy President 

Date23 March 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

(sgd) Duncan Chappell
  ..............................................
  Dr D Chappell
  Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION AND CITIZENSHIP – criminal deportation – citizen of New Zealand – entry into Australian at age 30 – convictions for series of assault, malicious wounding and breach of domestic violence order offences – previous consideration for deportation – history of alcohol use and dependency – consideration of seriousness of offences – risk of recidivism assessed to be moderate to high – prospects of rehabilitation assessed to be poor – recent acknowledgment of guilt in relation to domestic violence – consideration of best interests of applicants' children – children assessed to be "at risk" as result of Department of Community Services intervention – hardship to applicant and family – consideration of deterrent message – level of risk of further offending unacceptable to ensure protection of Australian community – best interests of children primary consideration – weighing of factors in favour of deportation.
Migration Act 1958 s200
Lokeni Hui and Minister of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] AATA 47
Hui v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 985
Epinisa Tiko Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 492
Epinisa Tiko Rokobatini v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (1999) FCR 583.

REASONS FOR DECISION

23 March 2000        Dr D. Chappell  

BACKGROUND
Application

  1. Mr Lokeni Hui, the applicant, seeks review of a decision of the delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (the Minister), made pursuant to s 200 of the Migration Act 1958 (the Act), to deport him from Australia. The Tribunal's jurisdiction to review that decision is granted by s 501(a) of the Act.

  2. Mr Cameron Jackson, of counsel, represented Mr Hui at the hearing.  Mr Hui also appeared in person and gave personal testimony to the Tribunal.

  3. Mr Robert Beech-Jones, of counsel, instructed by Mr Jason Fong, a departmental advocate, represented the respondent.  Dr Brent Waters gave evidence on behalf of the respondent.

  4. The Tribunal had before it documents and supplementary documents filed for the purposes of s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T and S documents). The following exhibits were also received into evidence on behalf of the applicant and respondent:
    Exhibit No.     Description    Date   
    A1      Inmate Development Committee sheet listing applicant          Undated        
    A2      Reference from Captain A.D. Carter, Anglican Chaplain, Corrective Services        11 March 1999  
    R1      Report by Dr Brent Waters, psychiatrist  18 November 1999 
    R2      Statement of Ms Hazel Haffenden          16 November 1999 

Referral by Federal Court

  1. This matter was remitted by the Federal Court to the Tribunal for reconsideration in July 1999;  see Hui v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [1999] FCA 985. The reasons for this Federal Court remittal…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hui and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 232
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) involves Lokeni Hui, a citizen of New Zealand, who has been in Australia since he was 30 years old. Hui has been convicted of a series of assault, malicious wounding, and breach of domestic violence order offences. The Tribunal was tasked with deciding whether Hui should be deported under section 200 of the Migration Act 1958. The primary issues for the Tribunal to determine were the seriousness of Hui's offences, the risk of recidivism, the prospects of rehabilitation, the best interests of Hui's children, and the potential deterrent effect of deportation on others. The Tribunal also had to consider the level of hardship Hui and his family would face if deported.

In reaching its decision, the Tribunal considered the extensive criminal history of Hui, which began in Western Samoa and continued in New Zealand and Australia. The Tribunal noted that Hui's offending had involved significant violence and was often accompanied by alcohol abuse. Despite his lengthy incarcerations, the Tribunal found that Hui had not demonstrated a sufficient change in behaviour to warrant a decision against deportation. The Tribunal accepted professional evidence suggesting that renewed access by Hui would not benefit his children, who had already experienced substantial trauma. The Tribunal concluded that the risk of Hui re-offending was too high to protect the Australian community and that the deterrent effect of deportation was a significant factor in favour of upholding the Minister's decision.

