DECISION AND REASONS FOR DECISION [2001] AATA 234
ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL )
) No N2000/843
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION )
Re MICHELLE HOKAFONU
Applicant
And MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS
Respondent
DECISION
Tribunal Deputy President J. Block
Date23 March 2001
PlaceSydney
Decision The decision under review is affirmed.
(signed Julian Block)
..............................................
Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
IMMIGRATION & CITIZENSHIP – spouse visa – refusal on character grounds – whether visa applicant fails the character test – offences against the Migration Act 1958 – criminal conviction for drug offences – false protection visa applications – false or misleading statements to immigration authorities – past and present general conduct – discretion – hardship.
Migration Act 1958 – ss 234, 235, 501.
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 – s 37
Ayaad v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2000] AATA 935
REASONS FOR DECISION
23 March 2001 Deputy President J. Block
The Applicant, Michelle Hokafonu, seeks the review of a decision made by a delegate of the Respondent on 3 March 2000 to refuse her husband, Villiami Kafo Hokafonu, a Subclass 309 Spouse (Provisional) Visa, pursuant to section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 ("the Act").
At the hearing the Applicant was self-represented, while Ms Bridget Quayle and Mr Marten Kennedy, Departmental advocates, appeared for the Respondent. The Tribunal had before it the T documents and Supplementary T documents, lodged pursuant to section 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975. It also took into account the following exhibits, tendered at the hearing:
Exhibit # Description of Exhibit Submitted by
A1 Applicant's Statement of Facts and Contentions Applicant
A2 Photo of Villiami Kafo Hokafonu Applicant
A3 Character reference from Brian Spurrell dated 24 November 2000 Applicant
A4 Character reference from Kerry James dated 01 December 2000 Applicant
A5 Character reference from Alan Gosling dated 11 December 2000 Applicant
A6 Character reference from Simote Po'uliva'ati, General Manager of the International Dateline Hotel, Tonga, dated 20 December 2000 Applicant
A7 Character reference from Christine O'Neale dated 04 March 2001 Applicant
A8 Character reference from John Daly, undated Applicant
A9 Statutory declaration of Villiami Kafo Hokafonu dated 21 December 2000 Applicant
A10 Statement of Sione Pinomi dated 09 March 2001 Applicant
R1 Visa Applicant's criminal records Respondent
Exhibit A1 was tendered simply because the Respondent was prepared to accept it in lieu of a witness statement of the Applicant.
The Applicant gave oral evidence in person and Mr Hokafonu gave oral evidence by telephone from Tonga with the occasional assistance of a Tongan interpreter.
background
In order to set the scene and the background, I include a number of documents before the Tribunal. The Respondent's Statement of Facts and Contentions reads as follows:
1. Michelle Anne Hokafonu is the sponsor of Viliami Kafo Hokafonu in an application for a subclass 309 Spouse (Provisional) visa.
2. On 3 March 2000, the application was refused on the basis that Mr Hokafonu did not pass the character test in section 501 of the Migration Act 1958. This is…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read HOKAFONU And MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION AND MULTICULTURAL AFFA... and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2001] AATA 234
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the applicant's conduct, including his overstaying of his visa, working illegally, and making false protection visa applications. The court also took into account the applicant's efforts to regularise his status, his marriage to an Australian citizen, and the hardship that would be caused by his deportation. The court concluded that the applicant's conduct was of a very serious nature, and the primary considerations outlined in the Ministerial Direction were against him. While the hardship factor was not severe, it did not outweigh the primary considerations. The court found that the decision to refuse the spouse visa on character grounds was justified.
The court affirmed the decision under review, upholding the Minister's refusal to grant the applicant a spouse visa on character grounds. The court did not exercise its discretion to intervene in the decision, finding that the primary considerations were sufficiently strong to justify the refusal. The applicant's arguments regarding his genuine desire to be reunited with his family and the hardship that would be caused by his deportation were not enough to overcome the primary considerations. The court found that the applicant's conduct demonstrated a disregard for Australia's immigration laws, and that the refusal of the spouse visa was in the public interest.
