Hughes v Steel

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read
5 CLR 755

COMPLAINANT, STEEL

RESPONDENT. DEFENDANT,

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Public Health Act 1902 (N.S.W.) (No. 30 of 1902), secs. SI, 82 -Sale of adulter-

ated liquor-Analysis of article sold-Certificate of analyst - Evidence of com- pliance with statutory directions.

Sec. 82 of the Public Health Act 1902 provides that a certificate may be given by an analyst of the result of his analysis of any food or drug sub- mitted to him for analysis in pursuance of the provisions of the Act; and that in any proceedings before any Court the production of a certificate pur- porting to be signed by the analyst shall be sufficient evidence of the identity of the food or drug analysed and of the result of the analysis without further proof of its authenticity.

Held, that on a prosecution for selling food which is not of the nature, substance, or quality demanded by the purchaser, where the certificate of an analyst is admitted in evidence under this section, it is not necessary for the prosecutor to prove that the analyst divided the food submitted to him by the purchaser into two parts as required by sec, 81.

Decision of Sly Acting-J.: Hughes v. Steel, 24 N.S.W. W.N., 146,

APPEAL from a decision of Sly Acting-J. on a special case stated under the Justices Act 1902.

The respondent, a hotel keeper, was proceeded against by the appellant under sec. 88 of the Public Health Act 1902, upon an

5 CLR 756

information charging him with having, to the prejudice of the

purchaser thereof, sold certain articles of food, namely, brandy and rum, which were not of the nature, substance, or quality of the foods demanded by the purchaser. It was proved that the appellant, an Inspector of Police and District Licensing Inspector, went to the hotel kept by the respondent, and there purchased some liquor. After the purchase the Inspector gave notice to the seller that he intended to submit the liquor pur- chased to the government analyst for analysis, and, as required by sec. 80 of the Act, offered to divide the liquor into three parts, to be separately sealed and labelled, and to leave one of the parts with the seller. This offer being refused, he labelled and sealed the bottles there and then, and afterwards handed them to the government analyst. This evidence having been given, a certifi- cate purporting to be signed by the government analyst and to show the result of his analysis of the liquor in question was put in evidence without objection. The evidence for the prosecution being closed the point was taken for the defendant that, as there was no evidence that the analyst had divided the samples given to him in accordance with sec. 81 of the Act, the information should be dismissed. The magistrate upheld the objection and dismissed the information.

A special case was stated by the magistrate for the opinion of the Supreme Court whether his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hughes v Steel and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1908] HCA 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales regarding a prosecution for selling adulterated liquor under the *Public Health Act 1902* (N.S.W.). The appellant, an inspector, had purchased brandy and rum from the respondent hotel keeper and, after offering to divide the samples into three parts as required by section 80 of the Act, submitted them for analysis. The respondent refused the offer to divide the samples. A certificate from the government analyst detailing the results of the analysis was admitted into evidence without objection. However, the magistrate dismissed the information on the grounds that there was no evidence that the analyst had divided the submitted liquor into two parts and retained one for production, as stipulated by section 81 of the Act.

The legal issue before the High Court was whether proof of the analyst's compliance with the requirements of section 81 of the *Public Health Act 1902*, specifically the division of the sample and retention of a part, was a necessary prerequisite for the admission and efficacy of the analyst's certificate in proceedings for selling food not of the nature, substance, or quality demanded by the purchaser.

The Court held that proof of the analyst's compliance with section 81 was not a condition precedent to the admission of the certificate under section 82. The Court reasoned that the primary purpose of section 82 was to obviate the necessity of calling the analyst as a witness, a provision particularly important in a large state like New South Wales. If proof of the analyst's actions under section 81 were required, it would negate the intended convenience of using the certificate. While the division of the sample was a duty imposed on the analyst for the benefit of the defendant, the failure to comply with this duty did not automatically invalidate the certificate or prevent a conviction. Such a failure might, if established by the defendant, afford a defence, but it was not incumbent on the prosecution to prove affirmatively that the analyst had complied with section 81. The Court distinguished the scheme of the New South Wales Act from that of the English Act, where a certificate was a prerequisite to prosecution and the defendant had a right to have the analyst called.

The appeal was allowed, the order of the Supreme Court was discharged, and the case was remitted to the magistrate for determination. The respondent was ordered to pay the costs in the Supreme Court, but no costs were awarded on the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established