Hudson v National Australia Bank

Link copied
Case Copied 77 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hudson v National Australia Bank [2022] FCA 1222

File number: NSD 1277 of 2019
Judgment of: MARKOVIC J
Date of judgment: 14 October 2022
Catchwords: CONSUMER LAW – misleading or deceptive conduct – unconscionable conduct – breach of contract – natural justice – where first applicant caused second applicant to enter into a sub-originator agreement with the second respondent – where second respondent terminated the sub-originator agreement – whether second respondent engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct by making representations to the effect that the first applicant had not performed her role satisfactorily – whether respondents engaged in unconscionable conduct in allegedly forming false conclusions about the applicants without giving them a proper hearing and then suspending and terminating the applicants by reason of those allegedly false conclusions – where the second respondent refused to provide a letter of separation in the terms requested by the applicants – whether in doing so the second respondent engaged in unconscionable conduct – whether second respondent breached confidentiality and good faith obligations contained in the sub-originator agreement – whether the respondents owed a duty to the applicants to afford them natural justice – application dismissed
Legislation:

Australian Consumer Law being Sch 2 to the Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 18, 21, 22

National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009 (Cth) ss 6, 7, 8, 9, 29, 35, 47, 64

Cases cited:

Australian Consumer and Competition Commission v TPG Internet Pty Ltd (2020) 278 FCR 450

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Kobelt (2019) 267 CLR 1

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v National Australia Bank Limited [2020] FCA 1494

Bodney v Bennell (2008) 167 FCR 84

Cordon Investments Pty Ltd v Lesdor Properties Pty Ltd [2012] NSWCA 184

Carey v Freehills [2013] FCA 954

Dasreef Pty Limited v Hawchar (2011) 243 CLR 588

Enderby Town Football Club Ltd v Football Association Ltd [1971] Ch 591

Good Living Company Pty Ltd v Kingsmede Pty Ltd (2021) 284 FCR 424

I&L Securities v HTW Valuers (Brisbane) Pty Ltd (2002) 210 CLR 109

Paciocco v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (2015) 236 FCR 199

R v Gaming Board for Great Britain; Ex Parte Benaim v Khaida [1970] QB 417

Re Pergamon Press [1971] Ch 388

R v Commission for Racial Equality; Ex Parte Hillingdon London Borough Council [1982] AC 779

Sundararajah v Teacher’s Federation Health Limited (2011) 283 ALR 720; [2011] FCA 1031

Trans Petroleum (Australia) Pty Ltd v White Gum Petroleum Pty Ltd (2012) 268 FLR 433; [2012] WASCA 165

Trivett v Nivison [1976] 1 NSWLR 312

Unique International College Pty Ltd v Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (2018) 266 FCR 631

Watson v Foxman (1995) 49 NSWLR 315

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Commercial and Corporations
Sub-area: Commercial Contracts, Banking, Finance and Insurance
Number of paragraphs: 446
Date of hearing: 30 August 2021 – 6 September 2021
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr M W Young SC
Solicitor for the Applicants:
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hudson v National Australia Bank and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 1222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The applicants, Ms Hudson and Leaseworks, filed an application against the respondents, National Australia Bank (NAB) and FAST, for relief including damages and an order under s 236 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth). The applicants sought to establish that the respondents engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct, and a breach of contract. The applicants also sought to establish that the respondents failed to afford natural justice, and that FAST breached the sub-originator agreement. The primary legal issues were whether the respondents engaged in misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct, and a breach of contract, and whether FAST breached the sub-originator agreement. The court found that the applicants failed to establish any of their pleaded claims. The court found that the respondents did not engage in misleading or deceptive conduct, unconscionable conduct, or a breach of contract, and that FAST did not breach the sub-originator agreement. The court found that the applicants had not established a causal link between the respondents’ conduct and the losses they suffered. The court dismissed the proceeding and reserved the question of costs. The court ordered the parties to confer on the question of costs and, if they were unable to reach an agreement, to file and serve their submissions on the question of costs. Unless either party requested an oral hearing, the question of costs would be determined on the papers. The court made orders dismissing the originating application and further amended statement of claim and ordering the parties to confer on the question of costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The originating application filed on 8 August 2019 and the further amended statement of claim filed on 6 May 2020 be dismissed.

2. The parties are to confer on the question of costs of the proceeding and either:

(a) on or before 28 October 2022 provide the Associate to Markovic J with proposed consent orders addressing the costs of the proceeding; or

(b) if the parties are unable to agree as to the proposed form of orders then:

(i) on or before 4 November 2022 the respondents are to file and serve their submissions on the question of costs of the proceeding, not exceeding five pages in length; and

(ii) on or before 11 November 2022 the applicants are to file and serve their submissions on the question of costs of the proceeding, not exceeding five pages in length; and

(c) unless either party requests an oral hearing, the question of costs will be determined on the papers.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

THE STATUTORY CONTEXT

[4]

THE FACTS

[13]

The witnesses

[13]

Ms Hudson and Leaseworks

[15]

FAST

[22]

NAB

[31]

BPM

[33]

BPM broker reviews

[34]

BPLAC

[38]

Leaseworks is accredited and enters into a sub-originator agreement with FAST

[45]

Submitting loan applications to Panel Lenders

[55]

Leaseworks’ FAST affiliated accreditations

[60]

Ms Hudson meets Mr Dandachli

[65]

Ms Hudson meets with Mr Maroun, ANZ

[72]

Events following Ms Hudson’s meeting with Mr Maroun

[74]

The August 2014 email

[89]

Accreditation with ANZ

[98]

The Dandachli database of files

[101]

Mr Mohamed’s early interactions with Ms Hudson

[103]

First BRR Report

[106]

First file review meeting

[113]

Events following the first file review meeting

[134]

First BPLAC Submission

[139]

May 2016 BPLAC meeting

[144]

First and final warning letter

[146]

Second BRR Review

[155]

Second BPLAC Submission

[159]

Ms Nguyen recommends that Ms Hudson undertake a compliance audit

[164]

April to June 2017

[171]

NAB suspends Ms Hudson

[188]

Second file review meeting

[195]

Third BPLAC Submission

[225]

Events following the second file review meeting

[227]

Ms Hudson’s health

[234]

Mr Davidson prepares a “BPLAC Firm Review Submission”

[239]

Extraordinary BPLAC meeting – 14 August 2017

[241]

NAB cancels Ms Hudson’s accreditation and FAST gives notice of its intention to terminate the Sub-Originator Agreement

[251]

FAST issues a letter of separation

[256]

Steps taken by other Panel Lenders – August 2017

[260]

BPLAC meetings – 30 August 2017 and 12 September 2017

[264]

FAST terminates the Sub-Originator Agreement

[267]

Ms Hudson’s accreditation terminated by other Panel Lenders – September 2017

[268]

Correspondence between the parties

[271]

Evidence given by Mr Currie and Dr Hasham

[276]

THE PLEADED CASE

[289]

DID NAB AND FAST ENGAGE IN MISLEADING OR DECEPTIVE CONDUCT?

[298]

Statutory framework and legal principles

[298]

The applicants’ submissions

[302]

Consideration

[306]

DID NAB AND FAST ACT UNCONSCIONABLY?

[312]

Statutory framework and legal principles

[312]

The applicants’ submissions

[319]

Consideration

[333]

DID NAB AND FAST FAIL TO AFFORD NATURAL JUSTICE?

[345]

The applicants’ submissions

[346]

Consideration

[353]

DID FAST BREACH THE SUB-ORIGINATOR AGREEMENT?

[374]

The applicants’ submissions

[377]

Consideration

[379]

DAMAGES

[394]

The expert evidence

[395]

Mr Monaghan’s evidence

[397]

Objection to Mr Monaghan’s report

[404]

Respondents’ submissions

[406]

Reasons for overruling the respondents’ objection

[413]

Mr Giliberti’s evidence

[422]

The joint report

[425]

The applicants’ alternate claim for damages

[440]

CONCLUSION

[444]

Background

Background to the litigation

Against that background I turn to set out the facts.THE FACTSThe witnesses The following witnesses gave evidence for the applicants:(1)Ms Hudson. She has been a director of Leaseworks since its incorporation save for the period from 30 July 2017 to 19 August 2018. Ms Hudson has worked in the finance industry for 20 years. She has a Certificate III in financial services and a Certificate IV in finance and mortgage broking. Since May 2012 Ms Hudson has been an accredited member of the Finance Brokers Association of Australia Limited, and as part of maintaining her membership, has completed various courses. Ms Hudson was the principal witness relied on by the applicants. She gave evidence about Leaseworks’ business, her own experience as a broker and her dealings with NAB and FAST. Ms Hudson was cross-examined. While I accept that she was doing her best, Ms Hudson’s evidence was unreliable in some respects which I have described below. While I accept that her recollection of events was likely affected by the passing of time and possibly by her health issues which, unbeknownst to her, she was experiencing at the time, there are instances where her recollection cannot not be accepted;(2)John Christopher Currie who was a director of Leaseworks from its incorporation in 2007 until 2012. He holds 41% of the shares in Leaseworks. Mr Currie gave evidence about his interactions with Anthony Hasham who had an interest in acquiring Leaseworks or its business. Mr Currie was cross-examined;(3)Anthony Hasham who is the sole director of Australian Consulting Engineers Pty Ltd (ACE), a multi-disciplinary firm that provides civil and structural engineering services. ACE has around 150 staff with offices in Lebanon, Abu Dhabi, the Philippines and Australia. Dr Hasham gave evidence about his interest in acquiring Leaseworks, or its business, and discussions he had in about 2015 to 2017 about that. He was cross-examined; (4)Professor Stan Sidhu, a specialist endocrine surgeon, who provided a report on Ms Hudson’s health as at July 2017. Professor Sidhu was not cross-examined; and(5)Trevor Monaghan, an accredited business valuation specialist under the Chartered Accountants Australia and New Zealand (CAANZ). Mr Monaghan prepared two reports on behalf of the applicants in which he opined as to the loss suffered by each of Ms Hudson and Leaseworks as a result of the conduct that they allege was engaged in by NAB and FAST. Mr Monaghan also prepared a joint report with the respondents’ expert, Adam Giliberti. Mr Monaghan gave evidence concurrently with Mr Giliberti. The following witnesses gave evidence for the respondents:(1)Rob Ryan who was an employee of NAB from November 2006 until March 2021. From August 2013 until the sale of FAST in early 2021, Mr Ryan was the Head of Northern Region for FAST, a leadership and management function for New South Wales (NSW), the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) and Queensland (QLD). In that role, he was involved in managing operations in those states and leading and managing a team of eight partnership managers, including Patrick Clarkson and Hien Nguyen (see below), who together practice managed about 800 brokers in NSW, the ACT and QLD. Mr Ryan was also a member of the FAST Leadership Team. This involved managing, coaching and leading a distribution team. Mr Ryan was cross-examined;(2)Patrick Clarkson who has been employed by NAB since 2013 in the role of FAST partnership manager. In that role Mr Clarkson was responsible for: (a)developing and managing