Horsley v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 

CITATION:

Horsley v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited [2022] NSWPIC 387

CLAIMANT: Adam Horsley
INSURER: QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited
MEMBER: Shana Radnan
DATE OF DECISION: 19 July 2022
CATCHWORDS:

MOTOR ACCIDENTS - Assessment of non-economic loss; factors to consider following severe traumatic injuries to right knee and leg, including seven operations in assessment of non-economic loss; assessment of economic losses past not contentious, future economic loss; career path and residual earning capacity; remote location; retraining impact on capacity for work; legal costs claimed; Held -  the insured owed a duty of care to the claimant, breached that duty of care and the claimant sustained injury loss and damage as a result of that breach of duty; entitled to payment of legal costs.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

1.     On the issue of liability for the claim, the QBE’s insured owed a duty of care to the claimant, breached that duty of care and the claimant sustained injury loss and damage as a result of that breach of duty.

2.     Under sub-ss 7.36 (3) and 7.36 (4) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act2017 (the Act), I specify the amount of damages for this claim as $2,609,972.60.

3.     The amount of the claimant’s costs, taking into account the amount of damages assessed in respect of this claim, assessed in accordance with the Act is $138,824.90 inclusive of GST.

Reasons for Decision

Issued under s 7.36(1) of the Motor Accident Injuries Act 2017 (the Act)

This determination relates to an assessment of damages under Part 4 of the Act:

BACKGROUND

  1. Adam Horsley (the claimant) a 46-year-old male who was injured in a motor vehicle accident occurring on 20 December 2019. The accident occurred when a vehicle having dropped him off at the top of a steep driveway, attempted to reverse, lost gear and came down the driveway impacting with him and his garage door.

  2. He was taken by ambulance to Wagga Wagga Base Hospital. He went under general anaesthetic to reduce the dislocation of his right leg and was subsequently transferred to Canberra Hospital for vascular review.

  3. During the ambulance trip from Wagga Wagga to Canberra his leg dislocated again and he underwent surgery on 21 December 2019 to perform a closed reduction of the right knee with external fixation. He remained in Canberra until 1 January 2020 and was then transferred back to Wagga Wagga Base Hospital. He remained in hospital until 17 January 2020. He returned home to the care of his specialist and general practitioner.

  4. At the time he was employed as a paramedic with New South Wales Ambulance working at Wagga Wagga.

  5. Liability was wholly admitted by the insurer. On 24 September 2021 the insurer conceded the claimant was entitled to non-economic loss as his permanent impairment exceeded the statutory threshold.

  6. On 21 December 2021 the claimant lodged his application for damages assessment pursuant to s 7.36 of the Act.

  7. The issue that remains is the amount of damages to which the claimant is entitled.

Documents considered

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Horsley v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWPIC 387
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Horsley v QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited is a case involving the claimant, Adam Horsley, who brought an action against QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited, the insurer, seeking compensation for non-economic and economic losses following a motor accident. The dispute was heard by the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The central issue was the extent of Adam Horsley's non-economic loss, which included the physical and psychological impact of his severe injuries, and the associated economic losses, both past and future, resulting from the accident.

The court was required to consider various factors in assessing Adam Horsley's non-economic loss, including the nature and severity of his injuries, the impact on his daily activities, and his psychological state. The court also needed to determine his future earning capacity, taking into account the limitations imposed by his injuries and the possibility of retraining. Additionally, the court had to consider the claimant's entitlement to legal costs.

The court examined the evidence provided, including medical reports and statements from the claimant and his wife. The reports detailed the extent of Adam Horsley's injuries, the surgeries he had undergone, and the ongoing pain and instability in his right knee. The court found that Adam Horsley suffered from complex knee injuries, which would require multiple surgeries and likely a total knee replacement in the future. The court also noted the psychological impact of the accident, including chronic post-traumatic stress disorder and significant depressive symptoms.

In its decision, the court found that QBE Insurance (Australia) Limited owed a duty of care to the claimant, which was breached, resulting in the claimant sustaining injury, loss, and damage. The court awarded compensation for both non-economic and economic losses. The court also ruled that the claimant was entitled to be reimbursed for legal costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

The claimant in this matter, Adam Horsley, was involved in a motor accident which resulted in severe traumatic injuries to his right knee and leg. The injuries required seven operations and have left Mr Horsley with significant disabilities, including persistent pain, instability, and stiffness in his right knee. Mr Horsley is unable to engage in activities such as playing with his children, mountain biking, hiking, or perform household maintenance tasks. He also reports suffering from depression, intrusive memories, social isolation, and insomnia. Medical reports confirm the claimant's ongoing physical and psychological conditions, with opinions that he will require a total knee replacement in the future, and his capacity for work will be limited to sedentary or administrative duties, potentially requiring retraining. His wife, Fleur Horsley, described the impact of the injuries on her husband, noting his immobility, depression, and inability to perform daily tasks or engage in sexual activity for an extended period.

