Hoyts Cinemas Ltd v Penrith City Council

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales

          CITATION:
Hoyts Cinemas Ltd - v - Penrith City Council & Anor [1999] NSWLEC 187
          PARTIES
APPLICANT:
Hoyts Cinemas Ltd
RESPONDENT:
Penrith City Council & Anor
          NUMBER:
40246 of 1998
          CORAM:
Lloyd J
          KEY ISSUES:
Judicial Review :- failure to take into consideration relevant matters
- consideration of irrelevant matters
- Wednesbury unreasonableness
Construction & interpretation:- "development standard"
          LEGISLATION CITED:
Environmental Planning & Assessment Act, s 90(1)(d) (now s 79C(1)(b)
Penrith Local Environmental Plan No 43, cl 2(2)(b)(i), cl 16(2)
          DATES OF HEARING:
06/21/1999; 06/22/1999
          DATE OF JUDGMENT DELIVERY:

08/13/1999
          LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:


APPLICANT:
W R Davison SC
AND:
D Miller
SOLICITORS:
Mallesons Stephen Jaques

FIRST RESPONDENT:
S B Austin QC
AND:
A Pickles
SOLICITORS:
Phillips Fox

SECOND RESPONDENT:
B A J Coles QC
AND:
C J Leggat
SOLICITORS:
Cutler Hughes & Harris


    JUDGMENT:

Contents

Paragraph

Introduction 1

Consideration of the social and economic impact 7

Manifest unreasonableness 38

Consideration of irrelevant matters 40

Access 44

Conclusion 62

_______________IN THE LAND AND Matter No: 40246 of 1998

ENVIRONMENT COURT Coram: Lloyd J


OF NEW SOUTH WALES Decision date: 13/08/99

HOYTS CINEMAS LIMITED


Applicant

v

PENRITH CITY COUNCIL & ANOR


Respondent

JUDGMENT



HIS HONOUR:

Introduction

1. The applicant, Hoyts Cinemas Limited (“Hoyts”), claims a declaration to the effect that a development consent granted by the first respondent, Penrith City Council (“the Council”) to the second respondent, Penrith Rugby League Club Limited (“the Club”) for a thirteen-screen cinema complex at the Club’s premises in Mulgoa Road, Penrith (known as “Penrith Panthers”) is void.

2. It must be emphasised at the outset that the decision of the Council to grant development consent cannot be reviewed unless it involves jurisdictional error or Wednesbury unreasonableness (cf Associated Provincial Picture Houses Ltd v Wednesbury Corporation [1948] 1 KB 223 at 233-234; Minister for Aboriginal Affairs v Peko-Wallsend Ltd (1986) 162 CLR 24 at 41). The Council was the body entrusted with the task of determining the development application. If it acted lawfully, bona fide and reasonably its decision cannot be challenged, even if some other body on the same material might legitimately have reached a different view. The other preliminary observation to be noted is that in a challenge to the validity of a development consent, the proof of invalidity rests on the challenger ( Danis Hotels Pty Ltd v Dubbo City Council (1991) 72 LGRA 35 at 37).

3. Penrith Panthers is about 1.5 kilometres from the Penrith central business district. It is on land which is partly zoned Open Space 6(c), partly Residential 2(d) and partly Rural 1(d) under the relevant environmental planning instruments, being Penrith Local Environmental Plan No 43 (as amended) (“LEP 43”) and Penrith Interim Development Order No 93 (as amended). Penrith Panthers is outside the boundary of Penrith City Centre as defined in Penrith Local Environmental Plan (Penrith City Centre) (“Penrith LEP 1997”).

4. On 23 June 1998 the Club lodged a development application for the following development at Penrith Panthers:


      (i) 12…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hoyts Cinemas Ltd v Penrith City Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1999] NSWLEC 187
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hoyts Cinemas Ltd sought a declaration that the development consent granted by Penrith City Council to Penrith Rugby League Club Limited for a cinema complex at Penrith Panthers was void. The applicant claimed that the consent was granted in breach of the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act 1979 (NSW) and the Penrith Local Environmental Plan No 43 (LEP 43). The applicant argued that the Council failed to take into consideration the social and economic impact of the development, failed to consider the objectives of the Penrith Local Environmental Plan 1997, took into consideration irrelevant matters, failed to take into consideration the provision for vehicular access, and granted consent to a development which was in breach of LEP 43. The applicant also claimed that the Council was not authorised to resolve to support variations to clauses 2(2)(b)(i) and 16(2) of LEP 43 pursuant to the State Environmental Planning Policy No 1, and that the resolution of the Council to grant the consent was manifestly unreasonable. The Land and Environment Court found that the Council had considered the social and economic impact of the development, had identified the locality for the purpose of s 90(1)(d) of the Act, and had not failed to take into consideration the relevant matters. The Court also found that the Council had considered the provision for vehicular access and that clauses 2(2)(b)(i) and 16(2) of LEP 43 were development standards which were subject to objection under the State Environmental Planning Policy No 1. The Court concluded that none of the grounds of challenge to the Council’s determination were established and dismissed the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established