Howard and Anor and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 59 min read

DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2002] AATA 400

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL      )

)          No N2000/1918

GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE  DIVISION       )          
           Re      RAYMOND HOWARD  GOODMAN CHAPMAN       
  Applicant
           And    AUSTRALIAN POSTAL CORPORATION        
  Respondent

DECISION

Tribunal       Mr M J Sassella Senior Member

Date28 May 2002

PlaceSydney

Decision      The tribunal affirms the decision under review.  The applicant is not entitled to costs in respect of this application.        
   [SGD] M J SASSELLA
  Senior Member
CATCHWORDS
WORKERS COMPENSATION – right lateral epicondylitis – generalised tendonopathy – egg-shell skull analysis – temporary or ongoing aggravation of underlying condition – injury – incapacity for work – incapacity payments – provision of suitable work – work at same level as before injury

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ss 4(1) ("ailment", "injury", "suitable employment"), (9), 14(1), 16(1), 19(1), (2), (4)(a), (g), 40.

Asioty v Canberra Abattoir Pty Ltd (1989) 87 ALR 385
Australian Postal Corporation v Bessey (2001) 32 AAR 508
Re Raymond Howard Chapman and Australian Postal Corporation [2000] AATA 182
Chapman v Australian Postal Corporation [2000] FCA 1700
Re Gibson and Commonwealth (1985) 7 ALD 558
Re Prica and Comcare (1996) 44 ALD 46
Tippett v Australian Postal Corporation (1997) 27 AAR 40

REASONS FOR DECISION

28 May 2002           Mr M J Sassella Senior Member             

HISTORY OF APPLICATION

  1. On 23 October 1998 the applicant, Raymond Howard Goodman Chapman, working for Australian Postal Corporation ("the respondent") in Murwillumbah, lodged an incident report in respect of soreness in his right elbow and right wrist which was caused by sorting of second class mail "over a long period of time".  At the time of the incident he was sorting large letters and small packets and, according to his supervisor Colin Kem, the applicant had claimed that this activity had been affecting his right elbow and wrist for some time (T3).

  2. On the same date as the incident report the applicant also lodged a claim for compensation with his employer (T4).  He again identified the site of the injury as the right wrist and elbow and the cause of the pain as the continuous sorting of small packets and large letters over a long period.  Attached to this claim was a witness statement by a colleague of the applicant, Mark Booth, who stated that "Ray complained of a saw [sic] arm to me about a month ago."  The applicant authorised his doctors to provide information to the Respondent in relation to tennis and golf elbow and tennis wrist of the right arm, which he said were conditions he had been treated for before the incident of 23 October 1998.

  3. On 24 December 1998 a delegate within the Australian Postal Corporation ("the respondent") approved payment of compensation under s 19 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 ("the Act") for the period 24 December 1998 to 20 January 1999.  The compensation was paid in respect of the aggravation of a pre-existing condition, lateral epicondylitis of the right elbow (T9/50).

  4. This condition caused the applicant to be unfit for work, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Howard and Anor and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] AATA 400
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court was an appeal brought by Raymond Howard Chapman and another against the Australian Postal Corporation. The appeal related to a workers compensation claim brought by Mr Chapman following a workplace injury that led to a condition of generalised tendonopathy. The central issues were whether Mr Chapman was entitled to ongoing compensation for an injury that was temporary or ongoing, and whether the respondent was required to provide him with suitable employment. The court was required to determine the correct characterisation of Mr Chapman's injury, its alleged continuing effect, and whether the tribunal had properly considered the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988.

The court considered the evidence from several medical experts, including Dr McGill and Dr Stabler. Dr McGill found no physical condition to account for Mr Chapman's symptoms, while Dr Stabler diagnosed lateral and medial epicondylitis of the right elbow, attributing the condition to Mr Chapman's work activities. The tribunal had previously affirmed the decision that Mr Chapman was not impaired and had no incapacity for work, thus the respondent was not liable to pay further compensation. Mr Chapman appealed this decision on several grounds, including that the tribunal had misinterpreted the meaning of "incapacity for work" under the Act.

The court found that Mr Chapman had the proverbial "egg-shell skull" in that he was unusually susceptible to elbow injury. The court agreed with Mr Grey that Mr Chapman had suffered an injury, but the characterisation and its continuing effect were matters of dispute. The court considered the tribunal's findings on the evidence provided and concluded that Mr Chapman was entitled to compensation for his condition, which was an aggravation of a pre-existing condition. The court noted that the respondent had recognised Mr Chapman's susceptibility to a recurrence of the injury if he returned to his old job.