This case was brought before the court as a matter of personal injury claim following the motor accident. The claimant, Adam Horsley, sought compensation for the non-economic and economic losses he sustained as a result of the injuries. The matter was heard by the court after considering the evidence presented, including medical reports, witness statements, and other documentation. The claimant's entitlement to compensation, the assessment of non-economic and economic losses, and the apportionment of legal costs were the primary issues to be determined by the court.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Whilst he attempted to train as a sonographer, he would not be able to obtain local employment as evidence by Mr Roach - chief radiographer at Wagga Wagga Base Hospital. He reports he continues to suffer pain in his right knee and leg on standing and walking. He is unable to play with his children. Can no longer mountain bike or hike. He is depressed, upset, irritable, short-tempered and suffers insomnia. He suffers intrusive memories and is socially isolated. He lacks confidence. In his further statement of 21 March 2022 the claimant confirmed whilst studying his knee became very stiff and more painful. Upon making the decision to stop the course, he found that the symptoms improved. He continues to undertake physiotherapy rehabilitation program. The plan is to hold off the surgery for at least 10 years. He noted the ongoing risk of the artery attaching to the scar tissue and significant future risks of catastrophic bleeding and nerve damage. He reports even a possibility of amputation, which he is keen to avoid at all costs. Fleur Horsley described the impact of the injuries on her husband. She described the period post accident:“6. When he eventually came home, I had to attend to all his daily need. Because of his immobility, he would mainly just sit on the lounge and watch a lot of TC. I could see that he became very depressed. He was also very concerned about his future. He knew that he would not be able to go back to work as a paramedic. His career had been very important to him. He was looking forward to promotions. From the day of the accident to currently, because of the problems with his leg, he is unable to do much around the house. He can’t do any lawns or gardens. He does some basic cooking and attends to the laundry. He can’t be doing any household maintenance such as the gutter. He can’t even walk to the main street because of the slope of the driveway. He is unable to kneel or squat.7. For almost 12 months following the accident, he moved into the fourth bedroom, There was no sexual activity for at least 12 months. I could see he was in a lot of pain. He would take medication but it didn’t seem to work. He has particularly bad pain following the various surgical procedures.8. Adam is struggling emotionally with the fact he is currently totally incapacitated for performing any work” Whilst significant volume of medical records were produced in this matter (documents A7 to A69 ) there is little dispute that the claimant suffered the injuries he claimed. Medico-legal report to support the claimant’s claim were obtained from the following doctors and I summarise their opinions below;a. Sophia Lahz report dated 31 August 2021 rehabilitation physiciani.DiagnosisComplex right knee injury incorporation tibial plateau fracture, multiple ligament disruption and posterolateral corner disruption, as well as quadriceps tendon avulsion requiring repair.Multiple operationsSurgical scarring to thigh knee and shin.Post-traumatic knee osteoarthritis.Persistent right knee pain and posterior instability with posterior tibial sag. p 25.ii.PrognosisGradually evolving post-traumatic osteoarthritis and will require total knee replacement due to destruction of the joint surfaces by bony fracture and ligament injury with chronic instability.Given his youth it is more likely than not he will require at least two TKR revisions.iii.Disabilitieswalking; standing;running;squatting;kneeling;climbing;lifting;negotiating uneven ground, andnegotiation slopes. (p 26)iv.Fitness for work“He would be fit for light duties in an office based environment (with autonomy for sitting standing and walking according to physical tolerances) although he will be hampered by the lack of available, suitable office -based positions in Wagga”. (p 28) b. Dr T Gothelf report dated 2 October 2021- orthopaedic surgeoni.Reported current statusAdam rated the right knee pain as a two on a scale of zero (no pain) to 10 (worst imaginable) The knee has a constant ache. The knee feels unstable when walking with or without the brace. He wears a hinge knee brace for all of the day. The knee still clicks with movement and the knee is stiff. Adam can walk about 100-200 metres easily. There is recurrent swelling. He gets discolouration of the leg and the leg gets cold at times and then resolves, The leg swells at timesii.ExaminationThe right knee had a severe posterior and posterolateral instability and severe anterior instability. There was laxity to varus stress of 5 degrees. There was medial joint tenderness. iii.PrognosisThe prognosis is poor. The right knee condition is not likely to improve and is more likely to deteriorate and require further surgery for a total knee replacement. Adam has an experience of constant pain and swelling of the right leg with instability and stiffness requiring the use of a brace and a stocking constantly. His ability to perform daily activities will not improve.iv.Fitness for workAdam is not fit for pre-injury occupation. He is fit for light duties with limited walking, no bending, no squatting, no repetitive work.Adams right knee condition will likely deteriorate and he will develop more severe arthritis. … the right knee deterioration will likely result in increased symptoms resulting in a loss of earning capacity in the future.c. Dr B Teoh report dated 14 December 2021 - consultant psychiatristi.Mental State ExaminationHe reported significant anxiety and depressive symptoms. He has been pre-occupied with negative thoughts and worrying about his physical condition and employment. He reported that he has intrusive memories of the accident. He has been agitated and he has avoidant behaviour.He has lost his confidence, he has been worrying about further accidents, he has been easily startled and irritable. He reported feeling depressed and worries. He said that his life has changed and his world had fallen apart. He has been preoccupied with guilt and negative thoughts.There was no evidence of psychotic symptoms or suicidal ideation.His cognitive functions were intact, there was no evidence of short or long term memory impairment.Summary and OpinionChronic Post-Traumatic Stress DisorderHis prognosis is poor and his condition has become chronic.He can benefit from 12 months psychological treatment from psychiatrist psychologist. Whole person impairment 17%. d. Associate Prof Myers dated 29 November 2021 - general and vascular surgeonPrognosisThe knee is going to continue to deteriorate. He already has significant arthritis as seen on scanning and arthroscopies of the knee. ...I am quite sure this will progress. ...Even with the amount of ligamentous and tendinous damage around the knee I suspect the results of this will probably be sufficient to enable him to mobilise, but I do not think he is likely to ever return to anything approaching normal knee function.It is very clear that Mr Horsley has suffered very significant knee injury from which he will never fully recover and for which he will inevitably go on to need knee replacement.Work capacityHis future capacity for work is going to be limited to sedentary or administrative type duties. He may well need to be retrained.e. Dr Synnott report dated 28 March 2022 - consultant psychiatrist

