Horwood and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Horwood and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) [2017] AATA 87 (31 January 2017)

Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION

File Number:           2015/0114

Re:Gloria Horwood

APPLICANT

AndRepatriation Commission

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member
Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:31 January 2017

Place:Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 26 November 2013 and substitutes therefor, the decision that the applicant is granted the war widow’s pension with effect from 19 September 2013.

.................[sgd].......................................................

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

Veterans' affairs - entitlements - war widow's pension - hypertension causing death - where hypertension caused by consumption of alcohol - whether there is a causal connection between consumption of alcohol and operational service - whether there is a reasonable hypothesis connecting death from hypertension with operational service - whether satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the death was not war-caused - decision set aside and substituted

LEGISLATION

Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) ss 196B(14)(d), 120, 120A

CASES

Repatriation Commission v Deledio [1998] FCA 391, (1998) 83 FCR 82

Repatriation Commission v Tuite (1993) 39 FCR 540

Roncevich v Repatriation Commission (2005) 222 CLR 115

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Statement of Principles concerning cardiomyopathy No. 85 of 2015

Statements of Principles concerning hypertension, No. 63 of 2013
Statement of Principles concerning ischaemic heart disease (Reasonable Hypothesis), No. 1 of 2016

'Advisory from Disability Compensation Branch No 2/2000', Department of Veterans Affairs and the Repatriation Medical Authority

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mrs J C Kelly, Senior Member
Dr L Bygrave, Member

31 January 2017

THE REVIEWABLE DECISION

  1. Mrs Gloria Horwood, the applicant, has asked the Tribunal to review the decision the Repatriation Commission made on 26 November 2013 refusing her claim for the war widow’s pension under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act). That decision was affirmed by the Veterans’ Review Board on 27 October 2014.

    BACKGROUND

  2. The following findings are not contentious. The applicant’s husband, Mr John Horwood, was born in 1926 and died on 18 September 2013. He enlisted in the Australian Navy on 18 May 1945. He had five months training at HMAS Cerberus and was then sent to HMAS Penguin to wait for a draft to a ship. He joined HMAS Bataan on 12 December 1945 and spent just under nine months in the ship in Australian waters and then five months on passage to Japan, service in Japan and passage back to Australia.  He remained in the ship until 24 February 1947 and was discharged on 18 April 1947.  His service is relevantly “operational” service under the Act. Therefore the standard of proof is that of reasonable hypothesis. Mr and Mrs Horwood met just after Mr Horwood turned 21 in November 1947. They were engaged in 1948 and married in 1950 and had three children, including Max who was born in 1956. The applicant suffered from hypertension at the time of his death. The parties agreed that the clinical onset of hypertension was July 1997.

  3. In summary, before the hearing, the applicant’s contention…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horwood and Repatriation Commission (Veterans’ entitlements) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 87
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mrs Gloria Horwood for a review of the Repatriation Commission's decision to refuse her claim for a war widow's pension. The applicant's husband, Mr John Horwood, who had served in the Australian Navy during a period considered operational service under the *Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986* (Cth), died from hypertension. The applicant contended that her husband's death was war-caused, arguing that his service led to his consumption of alcohol, which in turn caused his hypertension and ultimately his death from ischaemic heart disease.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether there was a causal connection between Mr Horwood's operational service and his consumption of alcohol, and consequently, whether there was a reasonable hypothesis connecting his death from hypertension with his operational service. The Tribunal was required to determine if the material before it satisfied the requirements of the relevant Statements of Principles (SoPs) for hypertension and ischaemic heart disease, and if so, whether it was satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that his death was not war-caused.

The Tribunal applied the principles established in *Repatriation Commission v Deledio*, which outline a four-step process for assessing claims involving operational service. This process requires the Tribunal to first consider if the material points to a hypothesis connecting the death with service, then ascertain if an applicable SoP is in force. If an SoP is in force, the Tribunal must determine if the hypothesis fits the SoP's "template." Only at the final stage does the Tribunal consider whether it is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the death was not war-caused, at which point factual findings are made. In this case, the applicant conceded that she would not press the ischaemic heart disease aspect of her claim, and the respondent conceded that Mr Horwood likely met the criteria for hypertension under the relevant SoP regarding alcohol consumption. However, the respondent argued that there was no material demonstrating a causal connection between Mr Horwood's service and his commencement of drinking alcohol, citing his statement that he began drinking due to peer pressure and referring to an advisory suggesting military service might have the opposite effect on alcohol habituation.

