Howden Australia Pty Ltd v Minetek Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Howden Australia Pty Ltd v Minetek Pty Ltd [2019] FCA 981

File number: NSD 827 of 2019
Judge: JAGOT J
Date of judgment: 21 June 2019
Catchwords: EQUITY – interlocutory application –breach of confidence – whether the applicant has shown a sufficient likelihood of success to justify in the circumstances the preservation of the status quo pending the trial – balance of convenience – the interlocutory application, insofar as it remains undetermined, be dismissed
Cases cited: Samsung Electronics Co Limited v Apple Inc [2011] FCAFC 156; (2011) 217 FCR 238
Dates of hearing: 7 and 17 June 2019
Date of last submissions: 6 June 2019
Registry: New South Wales
Division: General Division
National Practice Area: Intellectual Property
Sub-area: Copyright and Industrial Designs
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 43
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr J Hennessy SC with Ms F John
Solicitor for the Applicant: Bird & Bird
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr F Corsaro SC with Mr M Connor
Solicitor for the Respondent: HWL Ebsworth Lawyers

ORDERS

NSD 827 of 2019
BETWEEN:

HOWDEN AUSTRALIA PTY LTD

First Applicant

JAMES HOWDEN & COMPANY LTD

Second Applicant

AND:

MINETEK PTY LTD ACN 167 164 936

First Respondent

MINETEK INVESTMENTS PTYLTD

Second Respondent

REMY MARCEL SYDNEY BOURCIER

Third Respondent

JUDGE:

JAGOT J

DATE OF ORDER:

21 JUNE 2019

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The interlocutory application, to the extent it has not yet been determined, be dismissed.

2.The applicants pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application as agreed or taxed.

Note:   Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.


REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JAGOT J:

  1. These reasons for judgment explain why I have decided that interlocutory relief should be refused.

    Background

  2. The applicants (together, Howden) are the owners and licensee of information they claim to be confidential relating to the design and construction of large industrial-scale fans known as mixed flow fans.  These fans are used in the mining industry to ventilate mine shafts. 

  3. The third respondent, Mr Bourcier, was employed as Howden Australia’s senior design engineer.  In that capacity he had access to information claimed to be confidential.  Mr Bourcier left Howden’s employ on 1 September 2016 and went to work with the first respondent (Minetek).  At this time Minetek did not produce mixed-flow fans for mine ventilation.  Five months later Minetek filed two provisional patent applications for mixed flow fans naming Mr Bourcier as the inventor.  In mid-April 2019, one of engineers saw a fan on a site which bore the name Minetek.  The engineer took photographs of this fan which Minetek calls a “high output axial fan”.

  4. Howden commenced this proceeding alleging breach of confidence, breach of contract, and misleading or deceptive conduct.  In addition, Howden claim interlocutory relief seeking to restrain Minetek from supplying, or promoting for supply, the high output axial fan or components of it and from using or disclosing the Howden Confidential Information and making certain representations.  In the oral…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Howden Australia Pty Ltd v Minetek Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FCA 981
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Howden Australia Pty Ltd sought an interlocutory injunction against Minetek Pty Ltd, Mr Bourcier, and others, claiming that Minetek had breached confidence by using confidential information relating to the design and construction of industrial-scale fans. Howden alleged that Mr Bourcier, who left Howden and joined Minetek, used confidential information from Howden in the development of Minetek's high output axial fan. Howden sought an injunction to restrain Minetek from using or disclosing this information and from supplying or promoting the fan.

The court had to decide whether Howden had established a sufficient likelihood of success to justify the preservation of the status quo pending the trial. The court also had to consider the balance of convenience, weighing the potential harm to Minetek if the injunction was granted against the potential harm to Howden if it was not.

The court found that Howden had not demonstrated a sufficient likelihood of success on the merits of its claim. The evidence provided by Howden was insufficient to show that Minetek had used specific confidential information from Howden in the development of its fan. Furthermore, the evidence suggested that the information in question was not unique to Howden and may have been general knowledge in the industry. The court also considered the balance of convenience and found that granting the injunction would cause significant harm to Minetek, potentially resulting in the loss of up to 90% of its revenue, redundancy of employees, and breach of contracts with third parties. The court therefore dismissed the interlocutory application.