relationships with a portfolio of brokers aggregated with FAST;(b)assisting brokers to obtain accreditation with Panel Lenders (described at [24] below);(c)assisting brokers with compliance and risk management, commissions, managing broker relationships for FAST’s Panel Lenders, client relationship management (CRM) and training, including in the use of the CRM system. From March 2013 until 30 September 2014, Mr Clarkson was Ms Hudson’s FAST partnership manager. He gave evidence about his interactions with Ms Hudson. Mr Clarkson was cross-examined;(3)Hien Nguyen who was an employee of FAST from September 2015 to February 2019 and also held the role of FAST partnership manager. In that role she had the responsibilities described at (2)(a)-(c) above. From about July 2015 until Ms Hudson’s termination in 2018, Ms Nguyen was Ms Hudson’s FAST partnership manager. She gave evidence about her interactions with Ms Hudson in that role. Ms Nguyen was cross-examined;(4)Allison Smith who has been an employee of NAB since 23 January 1989. She is currently the manager of broker partnerships monitoring and the chair of the Broker Partnerships Lender Accreditation Committee (BPLAC), a committee within NAB (described at [38] below). Ms Smith gave evidence about her review of submissions for and attendance at relevant BPLAC meetings. She was cross-examined; (5)Nick Notaras, NAB’s “head of broker distribution for NSW/ACT”. Mr Notaras is responsible for managing a team of business development managers (BDM) and relationship associates who, in turn, support brokers submitting home loan applications to NAB in relation to, among other things: NAB policy; process; pricing and compliance. Mr Notaras’ team manages day to day interactions with the brokers in their respective portfolios, part of which involves reviewing and managing broker activity that may be a potential risk to NAB. Mr Notaras had limited direct involvement with individual brokers. Mr Notaras gave evidence about his role in completing and considering submissions prepared for BPLAC. Mr Notaras was cross-examined;(6)Brent Davidson, a NAB employee from May 2011 until March 2018. From August 2015 to March 2018, Mr Davidson held the role of “manager broker relationship team NSW/ACT, broker distribution”. In that role, he conducted file review meetings with brokers accredited with NAB for the purpose of reviewing a selection of files for loans the broker had submitted to NAB for approval. From August 2015 to March 2018, Mr Davidson attended approximately eight to 15 file review meetings each month with brokers accredited with NAB. Mr Davidson gave evidence about his attendance at file review meetings with Ms Hudson and subsequent reporting. Mr Davidson was cross-examined; (7)Mustafa Mohamed who has held the role of “BDM, broker distribution”, with NAB since 2015. Mr Mohamed is a member of the BDM team managed by Mr Notaras. He was Ms Hudson’s NAB BDM from 1 February 2015 to July 2017 and gave evidence about some of his discussions and other interactions with Ms Hudson. Mr Mohamed was cross-examined; (8)Shane Mahoney who is a senior consultant, cyber forensic and investigations, with NAB. Mr Mahoney gave evidence about conducting an “email recovery search” for emails sent between the emails addresses of Ms Hudson, Mr Ryan and Mr Clarkson between July and October 2014. Mr Mahoney was not cross-examined;(9)Monique Tavares, a solicitor in the employ of Dentons, the respondents’ solicitors. Ms Tavares gave evidence about her review of the material identified during the “email recovery search” undertaken by Mr Mahoney. Ms Tavares was not cross-examined; and(10)Adam Giliberti who is a member of CAANZ and is recognised by CAANZ as a forensic accounting specialist and a business valuation specialist. Mr Giliberti provided his expert opinion on Ms Hudson and Leaseworks’ claim for damages and responded to Mr Monaghan’s report. Mr Giliberti gave evidence concurrently with Mr Monaghan.Ms Hudson and Leaseworks