The court ultimately held that Mr Chapman was entitled to ongoing compensation and that the respondent was required to provide him with suitable employment, in line with the provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988. The appeal was allowed, and the matter was remitted back to the tribunal for further consideration in light of the court's findings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The tribunal's Queensland registry assigned application number Q2000/1125 to the matter as remitted. At a directions hearing in Brisbane on 19 December 2000 Senior Member K L Beddoe issued directions that the application was to be transferred to the tribunal's Sydney registry for it to arrange for a hearing to be held in Murwillumbah and Sydney. The application was then assigned its present number, N2000/1918.BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 28 August 1957 (T1/3). In 1994 his wife left him with three children aged 18, 15 and 13 (T13). He has remarried and has four children from his second wife's family. All seven children live with the applicant and his wife, one of the children having muscular dystrophy (T22). The applicant left school in year 10 (T22) in 1973 (ex A1). In his written statement of evidence (ex A1) the applicant detailed his work history. He worked for the State Rail Authority from 1977 to 1990 as a porter, in a booking office, in a public relations section, as a guard and as a bus coach driver. He was made redundant in 1990. He then did further work driving buses and in ticket sales. He became a carer of his children and then worked for a short while as a school bus driver. He married for a second time in 1995 and returned to work at Australia Post as a casual early in that year. The tasks that he fulfilled as a postal delivery officer were as follows (T29): Mr Chapman had an earlier compensation claim. On 30 September 1997 the respondent had accepted liability in respect of Mr Chapman's "right groin, pulled or stretched muscle for date of incident 16 September 1997". The period of liability was 17 to 23 September 1997 (T9/49).RELEVANT LEGISLATION The relevant provisions from the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 are: ss 4(1) ("ailment", "injury", "suitable employment"), (9), 14(1), 16(1), 19(1), (2), (4)(a), (g), 40.SAFETY, REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION ACT 1988Interpretation4. (1) In this Act, unless the contrary intention appears:…ailment means any physical or mental ailment, disorder, defect or morbid condition (whether of sudden onset or gradual development);…injury means:…(b) an injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee, being a physical or mental injury arising out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment; or(c) an aggravation of a physical or mental injury (other than a disease) suffered by an employee (whether or not that injury arose out of, or in the course of, the employee's employment), being an aggravation that arose out of, or in the course of, that employment;…suitable employment, in relation to an employee who has suffered an injury in respect of which compensation is payable under this Act, means:(a) in the case of an employee who, on the day on which he or she was injured was a permanent employee of the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation and who did not subsequently terminate that employment-employment by the Commonwealth or the licensed corporation, as the case may be in work for which the employee is suited having regard to:(i) the employee's age, experience, training, language and other skills;(ii) the employee's suitability for rehabilitation or vocational retraining;(iii) where employment is available in a place that would require the employee to change his or her place of residence-whether it is reasonable to expect the employee to change his or her place of residence; and(iv) any other relevant matter; and(b) in any other case-any employment (including self-employment), having regard to the matters specified in subparagraphs (a) (i), (ii), (iii) and (iv);…(9) A reference in this Act to an incapacity for work is a reference to an incapacity suffered by an employee as a result of an injury, being:(a) an incapacity to engage in any work; or(b) an incapacity to engage in work at the same level at which he or she was engaged by the Commonwealth or a licensed corporation in that work or any other work immediately before the injury happened.…Compensation for injuries14. (1) Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation in accordance with this Act in respect of an injury suffered by an employee if the injury results in death, incapacity for work, or impairment.…Compensation in respect of medical expenses etc.16. (1) Where an employee suffers an injury, Comcare is liable to pay, in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances), compensation of such amount as Comcare determines is appropriate to that medical treatment.…Compensation for injuries resulting in incapacity19. (1) This section applies to an employee who is incapacitated for work as a result of an injury, other than an employee to whom section 20, 21, 21A or 22 applies.(2) Subject to this Part, Comcare is liable to pay compensation to the employee in respect of the injury, for each of the first 45 weeks (whether consecutive or otherwise) during which the employee is incapacitated, of an amount calculated under the formula: NWE - AEwhere:NWE is the amount of the employee's normal weekly earnings; andAE is the amount per week (if any) that the employee is able to earn in suitable employment.…(4) In determining, for the purposes of subsections (2) and (3), the amount per week that an employee is able to earn in suitable employment, Comcare shall have regard to:(a) where the employee is in employment-the amount per week that the employee is earning in that employment;…(g) any other matter that Comcare considers relevant.…Duty to provide suitable employment40. (1) Where an employee is undertaking, or has completed, a rehabilitation program, the relevant employer shall take all reasonable steps to provide the employee with suitable employment or to assist the employee to find such employment.(2) In this section:"relevant employer" means:(a) in relation to an employee employed by a Commonwealth authority-that authority; and(aa) in relation to an employee employed by a licensed corporation-that corporation; and(b) in relation to any other employee-the Commonwealth.…

