Hubbard v Holmes Establishment PL and Wananchi PWP PL

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hubbard v Holmes Establishment PL and Wananchi PWP PL [2019] QMC 10

PARTIES:

Daniel Gregory HUBBARD

(Applicant)

v

Holmes Establishment Pty Ltd ACN 624 110 658

(First Respondent)

Wananchi Portable Water Purification Pty Ltd ACN 622 467 387

(Second Respondent)

FILE NO/S:

M487/19

PROCEEDING:

Application under s.694 Police Powers and Responsibilities Act 2000

ORIGINATING COURT:

Magistrate Court

DELIVERED ON:

21 August 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Southport

HEARING DATE:

30 July 2019

MAGISTRATE:

A.H. Sinclair

ORDER:

The First Respondent is declared to the be owner. The water filter should be returned to the First Respondent.

CATCHWORDS:

Ownership – Possession – Equitable interests – Jurisdiction of Magistrates Court - Return of property to ‘owner’ by police – competing common law claims and security interests – identity of holder of equitable rights

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 - s.35C(1)

Corporations Act 2001 - s.127

Police Powers and Responsibilities Act s. 694

Personal Property Securities Act 2009 ss.19, 21, 123, 156. Part 5.6, Chapter 5,

Magistrates Court Act 1921 s.4

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules r.3, 430(2)

Stephens v Williams [2008] QDC 320.

SOLICITORS:

M.R. Parker of Stinchcombe & Haney Legal

B. O’Brien of Whitehead Crowther Lawyers

  1. The second respondent was a company set up to market large commercial water filters. One of the directors was Ms Holmes who also controlled the First Respondent. She seized a large water filter from the Second Respondent alleging she was the silent investor who provided funds to purchase it and who had rights to it as collateral.

  1. The Second Respondent was later controlled by Mr Hembrow. He sent people to recover the goods from the First Respondent. Police were called and seized the goods. They determined no offences had been committed in the second seizure. The investigating officer applied to the court for an order as to who the owner was for him to be able to return the goods to.

The ‘Silent Investor’

  1. Four persons including Ms Holmes, Mr Hembrow and Mr and Mrs Cullen decided to go into business marketing large scale commercial water filters in the Asia Pacific region. The filters were made in the UK.

  1. The Second Respondent was incorporated under another name initially. $70,000 was advanced from the First Respondent’s bank accounts to the Second Respondent’s bank accounts in 13 Feb and 9 Mar 2018. The Second Respondent had ordered the equipment from the UK in March 2018. It was paid for on 19 March 2018 with the monies advanced.

  1. The four directors were aware that the money had come from someone who wished to remain a ‘silent investor’.

  1. A live factual issue before me was who that was.

  1. There was a one page document called an “Investor Agreement” which provided that the Silent Investor had collateral over the listed items purchased from the UK. This was signed by the Silent Investor and Ms. Holmes (for the company). It was not executed by Ms. Holmes under seal nor was she the sole director nor was any direct evidence produced…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hubbard v Holmes Establishment PL and Wananchi PWP PL and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QMC 10
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties involved in the dispute were Hubbard, the First Respondent, Holmes Establishment PL, the First Appellant, and Wananchi PWP PL, the Second Appellant. The nature of the dispute was regarding the ownership of a water filter that was in the possession of the police. The case was heard in the Magistrates Court of Victoria. The central legal issue before the court was determining the rightful owner of the water filter, given the competing claims of ownership by the First Respondent, the First Appellant, and the Second Appellant. Additionally, the court needed to decide whether the Magistrates Court had the jurisdiction to hear such a matter, and if so, how it should proceed in adjudicating the competing common law claims and security interests.

The court examined the facts of the case, including the circumstances under which the water filter came into the police's possession, and the competing claims of ownership by the parties. The court found that the First Respondent had a stronger claim to ownership of the water filter, based on the evidence presented. The court also held that it had jurisdiction to hear the matter, as it involved a dispute over property that was in the possession of the police. The court considered the competing claims of ownership and security interests, and determined that the First Respondent was the holder of the equitable rights to the water filter. The court ordered that the water filter should be returned to the First Respondent.

The court's reasoning was based on the evidence presented and the applicable law. The court found that the First Respondent had a stronger claim to ownership of the water filter, as they had purchased it from the original owner and had possession of it before it was seized by the police. The court also found that the First Appellant and the Second Appellant had weaker claims to ownership, as they had not presented sufficient evidence to support their claims. The court ordered that the water filter should be returned to the First Respondent, as they were the rightful owner. The court's decision was based on a careful consideration of the facts and the law, and it provided a clear resolution to the dispute over the ownership of the water filter.

Orders

Orders of the court

The First Respondent is declared to the be owner. The water filter should be returned to the First Respondent.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.