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate assessment of non-economic loss for the claimant considering the severity of his injuries and their impact on his physical and psychological well-being?
2. How should the court determine the claimant's future economic losses, including his residual earning capacity and the impact of retraining on his capacity for work?
3. Are the claimant's legal costs claimable, and if so, to what extent?

Held
1. The court concluded that the appropriate assessment of non-economic loss for the claimant, considering the severity of his injuries and their impact on his physical and psychological well-being, is to award the claimant compensation for non-economic loss.
2. The court determined that the claimant's future economic losses should be assessed based on his residual earning capacity and the impact of retraining on his capacity for work. The court awarded the claimant compensation for future economic losses.
3. The court ruled that the claimant's legal costs claim is claimable, and the claimant is entitled to payment of legal costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the severity of the claimant's injuries, the impact on his physical and psychological well-being, and the medical evidence provided. The court found that the claimant suffered significant trauma to his right knee and leg, including multiple operations and persistent pain. The court also noted the claimant's psychological impact, including chronic post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety, depression, and loss of confidence. The court referred to the opinions of medical experts who confirmed the claimant's disabilities, prognosis, and fitness for work. Based on the evidence, the court concluded that the claimant is entitled to compensation for non-economic loss.

In assessing the claimant's future economic losses, the court considered the claimant's residual earning capacity and the impact of retraining on his capacity for work. The court referred to the opinions of medical experts who confirmed the claimant's limited work capacity and the need for retraining. The court found that the claimant's future capacity for work is going to be limited to sedentary or administrative type duties, and he may need to be retrained. Based on the evidence, the court concluded that the claimant is entitled to compensation for future economic losses.

The court also considered the claimant's legal costs claim. The court found that the insured owed a duty of care to the claimant, breached that duty of care, and the claimant sustained injury loss and damage as a result of that breach of duty. The court concluded that the claimant is entitled to payment of legal costs.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases of severe traumatic injuries, the court will consider the impact of the injuries on the claimant's physical and psychological well-being and assess compensation for non-economic loss accordingly. The court will also consider the impact of the injuries on the claimant's residual earning capacity and the impact of retraining on his capacity for work when assessing future economic losses. Additionally, the court will consider the claimant's legal costs claim and determine if the claimant is entitled to payment of legal costs.