CITATION: Hortis v Papanikolaou [1999] NSWSC 805 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Equity Division FILE NUMBER(S): 3643/97 HEARING DATE(S): 5 August 1999 JUDGMENT DATE:
5 August 1999PARTIES :
Edison Hortis and Dionysia Hortis (P)
George Papanikolaou and Maria Papanikolaou (D)JUDGMENT OF: Master McLaughlin
COUNSEL : Mr. M. W. Young (P) SOLICITORS: Lawrence F. Tanna (P)
Douglas Knaggs (D)CATCHWORDS: CASES CITED: General Steel Industries Incorporated v Commissioner for Railways (1964) 112 CLR 125 DECISION:
SUPREME COURT OF
NEW SOUTH WALES
EQUITY DIVISIONMASTER McLAUGHLIN
Thursday, 5 August 1999
3643/97 EDISON HORTIS & ANOR -v- GEORGE PAPANIKOLAOU & ANORJUDGMENT
1 MASTER: There is presently before the Court an application by the plaintiffs Edison Hortis and Dionysia Hortis made by way of notice of motion filed on 21 July 1999. By that notice of motion the plaintiffs seek orders for the dismissal of certain parts of the amended cross-claim filed by the defendants George Papanikolaou and Maria Papanikolaou on 11 March 1998 and, in the alternative, an order that certain parts of that amended cross-claim be struck out. 2 The plaintiffs are named as cross-defendants to that amended cross-claim in which the defendants are the cross-claimants. 3 The proceedings were instituted by statement of claim filed on 18 August 1997. Subsequently there was on 22 September 1997 filed an amended statement of claim. The cause of action relied upon by the plaintiffs in the amended statement of claim related to the rights of the plaintiffs as the owners of certain property at Bankstown against the defendants as guarantors of a lease entered into in respect of that property by a company Kalwino Pty Ltd (to which I shall refer as “Kalwino”) as lessee, on 13 March 1996 with the plaintiffs as lessors. The defendants guaranteed the performance by Kalwino of its obligations under that lease. 4 There was filed a defence to the amended statement of claim on 16 October 1997 and there was also filed a cross-claim, and subsequently on 11 March 1998 an amended cross-claim. It is that amended cross-claim which is the subject of the present application. 5 By that amended cross-claim the defendants in paragraph 2, which is headed 'Refusal of Assignment' assert that they were sole shareholders and directors of Kalwino (that company being described as 'now in liquidation') and assert that the company entered into a contract for the sale of a business conducted by Kalwino as a reception centre operator, such sale being subject to the assignment of the lease (being described as ‘subject to the assignment of the lease between the plaintiff and the company as lessee and the defendants as guarantors’). 6 Paragraphs 3 and 4 assert that the consent of the plaintiff as lessor was sought to the assignment of the lease, such consent being conditional on the sale of the business, and that the plaintiff wrongfully refused to consent to the assignment. 7 Paragraph 5 asserts that the defendants as a result of such refusal suffered damage (such damage being described…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hortis v Papanikolaou and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
Details
- Case
- [1999] NSWSC 805
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
In the case of Hortis v Papanikolaou, the plaintiffs, Edison Hortis and Dionysia Hortis, filed an application seeking orders for the dismissal of certain parts of the amended cross-claim filed by the defendants, George Papanikolaou and Maria Papanikolaou. The plaintiffs argued that the parts of the amended cross-claim in question disclosed no cause of action, were frivolous and vexatious, and constituted an abuse of the court's process. The defendants, who were the sole shareholders and directors of Kalwino, a company that had leased property from the plaintiffs, claimed damages due to the plaintiffs' refusal to consent to the assignment of the lease to facilitate the sale of Kalwino's business.
The court had to determine whether the defendants had a valid cause of action against the plaintiffs for the alleged refusal to consent to the assignment of the lease and whether the plaintiffs' failure to mitigate their loss constituted a cause of action. The court found that the defendants, as shareholders, did not have a contractual right with the plaintiffs and that any rights arising from the lease assignment would be pursued by Kalwino's liquidator, not the defendants. Furthermore, the court held that the failure to mitigate loss did not constitute a cause of action known to the law.
Consequently, the court dismissed the defendants' claims regarding the refusal to consent to the lease assignment and the plaintiffs' failure to mitigate their loss. The court also ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs for the motion, granted the plaintiffs leave to assess these costs, and allowed the defendants to file an amended defence asserting failure of the plaintiffs to mitigate their loss by a specified date.
The court had to determine whether the defendants had a valid cause of action against the plaintiffs for the alleged refusal to consent to the assignment of the lease and whether the plaintiffs' failure to mitigate their loss constituted a cause of action. The court found that the defendants, as shareholders, did not have a contractual right with the plaintiffs and that any rights arising from the lease assignment would be pursued by Kalwino's liquidator, not the defendants. Furthermore, the court held that the failure to mitigate loss did not constitute a cause of action known to the law.
Consequently, the court dismissed the defendants' claims regarding the refusal to consent to the lease assignment and the plaintiffs' failure to mitigate their loss. The court also ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiffs' costs for the motion, granted the plaintiffs leave to assess these costs, and allowed the defendants to file an amended defence asserting failure of the plaintiffs to mitigate their loss by a specified date.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi