Hughes v Catholic Church Endowment Society

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Hughes v Catholic Church Endowment Society [2022] FedCFamC2G 105

File number(s): ADG 176 of 2020
Judgment of: JUDGE BROWN
Date of judgment: 25 February 2022
Catchwords:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – application for breach of a general protection under the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth).

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – pleadings – whether statement of claim discloses a reasonable cause of action – application for dismissal – matters to be considered.  

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) Pt 3-1, ss 340, 341, 342, 351, 361, 550, 546.
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) Rules 2021 (Cth) rr 1.04, 1.06.
Federal Circuit Court Rules 2001 (Cth) rr 4.05, 45.08.
Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) ss 174, 190.
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 5, 31A, 37M.
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) Pt 16, rr 8.05, 16.02, 16.21
Work Health and Safety Act 2011 (Cth).
WorkHealth and Safety Act 2012 (SA).
Cases cited: Adachi v Qantas Airways Limited [2019] FCCA 1107.
Banque Commerciale SA (in liq) v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279.
Bruce v Oldhams Press Ltd [1936] 1 KB 697.
Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658.
Ermel v Duluxgroup (Aust) Pty Lty (No 2) [2015] FCA 17.
Gaven & Gaven (No 2) [2012] FMCAfam 1005.
Gould & Ors v Mount Oxide Mines Ltd (In Liquidation) (1916) 22 CLR 490.
Kakayzich v Santa Sabinda College & Anor [2020] FCCA 11.
Kelly v Atanaskovic Hartnell Corporate Services Pty Ltd [2021] FCCA 552.
State of Victoria (Office of Public Prosecutions) v Grant [2014] FCAFC 184.
Takemoto v Moody’s Investors Service Pty Limited [2014] FCA 1081.
Vitale v The Trustee for the Davis Bros Unit Trust [2021] FCCA 214.
Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 91
Date of hearing: 13 December 2021
Place: Adelaide
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Manuel
Solicitor for the Applicant: Starke Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms McCarthy
Solicitor for the Respondents: Piper Alderman

ORDERS

ADG 176 of 2020

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

KEIRAN HUGHES

Applicant

AND:

CATHOLIC CHURCH ENDOWMENT SOCIETY

First Respondent

ANDREW PETER NEVILLE

Second Respondent

MAJELLA JOVANOVICH (and another named in the Schedule)

Third Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE BROWN

DATE OF ORDER:

25 FEBRUARY 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.Pursuant to rule 16.21 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth), the amended Statement of Claim filed by the applicant, Keiran Hughes (hereinafter referred to as “the applicant”) on 13 September 2021 be struck out in its entirety.

2.The matter be adjourned to 29 March 2022 at 10:00 am by Microsoft Teams for directions and submissions on whether the case should proceed on the basis of affidavit evidence, or whether the applicant should be given a further opportunity to amend her Statement of Claim NOTING THAT the parties will be forwarded a link for the hearing by…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hughes v Catholic Church Endowment Society and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC2G 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Hughes v Catholic Church Endowment Society, Ms Hughes sought to amend her Statement of Claim in the Federal Circuit Court to include additional respondents and allegations. The primary dispute concerns whether the second, third, and fourth respondents are involved in the Society’s contravention of section 340 of an applicable statute. Ms Hughes argued that these respondents had aided, abetted, counselled, or procured the contravention, while the respondents contended that the proposed amendments were improper and should be rejected.

The legal issues before the court included whether the proposed amendments to the Statement of Claim were permissible under the rules and whether the amendments sufficiently identified the case against each respondent. The court examined whether the amended Statement of Claim provided the respondents with a clear understanding of the allegations against them, which is essential for procedural fairness and efficient use of judicial resources. The court also considered whether the proposed amendments were consistent with the overarching purpose of the court’s civil litigation rules, which aim to facilitate the identification of issues in dispute and the efficient conduct of proceedings.

The court found that the amended Statement of Claim was irremediably bad and should be struck out. The document was difficult to read and comprehend, failing to provide the respondents with a clear understanding of the allegations against them. This failure meant that it did not meet the fundamental function of a pleading, which is to state, with sufficient clarity, the case that must be met. The court determined that it would be unfair to require the respondents to defend against the amended Statement of Claim in its current form.

