Holmdahl v Australian Electoral Commission (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 56 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Full Court)

HOLMDAHL v AUSTRALIAN ELECTORAL COMMISSION (No 2)

[2012] SASCFC 110

Judgment of The Full Court

(The Honourable Chief Justice Kourakis, The Honourable Justice Gray and The Honourable Justice Sulan)

24 September 2012

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW - THE NON-JUDICIAL ORGANS OF GOVERNMENT - THE LEGISLATURE - ELECTIONS AND RELATED MATTERS - FAILURE TO VOTE

Appeal referred for hearing and determination by the Full Court pursuant to section 42(2)(b) of the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) and rule 280(2) of the Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) - the appellant was convicted of an offence against section 245(15) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) - where the appellant was enrolled as an elector on the Commonwealth Electoral Roll as at the date of an election - where the appellant did not attend a polling booth - whether section 245(15) is a law with respect to a head of power in the Commonwealth Constitution - whether section 245(15) detracts from the mandate in sections 7 and 24 of the Commonwealth Constitution that Members of Parliament be "directly chosen by the people" - alternatively, whether, read in light of that mandate, section 245(15) permits an elector to "vote" by choosing not to attend a polling booth - whether section 245(15) is specific enough such that non-attendance can be said to amount to a failure to vote - whether the respondent bore an onus of establishing the appellant did not have a valid and sufficient reason for failing to vote.

Held per Gray J (Kourakis CJ and Sulan J concurring): Appeal dismissed. Section 245(15) is a law with respect to elections, supported by sections 10, 31 and 51(xxvi) of the Commonwealth Constitution - the phrase "directly chosen by the people" should not be dissected in a way that gives the expression an operation distinct from that of sections 7 and 24 when read as a whole - the phrase identifies the requirement of a popular vote, it does not require a particular electoral system nor a system with some particular feature - the expression admits a considerable measure of legislative freedom as to the method of choice of Members of Parliament - section 245(15) does not detract from the mandate in sections 7 and 24 of the Commonwealth Constitution - a non-postal voter who fails to attend a polling booth without valid and sufficient reason contravenes section 245(15) - the appellant bore an evidential burden of establishing he did not have a valid and sufficient reason for failing to vote.

Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918 (Cth) s 4, s 4D, s 81, s 82, s 83, s 94, s 96, s 101, s 104, s 221, s 222, s 229, s 231, s 232, s 233, s 239, s 240, s 245(1), s 245(15), s 245(15A) and s 245(15B); Criminal Code (Cth) s 4.3, s 6.1 and s 13; Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA) s 42; Supreme Court Civil Rules 2006 (SA) r 280(2); Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Holmdahl v Australian Electoral Commission (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] SASCFC 110
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal concerned a conviction for failing to vote at a federal election contrary to section 245(15) of the *Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918* (Cth). The appellant, who was enrolled as an elector, did not attend a polling booth on the election date. The central dispute revolved around the constitutional validity of the compulsory voting provisions and whether the appellant's non-attendance constituted a failure to "vote" in a manner that contravened the Act. The matter was heard by the Full Court of the Supreme Court of South Australia.

The legal issues before the court were whether section 245(15) of the *Commonwealth Electoral Act* was a valid law enacted under the Commonwealth Constitution, specifically whether it detracted from the constitutional mandate that Members of Parliament be "directly chosen by the people" as stipulated in sections 7 and 24. Alternatively, the court considered whether, when read in light of this mandate, section 245(15) permitted an elector to "vote" by choosing not to attend a polling booth, and whether the provision was sufficiently specific to deem non-attendance a failure to vote. Finally, the court had to determine whether the respondent bore the onus of proving the appellant lacked a valid and sufficient reason for failing to vote.

The Full Court dismissed the appeal, holding that section 245(15) is a valid law with respect to elections, supported by constitutional provisions including sections 10, 31, and 51(xxxvi). The phrase "directly chosen by the people" was interpreted as requiring a popular vote but not dictating a specific electoral system, thus allowing for legislative freedom in the method of choosing representatives. The court found that compulsory voting did not detract from the constitutional mandate. It was held that a non-postal voter who fails to attend a polling booth without a valid and sufficient reason contravenes section 245(15), and that the appellant bore an evidential burden to establish such a reason.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Pursuant to section 4D of the Commonwealth Electoral Act, Chapter 2 of the Criminal Code (Cth) applies to all offences against that Act. As a strict liability offence under the Criminal Code, the offence contains no fault element, but the defence of mistake of fact applies.[1] With respect to that defence, defendants bear the burden of establishing that they laboured under a mistake of fact to the civil standard.[2] Further, to the extent that a failure to vote may be characterised as an omission, section 4.3 of the Criminal Code applies.[1] Criminal Code (Cth) section 6.1.[2] Criminal Code (Cth) sections 13.3(2), 13.5.Background The facts are not in dispute. It is agreed by the parties that on 21 August 2010, the defendant was enrolled as an elector on the Commonwealth Electoral Roll for the Division of Hindmarsh. An election was held on that date. The defendant did not attend the polling booth on that date. The defendant did not have his name marked off the electoral roll. The defendant did not receive ballot papers and deposit them into a ballot box. The defendant made a deliberate decision not to attend the polling booth on 21 August 2010. The defendant was charged with the offence of failing to vote without a valid and sufficient reason contrary to section 245(15) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act. The following particulars were provided as part of the complaint:[3]1)On the twenty first day of August 2010, there was a general election and a Senate election in the State of South Australia.2)That the defendant on the twenty first day of August 2010 was enrolled as an elector on the Commonwealth Electoral Roll for the Division of Hindmarsh and did not vote at the election held on that date.3)That the defendant failed to vote at the election and has not paid the penalty for failing to vote. 4)That the Complainant is an officer authorised in writing by the Electoral Commissioner to institute proceedings for an offence against Section 145 of the Commonwealth Electoral Act 1918.[3] Australian Electoral Commission v Holmdahl [2012] AMC-11-5176 (Unreported, Mr JM Baldino SM, 3 February 2012) 1. On 7 December 2011, the defendant pleaded not guilty to the charged offence. The trial proceeded before a Magistrate. As noted above, the parties agreed all relevant facts. No evidence was led by either party. On 3 February 2012, the Magistrate convicted the defendant of the offence as charged. In the course of his reasons, he made the following observations:[4][4] Australian Electoral Commission v Holmdahl [ 2012] AMC-11-5176 (Unreported, Mr JM Baldino SM, 3 February 2012) 2-4. 1) The court must consider a question of law. The Defendant challenges the validity of compulsory voting in Federal Elections. He asserts that Section 245(15) of the Act is not a valid law.2) The basis of the Defendant’s argument is that Section 245(15) is contrary to the basic meaning of the word ‘vote’ as it forces a person to make a choice. He further asserts that Parliament can not compel persons to vote.3) Section 245(15) makes it an offence to fail to vote at a Federal election without a valid and sufficient reason for the failure. This subsection, combined with subsection 245(1) makes voting at Federal elections compulsory.4) Voting at Federal Elections has been compulsory since 1924. The validity of compulsory voting in Federal Elections has long been upheld by the High Court of Australia. Judd v McKeon (1926) 38 CLR 380 involved the predecessor to Section 245. Subsequent Members of the High Court have cited that authority without casting any doubt on its validity.5) As a decision of the High Court, Judd v McKeon must be followed by lower courts unless and until it is overruled by the High Court.6) The act of voting is a process set out in Part XVI of the Act. In pursuance of his defence the Defendant sought reliance on the meaning of the word ‘vote’ as defined in various dictionaries.7) However, the meaning of the words ‘to vote’ in regard to Federal Elections is well established by case law.8) Section 245 of the Act furthers the requirements of Sections 7 and 24 of the Constitution that, Parliament be ‘directly chosen by the people’ by providing for compulsory voting subject to limited exceptions.9) As the defendant has admitted that he did not vote at the 2010 Federal Election (and that he did not pay the pecuniary penalty for failing to vote) unless he can show a valid and sufficient reason for his failure, there is compelling evidence to find the charge proved.10) It appears the Defendant’s reason for not voting is based on his assertions about the invalidity of the compulsory voting system as constituting ‘a valid and sufficient reason’ for failing to vote.11) Nevertheless, as remarked by Hogarth J in Douglas v Ninnes (1976) 14 SASR 377 at 383:Objection to compulsory voting of itself does not amount to a valid and sufficient reason… The principle seems to be that objection to compulsion is simply objection to being obliged to obey the law as laid down by Parliament, a contradiction of the obligation imposed by Parliament, and not a valid and sufficient reason for not observing it.12) I find that the defendant has not discharged the evidential burden to satisfy the court that he has ‘a valid and sufficient reason’ for failing to vote at the Federal Election held in August 2010.13) I am satisfied of my finding and determination beyond reasonable doubt.14) I find the Defendant guilty of having committed the offence of failing to vote, contrary to Section 245(15) of the Act as charged.[Emphasis in original.]

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Commonwealth electoral system, as described above, represents a system designed to support the election of the House of Representatives and of the Senate by the people of Australia. The Commonwealth Electoral Act has the purpose of ensuring representative democracy. The broad effect of the statute is to require all eligible persons to enrol as voters and then to require those electors to attend and vote. The terms of sections 245(1) and 245(15) establish a duty to vote and a failure to vote attracts a criminal sanction. It is difficult to understand how the obligation to enrol and the obligation on an elector to vote could detract from a representative democracy in which the people of Australia choose who is to represent them in the House of Representatives and in the Senate. To my mind, the Commonwealth Electoral Act is legislation enacted within power. It provides a relevant system in contemporary times to ensure that Australia is a representative democracy. Conclusion I summarise my principal conclusions as follows:-Sections 7 and 24 of the Commonwealth Constitution mandate a system of representative government with a particular characteristic, namely, ultimate control by the people exercised by representatives who are elected periodically.-Section 245(15) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act is a law with respect to elections. It is supported by sections 10, 31 and 51(xxxvi) of the Commonwealth Constitution.-The Commonwealth Electoral Act is legislation enacted within power. The legislation is relevantly limited and restricted by the Commonwealth Constitution.-Whether or not the elements of an offence against section 245(15) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act are made out by the failure to mark the ballot paper in a fashion prescribed by sections 239 and 240 of that Act need not be resolved in this case.-For the purposes of section 245(15) of the Commonwealth Electoral Act, the defendant was an elector who failed to vote at an election. Accordingly, pursuant to section 245(15), he is guilty of an offence. -The Commonwealth Constitution does not vest a personal right in an elector to vote in a federal electionI would dismiss the appeal. SULAN J: I agree that the appeal should be dismissed. I agree with the reasons of Gray J

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.