The Tribunal ultimately found that the seriousness of Hui's offences, combined with the risk of recidivism and poor prospects for rehabilitation, outweighed the hardship to Hui and his family. The best interests of Hui's children were deemed to be best served by his deportation, as it would protect them from further harm and trauma. The Tribunal affirmed the decision of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs to deport Hui to New Zealand.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Given the importance and relevance of the three factors which have just been listed, attention is now turned to the evidence before the Tribunal in relation to each. Following this review the evidence concerning the best interests of the children is examined, together with certain other factors which the Policy Direction indicates require consideration by the Tribunal.EVIDENCESeriousness and Nature of the Crime As is apparent from the general chronology set out earlier, this is the third occasion upon which Mr Hui has been considered for deportation following his conviction for offences bringing him within the framework of s 200 of the Act. It is also apparent from the information contained in Attachment 1 that Mr Hui's criminal offending at large commenced in 1981 in Western Samoa, and continued during the time that he was resident in New Zealand. The first offence which led to Mr Hui's consideration for deportation was committed on 4 December 1991. The facts surrounding this offence, which resulted in Mr Hui's conviction of malicious wounding, were described in the following way by Mitchelmore J at the time of his consideration of Mr Hui's appeal against the severity of his sentence:The facts may be shortly stated.It was about 9pm on 4 December 1991, the prisoner and co-offender went to a unit at Bankstown. They spoke to the victim. His name is Paul Gregory Jones. The prisoner said to the victim, "I am going to kill you." The prisoner produced a large bladed machete. The prisoner slashed the victim on the left arm causing a severe wound. A struggle ensued, the victim escaped. He escaped by running to the balcony and climbing to the balcony below. The alarm was sounded. The police attended. The prisoner was located. The following day he was interviewed by way of electronic recording equipment. The victim received 30 stitches to his upper arm. The relevant statement of Paul Jones says as follows in paragraph seven: "Just after Jodie left the islander turned his back on me and when he turned around again he had a machete in his hands. He said, "we're going to kill you." I said, "What for?" He says, "What's been going on around here?" I said, "I've been watching TV and waiting for Michelle to come home." He said something else then he grabbed me by the shirt and tore it off my back. I fell to the floor and I don't know whether he chopped me while I was standing or as I hit the ground, but he chopped me on the left arm with the machete. I realised he meant business and I saw the extent of my wound. I was terrified of the machete so I grabbed the bean bag on the floor and held it up to protect myself. He kept trying to chop me again with the machete. I wasn't able to get away from him because the Australian guy was standing in the doorway. I saw the balcony door open, I threw the bag at him, ran outside. I jumped over the balcony and somehow swung onto the balcony on the unit second floor below. I was terrified of the machete and just had to get away from it."There is a statement from a neighbour. Her name is Leanne Birch. She appears to have been in a flat nearby on 4 December at 9.15 when these events occurred. She heard screaming for about three and four minutes. She went outside, she made certain investigations. She noticed:"The Maori bloke was holding a large knife in his right hand. The knife was about 30 centimetres long and had a blade about four centimetres. The blade was dark, it wasn't shiny, it had blood on it. It had a wood handle.The following conversation then took place, according to paragraph eight of Leanne Birch's statement. "When the three of them were running towards the car I said, "Is Paul all right?" Jodie said, "He deserved what he got." As I was saying this the bloke with the knife came at me with the knife. He raised the knife, pointed it at me and said, "Fuck off." I told my daughter to take off and I ran up the stairs to Paul's unit.Those then shortly are the facts of the matter. In the record of interview the appellant raised the matter of child abuse. The justification for his aggressive behaviour was a claim that the victim had been improperly interfering with his wife's sister's two year old child. The appellant himself gave evidence. He said:"My girlfriend Jodie, her sister, told me what her ex-boyfriend had done to her daughter."The appellant said he had two case of beer to drink. He agrees he took a knife to the premises. He said that he wanted to bash the man because of what he did to the little girl. The appellant gave evidence that he pulled out the knife and that he used it. He did not mean to use it. He has been in Australia two or three years, had a difficult childhood in Apia in Samoa. He has a two week old son. He has a problem with his drinking but has made a genuine effort to overcome that. (T5: 20-22)

