TRADE MARKS ACT 1995
DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS
Re:Oppositions by HS TM, LLC to applications by Schein Orthopadie-Service KG to (partially) remove trade mark registrations 562338 (5) & 562340 (10) HENRY SCHEIN, INC. owned by HS TM, LLC
Delegate:
Michael Kirov
Representation:
Opponent: Sam Hallahan of Corrs Chambers Westgarth, assisted by Tatiana Stein of the same firm
Applicant: Relied on written submissions prepared by Phillips Ormonde Fitzpatrick
Decision:
2016 ATMO 63
Oppositions pursuant to s 96 of the Trade Marks Act 1995: s 92(4)(b) considered - use shown for a broad range of goods and s 92(4)(b) ground only partially established. Exercise of discretion in Opponent’s favour for the remaining goods.
Background
HS TM, LLC (“the Opponent”) is the registered owner of trade mark registrations 562338 and 562340 (“the Registrations”), relevant details of which are as follows:
Registration Number: 562338
Filing Date: 27 August 1991
Goods: Class 5: Pharmaceutical preparations, namely, analgesics, anaesthetics, antacids, antibiotics, antihistamines, cathartics, depressants, expectorants, hormones and stimulants; external and topical preparations and dermatological preparations, namely, acne cleansers and creams, anti-bacterial ointments, antiseptic cleansers, eardrops and moisturizing creams; opthalmic preparations, namely eyedrops and solutions used in connection with contact lenses; veterinary preparations for the treatment of animals, coughing, motion sickness, vitamin and mineral deficiencies and worm infections for pets; dental preparations, namely, adhesives, alginates, alloys, anaesthetics, cements, germicides and sealants; and all other goods included in this class
Trade Mark: HENRY SCHEIN, INC.
Endorsement: Registration gives no right to the exclusive use of the word HENRY. The preceding endorsement(s) were recorded prior to commencement of the Trade Marks Act 1995.
Registration Number: 562340
Filing Date: Same as 562338
Goods: Class 10: Medical, veterinary, podiatric and dental apparatus and accessories, included in this class; dentists chairs, dental care units for association with dentists chairs comprising apparatus and accessories for servicing the patient in the chair including the basin, the tray, drills, drill supports and an ancillary equipment; dental curing lights for heating and drying non-metal based dental plates, bridges and teeth fillers; dental hand pieces; veterinary, dental, podiatric and medical instruments; vibrators and wax pots for heating dental waxes; syringes; surgical gloves, masks included in this class and gowns included in this class; dental, podiatric and medical instruments including amalgam carriers, burnishers, bone chisels, curettes, excavators, explorers, forceps, hemostats, knives, mallets, needle holders, probes, scales, scissors included in this class and sutures; and all other goods included in this class
Trade Mark: Same as 562338
Endorsement: Same as 562338
For convenience I will hereafter refer to the trade mark subject of the Registrations collectively as “the Trade Mark”.
On 20 February 2013 Schein Orthopadie-Service KG (“the Removal Applicant”), filed applications based on s 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (“the Act”) seeking partial removal of the Registrations from the Register in relation to the following goods: (“the Removal Goods”).
562338 (5): “and all other…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read HS TM, LLC v Schein Orthopadie-Service KG and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ATMO 63
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issues before the hearing officer were whether the Opponent had used its trade marks in Australia for goods falling within the broad descriptions of the registrations, and if not, whether the Registrar's discretion should be exercised to allow the registrations to remain unamended. Specifically, the hearing officer had to determine if the Opponent had demonstrated use of the trade mark in Class 5 for "Pharmaceutical and veterinary preparations", "Sanitary preparations for medical purposes", "Plasters", "Materials for dressings", "Material for stopping teeth, dental wax", and "Disinfectants", and in Class 10 for "Surgical, medical, dental and veterinary apparatus and instruments" and "orthopaedic casting tape".
The hearing officer found that the Opponent had indeed used the trade marks in Australia during the relevant period for goods falling within these specified broad descriptions. While the applications for removal were therefore successful in principle to the extent that the registrations covered goods beyond these categories, the hearing officer exercised the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3) of the Act in favour of the Opponent. This discretion was exercised because there was no evidence or persuasive submission from the Removal Applicant demonstrating why it would be against its interests or otherwise unreasonable to allow the registrations to remain unamended, given the extensive use of the trade marks and their variants featuring the "HENRY SCHEIN" name in Australia over many years.
Consequently, the hearing officer ordered that the registrations should remain unamended. In relation to costs, as both parties achieved partial success and the ultimate decision to leave the registrations unamended relied on the exercise of discretion, the hearing officer determined it appropriate for each party to bear its own costs.