The court ordered that the interlocutory application be dismissed and that Howden pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application as agreed or taxed.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The interlocutory application, to the extent it has not yet been determined, be dismissed.

2. The applicants pay the respondents’ costs of the interlocutory application as agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons for judgment explain why I have decided that interlocutory relief should be refused. Background The applicants (together, Howden) are the owners and licensee of information they claim to be confidential relating to the design and construction of large industrial-scale fans known as mixed flow fans. These fans are used in the mining industry to ventilate mine shafts. The third respondent, Mr Bourcier, was employed as Howden Australia’s senior design engineer. In that capacity he had access to information claimed to be confidential. Mr Bourcier left Howden’s employ on 1 September 2016 and went to work with the first respondent (Minetek). At this time Minetek did not produce mixed-flow fans for mine ventilation. Five months later Minetek filed two provisional patent applications for mixed flow fans naming Mr Bourcier as the inventor. In mid-April 2019, one of engineers saw a fan on a site which bore the name Minetek. The engineer took photographs of this fan which Minetek calls a “high output axial fan”. Howden commenced this proceeding alleging breach of confidence, breach of contract, and misleading or deceptive conduct. In addition, Howden claim interlocutory relief seeking to restrain Minetek from supplying, or promoting for supply, the high output axial fan or components of it and from using or disclosing the Howden Confidential Information and making certain representations. In the oral hearing, however, Howden confirmed that it sought the interlocutory injunction based solely on the alleged breach of confidence. The Howden Confidential Information is defined as including certain sections of the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual and of the General Design Manual. The definition is as follows:Howden Confidential Information includes:(a) The information contained in the following sections of the James Howden & Company Limited Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual:(i)06.00.06- Design Process;(ii)06.06.02- Fan Curves;(iii)06.08.06- Impeller Dimensions;(iv)06.08.07- Tip Clearance;(v)06.10.12- Weld Toe Fatigue Design; (vi)06.10.14- Weld Throat Fatigue Design;(vii)06.16.12 Flow Control;(viii)06.16.22- Straightener Design;(ix)06.16.24- Diffuser;(b)(b) The information contained in the following sections of the Howden General Design Manual:(i)20.40.002- Fatigue Analysis of Welds;(ii)20.40.004- Classification of Weld Details;(iii)20.40.006- Stress Calculations;(iv)20.40.008- Fatigue Assessment;(v)20.40.010- High Stress High Cycle Fatigue;(vi)20.40.012- Joints Subject to A Stress Spectrum;(vii)20.40.014- Cycle Counting in Load Spectra;(c)The research product and the engineering and design specifications created in the course of the Project described in Confidential Annexure LS-8 to the affidavit of Livio Salvestro affirmed 24 May 2019;(d)The Mixed Flow File referred to in paragraph 2 of the Affidavit of George Abdo affirmed 24 May 2019. The representations are that the high output axial fan is the subject of a granted patent, is a new invention, that the respondents were the inventors of the high output axial fan, and that the high output axial fan is the product solely of the design and development of the respondents.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

