Hossain v Ray White Sunnybank Hills

Link copied
Case Copied 13 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Hossain v Ray White Sunnybank Hills  [2022] QCATA 066

PARTIES:

MOAZZEM HOSSAIN

(applicant/appellant)

v

RAY WHITE SUNNYBANK HILLS

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

APL226-21

ORIGINATING APPLICATION NO/S:

MCDT84/21

MATTER TYPE:

Appeals

DELIVERED ON:

24 May 2022

HEARING DATE:

13 May 2022

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

A/Senior Member Traves

ORDERS:

1.     Leave to rely on fresh evidence is refused.

2.     Leave to appeal is refused. The appeal fails.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – where minor civil dispute heard by Member  - where tenant sought to raise hardship through COVID-19 on appeal – where tenant made oral application to rely on fresh evidence as to hardship at the hearing of the appeal – where application opposed – where tenant claims member erred in not applying special term of lease which tenant claimed entitled him to one week free rent  - where tenant purported to add to grounds of appeal by claiming during hearing of appeal that Member did not allow him to be heard – whether application for fresh evidence should be allowed – whether any reasonably arguable grounds of appeal 

Residential Tenancy and Rooming Accommodation Act 2009 (Qld) s 277, s 308, s 327, s 331.

Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 147

Clarke v Japan Machines (Australia) Pty Ltd [1984] 1 Qd R 404.

Cordery v Century 21 – Investment Focus [2013] QCATA 218.
Hiscox v PBG Realty [2019] QCATA 112
Lombato v Gardian Real Estate Pty Ltd [2021] QCATA 130
Pickering v McArthur [2005] QCA 294

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

Respondent:

Self-represented

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. This is an appeal by a tenant, Moazzem Hoassain, from a decision of an Adjudicator  in a residential tenancy matter. The Adjudicator ordered the residential tenancies authority to pay the sum of $836.90 held as rental bond as follows: the sum of $833.67 to the lessor and the sum of $3.23 to the tenant.

    The decision at first instance

  2. The tenancy agreement between the lessor (represented by Mr Zhu on behalf of Ray White Sunnybank Hills) and the tenant was a tenancy for a fixed term expiring on 27 March 2021. On 24 February 2021 the tenant gave the lessor’s agent a notice of intention to leave without grounds, with a handover date of 10 March 2021.[1]

    [1]Form 13 issued on 24 February 2021; Residential Tenancy and Rooming Accommodation Act 2009 (Qld) (RTRA Act), s 308.

  3. The lease contained a special term which provided:

    One week free will be available by the end of the last week of the lease date.[2]

    [2]Lease dated 26 September 2020, Part 3 Special Terms, clause 7.

  4. It is the application of that term in circumstances where Mr Hoassain vacated early that is at the heart of this dispute. Mr Hoassain submitted at first instance, and on appeal, that he was entitled to one week free rent up to 10 March 2021, the day he vacated. Mr Zhu, on behalf of the lessor, submitted that the clause applied…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hossain v Ray White Sunnybank Hills and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] QCATA 66
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hossain v Ray White Sunnybank Hills involved an appeal by a tenant, Moazzem Hossain, from a decision of an Adjudicator in a residential tenancy matter. The Adjudicator ordered the residential tenancies authority to pay the sum of $836.90 held as rental bond to the lessor, with a small amount to be returned to the tenant. The dispute centered on the application of a special term in the lease which provided for one week free rent at the end of the lease date. Hossain claimed he was entitled to this benefit despite vacating early, while the lessor argued the term applied to the week immediately preceding the end of the lease.

The legal issues before the court were whether the application for fresh evidence should be allowed and whether there were any reasonably arguable grounds of appeal. Hossain sought to introduce new evidence of financial hardship due to COVID-19 and claimed procedural unfairness in the original hearing. The court examined whether these grounds met the criteria for leave to appeal, which requires a reasonable argument that the decision was attended by error and that an appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice.

The court found that the application for fresh evidence was not warranted as it was unlikely to change the outcome of the appeal. Regarding the grounds of appeal, the court held that Hossain had not demonstrated that the Adjudicator's decision was attended by error. The court found that the Adjudicator correctly interpreted the lease term and that there was no basis to conclude that procedural unfairness occurred. As a result, the appeal was dismissed, and leave to appeal was refused.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Leave to rely on fresh evidence is refused.

2. Leave to appeal is refused. The appeal fails.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute concerning a residential tenancy agreement between Moazzem Hoassain, the tenant, and the lessor represented by Mr Zhu on behalf of Ray White Sunnybank Hills. The tenancy agreement was for a fixed term, expiring on 27 March 2021, and included a special term providing for one week of free rent by the end of the last week of the lease date. On 24 February 2021, Mr Hoassain gave notice of his intention to leave without grounds, with a handover date of 10 March 2021. The primary dispute concerns the interpretation and application of the one week free rent term. Mr Hoassain contends that he is entitled to one week free rent up to 10 March 2021, the day he vacated, while Mr Zhu argues that the term applies to the week immediately preceding the end lease date, i.e., from 20 March to 27 March 2021. The Adjudicator ruled that the end lease date remained 27 March 2021 and that the one week free rent applied to the week immediately preceding that date, regardless of Mr Hoassain vacating early. Consequently, the Adjudicator held that Mr Hoassain was not entitled to one week free rent, owing $668.55 for rent and $165.12 for water charges, making a total of $833.67. Mr Hoassain appealed this decision, raising the grounds of appeal concerning the interpretation of the lease term and the financial hardship caused by COVID-19, which he claimed was not adequately considered.