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal accepts Mr Hui's present and expressed desire to maintain ties with his children and to assume the responsibilities of fatherhood. The Tribunal also accepts the indirect evidence referred to by Dr Waters of Ricky's continuing interest in his father, expressed through his reaction to photographs. In Vessie's case, the tender age at which she was separated from her father through his imprisonment suggests that she has no direct memory of his presence but still has positive feelings about the person that is her natural father. Despite these feelings, the Tribunal finds persuasive the professional opinion expressed by Dr Waters that renewed access by Mr Hui would not lead to an overall benefit to either Ricky or Vessie. As Dr Waters also indicated, ultimately both children may wish to form a relationship with their father but the most prudent time for this to occur would be when the children are mature enough to make their own decisions about this crucial issue.CONCLUSION Since 1990 Mr Hui has been able to enjoy the benefits and privileges of living in Australia. During this time Mr Hui has made few contributions to this country, while inflicting upon a number of its citizens significant anguish and harm through his violent conduct. He has been punished for that conduct by a series of prison sentences which have failed to act as a deterrent or a path to rehabilitation. The Tribunal has already concluded that if released back into the community there is a strong possibility that he will re-offend. Having given very careful consideration to the evidence which has been presented to the Tribunal about what is in the best interests of Mr Hui's children, Ricky and Vessie, and to the hardship which Mr Hui and his immediate family would suffer if he is to be deported to New Zealand, the Tribunal believes that this evidence is insufficient to outweigh the Australian community's legitimate expectation that it will be protected against the risk of a non-citizen like Mr Hui committing further acts of violence. It is never an easy matter to separate two children, both Australian citizens, from one of their parents. Nonetheless, in the present case the weight of the professional evidence suggests that such separation is, in the circumstances, in the best interests of these children, who have already been subjected to substantial trauma and disadvantage. Deportation will also cause hardship to Mr Hui and to his brother, but it remains a factor which is insufficient to preclude the need to protect the Australian community and deter like conduct by other non-citizens. The decision under review is thus affirmed.I certify that the 88 preceding paragraphs are a true copy of the reasons for the decision herein of Dr D. ChappellSigned: ..................................................................................... AssociateDate of Hearing 7 February 2000 Date of Decision 23 March 2000Counsel for Applicant Mr Cameron Jackson Counsel for Respondent Mr Robert Beech-Jones Representative for Respondent Mr Jason Fong

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Lokeni Hui was also interviewed about the same time as his brother about his family circumstances (see for example T49:197-198). In the course of the interview Mr Hui indicated that he had come to New Zealand from Western Samoa when he was 15 years of age. He had no contact with his father for 15 years and he had no contact with his other brothers and sisters whose whereabouts were unknown. He had been employed in New Zealand as a builder and after his arrival in Australia he had been employed as a bricklayer for two weeks and then in 1990 as a factory hand for several years.CONSIDERATIONSubmissions and Policy: Expectations of the Community The relevant factors which require consideration by the Tribunal in relation to the expectations of the Australian community have already been referred to. Addressing these factors in his submissions Mr Jackson, on behalf of the applicant, acknowledged that the offences committed by Mr Hui were serious. They were very violent crimes committed impulsively. Nonetheless, when looking at the maximum sentences that were available in relation to each of the offences of which Mr Hui had been convicted the actual sentences imposed were at the lower end of the scale. Mr Jackson said that the critical area in this case came in assessing the community's desire not to be put at risk by Mr Hui re-offending. Mr Jackson conceded that at "first blush" a person who had committed a number of violent crimes and who had not heeded past deportation warnings was a person at risk of recidivism. However, Mr Hui had, during the most recent period of incarceration, demonstrated a change in his behaviour. This change was evident from his acknowledgment of the commission of the offences of domestic violence and also his appointment as a peacemaker in the prison system. This was further evident from the reference provided by the Anglican chaplain, Captain Carter (A2). Mr Jackson acknowledged that the difficulty for Mr Hui was that he had been in prison for a substantial period of time and had not been exposed in that environment to alcohol. No one could say for certain that there was no prospect of re-offending should Mr Hui be allowed to remain in Australia but there was some comfort to be taken from the fact that he had evidenced change in his attitude and behaviours while serving his most recent prison sentence. In his submissions made on behalf of the respondent, Mr Beech-Jones pointed to the repetitive nature of the violence committed by Mr Hui. It revealed a dangerous offender and the pattern was also one which was always accompanied by the abuse of alcohol. Each time he had been incarcerated Mr Hui had professed to now realise that he needed to change his behaviour but the degree of repetition of his violence was such that there was really nothing which had been advanced on behalf of the applicant to suggest that the pattern would not be repeated in the future. The Policy made it clear that crimes of violence or the threat of violence were of special concern to the welfare and safety of the Australian community. This was especially the case when that violence involved mothers or women. The Tribunal now had the opportunity to break this cycle of violence and to protect the Australian community by deporting Mr Hui.The Tribunal's Views