Orders
Orders of the court
The decision under review is affirmed.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
By way of balance, I also include the Applicant's Statement of Facts and Contentions (Exhibit A1), reading as follows:Chronology of Immigration History1.07/02/92 Villiami (Kafo) Hokafonu arrived in Australia as a holder of a temporary entry permit. Kafo came to visit his family who had migrated to Australia during the 1980's.2.09/07/92 Kafo's visa expired. Kafo decided to stay on in Australia and began the process of gaining permanent residency so that he could stay together with his parents and siblings.3.31/05/93 Kafo applied for a protection visa. He hired the services of a migration agent to get him a visa. This agent lodged a protection visa for him. 4.31/8/93 The protection visa application was refused.5.April 1995 Kafo met Michelle Jacobs (now his wife). They began to live together that same year.6.03/08/95 Kafo applied for a protection visa. A member of the Tongan community who helped people with their visa applications put in the application for Kafo.7.20/02/96 The protection visa application was refused.8.05/03/96 Kafo applied to the RRT to review his application.9.22/03/96 Kafo and Michelle married.10.09/09/97 The RRT affirmed the refusal.11.03/09/98 Kafo applied for permanent residency by lodging an application for change in circumstances on family grounds.12.28/09/98 Application refused because it was not lodged within 12 months of having had a substantive visa.13.12/10/98 Applied for a review of the decision with the IRT based on compassionate grounds.14.16/04/99 IRT affirmed the refusal.15.08/07/99 Kafo departed Australia to lodge a spouse visa application in Tonga.16.14/9/99 Kafo had an interview with DIMA in Tonga.17.November 1999 Michelle joined Kafo in Tonga for four months.18.03/03/00 Application refused because Kafo did not pass the character test.19.July 2000 Michelle applied to the AAT for an appeal.20.September 2000 Michelle joined Kafo in Tonga for another four months.To the tribunal,21.After having read the facts and contentions from the respondent I would like to now reply to their statements. I can understand from their perspective some of their contentions. I appeal to the tribunal to understand our situation and series of events that have led us to this hearing today. I would like to point out that Kafo has not intentionally been dishonest or blatantly disregarded Australia's Immigration Law.22.Kafo overstayed his original temporary entry permit.Kafo had made a decision to stay on in Australia and apply for a visa that would allow him to do that.23.Kafo worked illegally in AustraliaThere were periods of time when Kafo worked when he did not have permission to do so.24.Kafo applied for a protection visa.The respondent contending that Kafo knew that the claims he made were false. Kafo had hired the expertise of a migration agent, Finau and Associates, to help him get a visa to stay in Australia. The agent got Kafo to sign some blank forms and the agent lodged the application for Kafo. Kafo thought he was applying for a visa to live and work in Australia, not applying for refugee status.25.Kafo did not know what the claims were, the agent made on his behalf. As far as Kafo was aware, he was applying to stay in Australia on compassionate grounds. He wanted to remain united with his family in Australia. He has no family in Tonga, except for one brother (who he does not get on with).26.Kafo applied for a protection visa again.Two years had passed when Kafo attempted again to legalise his status. By this time Kafo and I had met and were living together. Kafo had enlisted the help of a member of the Tongan community, who often helped people with their visa applications (for no charge). Again Kafo signed blank forms and this man Mr (I will get his name by the hearing) lodged them for Kafo. We paid him $50 which he said would pay for the cost of the visa and postage. 27.On this occasion we were aware it was an application for a protection visa. We were not aware of the claims made on our behalf by Mr (?). We put in this application because we were advised by his family and community elders this was the only kind of visa application he could lodge while still residing in Australia.28.Kafo was the subject of a deportation order.This order was not executed because Kafo's whereabouts were not known by the respondent. This is not to say that Kafo was not aware of his illegal status, because he was. Hence his applications to legalise his status since 1993.29.Kafo departed AustraliaThe respondent contending that Kafo left only after threat of detention and removal. Kafo was advised by both DIMA and the Immigration Rights and Advice Centre that the only way he could get an Australian resident visa was to lodge a spouse visa application offshore. To go back to Tonga and lodge it there.30.On 16/4/99 the IRT affirmed the respondent's decision, and Kafo was given 28 days to leave Australia. Kafo voluntarily approached the compliance section of DIMA to organise bridging visas while we raised the money to pay for his fare to Tonga and his application for Australian residency. In this context we thought Kafo was leaving voluntarily.31.Evidence of rehabilitation and recent good conductSince 1993 Kafo has been trying to legalise his status. Kafo has always voluntarily approached DIMA in all his dealings with them. We feel that the way he departed Australia is an exampled of his rehabilitation and recent good conduct.32.Kafo has no contempt or blatant disregard for Australia's immigration laws. There was no intention to be dishonest, either past or present.I understand that people from other countries have had bad experiences with their own governments. This has led to distrust and fear when dealing with any authority in their new country of residence. Unfortunately I can see where this has led people to go up the wrong path when dealing with various government departments here in Australia, where there is a history of human rights and equal opportunity. This fear and distrust has influenced Kafo and how he has gone about legalising his status.33.Kafo has been terrified of being separated from the support of his family. He thought he'd never get another chance of legalising his status once he left Australia. So he tried all he could to legalise his status while still being able to stay with his family in Australia.34.English is not Kafo's first language, in fact he cannot read or write English. Kafo does not understand Immigration law and did not have the finances to hire a qualified migration agent. He also had a deep desire not to be separated from his family. He also received the wrong advice from the people who he thought knew what they were doing. All of this contributed to the situation Kafo now finds himself in. His good character now being in question. 35.Kafo did not intentionally disregard Australia's Immigration laws. He did his best with the resources he had at hand. Even when I stated to assist Kafo, and English is my first language and also further education behind me, I had just as much difficulty understanding the process involved.36.The respondent contends that Kafo made false and misleading statements.Due to the reasons stated in paragraphs 32-35, this influenced Kafo in the way he answered the following questions.The protection visa. The respondent contends that Kafo knew that his claims were groundless. In 1993 Kafo hired a migration agent (Finau & Associates) to help him get a visa to live and work in Australia. He signed some blank forms and the migration agent lodged the application for Kafo. Kafo did not know what claims the migration (sic) made on his behalf. Hence the contradicting statements made at the interview. As far as Kafo was concerned he was appealing on compassionate grounds to be re-united with his family in Australia. Kafo realises ignorance is not an excuse. But he thought by hiring a migration agent to help him, he would be given the right advice.37.Deportation order. Kafo answered No to the following questions. No I have not left any country to avoid being removed or deported, and no I have never been excluded or asked to leave any country (including Australia). Kafo misunderstood the question and answered it incorrectly. It was our wrong interpretation of the question. We did not intentionally lie or try to mislead DIMA. As far as we were concerned Kafo had not left Australia to avoid being removed or deported. Kafo had never received the official deportation order, he know he was illegal, but didn't think he'd actually bee asked to leave Australia. As again he thought he was leaving voluntarily to apply off-shore. We actually interpreted the question as have you been asked to leave any country, as in the past. If Kafo had been to Australia before an been asked to leave. 38.We thought Kafo had left voluntarily, by contacting compliance and organising his departure willingly. We had been advised by both DIMA and the Immigration rights and advice centre that his was the only way Kafo could apply for permanent residence. Being married to an Australian citizen made him eligible to apply on spouse grounds. Being an Australian citizen I thought I had the right to sponsor my husband so that he could get an Australian resident visa. We were willing to sacrifice an initial separation so that we could be together in Australia in the future. We realised we had exhausted all avenues of being able to apply for a visa while staying Australia and therefore not having to be separated. So we took the advice of DIMA and applied off-shore.39.We contacted compliance to give us an extension on his bridging visa so that we could raise the funds for Kafo's ticket and his application fee.40.Kafo had answered no to the following questions. Have you been charged with any offence that is currently awaiting legal action. Have you been convicted of a crime or offence in any country.41.Kafo did not think that his situation applied to the timing of these questions. By the time he lodged his application in September 1998 Kafo had been arrested but not convicted of possesion (sic) and supply of a small amount of canabis (sic). We were hoping for a favourable outcome in court and so we did not mention it. Thing it did not pertain to the question at the time of answering it. 42.In the July 1999 application Kafo had been convicted and released on a good behaviour bond. We were hoping to appeal the conviction but could not because Kafo had to return to Tonga. As far as we were concerned his conviction was subject to appeal and therefore not fixed.43.We realise in hindsight that with correct advice we would have answered yes to those questions. We are sorry that we did not bring it to the attention of DIMA before now. We were hoping that it did not apply to the time of the application. Kafo was in the wrong place at the wrong time. The conviction does not reflect the type of person he is. I hope you will see this and understand our fear and hesitation in not bringing it your attention in the past. 44.Factors mitigating against compassionate grounds.Because I was aware of Kafo's illegal status early on in our relationship, it seems to diminish the level of hardship I should be experiencing. Like I knew what I was getting into. Maybe so in the early years. I knew that there may be a waiting period and that Kafo may have to go to Tonga to apply off-shore. But I always thought he'd eventually be granted a visa to live with me and his family in Australia.45.I never once thought he'd be refused on character grounds. I knew he'd overstayed his visa and worked illegally in Australia. But all the advice we received from DIMA and the Immigration Advice and Rights Centre, and some immigration lawyers was that Kafo would have to lodge a spouse application off-shore. And eventually he'd be back with me in Australia.46.I feel it is extreme hardship. As I supported him knowing that as an Australian citizen I had some rights. And should be able to sponsor my husband in getting a resident visa. I had no idea it would take six years, and that he'd get refused on character grounds. What this does prove is that our relationship is strong and we are committed to legalising his status.47.Likelihood that conduct may be repeatedKafo is guilty of a desire to be re-united with his family in Australia. He is sorry that he did not get better advice as the path he took got him into the position he is now in. Kafo did overstay his visa and he did work illegally and he hopes the Australian community will not hold against him. He hopes that the AAT will focus on the fact that he has done all he can to legalise his status. And that his judgement was influenced by his emotions not to be separated (for life) from his family. Kafo truly believed that he had to stay in Australia to legalise his status. That was where his support structure was. He did not believe that once back in Tonga he'd be able to get a visa to come back to live in Australia.48.As far as repeating his conduct, the respondent feels that if Kafo broke the Immigration law, he might break other laws. Please see from how Kafo has lived his life and his character references that he is a responsible person. Kafo values the opportunities that would be available to him in Australia and would not abuse them. He would only respect and thank the Australian community for allowing him to make a life for himself here with his family.49.General deterrenceI can understand why the respondent wants to send out a message of don't do the right thing and you won't necessarily get in! But Kafo did not go into seeking Australian residency by willingly abusing the system. He was ill advised by his family and Tongan community. He was also ill advised by a paid migration agent. He started off badly and it only got worse. I can only implore that the AAT can see this case as the individual one that it is. That Kafo has made mistakes, and he has tried to correct them. If there was more counselling and support for people like Kafo he may have been able to make less mistakes throughout the process of legalising his status in Australia.50.Kafo is trying to come in through the front door to Australia. He has a family who are citizens of Australia, and he is married to an Australian citizen. I do hope that the tribunal can see past all these contentions made by DIMA and see that there is a man who just wants to be with the people he loves, his family.OTHER CONSIDERATIONS51.The extent of disruption of the non-citizen's family, business and other ties to the Australian communityIf my husband is not granted a visa, it means that I will have to join him in Tonga. I have already had to close down my business due to stress and health problems because Kafo has been refused a visa and the possibility of him not ever being able to return to Australia.52.My health has been effected by the stress of being separated from my husband and not knowing the future. I always thought he'd be back on day. Please see my Doctors report. I have had suicidal thoughts. The stress building up over the six years that we have been involved in legalising his status with DIMA. The constant knock backs and frustration we feel and powerlessness at not being able to give this good man a chance with his family.53.If I go to Tonga it will be difficult for me to come and go to visit my elderly mother. Firstly, it will involve long separations from my husband, as I have to find work once in Australia and save for the fare back to Tonga. Sure I have permission and the freedom to come and go but not economically. The average wage in Tonga is $1.50 and hour. Because Kafo does not have any family in Tonga we will have to rent a house, so it will be difficult to save up to visit my mother, as most of our money will go into day to day living costs. Food is more expensive in Tonga than in Australia. I will have trouble finding work as I don't speak Tongan and most jobs advertised require that the applicant speak English and Tongan. We cannot rely on any remittances from our families in Australia as they all have their own families to look after. For example Kafo's brother-in-law is recovering from liver cancer so a lot of the family focus is supporting his recovery.54.This process of legalising Kafo's status has put us in debt. I would never be able to honour my financial commitments if I had to live in Tonga.55.Going to Tonga would mean I would have to leave my elderly mother (85 yrs) and my teenage daughter (19 yrs). Neither of them are dependent upon me. My mother is fiersly (sic) independent and in good health. But as time goes on she will need my care more and more. Especially now around the house with repairs and general maintenance. My daughter will always need her mother, although she probably wouldn't admit to it at this stage of her life. 56.I would be eligible for a permanent resident visa in Tonga, renewable every 2 years. But what kind of stability its that, knowing that the Tongan government could refuse to renew it anytime it chose. I would never think of forfeighting (sic) my Australian passport to become a Tongan citizen for the same reasons I am trying to get an Australian visa for my husband. So we can live in Australia and be with our families where our responsibilities lie. 57.Kafo and I cannot do anything for ourselves or our families living in Tonga, but to survive on a day to day basis. Tonga is a lovely country to visit, but difficult to live in if you don't have the family support systems in place.58. Kafo's marriage is genuine. This has been proven by our commitment to each other over the past six years, it has also proven our commitment to legalise Kafo's visa status.59.Can family members travel to Tonga? Family is dependant on Kafo.I can travel to Tonga but at great hardship, please see # 51-57. I am dependant on Kafo as his wife. I am dependant on Kafo for emotional support and love that he gives me. I also need him to help me with our financial commitments that we have incured (sic) in Australia. He has also proven to be a great support for my mother especially as her son-in-law, but he also helps her with repairs and maintenance of her house and garden. 60. Kafo would also like to be able to contribute to his family in Australia. In Tonga he feels isolated and impotent to not be able to fulfil his family responsibilities. Kafo's mother could visit Kafo in Tonga, but not on a regular basis. My mother could not visit Tonga as the heat and living conditions would make it very uncomfortable for her. The health resources in Tonga are not the same standard as here in Australia. And as she gets older she may need more care with her health.FAMILY COMPOSITION IN AUSTRALIA AND TONGA61.In Tonga: Kafo has one brother who he does not get on well with. Michelle has no family in Tonga except her husband.In Australia: Kafo has his mother. His father died here in 1992. His grandmother (who was over 100 yrs) died last Christmas. He was not able to see her before she died. Kafo has four brothers and three sisters and their respective partners and children.Michelle has her mother. Her father died in 1990. She also has a daughter.62. Compasionate (sic) reasons to stay in AustraliaSo that Kafo and I do not have to be separated. It would cause me extreme hardship if I had to live in Tonga as it would disadvantage my mother and daughter. We would not be able to get out of debt, nor be able to support our families financially. My career would be disadvantaged. In Tonga massage is seen as a sex service rather than a healing modality. So I feel it would be difficult to build up a business in Tonga. Health and education are not to the same standards as in Australia, and once in Tonga I may not be able to avail myself to these services due to financial constraints. I certainly have taken for granted the equal opportunities and freedom of speech a women (sic) in the new millennium has in Australia. I would not have those same rights available to me in Tonga.63.Our hopes for our future in Australia were to live in the Blue Mountains to be near my mother. Rebuild our massage therapy business, work part-time while we build up our clientelle (sic) and get out of debt. Be able to fulfil our family responsibilities and begin to live the life we have put on hold while we have been in limbo waiting for Kafo's visa to be processed.64.At the moment so many lives have been torn apart and we appeal to the Tribunal to look favourably at our request to have my husband, Kafo's, visa application reviewed and accepted. Kafo is truly remorseful for the way in which he conducted his visa application to remain in Australia. In hindsight if I knew then what I knew now I would have encouraged Kafo to go to Tonga and lodge a spouse visa application in 1995 rather than take the advice of his family and community. But unfortunately that did not happen, and we have to work with what did. I do hope the tribunal will see the compasionate (sic) reasons outweighing the primary considerations.SignedMichelle Hokafonufor Kafo Hokafonu