This case involves an appeal from a decision of an Adjudicator under the Residential Tenancy and Rooming Accommodation Act 2009 (Qld). Mr Hoassain filed an application for leave to appeal on 19 July 2021, seeking permission to appeal the Adjudicator's decision to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT). The appeal concerns the Adjudicator's interpretation of the lease term regarding one week of free rent and the consideration of financial hardship due to COVID-19. During the hearing of the appeal, Mr Hoassain made an oral application to rely on fresh evidence regarding his financial hardship due to COVID-19, which was opposed by Mr Zhu. Additionally, Mr Hoassain claimed that the Adjudicator did not allow him to be heard and that the respondent's representative dominated the hearing. The appeal was heard, and the court had to determine whether Mr Hoassain's application for fresh evidence should be allowed and whether there were reasonably arguable grounds of appeal.

Decision

Reasons for decision

This is an appeal by a tenant, Moazzem Hoassain, from a decision of an Adjudicator in a residential tenancy matter. The Adjudicator ordered the residential tenancies authority to pay the sum of $836.90 held as rental bond as follows: the sum of $833.67 to the lessor and the sum of $3.23 to the tenant.The decision at first instance The tenancy agreement between the lessor (represented by Mr Zhu on behalf of Ray White Sunnybank Hills) and the tenant was a tenancy for a fixed term expiring on 27 March 2021. On 24 February 2021 the tenant gave the lessor’s agent a notice of intention to leave without grounds, with a handover date of 10 March 2021.[1][1]Form 13 issued on 24 February 2021; Residential Tenancy and Rooming Accommodation Act 2009 (Qld) (RTRA Act), s 308. The lease contained a special term which provided:One week free will be available by the end of the last week of the lease date.[2][2]Lease dated 26 September 2020, Part 3 Special Terms, clause 7. It is the application of that term in circumstances where Mr Hoassain vacated early that is at the heart of this dispute. Mr Hoassain submitted at first instance, and on appeal, that he was entitled to one week free rent up to 10 March 2021, the day he vacated. Mr Zhu, on behalf of the lessor, submitted that the clause applied to the week immediately prior to the end lease date, that is, from 20 March to 27 March 2021. The Adjudicator held that the end of lease date remained 27 March 2021 (despite the notice of intention to leave) and that the one week free rent provided for in the lease applied to the week immediately preceding that date, whether or not Mr Hoassain had elected to leave early. On that basis, the Adjudicator held that Mr Hoassain was not entitled to one week free rent and that he owed the lessor $668.55 for rent up to 11 March 2021 and $165.12 for water charges, making a total of $833.67. Grounds of appeal Mr Hoassain wants to appeal that decision. Because this is an appeal from a decision of the Tribunal in its minor civil disputes jurisdiction, leave is necessary.[3] Leave to appeal will usually be granted where there is a reasonable argument that the decision is attended by error, and an appeal is necessary to correct a substantial injustice to the applicant caused by that error.[4][3]Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld) (QCAT Act), s 142(3)(a)(i).[4]Pickering v McArthur [2005] QCA 294 at [3]. Mr Hoassain relies on two grounds of appeal in his application for leave to appeal filed on 19 July 2021. They are, to summarise:(i) The one week free rent period in the tenancy agreement was altered on 24 February 2021 when ‘[Mr Hossain] agreed to vacating without ground’ by submitting the Form 13 to Ray White. The parties agreed that the tenancy was to end on 10 March 2021. (ii) Financial hardship suffered by Mr Hoassain due to the financial impact of COVID-19 on his investment income which was not properly considered by the Adjudicator at first instance. After Mr Hossain had been heard in relation to those grounds of appeal, Mr Hoassain said that he was not given a fair amount of time in the hearing at first instance to raise his arguments, and that the respondent’s representative screamed and was otherwise allowed to dominate the hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The appeal in Hossain v Ray White Sunnybank Hills was dismissed by the court, focusing on three main issues. Firstly, the court refused the application for fresh evidence, finding that the evidence Mr Hoassain sought to introduce was not new and did not relate to the grounds of appeal as initially presented. Secondly, the court examined the grounds of appeal concerning the interpretation of the lease term and the consideration of financial hardship due to COVID-19. The court held that Mr Hoassain's arguments lacked merit as the lease term was clearly interpreted by the Adjudicator, and the financial hardship due to COVID-19 was not a factor that could alter the terms of the lease. Thirdly, the court found no error in the Adjudicator's handling of the hearing at first instance, dismissing Mr Hoassain's claims that he was not given a fair opportunity to present his arguments or that the respondent's representative dominated the hearing. The court's reasoning was grounded in the interpretation of the lease terms and the procedural fairness of the initial hearing. The binding legal principle established in this case is that fresh evidence not pertinent to the grounds of appeal cannot be introduced during the appeal process, and financial hardships due to external events such as COVID-19 do not alter the agreed terms of a lease. The court did not depart from prior authority in its decision but applied established principles of lease interpretation and appeal procedure.