There are two kinds of ventilation systems in mines. One, primary ventilation, supplies air in and out of the mine. This is the business Howden is in. The other, secondary ventilation, is the distribution of the air within the mine. This is the business Minetek was in before developing its high output axial fan. Howden’s evidence Mr Mitchell is employed as Howden’s Director of Technology. He is a mechanical engineer. He described Howden’s mixed flow fans as bespoke technology and large infrastructure projects. Apart from Howden only one other company competes in the global market using similar technology. He explained that the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual was available within Howden on a restricted basis. The current version, from 2017, is only available electronically. It is maintained on a server to which only Howden employees with approval have access. The same controls apply to the General Design Manual. Howden’s policy is that instruction manuals, and engineering and manufacturing drawings are not supplied to customers. Further, the technology cannot be reverse engineered as the design rules by which the fans are constructed are not able to be discerned by mere inspection (and inspection would require the powering down of the mine ventilation system and access to the fan which is enclosed). Mr Mitchell said that Mr Bourcier was part of a team at Howden that from 2012 substantially re-engineered a mixed flow fan project. The work done by that team was ultimately included into the upgraded 2017 Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual. Mr Mitchell viewed the photographs of the Minetek high output axial fan. By reference to the defined confidential information and other information not so defined, Mr Mitchell annotated the photographs. As a result of Mr Mitchell’s reference to other information not within the scope of the definition of the Howden Confidential Information many of Mr Mitchell’s observations are extraneous to the debate. To the extent that the defined confidential information was referred to by Mr Mitchell, his observations are now summarised. By reference to the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual at 06.08.06, Mr Mitchell said the hub of the Minetek fan appears to have a similar angle and that this is a critical feature of mixed flow fans, the blades appear to have the same radius on the leading edge and appear to have similar proportions. Section 06.08.06 contains drawings, calculations and dimensions for the impeller. For 06.10.12 and 06.10.24, Mr Mitchell said the weld between the blades and hub of the Minetek fan has been made in a similar manner including grinding to provide a reduced stress concentration and better fatigue resistance. Those sections of the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual deal with a method to assess weld toe fatigue and a process for welding. For 06.16.22, Mr Mitchell said that the straightening vanes following the impeller appear to be in a similar position to the Minetek fan, have a different number of vanes to impeller blades and the guide vanes are similarly designed to result in axial flow. That section of the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual deals with the outlet guide vane design. For 06.16.24, Mr Mitchell said that the diffuser arrangement appears to be similar to one Howden had used in the past and is also located in a similar position relative to other components. 06.16.24 deals with diffuser design.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Minetek contends that Howden has not established a prima facie case at all. First, Howden does not articulate with sufficient precision or at all the aspects of the confidential information said to be embodied in or otherwise to have permitted the design of the Minetek fan. Second, the assertions that it would have been impossible to design the Minetek fan in the time without resort to Howden’s confidential information has been denied and fully answered by Mr Bourcier. Third, to the extent the Minetek fan reflects any aspect of the asserted confidential information, that is because such information is general knowledge in the industry. Minetek also observed that the case against it is wholly circumstantial. There is no evidence that Mr Bourcier took any Howden information with him and he denies having done so. Further, the confidential information in the manuals post-dates Mr Bourcier’s time at Howden and the evidence indicates that the manuals were in hard copy only while Mr Bourcier was working there. For these reasons there is no, or only a very weak, prima facie case. As to the balance of convenience, the orders sought will place Minetek in breach of contracts making it liable for substantial damages and will impact upon the third parties who have placed orders. It will also impact on two third parties who have partly completed works on their sites which Minetek has been carrying out and will expose Minetek to claims of damages for breach of those contracts. As Mr Bird said, there will be a very serious deleterious effect on Minetek including loss of up to 90% of its revenue, redundancy of employees and redundancy of rental space.Consideration Has Howden established a sufficient or “some” likelihood of success to justify, in the circumstances, the preservation of the status quo pending the trial having regard to the nature of the rights Howden asserts and the practical consequences likely to flow from the order it seeks? In my view, the answer is no. It may be accepted that while working at Howden Australia Mr Bourcier had access to Howden’s manuals in hard copy and also to all engineering drawings and the like stored on the R://drive. It may also be accepted on the evidence that Mr Bourcier was involved in the major project which ultimately led to substantial revisions to the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual. There is no evidence of (and Mr Bourcier denies) taking any of this information with him when he left Howden. More relevantly still, there is no evidence that any information defined in sub paragraphs (c) or (d) of the definition of the Howden Confidential Information has been used in any way in the design of the Minetek fan. The evidence, such as it is, is confined to the alleged use of information from the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual which, in turn, refers to the defined parts of the General Design Manual. This is important, as will become apparent below. The first problem with Howden’s evidence is that it does not disclose what parts of the design work, with which Mr Bourcier was involved between 2012 and 2016 as part of a significant development project, found their way into the Mixed Flow Fan Design Manual or the form in which this work was incorporated into that manual. The evidence is at a very general level. Mr Mitchell said that he recalled that there were reports, emails and presentations that were circulated in relation to the new design development “that were ultimately adopted into the design rules and the electronic version of the Mixed Flow Fan Manual created in 2017”. Mr Salvestro said that the substantial engineering development of the mixed flow fan technology that was created in the course of that supply project “was incorporated in the Howden Mixed Flow Design Manual which was released in June 1997”. There is no information about what was adopted and the form in which it was incorporated.