Hornet Aviation Pty Ltd v Ansett Australia Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA  )
  )
TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY        )    No. TG 24 of 1994
  )
GENERAL DIVISION                  )

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE
                FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:HORNET AVIATION PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:ANSETT AUSTRALIA LIMITED

Respondent

CORAM:   JENKINSON, BEAUMONT AND VON DOUSSA JJ.

DATE:    30 MARCH 1995

PLACE:   HOBART

MINUTES OF ORDER

THE COURT ORDERS:

Appeal dismissed with costs.

Note:     Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with by Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA  )

TASMANIA DISTRICT REGISTRY        )    No. TG 24 of 1994
  )
GENERAL DIVISION                  )

ON APPEAL FROM A JUDGE OF THE
                FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

BETWEEN:HORNET AVIATION PTY LTD

Appellant

AND:ANSETT AUSTRALIA LIMITED

Respondent

CORAM:   JENKINSON, BEAUMONT AND VON DOUSSA JJ.

DATE:    30 MARCH 1995

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

INTRODUCTION

By a creditor's statutory demand dated 29 August 1994 for payment of debt ("the demand") addressed to Hornet Aviation Pty. Limited, the appellant, purportedly given under s.459E(2)(e) and Form 509H of the Corporations Law ("the Law"), Ansett International Air Freight, a division of Ansett Transport Industries (Operations) Pty. Ltd. (now named Ansett Australia Limited) the respondent ("Ansett") claimed that Hornet owed it the amount of $47,348.79, being the total of the amounts of the debts described in the Schedule to the demand.  In the Schedule, the following description of debt was given:

"Money owed pursuant to an Agreement between the company ["Hornet"] and the creditor ["Ansett"] whereby the creditor would transport goods on the company's behalf and the company would pay the

creditor's charges of transporting those goods.  Under that Agreement the following debts are owed."

Particulars of the debt in the form of references to dates (between 11 September 1992 and 23 August 1993) invoices and amounts were then given in the total sum of $64,408.94, less several payments made by Hornet between 8 December 1992 and 24 September 1993, giving a balance of $47,348.79.

By application under s.459G of the Law, filed on 20 September 1994, Hornet applied to set the demand aside on several grounds.  It contended that the demand was formally defective in a number of respects.  Hornet also argued that there was a genuine dispute about the debt and that it had an offsetting claim.  The application was contested.  A Judge of the Court (Northrop J.) dismissed the application.  Hornet now appeals from this order.

It will be convenient to deal with the questions argued on the appeal in turn as follows:

CONCLUSIONS ON THE APPEAL

(1)Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand by virtue of its alleged formal defects?

We will take the defects alleged in turn.

(a)  The identity of the creditor
         As has been seen, the creditor was described in the notice as "Ansett International Air Freight, a Division of (Ansett)".  There was evidence before his Honour, which was not challenged, that Ansett traded under "Ansett International Air…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hornet Aviation Pty Ltd v Ansett Australia Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1995] FCA 174
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hornet Aviation Pty Ltd appealed against the decision of a Judge of the Federal Court of Australia, Northrop J., who dismissed an application by Hornet to set aside a statutory demand made by Ansett Australia Limited under the Corporations Law. Hornet argued that the demand was defective in several respects, that there was a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt, and that it had an offsetting claim. The appeal was heard by Jenkinson, Beaumont, and Von Doussa JJ in the Federal Court of Australia. The Court found that the demand was not defective in the ways alleged by Hornet, that the Judge was correct to find that there was no genuine dispute as to the amount of the debt, and that Hornet's claim of an offsetting claim was not genuine. The Court also dismissed Hornet's application to adduce fresh evidence. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