Background
Background to the litigation
During the proceedings, it was established that Schein Orthopadie-Service KG had been using the trade marks in Australia during the relevant period for a range of goods and services that overlapped with those claimed by HS TM, LLC. Specifically, for Registration 562338, Schein Orthopadie-Service KG had used the trade mark for pharmaceutical and veterinary preparations, sanitary preparations for medical purposes, plasters, materials for dressings, materials for stopping teeth and dental wax, and disinfectants. For Registration 562340, the trade mark had been used for surgical, medical, dental and veterinary apparatus and instruments, as well as orthopaedic casting tape. The use of the trade marks was deemed to be genuine and continuous, and the Hearing Officer found that the applications to amend the registrations were in principle successful to the extent that they sought to exclude these goods and services.
However, the Hearing Officer exercised the Registrar’s discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) to leave the registrations unamended. The decision was based on the extensive use of the trade marks by Schein Orthopadie-Service KG in Australia over many years, and the lack of any compelling reason to amend the registrations. The Hearing Officer also noted that both parties were partly successful in the proceedings, and therefore, it was appropriate for each party to bear their own costs.
The case of HS TM, LLC v Schein Orthopadie-Service KG commenced with an application by HS TM, LLC to oppose the registration of certain trademarks held by Schein Orthopadie-Service KG. The opposition was brought under section 92(4)(b) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth), which allows for the opposition of a registered trademark on the basis that the opponent has used an earlier trademark in Australia. This application was heard by a Hearing Officer appointed under the Trade Marks Act. The opposition process included an extensive examination of the use of the trademarks in question in Australia, specifically focusing on whether the trademarks had been used in relation to certain goods during the relevant period. The case involved detailed submissions and evidence from both parties, with particular attention to the specific goods for which the trademarks were registered and the period during which they were used.
Subsequent to the initial opposition hearing, the matter involved further procedural steps, including applications and interlocutory orders. The Hearing Officer considered the submissions made by both parties regarding the exercise of the Registrar's discretion under section 101(3) of the Act. This discretion allowed for the Registrations to be amended or left unamended based on various factors, including the interests of the parties and public policy considerations. The decision to exercise the Registrar’s discretion ultimately hinged on the evidence and arguments presented regarding the use of the trademarks and the interests of the parties involved. Ultimately, the Hearing Officer decided to leave the Registrations unamended, exercising the discretion in favour of the opponent, Schein Orthopadie-Service KG.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the Registrar’s discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) and decided that it was appropriate to exercise this discretion in favour of the Opponent to leave the Trade Mark registrations unamended. The court's reasoning was grounded in the extensive use and recognition of the Trade Mark, featuring the HENRY SCHEIN name, in Australia within their specialized markets over many years. The decision was made in the absence of any compelling evidence or submissions from the Removal Applicant suggesting that exercising the Registrar’s discretion in this manner would be unreasonable or against its interests.
The court analyzed the usage of the Trade Mark in respect of registration 562338 in Class 5. It concluded that the Opponent had indeed used the Trade Mark in Australia during the Relevant Period for goods such as “Pharmaceutical and veterinary preparations”, “Sanitary preparations for medical purposes”, “Plasters”, “Materials for dressings”, “Material for stopping teeth, dental wax” and “Disinfectants”. This satisfied the requirements of section 92(4)(b) of the Act, making the s 92(4)(b) application successful to the extent that registration 562338 covers goods other than these specified categories. The court relied on evidence and submissions presented to substantiate the Opponent's use of the Trade Mark for these goods.
For registration 562340 in Class 10, the court similarly found that the Opponent used the Trade Mark in Australia during the Relevant Period for goods such as “Surgical, medical, dental and veterinary apparatus and instruments” and “orthopaedic casting tape”. This again satisfied the requirements of section 92(4)(b) of the Act, making the application successful in respect of goods other than those specified. The court applied the same legal principles and relied on the same type of evidence to substantiate the use of the Trade Mark for these goods.
In deciding to leave the Registrations unamended, the court exercised its discretion under section 101(3) of the Act. This decision, while recognizing the partly successful outcomes for both parties, turned on the discretionary nature of the Registrar’s decision. Given this discretionary aspect, the court deemed it appropriate that each party should bear its own costs.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Registrar’s discretion under section 101(3) of the Trade Marks Act 1995 (Cth) may be exercised to leave Trade Mark registrations unamended if there is substantial evidence of the Trade Mark’s extensive use in specialized markets over many years. Additionally, the court's decision highlights the importance of demonstrating actual use of a Trade Mark for specific goods to succeed in a s 92(4)(b) application, and in such cases where the discretion is exercised, each party should bear its own costs.