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Grey then explained that the applicant's position was that, where an employer puts an employee into a job for 11 hours a week and then, for over two years, employs the worker in a position where he or she works for 40 or more hours a week, then if positions of the full-time type are subsequently available, and the employee is not given one of these, then he or she is entitled to be measured against the full-time type of position for compensation purposes. applicant's oral evidence Mr Chapman told the tribunal that he was originally given permanent part-time work by the respondent for 11 hours a week in August 1996. In cross-examination it was established that he would work for 11 hours a week but also for additional hours depending on absences by other delivery officers. There was no "relieving" postal delivery officer. The depot was too small to justify one. The applicant filled in as such when required. He agreed that this was the only permanent position to which he had ever been appointed. The applicant said that before he was made permanent in 1996 he had worked effectively on a full-time basis. It was understood that he would be given full-time work once he was made permanent. He became full-time de facto. He said that he would not have taken the job if it was to be for only 11 hours a week. Mr Grey called for the applicant's employment contract. This was tabled (ex A10). It referred only to the applicant being required to work for 11 hours a week. There was no record within it of any of these understandings. He had worked additional hours, usually up to 40 hours a week, from the beginning. While his hours had fallen back to 11 a week for a time, they returned to 40 or more a week for two years before he reported his injury in October 1998. His duties had been the same every day, sorting second class mail. He was the only operative doing this work. He then delivered mail on his run using a motor cycle. He would use his left hand to deliver the mail and his right to steady the motor cycle. Prior to 1996 he had never had problems with his right arm, elbow, wrist or shoulder. When he did delivery work he was acting in the delivery depot for others who were absent. From about October 1997 the right arm became sore around the elbow. Mr Chapman was definite that the second class mail sorting was the cause. He reported it to a manager in about May 1998. He and a workmate, Mark Booth, had agreed to rotate their duties and requested approval to do so. The manager, "Louis", refused this and was adamant in the refusal. In October 1998 Mr Chapman could not bear the arm pain any longer. He saw general practitioner, Dr Moran, and was off work until January 1999. By that time the wrist was much improved, the elbow only slightly improved. In January 1999 Mr Chapman commenced a rehabilitation program, working 14 hours a week, spread over five days. He still had considerable pain in the right arm and treatment was ongoing. He did no second class mail sorting. Mr Chapman told the tribunal in the first hearing on 23 February 2000 that his elbow had never been pain-free since 1997 but that the level of pain fluctuated.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 21 July 1999 the applicant requested reconsideration of the decision of 13 July 1999 (T28).reviewable decision On 3 August 1999 the respondent's decision of 13 July 1999 was affirmed by a reconsideration officer (T28). In particular, the reconsideration officer took into account the reports of Dr McGill dated 20 May 1999 (T22) and Dr Stabler, an orthopaedic surgeon, dated 5 July 1999 (T26). Dr McGill found no swelling of any upper limb joint and none in the right elbow. Limb reflexes and x-rays of the right elbow were found to be normal. Specifically he stated: "I did not find evidence of any physical condition to account for his symptoms. His abnormal behaviour with respect to his right upper limb could not be accounted for on the basis of physical disease…"I think there is no physical connection between his current reported symptoms and his work currently or previously." Dr Stabler found that there was no wasting or deformity of right upper limb or neck. He also found that "the specific radiological signs for lateral medial epicondylitis were absent." However Dr Stabler did find that the applicant had widespread tendonopathy and lateral and medial epicondylitis of the right elbow. Dr Stabler stated, "I consider that the tendonopathy of the right elbow is consistent with having been caused by the nature of the work activities which Mr Chapman performs as a postal delivery officer." Despite the fact that Dr Stabler diagnosed lateral and medial epicondylitis of the right elbow, he also stated that x-rays showed "no evidence of an effusion in the right