Howe and Repatriation Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2000] AATA 1014

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)     No    N2000/133

VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION          )          

Re      JOHN LLOYD HOWE        

Applicant

And    REPATRIATION COMMISSION  

Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Rear Admiral A R Horton AO, Member   

Date17 November 2000

PlaceSydney

Decision      The decision under review is affirmed.   

[Sgd] A Horton
  Member
CATCHWORDS

VETERANS' AFFAIRS – gold card eligibility - service in Volunteer Defence Corps during period of hostilities - whether applicant rendered qualifying service – whether Australian or Allied mariner – whether incurred danger during warship sea trials – whether engaged in military operations against the enemy

Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 - ss 5B(1), 5C(1), 7A, 120(4)
Veterans' Entitlements Amendment (Gold Card) Act 1998 – s 85(4A)

Repatriation Commission v Thompson (1988) 44 FCR 20
Willcocks v Repatriation Commission (1992) 39 FCR 49
Repatriation Commission v Smith  (1987) 15 FCR 327
Re Meldrum and Repatriation Commission  [1999] AATA 330

REASONS FOR DECISION

Rear Admiral AR Horton AO, Member    

This is an application for review of a decision dated 30 September 1999 by a delegate of the Repatriation Commission ("the Respondent"), and affirmed by review under section 57 of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 ("the Act") on 13 January 2000, that John Lloyd Howe ("the Applicant") did not render qualifying service for the purposes of section 7A of the Act, and hence is not eligible for a Gold Card under subsection 85(4A) of the Veterans' EntitlementsAmendment (Gold Card) Act 1998 ("the Gold Card Act"). The Applicant lodged an application for review by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the Tribunal") on 28 January 2000.

At the hearing before the Tribunal on 10 October 2000, the Applicant was self represented. Mr J Marsh, Senior Advocate, appeared for the Respondent. The Tribunal had before it the documents provided by the Respondent pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 ("the T documents"). The Tribunal also took into evidence the following:

Statement by the Applicant dated 16 March 2000.       Exhibit A1     
Letter from the Applicant to the Tribunal dated 19 April 2000. Exhibit A2     
Statutory Declaration by the Applicant, undated, with attached copy of  apprentice indenture.           Exhibit A3     
Statutory Declaration by the Applicant dated 9 October 2000.          Exhibit A4     
Letter from Department of Defence (Naval History Directorate), with attachments, dated 25 September.    Exhibit A5     
Statement by the Applicant dated 9 October 2000.      Exhibit A6     
Respondent's statement of facts and contentions dated 3 October 2000.    Exhibit R1     

ISSUES BEFORE THE TRIBUNAL

  1. The Applicant claims qualifying service as a prerequisite for eligibility for a Gold Card. Eligibility is established pursuant to subsection 85(4A) of the Gold Card Act, which states:

    "(4A)    A veteran is eligible to be provided with treatment under this Part for any injury suffered, or disease contracted, by the veteran, whether before or after the commencement of this Act, if:

    the veteran is 70 or over; and

    the veteran has rendered qualifying service during the period covered by paragraph (b) of the definition of period of hostilities…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Howe and Repatriation Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] AATA 1014
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case between Howe and the Repatriation Commission came before the court in relation to eligibility for gold card status under the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986. The Applicant sought to establish that he was eligible for gold card status, asserting that he met the criteria for being an Australian or Allied mariner during the period of World War 2, or that his service in the Volunteer Defence Corps qualified him for the status. The Repatriation Commission contested the Applicant's eligibility on both grounds, arguing that he did not meet the statutory definitions or the criteria set out in the Ministerial Determination.

The central legal issues the court had to address were whether the Applicant's service met the statutory definition of an Australian or Allied mariner and whether his service in the Volunteer Defence Corps constituted qualifying service under the relevant legislation. The Applicant claimed that he was employed in sea-going service on ships that were either registered in Australia or engaged in trading, which would make him an Australian mariner under section 5C(1) of the Act. Alternatively, he argued that his service in the Volunteer Defence Corps qualified him under section 7A of the Act. The court had to examine the definitions provided in the Act, the evidence presented regarding the Applicant's service, and relevant precedents to determine the validity of these claims.

The court found that the Applicant could not satisfy the definition of either an Australian or an Allied mariner. The evidence demonstrated that the Applicant was an apprentice employed under indenture to Mort's Dock, and his periods at sea were in the context of assisting in trials being conducted by his employer, not in service on a ship registered in Australia or engaged in trading. The ships in question were under construction for naval service and did not meet the criteria for hospital ships, troop transports, or supply ships as outlined in the Act. The court relied on the decision in Re Meldrum and Repatriation Commission [1999] AATA 330, which had similar facts and concluded that the applicant was not employed in sea-going service on a ship registered in Australia. Therefore, the Applicant did not meet the statutory requirements for gold card eligibility.

The court ordered that the Applicant's application for gold card status be dismissed, as he did not meet the qualifying service criteria under the Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Applicant believed that his only periods at sea occurred prior to the relevant ship being commissioned, which the Tribunal assesses as builders trials, but he stated that he could have gone to sea after commissioning. In respect of his involvement in sea trials, the Applicant gave evidence that he was responsible at all times to his civilian employer, Mort's Dock, who gave all directions in regard to his duties. In cross examination, the Applicant stated that during his periods at sea there were no alerts or indications of the presence of enemy forces, nor was he aware of any incidents relating to possible enemy forces. ANALYSIS OF EVIDENCE AND FINDINGS The Applicant broadly based his application for review on either of two separate arguments; that he met the qualifying service criteria pursuant to section 7 of the Act by dint of being an Australian Mariner as defined in section 5C of the Act, and/or by reason of his service in the VDC, wherein such service came under the jurisdiction of the Ministerial Determination dated 18 December 1987 in respect of rendering continuous full time service. In final submission, the Respondent addressed both these issues, submitting that the Applicant did not meet the relevant conditions and had not rendered qualifying service. Section 5C of the Act states, relevantly:"Australian mariner means a person who was, during the period of World War 2 from its commencement to and including 29 October 1945:(a)a master, officer or seaman employed under agreement, or an apprentice employed under indenture, in sea-going service on a ship registered in Australia that was engaged in trading between a port in a State or Territory and any other port; or …(e)a master, officer, seaman or apprentice employed in sea-going service on a ship owned in Australia and operating from an Australian port, being a hospital ship, troop transport, supply ship…Allied mariner means a person who:(a)was during the period of World War 2 from its commencement to and including 29 October 1945:(i)a master, officer or seaman employed under agreement, or an apprentice employed under indenture, in sea-going service on a ship that was engaged in trading; or…" The Applicant was indentured as an apprentice to Mort's Dock to learn the trade of boilermaking. His periods at sea, which were acknowledged by the Respondent and accepted as fact by the Tribunal, were in the context of assisting in trials being conducted by his employer, Mort's Dock. The Respondent relied on the decision in ReMeldrum and Repatriation Commission [1999] AATA 330, in which the "facts are almost identical" and in which that tribunal concluded that "the Applicant was an apprentice employed under indenture to Hayden Engineering and not in sea going service on a ship registered in Australia." In this matter there is no evidence to suggest that the ships in which the Applicant undertook tasks as directed by his employers were registered in Australia, nor that those ships were engaged in trading, nor that the Applicant was "employed in a sea going ship." On the contrary, the evidence identifies that the ships were under construction for naval service. The ships did not meet the descriptive criteria in subsection 5C as hospital ship, troop transport, supply ship, etc. The Tribunal finds therefore that the Applicant cannot satisfy the definition of either an Australian or an Allied mariner.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established