HOLE V POLICE
[1999] SASC 153
Magistrates Appeal
1 MARTIN J. (Ex tempore) This is an appeal against penalties imposed in the Elizabeth Magistrates Court for the offences of larceny of a motor vehicle and illegal use of a motor vehicle.
2 On 14 October 1998, the appellant was sentenced in the District Court to six years imprisonment for the offence of robbery committed on 15 December 1997. A non-parole period of 30 calendar months was fixed. On 11 February 1999 the magistrate imposed a sentence of 14 months for the offence of larceny and ordered that it be cumulative upon the sentence being served for the robbery. A further period of nine months imprisonment was imposed for the illegal use to be served cumulatively upon the 14 months for larceny. In effect, the head sentence of six years being served by the appellant was increased by 23 months. The magistrate then increased the existing non-parole period of 30 months by 18 months.
3 The appellant is 29 years of age, he has a long record of prior convictions dating back to 1983. They include a number of assault and theft of motor vehicle offences. In 1989 the appellant was convicted of attempted robbery, and in 1992 of robbery and burglary.
4 The most recent offending by the appellant cannot be ignored. On 16 April 1997 he was sentenced to three months imprisonment for the offence of larceny. The sentence was to date from 16 January 1997. On 5 August 1997, a few months after his release, the appellant committed the offence of larceny of a motor vehicle for which he was sentenced to 14 months imprisonment by the magistrate. He was not charged with that offence however, until 12 December 1997. In the meantime on 27 October 1997 he was sentenced to 12 weeks imprisonment, commencing on 6 August 1997, for the offences of illegal use and interfering with a motor vehicle.
5 It is apparent, therefore, that the appellant had been out of prison only a matter of weeks, when on 15 December 1997 he committed the crime or robbery for which he was sentenced in the District Court as previously mentioned. On the same day, he committed the offence of illegal use for which he was sentenced by the magistrate.
6 The appellant was legally represented. Counsel advised the magistrate that the appellant had always intended to plead guilty to the charge of illegal use and, for that reason, the charge was transferred to the District Court to be dealt with by the judge who sentenced him for the robbery. Apparently, however, the presence of two other charges of assaulting police with intent to resist lawful apprehension to which the appellant intended to plead not guilty resulted in the judge remitting the charges of assaulting police and the charge of illegal use back to the Magistrates Court. Ultimately, the prosecution withdrew the assault with intent to resist lawful apprehension charges, and the matter proceeded by way of…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hole v Police No. Scgrg-99-272 Judgment No. S153 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [1999] SASC 153
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues in this appeal revolved around the appropriateness of the cumulative sentences for the larceny and illegal use offences, and whether the overall increase in the head sentence and non-parole period constituted a manifestly excessive penalty. The court considered the principles of totality, as articulated in Postiglione v R, and whether the magistrate had adequately considered the existing sentence and non-parole period imposed by the District Court when imposing the additional penalties.
The court found that while the individual sentences for the larceny and illegal use were not manifestly excessive in isolation, the magistrate had failed to adequately consider the totality of the appellant's criminal conduct and the sentences already imposed. The court held that the magistrate had not sufficiently exercised the principle of consistency in punishment and had not given appropriate weight to the sentences already being served. Consequently, the court allowed the appeal, modifying the sentences and the non-parole period to better align with the principles of totality and consistency. The final orders were that the appellant serve 14 months cumulatively on the six-year sentence for robbery, four months of the nine months for illegal use cumulatively on the 14 months for larceny, resulting in a total of 90 months to be served, and an increase in the non-parole period to 40 months. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant’s costs of the appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi