Horta & Ors v The Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 75 min read
~ ~~

IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Office of the Registry

Melbourne No M88 of 1993

B e t w e e n -

JOSE RAMOS HORTA (who brings

these proceedings on his own

behalf and on behalf of the

members of the National Council

of Maubere Resistance)

First Plaintiff

and

JOSE GUSMAO

Second Plaintiff

and

ABEL GUTERRES

Third Plaintiff

and

THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Horta 99 10/8/94

Defendant

Case Stated

MASON CJ
BRENNAN J
DEANE J

DAWSON J

TOOHEY J

GAUDRON J
MCHUGH J

TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS

AT CANBERRA ON WEDNESDAY, 10 AUGUST 1994, AT 10.18 AM

(Continued from 9/8/94)

Copyright in the High Court of Australia

MASON CJ: Yes, Mr Solicitor.

MR GRIFFITH:  Yesterday we made the point to the Court that

it is difficult to separate with finality the

issues of standing whether or not the issues are

justiciable and the question of the extended

external affairs power. The short point we sought

to make yesterday is that it now being an agreed

basis that it is an essential step of the

plaintiffs' case that it involve the Court
resolving the two issues identified in the exchange
with Your Honour Justice Brennan, the unlawfulness

of acquisition of Indonesia, or the second issue of

whether or not the people of East Timor have

exercised their rights of self-determination,

perhaps compendiously can be said to be the issue

of sovereignty in East Timor. We referred the

Court briefly to our submissions, paragraphs 1.l(c)

to (g) identifying those and other issues which we

see essential to determine.

If it is the case that the Court can never be

in a position to determine legality under

international law of the acquisition of East Timor

or sovereignty of Indonesia and these other issues, our submission is that it becomes inappropriate for
the Court to proceed any further with this action
and, in effect, the matter should be struck out.

Our submission is that Australian courts

cannot review these matters for consistency with

international law, and I referred the Court to our

submissions in paragraphs 5.7 to 5.9 of our

submissions.

As it is plain from the pleadings in the

argument that the Court is entitled to inquire into

these areas which it cannot determine, we say that
the Court should refuse to ent~rtain the claim and

we refer briefly at this stage to the Buttes Gas

Horta 100 10/8/94

case, (1982) AC 888 which is summarized in our

contentions, paragraphs 1.24 and 1.25.

I have a particular interest in the Buttes

case because at one stage I was involved as junior

counsel within the chambers in the preparation of

argument on that case, but when one goes to the

speech of Lord Wilberforce, I think uninfluenced by

any of the argument which I prepared, one sees, as

we have extracted in paragraphs 1.24 and 1.25, that

it was clear where there was a matter under

municipal law which the court was competent to

decide, the issue of slander, but where certain

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horta & Ors v The Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1994] HCATrans 426
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of Australia, Jose Ramos Horta, on behalf of the National Council of Maubere Resistance, brought proceedings against the Commonwealth of Australia. The central dispute concerned the plaintiffs' standing to bring the action and the justiciability of the issues raised, particularly in relation to the extended external affairs power. The plaintiffs argued that the Court could not determine the legality of Indonesia's acquisition of East Timor or the sovereignty of East Timor, and that if these issues were essential to the case, the matter should be struck out.

The legal issues before the Court included whether Australian courts were competent to review matters of international law concerning the acquisition of territory and the exercise of self-determination by the people of East Timor. The plaintiffs contended that if the Court was unable to determine these fundamental questions of international law, it should refuse to entertain the claim, drawing an analogy to the principles established in *Buttes Gas and Oil Co Ltd v Hammer (No 3)*. This precedent suggested that where a municipal court is required to decide issues that are inherently inappropriate for judicial consideration, such as significant interstate or international law matters, it cannot proceed with the case.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established