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

A summary of the evidence given by Mr Monaghan and Mr Giliberti follows.Mr Monaghan’s evidence In his first report Mr Monaghan was asked to address two questions:(1)what loss had Ms Hudson suffered as a result of the “Conduct”?; and (2)what loss has Leaseworks suffered as a result of the “Conduct”?In the letter of instruction provided to Mr Monaghan, the “Conduct” was defined as follows:In August 2017 the Respondents then proceeded first to suspend and then terminate their business relationships with the Applicants. Also in or around August and September 2017, the Respondents contacted a variety of lenders for whom the Applicants worked to inform them first of the suspension and then later of the termination. The communications carried the imputation that the suspension and termination were due to the misconduct of the Applicants. This imputation was strengthened by the subsequent (and ongoing) refusal by the Respondents to provide a letter to the Applicants (which they would then be able to show to other lenders to restore their reputation) stating that the termination was not as a result of misconduct on their part. … In answer to the first question, Mr Monaghan calculated that Ms Hudson had suffered a loss of personal income of $87,799 (after tax) for the period 1 July 2017 to 30 June 2020 in addition to lost potential dividends and share value. In order to assess Ms Hudson’s loss Mr Monaghan calculated the difference between what Ms Hudson actually earned in that period with what she would have earned in the same period “but for” the Conduct. For the purposes of calculating Ms Hudson’s actual remuneration, Mr Monaghan had regard to the pre-tax wages declared by Leaseworks for Ms Hudson, adjusted by any increase in her loan account, income tax and the Medicare levy. For the purpose of calculating the wage Ms Hudson would have received in the “but for” scenario, Mr Monaghan had regard to a document titled “PayScale salary data for mortgage brokers in Australia” (PayScale data document). He adopted the 90th percentile total pay for the 2020 financial year from the PayScale data document and reduced that amount by 3% for each preceding year to allow for deflation. He then adjusted the resulting amounts for income tax and the Medicare levy to give a net income figure in each of the relevant years. In answer to the second question, Mr Monaghan calculated Leaseworks’ loss for the period 1 July 2017 to 30 June 2020 as $378,755. He arrived at that figure by undertaking two calculations. The first was for loss of profits from declining lending commissions compared to the “but for” scenario between 1 July 2017 and 30 June 2020 which he calculated to be $168,880. The second was for loss of business goodwill as at 30 June 2020 from declining profits and, in particular, the declining trailing income when compared to the “but for” scenario. Mr Monaghan calculated loss of business value of $209,895. For the purpose of that valuation Mr Monaghan valued the business at 30 June 2020 and compared that value to what the value would have been “but for” the Conduct. In doing so he calculated the actual business valuation and the “but for” business valuation as at 30 June 2020 using the “recurring revenue method” which he opined is the primary valuation method used in the mortgage broking industry adopted by buyers and sellers, particularly for smaller businesses. As a check method of that calculation, Mr Monaghan also carried out calculations of the value of the actual and “but for” values of Leaseworks’ business as at 30 June 2020 using the capitalisation of future maintainable earnings method, which resulted in a lengthy lower valuation for both scenarios. Objection to Mr Monaghan’s report

Decision

Reasons for decision

Secondly, Dr Hasham accepted that before he could proceed with a sale he would need to satisfy himself that the trail commission figure was accurate and he would do that by inspecting Leaseworks’ books. As he said “once there was something solid [they] would be doing some forensic accounting confirming everything is fine and then moving on”. However, there was, to adopt Dr Hasham’s language, nothing “solid”. There had been discussions and, at best, an expression of interest. But no agreement had been reached on any terms, let alone purchase a price. CONCLUSION The applicants have failed to establish any of their pleaded claims. Accordingly the proceeding should be dismissed. Costs would ordinarily follow the event. However, the respondents have requested that I reserve on the question of costs. The parties are to confer on the question of costs of the proceeding and either to provide my Associate with proposed consent orders addressing the costs of the proceeding within 14 days of the date of publication of these reasons, or if they are unable to reach agreement on that issue:(1)the respondents are to file and serve their submissions on the question of costs of the proceeding, not exceeding five pages in length, within 21 days of the date of publication of these reasons; (2)the applicants are to file and serve their submissions on the question of costs of the proceeding, not exceeding five pages in length, within 28 days of the date of publication of these reasons; and(3)unless either party requests an oral hearing, the question of costs will be dealt with on the papers. I will make orders accordingly.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.