The Tribunal found that the respondent had not established beyond reasonable doubt that Mr Horwood's death was not war-caused. While the applicant had not established a causal link between Mr Horwood's service and his alcohol consumption, the respondent had also failed to discharge its onus of proving the death was not war-caused. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the previous decisions and substituted a decision in favour of the applicant, granting the war widow's pension.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mrs Gloria Horwood, the applicant, has asked the Tribunal to review the decision the Repatriation Commission made on 26 November 2013 refusing her claim for the war widow’s pension under the Veterans’ Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth) (the Act). That decision was affirmed by the Veterans’ Review Board on 27 October 2014.BACKGROUND The following findings are not contentious. The applicant’s husband, Mr John Horwood, was born in 1926 and died on 18 September 2013. He enlisted in the Australian Navy on 18 May 1945. He had five months training at HMAS Cerberus and was then sent to HMAS Penguin to wait for a draft to a ship. He joined HMAS Bataan on 12 December 1945 and spent just under nine months in the ship in Australian waters and then five months on passage to Japan, service in Japan and passage back to Australia. He remained in the ship until 24 February 1947 and was discharged on 18 April 1947. His service is relevantly “operational” service under the Act. Therefore the standard of proof is that of reasonable hypothesis. Mr and Mrs Horwood met just after Mr Horwood turned 21 in November 1947. They were engaged in 1948 and married in 1950 and had three children, including Max who was born in 1956. The applicant suffered from hypertension at the time of his death. The parties agreed that the clinical onset of hypertension was July 1997. In summary, before the hearing, the applicant’s contention was that her husband’s death was the result of his service. The connection with his service was that he began drinking alcohol because of his service, he suffered from hypertension as a result of his drinking, and his hypertension resulted in ischaemic heart disease (IHD), which was the “kind of death” Mr Horwood suffered. That contention depended on the Statements of Principles (SoP) for both hypertension and IHD being satisfied. In the hypertension SoP (No. 63 of 2013), at least one of several factors listed in cl 6 “must be related to the relevant service rendered by the person” (cl 5). Relevantly:6. The factor that must as a minimum exist before it can be said that a reasonable hypothesis has been raised connecting hypertension or death from hypertension with the circumstances of a person’s relevant service is: …(b) consuming an average of at least 300 grams of alcohol per week for at least the six months before the clinical onset of hypertension.THE PARTIES’ CONCESSIONS BY THE END OF THE HEARING The applicant’s counsel made the following concessions:·The applicant was not pressing the smoking aspect of her claim.·Although not made explicitly, after the evidence of Associate Professor Haber and Professor O’Rourke, both very experienced cardiologists, and the respondent’s concessions, the applicant did not press ischaemic heart disease as a cause of death or rely on the relevant SoP, No. 1 of 2016. The respondent’s counsel made the following concessions:·There was material before the Tribunal pointing to Mr Horwood satisfying factor 6(b) of the Hypertension SoP, to the extent that he was consuming an average of at least 300 grams of alcohol per week for at least the six months before the clinical onset of hypertension. ·The respondent was not contending that the cause of death was cardiomyopathy and was not relying on SoP for cardiomyopathy (No. 85 of 2015). The respondent accepted that the hypertension SoP applied because in this case, the cardiomyopathy was caused by hypertension. Those concessions were made after both Associate Professor Haber and Professor O’Rourke had given evidence. Professor O’Rourke gave evidence that the cause of Mr Horwood’s death was the effects of long standing high blood pressure, hypertension. He maintained that the hypertension was almost exclusively due to age and the stiffening of the aorta. Professor O’Rourke described the condition as hypertensive cardiomyopathy which he said was excluded from the SoP for cardiomyopathy. He explained that in general terms cardiomyopathy indicates some abnormality of the heart muscle which could be caused by a toxin like alcohol or a virus or the cause may be unknown. He explained that the distinction between the SoPs for hypertension and cardiomyopathy is that one deals with arteries and one deals with the heart muscle. THE ISSUE TO BE DETERMINED

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Repatriation Commission v Deledio, the Full Federal Court set out the approach to be taken to apply the legislative scheme of ss 120 and 120A of the Act when a claim is made for a pension in relation to operational service:[1] 1. The Tribunal must consider all the material which is before it and determine whether that material points to a hypothesis connecting the injury, disease or death with the circumstances of the particular service rendered by the person. No question of fact finding arises at this stage. If no such hypothesis arises, the application must fail. 2. If the material does raise such a hypothesis, the Tribunal must then ascertain whether there is in force an SoP determined by the Authority under s 196B(2) or (11). If no such SoP is in force, the hypothesis will be taken not to be reasonable and, in consequence, the application must fail. 3. If an SoP is in force, the Tribunal must then form the opinion whether the hypothesis raised is a reasonable one. It will do so if the hypothesis fits, that is to say, is consistent with the "template" to be found in the SoP. The hypothesis raised before it must thus contain one or more of the factors which the Authority has determined to be the minimum which must exist, and be related to the person's service (as required by ss 196B(2)(d) and (e)). If the hypothesis does contain these factors, it could neither be said to be contrary to proved or known scientific facts, nor otherwise fanciful. If the hypothesis fails to fit within the template, it will be deemed not to be "reasonable" and the claim will fail. 4. The Tribunal must then proceed to consider under s 120(1) whether it is satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that the death was not war-caused, or in the case of a claim for incapacity, that the incapacity did not arise from a war-caused injury. If not so satisfied, the claim must succeed. If the Tribunal is so satisfied, the claim must fail. It is only at this stage of the process that the Tribunal will be required to find facts from the material before it. In so doing, no question of onus of proof or the application of any presumption will be involved. [1] [1998] FCA 391, (1998) 83 FCR 82THE TRIBUNAL’S CONSIDERATION The respondent argued as follows. There is not material before the Tribunal pointing to the applicant’s service causing the applicant to commence drinking alcohol. The respondent accepted that there was a temporal connection but said that Mr Horwood’s statement in the 2009 alcohol questionnaire that he commenced drinking because of peer pressure does not automatically mean a causal connection without something more. It also argued that there was no material pointing to any causal connection between Mr Horwood’s service and his drinking habits later in his life and that there is no diagnosis or contention of alcohol abuse or dependence. The respondent referred to the “Advisory from Disability Compensation Branch No 2/2000” (the Advisory) prepared by the Department of Veterans Affairs and the Repatriation Medical Authority which states:The search revealed only one epidemiological study that bears on the “habituation” issue, that is, whether a “habit” of alcohol drinking continues from the service environment into the community after discharge from service. In fact that paper suggested that not only was there no association with military service there is some evidence that military service produces the opposite effect.