The court ordered that the amended Statement of Claim be struck out and directed the parties to consider alternative methods of defining the issues, such as filing affidavits of evidence or engaging in primary dispute resolution to limit expense. This decision aimed to ensure that the proceedings would proceed in a manner that was fair to all parties and aligned with the overarching purpose of the court’s civil litigation rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 550(2) of the section provides a definitive list of circumstances in which a person is to be treated as being involved in a contravention. They include a person being knowingly concerned in or a party to the contravention or having aided, abetted, counselled or procured such a contravention. It is Ms Hughes position that the second, third and fourth respondents are involved in the Society’s contravention of section 340.BACKGROUND The proceedings were commenced in the Federal Circuit Court prior to the creation of Division 2 of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia pursuant to the provisions of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth). At the time, the applicable provisions of the Federal Circuit Cout Rules 2001 (Cth) required applications to be commenced by the filing of an approved form.[10][10] Hereinafter referred to as “the FCC Rules”. Pursuant to rule 4.05 of the former FCC Rules, an applicant was ordinarily required to file an affidavit stating the facts relied upon in support of the relevant application. However, pursuant to rule 4.05(2), an affidavit was not required if the proceedings were filed in the court’s Fair Work Division, in which case a Statement of Claim or points of claim could be filed. In these circumstances rule 45.08, which applied to general protection applications, mandated the approved form be accompanied by a claim, the form of which was also subject to approval. The application is a simple document, analogous to a summons to attend court. It stipulates a place, date and time for hearing and indicates that the orders sought by the applicant and the grounds on which those orders are sought are set out in the claim accompanying the application. In accordance with the rules, Ms Hughes’ solicitor filed such a claim contemporaneously with her application on 12 May 2020. The first mention of the matter was fixed for 14 August 2020. Pursuant to rule 4.05(3) of the former FCC Rules, if a Statement of Claim, or points of claim are filed, any relevant respondent must file a defence or points of defence instead of an affidavit. As yet, no affidavits of evidence have been filed by either party, other than affidavits of documents, which have been filed on behalf of both parties. The term pleading refers to the formal documents, in which litigants set out the presentation of their claims and defences to those claims, in the suit, which they wish the court to determine. They are filed and served sequentially, according to the rules of the particular court in question. In Takemoto v Moody’s Investors Service Pty Limited,[11] Flick J observed that as a general proposition the function of pleadings is to state with sufficient clarity the case that must be met.[11] Takemoto v Moody’s Investors Service Pty Limited [2014] FCA 1081 at [23] (Flick J). A Statement of Claim must identify a set of alleged facts that have a particular quality, which if established at trial, will entitle the applicant to the remedy or remedies claimed. A defence is the formal rebuttal of those alleged facts. Pleadings are required to contain statements of material fact, which a defence, in turn, will either admit or deny.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As such, the amended Statement of Claim does not fulfil the basic requirement of a pleading in the sense that the respondents have not been sufficiently appraised of the case, which each has to meet. In this context, reliance is placed on statements of Judge Jarrett (as His Honour formerly was) in Vitale v The Trustee for the Davis Bros Unit Trust namely:[A] pleading is a means of achieving procedural fairness and efficient use of judicial resources and those of the parties by the identification of what is truly at issue. The purpose of the pleading is to identify with sufficient clarity the case which must be met. The Court should consider a statement which is unintelligible, ambiguous, vague or too general, or a pleading which is capable of various meanings, as an embarrassing pleading. Ultimately, the question for the Court is whether there is sufficient information in the pleading to permit the respondents to know the case against them.[36][36] Vitale v The Trustee for the Davis Bros Unit Trust [2021] FCCA 214 at [6] (Jarrett J). CONCLUSION I agree with the submissions of counsel for the respondent. In my view, the amended Statement of Claim is irremediably bad and should therefore be struck out. As it is presently drafted, it is a difficult document to read and comprehend. Therefore, in my assessment, it would be unfair for the respondents to be called upon to answer it, within the context of a general protection application, as opposed to some other form of action. As such, it fails to meet the fundamental function of a pleading, which is to state, with sufficient clarity, the case that must be met.[37] I do not consider that it would be fair to the respondents to be called upon to provide a defence to the amended Statement of Claim as it is currently drafted, or consistent with the overarching purpose as defined in the FCFCOA Act. [37] Gould & Ors v Mount Oxide Mines Ltd (In Liquidation) (1916) 22 CLR 490, 517 (Isaacs and Rich JJ). As previously indicated, the function of a properly drafted pleading is to provide procedural fairness.[38] It does so by the identification of issues in dispute, which in turn promotes the efficient conduct of proceedings, and in due course facilitates the court’s assessment of the relevance and admissibility of evidence.[39] These objectives are in keeping with the overarching purpose of the court’s civil litigation rules.[38] See Banque Commerciale SA (in liq) v Akhil Holdings Ltd (1990) 169 CLR 279, 286 (Mason CJ and Gaudron J).[39] Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658, 664 (Murphy, Wilson, Brennan, Deane and Dawson JJ). Thus far, the current proceedings have been far from efficient. The question remaining is what should happen next. Is this a case in which the issues arising are more amenable to being defined by affidavits of evidence being filed, rather than the case proceeding on the basis of pleadings? Is it a case which may be amenable to some form of primary dispute resolution in order to limit expense? If so, what needs to be done to prepare it for such a process?