| IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA | Not Restricted | |
AT MELBOURNE
PRACTICE COURT
No. 8499 of 2004
| JOHN HORVATH AND SUZI HORVATH |
| v |
| STATE CORONER OF VICTORIA |
---
JUDGE: | Morris J | |
WHERE HELD: | Melbourne | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 11 October 2004 | |
DATE OF ORDER: | 11 October 2004 | |
CASE MAY BE CITED AS: | Horvath v State Coroner of Victoria | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2004] VSC 452 | |
---
---
APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Plaintiffs | Mr P. Lithgow | |
| For the Respondent | No appearance |
HIS HONOUR:
The order of the court is, firstly, that pursuant to Rule 45.05(02) (a) The requirements Rules 5.03(1) and 8.02 be dispensed with. (b) The plaintiffs be authorised to commence the proceeding by originating motion in Form 5C. (2) Pursuant to s.29(4) of the Coroner's Act 1985 I order that no autopsy be performed upon the body of Johnny Horvath. Next, I order that the defendant pay the plaintiffs' costs of the proceeding.
My reasons: On 6 October 2004 Johnny Horvath, who was then aged seven days, died. Johnny was born at St Vincent's Private Hospital on 29 September 2004. Johnny never fed well and was always sleepy. From the time of his birth he vomited after most feeds. At approximately 7 a.m. on 6 October 2004 his mother, Susie Horvath, discovered Johnny in bed, unresponsive and with vomit in the bed. She immediately called her husband into the bedroom and they attempted to revive Johnny with CPR. They also called an ambulance. The MICA ambulance attended and continued resuscitation for about 35 minutes, when the paramedics and Johnny's parents realised that he had passed away and was beyond resuscitation. The last time Johnny was seen alive was at 4 a.m. when his mother fed him and put him back to bed. He appeared well at that time.
The police were notified of the death and conducted investigations. They are satisfied that the death is not a suspicious death. Johnny was taken to the Royal Children's Hospital and examined by Dr Mike Starr who was the rostered paediatrician. Dr Starr examined Johnny's body and spoke to Johnny's parents. Dr Starr told Mr and Mrs Horvath that the most likely cause of death was SIDS or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, and that he would like to see an autopsy performed to confirm his opinion. Naturally, Johnny's parents are deeply distressed as to the loss of their young son. They are also distressed at the prospect of Johnny's body being the subject of an autopsy. Mr John Horvath says that he and his wife are devout Catholics and it is their desire to be able to provide their son with a decent burial in an open coffin as quickly as possible. Johnny's death was reported to the Coroner. "Pursuant to the Coroner's Act 1985, an unexpected death is a reportable death. A Coroner has jurisdiction to investigate such a death. As part of that investigation if the Coroner reasonably believes that it is necessary for an investigation of a death, the Coroner may…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Horvath v State Coroner of Victoria and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2004] VSC 452
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was tasked with determining whether the Coroner's decision to order an autopsy was justified and whether the court should exercise its discretion under s.29(4) of the Coroner's Act 1985 to prevent the autopsy from occurring. The key issue was whether the public interest in conducting an autopsy outweighed the parents' legitimate concerns and desires regarding their son's burial. The court also considered the Coroner's obligation under s.19(1)(c) to find the cause of death if possible, and whether the potential benefits of an autopsy in this specific case justified the intrusion into the family's grieving process.
Morris J concluded that while the Coroner had a legitimate interest in determining the cause of death, the court's discretion under s.29(4) should be exercised to prevent the autopsy. The judge found that there was no suspicion surrounding the circumstances of Johnny's death, which reduced the necessity of an autopsy for public interest reasons. Furthermore, the court acknowledged the weight of the parents' concerns about the indignity of an autopsy and their desire for a religious burial. Morris J reasoned that the potential public benefits of an autopsy in this case were uncertain and not compelling enough to override the parents' rights and interests. Consequently, the court ordered that no autopsy be performed and that the Coroner pay the costs of the proceeding, mitigating the financial burden on the grieving parents.
The final orders included dispensing with certain procedural requirements, authorising the plaintiffs to commence the proceeding by originating motion, prohibiting the performance of an autopsy on Johnny's body, and directing the Coroner to pay the plaintiffs' costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi