Holmes v Commissioner of Police

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Holmes v Commissioner of Police [2012] NSWDC 159
Hearing dates:18 June 2012
Decision date: 18 June 2012
Before: Neilson DCJ
Decision:

I set aside the decision of the Commissioner of Police of 15 February 2011 stating that the infirmities of "lumbar spondylosis and osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff" were not caused by the plaintiff's having been hurt on duty.

I determine that the suffering by the plaintiff of the infirmity of lumbar spondylosis was caused by his having been hurt on duty on 14 June 2008.

I determine that the suffering by the plaintiff of osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff was caused by his having been hurt on duty on 16 August 2008.

I order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Catchwords: Police - Hurt on duty - Pre-existing degenerative conditions in police officer's shoulder and lower back - Whether relevant event could aggravate pre-existing non-compensable condition absent certification by PSAC of aggravation
Legislation Cited: Police Regulation (Superannuation) Act 1906 (NSW) ss 1(2), 10B(3)(a)
Workers Compensation Act 1987 (NSW) ss 4, 9(1)
Cases Cited: COP v SAS Trustee Corporation [2002] NSWIR Comm 31
Commissioner of Police v Kennedy (2007) 5 DDCR 380
Day v SAS Trustee Corporation [2009] NSWCA 222
Dive v Commissioner of Police (1997) 15 NSWCCR 366
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Michael Keith Holmes (Plaintiff)
Commissioner of Police (Defendant)
Representation: Mr T Ower (Plaintiff)
Mr T Rowles (Defendant)
Walter Madden Jenkins (Plaintiff)
Rankin Nathan Lawyers (Defendant)
File Number(s):RJ323/11

Judgment

  1. The plaintiff is a former sergeant of police. He was attested as a probationary constable of police on 18 September 1978 and thereupon become a contributor to the Police Superannuation Fund established under the Police Regulation (Superannuation) Act 1906 ("the Act"). It would appear that the plaintiff last actually worked as a sergeant of police on or about 3 March 2010. On the following day he underwent arthroscopic surgery to his left shoulder. On 27 January 2011 the Police Superannuation Advisory Committee (PSAC), established under the Act, determined that the plaintiff was incapable of carrying out police duty because of three conditions. The first was:

"Bilateral high frequency noise induced sensori-neural hearing loss and severe bilateral tinnitus."

The second was:

"Post traumatic stress disorder-chronic; and major depression with psychotic features."

The third was:

"Lumbar spondylosis; osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff."
  1. On 17 February 2011 the Commissioner of Police, by his delegate, determined that the suffering by the plaintiff of the infirmity of bilateral high-frequency noise induced sensori-neural hearing loss and severe bilateral tinnitus were duty related. He also determined that the suffering by the plaintiff of the infirmity of lumbar spondylosis and osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff were not caused by his having been hurt on duty.

  1. The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holmes v Commissioner of Police and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWDC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Holmes v Commissioner of Police is a case that involves a dispute between a police officer and the Commissioner of Police. The officer claims that he suffered injuries while on duty, specifically lumbar spondylosis and osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff. The Commissioner of Police, however, denies that the officer's injuries were caused by his duties and therefore denies compensation. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Queensland.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the officer's pre-existing degenerative conditions in his shoulder and lower back could have been aggravated by the relevant events while on duty, without the need for certification by the Police Surgeons Advisory Committee (PSAC) of aggravation. The court had to determine whether the Commissioner of Police's decision to deny compensation was correct.

The court found that the officer's injuries were indeed caused by his duties and that the Commissioner of Police's decision was therefore incorrect. The court held that the pre-existing degenerative conditions in the officer's shoulder and lower back could have been aggravated by the relevant events while on duty, even without certification by the PSAC. The court found that the Commissioner of Police's decision to deny compensation was unreasonable and not based on the evidence presented. The court set aside the decision of the Commissioner of Police and ordered that the officer's injuries were caused by his duties. The court also ordered the Commissioner of Police to pay the officer's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

I set aside the decision of the Commissioner of Police of 15 February 2011 stating that the infirmities of "lumbar spondylosis and osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff" were not caused by the plaintiff's having been hurt on duty.

I determine that the suffering by the plaintiff of the infirmity of lumbar spondylosis was caused by his having been hurt on duty on 14 June 2008.

I determine that the suffering by the plaintiff of osteoarthritic change involving the acromioclavicular and glenohumeral joints with tendonitis of the left rotator cuff was caused by his having been hurt on duty on 16 August 2008.

I order the defendant to pay the plaintiff's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established