Hoby v Workers' Compensation Regulator

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:        

Hoby v Workers' Compensation Regulator [2018] QIRC 021

PARTIES:   

Hoby, Susan Kaori
(Appellant)

v

Workers' Compensation Regulator
(Respondent)

CASE NO:

WC/2017/39

PROCEEDING:

Appeal against decision of the Workers' Compensation Regulator

DELIVERED ON:

2 March 2018

HEARING DATES: 

15 and 16 November 2017 (Hearing)
5 December 2017 (Hearing)
29 January 2018 (Appellant Submissions)
29 January 2018 (Regulator Submissions)

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

MEMBER:

Deputy President Swan
ORDERS

[1]     The Appeal is Dismissed.

[2]     The Appellant is to pay the Regulator's costs of, and incidental to the Appeal.

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS' COMPENSATION - APPEAL AGAINST DECISION - decision of Workers' Compensation Regulator - Appellant incurred a physical injury - Appellant worked in the kitchen of a nursing care facility - Appellant often worked alone and was responsible for the workings of the kitchen from 1.15 p.m. to 7.30 p.m. - Appellant undertook a range of repetitive and heavy duties and incurred pain in her right shoulder – Appellant's claim is that shoulder pain continued from 2014 onwards and was largely attributed to her work on and around the Bain Marie  in the kitchen - No medical report of any injury provided until mid 2016 - Orthopaedic medical specialist's opinions differed as to causation - Determined that "injury" was caused by "an aggravation of a condition" which could best be described as a lack of conditioning and reserve in the shoulder - Appeal dismissed.

CASES:

Workers' Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003
Cronin v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland (1997) 156 QGIG 100
Carman v Q-COMP (2007) 186 QGIG 512
Newberry v Suncorp Metway Insurance Ltd [2006] QCA 48
Pleming v Workers' Compensation Board of Queensland (1996) 152 QGIG 1181

APPEARANCES:

Mr P.B Rashleigh of Counsel, instructed by Ms M. King of Shine Lawyers for the Appellant.
Ms H. Blattman of Counsel, directly instructed by Mr G. Clark of the Workers' Compensation Regulator, the Respondent.

Decision

  1. Ms Susan Kaori Hoby (the Appellant), made a Workers' Compensation claim on 21 June 2016 for an injury described as "right shoulder bursitis", caused in the course of her employment as a kitchen hand at the Rosalie Nursing Centre (the Centre) operated by Alzheimer's Association Queensland.  The injury is claimed to have occurred on 1 February 2014 but had continued to become worse over time.  This date had been recorded on the Appellant's two Queensland Workers' Compensation Medical Certificates, by Dr Wilson (General Practitioner) which had been issued in June 2016.  [Exhibits 2 and 3]

  2. The Appellant, in her Statement of Facts and Contentions, states that prior to mid to late 2015, she had not suffered any injury or significant or regular symptoms in her right shoulder.  However, around mid to late 2015, she began suffering symptoms comprising of pain, restricted movement and "catching" (impingement) of her right shoulder.  She said that the pain she suffered related to her work at and around the Bain Marie in the kitchen.

  3. The Appellant says that she advised the Director of Nursing Care at the Centre of her…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hoby v Workers' Compensation Regulator and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QIRC 21
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hoby v Workers' Compensation Regulator, the appellant, who worked in the kitchen of a nursing care facility, sought compensation for a physical injury sustained during her employment. The appellant argued that her shoulder pain, which she attributed to her work around the Bain Marie in the kitchen, was a result of her employment. The Workers' Compensation Regulator, however, determined that the injury was caused by an aggravation of a pre-existing condition, specifically a lack of conditioning and reserve in the shoulder, and denied the claim.

The central legal issues in this case were whether the appellant's shoulder condition constituted a work-related injury and whether the appellant had provided sufficient evidence to support her claim. The key points of contention included the timing of the appellant's medical reports, the differing opinions of the orthopaedic medical specialists regarding causation, and the nature and extent of the appellant's injury. The court needed to determine if the injury arose out of and in the course of employment and if it was due to an aggravation of a pre-existing condition.

The court examined the evidence and the medical reports presented by both parties. Dr. Shaw, called by the appellant, diagnosed subacromial bursitis and impingement as a result of repetitive arm duties. However, the court found that the appellant had not reported her shoulder problems until December 2015, and there was no medical report of any injury until mid-2016. Additionally, the differing opinions of the orthopaedic medical specialists, particularly regarding the causation of the condition, played a crucial role in the court's decision. Ultimately, the court concluded that the injury was caused by an aggravation of a pre-existing condition rather than a direct result of the appellant's employment activities. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the appellant was ordered to pay the Workers' Compensation Regulator's costs of and incidental to the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

[1] The Appeal is Dismissed.

[2] The Appellant is to pay the Regulator's costs of, and incidental to the Appeal.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

This point was also confirmed by the Appellant's evidence that prior to the Bain Marie being replaced in December 2015, she suffered from neck pain for which she had been seeing a Physiotherapist. This was consistent with the fact that the Appellant had not reported her shoulder problems with her employer until December 2015.Medical Evidence Two Orthopedic Medical Specialists were called to give evidence. Dr Shaw was called by the Appellant and Dr Nutting by the Regulator. Dr Shaw's Report of 23 May 2017 [Exhibit 15] records the history given to him by the Appellant. This included the Appellant advising that over a period of time, in 2014, she had developed right shoulder subacromial bursitis and impingement as a result of the repetitive type of required in the performance of her job; the Appellant's hope that her pain would settle, but that this didn't occur; that she had experienced neck pain which settled over time; an account of her visits to a Physiotherapist; her reduced working hours and how the new Bain Marie in the kitchen had made her work easier when serving meals. The Appellant had advised Dr Shaw that at the time of the onset of her shoulder pain she was also suffering neck pain. She said that the neck pain had ceased, but that her shoulder pain had continued to worsen. Dr Shaw noted that there were no pre-existing injuries relevant to the right shoulder. Dr Shaw identified her current symptoms as a continuation of right shoulder pain which was intermittent but present on most days. The movement which brings on pain for her is undertaking activities with her right arm away from the side and out in the front and particularly over shoulder height. The Appellant, consequently, refrains from lifting her right arm overhead and reaching behind her. The Appellant advised that she lived in a house with her husband and two younger boys. She avoided overhead and low cleaning. An ultrasound of the Appellant's right shoulder which occurred on 2 September 2016 reported "there is bursitis with impingement". Concerning the nature and extent of the Appellant's injury, by his report, Dr Shaw stated:"Over a period of time, in 2014, Ms Hoby developed right shoulder subacromial bursitis and impingement as a result of repetitive right arm duties away from the side. These duties included reaching to overhead shelving for cups and saucers, repeated serving from a Bain Marie at shoulder height and reaching forwards with repetitive lifting, while serving and retrieving trays from the server window which was positioned at around shoulder height". [Exhibit 15, page 5] In Cross-Examination, Dr Shaw added further:"The work activity that worried me the most was actually serving from the Bain Marie because that involved the shoulders away from the side in the abductors, rather than the forward position. That was probably the activity that concerned me the most with regards to contributing to her shoulder pain". [T2-6] Dr Shaw stated that the diagnosis of bursitis and impingement is a clinical diagnosis which is "made on history, examination, and then we're looking for confirmation with investigations, or excluding other pathologies which can sometimes mimic that condition". [T2-11]

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.