elbow…the specific radiological signs for lateral medial epicondylitis were absent." On the basis of these two reports the respondent ceased liability for compensation, not being satisfied that the applicant's "employment continues to contribute to the condition he claims to be suffering from." On 13 August 1999 the Applicant lodged with the Administrative Appeals Tribunal ("the tribunal") an application for review of the decision (T1). This was lodged in Brisbane as application number Q1999/908. On 8 March 2000 the tribunal affirmed the decision under review in Re Raymond Howard Chapman and Australian Postal Corporation [2000] AATA 182. The tribunal found that even though the applicant could not return to his previous work of sorting mail because of his susceptibility to lateral epicondylitis, he was not impaired and therefore had no incapacity to work. The tribunal found that the availability of the work that the applicant wanted to do was irrelevant. The respondent was not liable to pay any further or ongoing compensation. On 7 April 2000 the Applicant lodged an appeal against the tribunal's decision with the Federal Court on the following grounds:(a)The Tribunal was in error in deciding the applicant was not impaired and had no incapacity for work. There was no evidence to support this finding. (b)The Tribunal misconstrued the meaning of "incapacity for work" pursuant to the Act. (c)The Tribunal failed to consider the provisions of s 19 of the Act. (d)The Tribunal failed to provide adequate reasons for its decision. (e)The Tribunal failed to consider the applicant's entitlements to medical expenses pursuant to s 16 of the Act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Grey responded. He agreed that Mr Chapman had the allegorical egg-shell skull in that he was unusually susceptible to elbow injury. He had had an up front injury rather than an aggravation. Australia Post has not asked Mr Chapman to resume his old job. They recognise that he is susceptible to a recurrence of the injury if he returns to that work. Section 40 identifies where the duty lies to give Mr Chapman a suitable job.tribunal consideration Mr Grey correctly identified the basic legal steps to be negotiated. The first issue is whether Mr Chapman suffered an injury and, if so, whether that is a continuing injury. Clearly Mr Chapman suffered an injury on or before 23 October 1998, the date of lodgement of his compensation claim. Australia Post accepted that as the case and provided compensation coverage until 13 July 1999. However, the correct characterisation of that injury and its alleged continuing effect are matters of dispute. The tribunal found Dr Stabler's evidence somewhat difficult to accept in full. He saw the applicant as suffering from lateral epicondylitis and considered that to be an ongoing, virtually permanent medical condition, albeit with periods of fluctuating intensity. In addition, he alone of the experts considered that he could see a point of ossification on a plain x-ray which, in his view, confirmed the diagnosis of lateral epicondylitis. In his oral evidence he contended that an orthopaedic surgeon is in a better position than a rheumatologist to diagnose such a condition as epicondylitis because of the surgical experience of operating on sites of pain. While this might, at face value, suggest that his assessment of lateral epicondylitis as a permanent condition forms the better view, it is significant that another orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Sweeney, who also diagnosed epicondylitis in late 1998 (T13) and saw it as attributable to his employment. He also saw it as a temporary phenomenon. Indeed, for reasons that will be clear below, his report is quite telling. He saw the injury as an injury in the form of an aggravation of Mr Chapman's pre-existing condition. Unfortunately he says little about that pre-existing condition other than to say "there may be some degeneration pre-existing the causative effects of sorting mail" (T23/68). He wrote, "In my opinion, his work has aggravated his condition and I am uncertain when the effects of the work relation aggravation will cease" (T13/68). He saw the condition as "quite acute" in November 1998. He regarded that as a little unusual for epicondylitis and he thought that rest and the injection of cortisone in the extensor region would relieve the condition. He regarded Mr Chapman as partially incapacitated for work, in part on the basis of what Mr Chapman said he could still do despite the elbow complaint. Dr Sweeney thought Mr Chapman would be partially incapacitated for approximately six months (ie until May 1999 or thereabouts). He thought that "Mr Chapman's symptoms should settle within 12 months" and that the "prognosis [was] good as this condition usually responds to treatment".