The Court found that the demand was not defective in identifying the creditor, as it was correctly described as Ansett International Air Freight, a division of Ansett. The omission of the date of the affidavit was not a defect that could cause substantial injustice, and the signature of the "executive officer" was valid as the Credit Controller was responsible for managing the debt. The Court accepted the Judge's finding that there was no genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt, and that Hornet's claim of an offsetting claim was not genuine as it was not supported by any evidence. The Court dismissed Hornet's application to adduce fresh evidence as it was not relevant to the decision that ought to have been given at the original hearing. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Hornet Aviation Pty Ltd, the appellant, was addressed by Ansett Australia Limited, the respondent, with a creditor's statutory demand on 29 August 1994 for payment of a debt. The demand, issued under section 459E(2)(e) of the Corporations Law and Form 509H, claimed that Hornet owed Ansett the sum of $47,348.79. This amount represented the total debts listed in the Schedule to the demand, which detailed amounts owed for the transportation of goods by Ansett on Hornet's behalf from 11 September 1992 to 23 August 1993. Hornet applied to set the demand aside on 20 September 1994, arguing that the demand was formally defective and that there was a genuine dispute about the debt and an offsetting claim. A Judge of the Court (Northrop J.) dismissed the application, leading to Hornet's appeal against this order.

The matter was initially heard by a Judge of the Federal Court of Australia, Northrop J., who dismissed Hornet's application to set aside the statutory demand. Hornet appealed this decision to the Federal Court of Australia, where the appeal was heard by Jenkinson, Beaumont, and Von Doussa JJ. The appeal was argued on 29 March 1995, and the judgment was delivered on 30 March 1995, dismissing the appeal with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand by virtue of its alleged formal defects?
2. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand on the ground that there was a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt?
3. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand on the ground that there was an offsetting claim?

Held
1. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand by virtue of its alleged formal defects?
The Court held that there were no formal defects in the demand that could result in substantial injustice to the debtor company. The identity of the creditor, the omission of the reference to the date of the affidavit, and the identity of the "executive officer" signing the demand were not considered defects.

2. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand on the ground that there was a genuine dispute as to the existence or amount of the debt?
The Court held that there was a genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt, but to the extent of $10,483.98, and even allowing for that there was still an amount owing by the debtor company to the creditor of some $36,864.81. However, the appeal failed in this respect as the findings of the primary judge were not challenged.

3. Did his Honour err in refusing to set aside the demand on the ground that there was an offsetting claim?
The Court held that the debtor company did not have a genuine offsetting claim, and the primary judge's conclusion was open to him based on the limited material before him. The Court also dismissed the debtor company's application to adduce fresh evidence.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by addressing the alleged formal defects in the demand, which the debtor company claimed justified setting aside the demand. The Court found that there was no misdescription of the creditor, as the demand clearly referred to the creditor trading under the business name "Ansett International Air Freight." The omission of the reference to the date of the affidavit was also not considered a defect, as the affidavit itself was attached and dated. Lastly, the Court held that the "executive officer" signing the demand was indeed an executive officer within the meaning of the Corporations Law, and therefore the demand was not defective in this respect.

Moving on to the genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt, the Court found that there was a genuine dispute to the extent of $10,483.98, but even allowing for that there was still an amount owing by the debtor company to the creditor of some $36,864.81. The Court followed the submissions advanced on behalf of the debtor company, and as the findings of the primary judge were not challenged, the appeal failed in this respect.

The Court then addressed the issue of the offsetting claim, which the debtor company claimed justified setting aside the demand. The Court held that the debtor company did not have a genuine offsetting claim, as the only real evidence before the primary judge to support this contention was inadmissible. The Court further found that it was open to the primary judge to arrive at the conclusion he did based on the limited material before him. The Court also dismissed the debtor company's application to adduce fresh evidence, as the appeal was not by way of re-hearing and events occurring after the judgment under appeal had been given could not be taken into consideration.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a creditor's statutory demand may not be set aside on the basis of alleged formal defects, genuine disputes as to the existence or amount of the debt, or the existence of an offsetting claim, if the primary judge's conclusions are open to him based on the evidence before him. Additionally, an appeal to the Federal Court of Australia under s.24 of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 is not by way of re-hearing, and events occurring after the judgment under appeal has been given cannot be taken into consideration in determining what that judgment ought to have been.