Hoogendoorn v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 20 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

Hoogendoorn v State of Queensland & ors [2021] QCAT 352

PARTIES: MICHAEL JOHN HOOGENDOORN

(applicant)

v

STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(First respondent)

SERCO AUSTRALIA PTY LTD
(Second respondent)

LUKE MAKEJEV
(Third respondent)

CAMERON STERLING
(Fourth respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

ADL067-17; ADL038-18

MATTER TYPE:

Anti-discrimination matters

DELIVERED ON:

12 October 2021

HEARING DATE:

On the papers

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Traves

ORDERS:

1. Declare that the Heads of Agreement dated 10 February 2021 between the applicant and the second, third and fourth respondents is illegal and void by reason of s 319M(3) of the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld).

2.       Order that the Heads of Agreement dated 10 February 2020 between the applicant and the second, third and fourth respondents be set aside.

3.       Direct that the matter be listed for a Directions Hearing on a date and time to be advised.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – GENERAL CONTRACTUAL PRINCIPLES – FORMATION OF CONTRACTUAL RELATIONS – SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT CONTEMPLATING EXECUTION OF FORMAL DOCUMENT – where ‘heads of agreement’ entered into between applicant and second, third and fourth respondents at compulsory conference – whether concluded agreement – whether agreement should be set aside – where applicant alleges duress – whether agreement void for mistake or illegality – whether agreement void under the Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld) – application of s 74 and s 83 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld).

Corrective Services Act 2006 (Qld), s 319J, s 319M, s 319N, Schedule 4

Queensland Civil and Administrative Act 2009 (Qld), s 28, s 74, s 83, s 84, s 87

State of Queensland v Aigner [2013] QCATA 151

REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

Self-represented

First Respondent:

Mr S Mackie, counsel, instructed by Crown Law

Second, Third and Fourth Respondent:

Carter Newell

This matter was heard and determined on the papers pursuant to s 32 of the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld)

REASONS FOR DECISION

  1. The matter before the Tribunal concerns whether the settlement agreement which was struck on 10 February 2020, following a conciliation conference chaired by Member Paratz, is void or should otherwise be set aside. The Heads of Agreement was executed at the conference by Mr Hoogendoorn and the second, third and fourth respondents.

  2. The applicant, Mr Hoogendoorn, submits that the agreement should be set aside because he says he was coerced or unduly influenced into entering into the agreement. Alternatively, Mr Hoogendoorn submits that it should be set aside because the respondents breached the agreement by tendering to the applicant a comprehensive settlement deed following execution of the agreement on 10 February 2020 which was different in a material respect to the terms of the Heads of Agreement.

  3. The Tribunal, during consideration of the matter, requested submissions on the issue (amongst others) of illegality.[1] The first respondent did not execute the Heads of Agreement but, in response to the directions, made brief submissions in relation to the matter.[2] The position of the second, third and fourth respondents is that the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hoogendoorn v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] QCAT 352
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hoogendoorn v State of Queensland, the central issue revolved around the validity and enforceability of a settlement agreement reached during a compulsory conference under the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) Act. The applicant, Mr. Hoogendoorn, contested the settlement, alleging potential issues of illegality or mistake. The respondents, including the State of Queensland, argued that the settlement agreement was binding and that no legal grounds existed to set it aside. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether it should consider the legality of the settlement agreement despite it not being raised by the applicant.

The primary legal issues the court had to decide were whether the Tribunal was bound to consider issues not directly raised by the parties, specifically the potential illegality or mistake in the settlement agreement, and whether it could set aside the agreement despite the parties' consent. The court needed to balance the statutory obligation to act fairly and according to the substantial merits of the case against the principle of finality in settlement agreements. Additionally, the court had to consider the admissibility of evidence related to the settlement negotiations under the QCAT Act.

The court found that while the Tribunal is not bound by the legal issues raised by the parties, it has a statutory obligation to act fairly and in accordance with the substantial merits of the case. The court concluded that it was incumbent upon the Tribunal to consider issues that were relevant to the validity of the settlement agreement, even if not directly raised by the parties. The court emphasized that this approach was in the interests of justice and did not prejudice the respondents, who were given the opportunity to make submissions on these issues. Regarding the legality of the settlement, the court determined that the Tribunal could not set aside the agreement unless there was evidence of illegality or mistake, which the applicant had not provided. Ultimately, the court upheld the validity of the settlement agreement based on the absence of such evidence.

The final orders of the court were that the settlement agreement reached during the compulsory conference was valid and enforceable, and the Tribunal was not required to consider issues of illegality or mistake not raised by the applicant. The court reinforced the principle that while the Tribunal has broad powers to inform itself in any way it considers appropriate, it must ensure that all relevant material is disclosed to enable it to decide the proceeding with all the relevant facts.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The Tribunal, during consideration of the matter, requested submissions on the issue (amongst others) of illegality.[1] The first respondent did not execute the Heads of Agreement but, in response to the directions, made brief submissions in relation to the matter.[2] The position of the second, third and fourth respondents is that the Heads of Agreement resolved the matter and there is no legal basis for setting that agreement aside. Further, it was submitted that, as the applicant had not alleged nor provided evidence that the settlement agreement might be set aside for mistake or illegality, there was no basis for the Tribunal to give any consideration to those issues.[3][1]Tribunal Directions dated 30 April 2021.[2]First Respondent’s supplementary submissions regarding dismissal of applications filed on 14 June 2021.[3]Submissions of the Second, Third and Fourth Respondents in response to directions issued on 30 April 2021 at [5].Background The parties attended a compulsory conference on 10 February 2020 at which they negotiated a resolution of the proceedings.[4] A document titled “Heads of Agreement” was signed at the conference on 10 February 2020 by Mr Hoogendoorn and the lawyer on behalf of the second, third and fourth respondents. I note that the Heads of Agreement names Serco Asia Pacific Pty Ltd ACN 55 061 889 763 (Serco Asia) as the second respondent and the agreement is signed on behalf of Serco Asia by the lawyers for the second, third and fourth respondents. There is no explanation before me as to why this occurred and no party has contended that the Heads of Agreement is not binding on the second, third or fourth respondents as a consequence.[4]Applications ADL067-17 and ADL038-18. The Heads of Agreement stated that: 1. The parties participated in a compulsory conference before Member Paratz on 10 February 2020 in the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal in Ipswich.2. The parties have agreed to settle all matters in issue between them on the basis that a comprehensive deed of release, discharge and indemnity will be delivered to the applicant for his execution by close of business on Thursday, 13 February 2020. Notwithstanding that, the parties agree that the essential terms of the settlement agreement are set out in these heads of agreement. The terms of the Heads of Agreement included, relevantly, terms that an amount of money would be paid into the applicant’s nominated bank account in full and final settlement of all and any claims the applicant has or may believe he has against the respondents arising out of, referable to or as a consequence of the applicant’s incarceration in Queensland prisons; the settlement sum was to be paid within 28 days of the date of the applicant’s execution of the full deed of release, discharge and indemnity; there was no admission of liability; the terms of the settlement and all negotiations leading up to the settlement were to remain strictly confidential; and that the applicant acknowledges that he has been afforded the opportunity to consider his position with respect to the heads of agreement and to seek advice with respect to accepting these heads of agreement and he does so voluntarily and of his own accord.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In relation to mistake or illegality, it is submitted that there is no evidence or allegation by the applicant that the settlement agreement of 10 February 2020 was infected by mistake or is otherwise liable to be set aside for illegality. Further, apart from the exceptions in s 83(2)(b) of the QCAT Act there is no basis for going behind a settlement agreement reached at a compulsory conference convened pursuant to that Act, unlike the position at common law.[6][6]cf Harvey v Phillips (1956) 95 CLR 235.Consideration Subject to ensuring procedural fairness, the Tribunal is not bound to the legal issues advanced by the parties. Section 28(2) of the QCAT provides:In all proceedings, the tribunal must act fairly and according to the substantial merits of the case. Further s 28(3) provides:(3) In conducting a proceeding, the tribunal—(a) …(b) is not bound by the rules of evidence, or any practices or procedures applying to courts of record, other than to the extent the tribunal adopts the rules, practices or procedures; and(c) may inform itself in any way it considers appropriate; and(d)…(e) must ensure, so far as is practicable, that all relevant material is disclosed to the tribunal to enable it to decide the proceeding with all the relevant facts. Further, the Tribunal, under s 84 may record the terms of a settlement reached at a compulsory conference in writing and make orders necessary to give effect to the settlement. Relevantly, s 87 provides that:An order under this division giving effect to a settlement for a proceeding may be made only if the entity making the order is satisfied the tribunal could make a decision in the terms of the settlement or in terms consistent with the settlement. In my view, where the tribunal has a statutory obligation to act fairly and in accordance with the substantial merits of the case, it is incumbent on the Tribunal to raise and ask for submissions about issues which are important to the resolution of the dispute according to law. This approach is in the interests of justice and does not prejudice the respondents who were given the opportunity to make submissions about those issues. Further, before the Tribunal can make orders giving effect to the settlement, it must be satisfied that it could have made a decision in the terms of the settlement. This applies regardless of the submissions made by the parties. Accordingly, I have considered below issues not raised directly by the applicant but which I considered to be relevant to the validity of the Heads of Agreement. The following provisions of the QCAT Act are relevant to what transpires at a compulsory conference:74 INADMISSIBILITY OF PARTICULAR EVIDENCE(1) Evidence of anything said or done during a compulsory conference for a proceeding is not admissible at any stage in the proceeding.(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to—(a) evidence that all parties to the proceeding have agreed may be admitted into evidence; or(b) evidence of an order made or direction given at a compulsory conference or the reasons for the order or direction; or(c) evidence of anything said or done that is relevant to a proceeding—(i) for an offence relating to the giving of false or misleading information; or(ii) for contempt; or(iii) relating to an order made under section 72 (1) (b).83 INADMISSIBILITY OF PARTICULAR EVIDENCE(1) Evidence of anything said or done during mediation for a proceeding is not admissible at any stage of the proceeding.(2) Subsection (1) does not apply to—(a) evidence that all parties to the proceeding have agreed may be admitted into evidence; or(b) evidence of anything said or done that is relevant to a proceeding—(i) for an offence relating to the giving of false or misleading information; or(ii) for contempt.