HNA Irish Nominee Limited v Kinghorn

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

HNA Irish Nominee Limited v Kinghorn [2010] FCA 311

Citation: HNA Irish Nominee Limited v Kinghorn [2010] FCA 311
Parties: HNA IRISH NOMINEE LIMITED and ANOR v GEOFFREY ANDREW KINGHORN and ORS
File number: NSD 94 of 2010
Judge: EMMETT J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2010
Date of hearing: 22 and 23 March 2010
Place: Sydney
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: No catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 39
Counsel for the Plaintiffs: M Leeming SC with J Hewitt
Solicitor for the Plaintiffs: Chang, Pistilli & Simmons
Counsel for the Defendants: SD Robb QC with J Clarke
Solicitor for the Defendants: DibbsBarker

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

NEW SOUTH WALES DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

NSD 94 of 2010

BETWEEN:

HNA IRISH NOMINEE LIMITED
First Plaintiff

ALLCO MANAGED INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Second Plaintiff

AND:

GEOFFREY ANDREW KINGHORN
First Defendant

DAVID LLOYD VEAL
Second Defendant

KV AVIATION HOLDINGS PTY LIMITED
Third Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQZ PTY LIMITED
ACN 110 563 007
Fourth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQW PTY LIMITED
ACN 110 562 831
Fifth Defendant

RIL AVIATION MSN 163 PTY LIMITED
ACN 111 127 087
Sixth Defendant

RIL AVIATION MSN 185 PTY LIMITED
ACN 111 127 130
Seventh Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQU PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 833
EIGHTH DEFENDANT

RIL AVIATION VQT PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 842
Ninth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQS PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 860
Tenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQR PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 922
Eleventh Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQQ PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 940
Twelfth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQP PTY LIMITED
ACN 114 265 968
Thirteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION 9V-SFG PTY LIMITED
ACN 116 838 905
Fourteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION 9V-SLE PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 858 298
Fifteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DLN PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 857 488
Sixteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DLO PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 857 684
Seventeenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQG PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 079 751
Eighteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DLR PTY LIMITED
ACN 121 180 470
Nineteenth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPB PTY LIMITED
ACN 122 128 830
Twentieth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPD PTY LIMITED
ACN 122 642 031
Twenty-First Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPC PTY LIMITED
ACN 122 641 963
Twenty-Second Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPT PTY LIMITED
ACN 124 271 236
Twenty-Third Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPW PTY LIMITED
ACN 124 850 255
Twenty-Fourth Defendant

RIL AVIATION EI-DPX PTY LIMITED
ACN 124 850 317
Twenty-Fifth Defendant

RIL AVIATION OJJ PTY LIMITED
ACN 102 697 709
Twenty-Sixth Defendant

RIL AVIATION OJG PTY LIMITED
ACN 102 697 914
Twenty-Seventh Defendant

RIL AVIATION OJH PTY LIMITED
ACN 102 697 549
Twenty-Eighth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQY PTY LIMITED
ACN 110 562 957
Twenty-Ninth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQX PTY LIMITED
ACN 110 562 902
Thirtieth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQV PTY LIMITED
ACN 110 562 699
Thirty-First Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQJ PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 079 171
Thirty-Second Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQI PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 079 322
Thirty-Third Defendant

RIL AVIATION 9V-SLD PTY LIMITED
ACN 115 857 899
Thirty-Fourth Defendant

RIL AVIATION VQH PTY LIMITED

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HNA Irish Nominee Limited v Kinghorn and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2010] FCA 311
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of HNA Irish Nominee Limited v Kinghorn, the parties were HNA Irish Nominee Limited and Allco Managed Investment Scheme, acting on behalf of unitholders, versus Kinghorn and Veal. The dispute involved the alleged improper issuance of shares and the conduct of general meetings of certain companies. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia. The legal issues that the court had to decide centred on the interpretation of the company constitutions and whether certain provisions entitled holders of preference shares to vote on resolutions. Additionally, the court had to determine if these resolutions would alter the rights attached to ordinary shares without the consent of the ordinary shareholders.

The court began by examining the constitutions of the relevant companies, particularly focusing on the company RILA VQY Pty Limited. The court noted that the constitutions of these companies provided for different classes of shares, including ordinary and preference shares. The primary question before the court was whether the holders of preference shares had the right to vote on resolutions as specified in the notices of a meeting held on 3 February 2010. If such a right existed, the court also had to determine whether these resolutions would alter the rights attached to ordinary shares.

After careful consideration of the constitutions and the notices of meeting, the court concluded that the holders of preference shares did not have the right to vote on the resolutions in the specified form. Consequently, the question of whether these resolutions would alter the rights of ordinary shareholders did not arise. The court therefore declared that no ordinary shares were issued on or after 3 February 2010. As a result, certain claims for relief by HNA and Allco Managed were dismissed. The court also noted that if either of the preliminary questions had been answered in the affirmative, certain claims would have been upheld, but since both questions were answered in the negative, the claims were dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

It follows that the question of whether the proposal would vary the rights attached to the ordinary shares does not arise. I do not consider that it is appropriate to deal with the second question on a purely hypothetical basis.CONCLUSION The first question should be answered no. The second question does not arise. There should be a declaration in terms of the first question.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In their further amended originating process, HNA and Allco Managed sought:·declaratory relief in relation to the purported issuing of further ordinary shares in the RILAs;·orders setting aside the purported issue of ordinary shares;·declaratory relief in relation to the conduct of, and resolutions passed at, the general meetings of the RILAs referred to above;·injunctive relief with respect to conduct that Messrs Kinghorn and Veal are alleged to have engaged in or propose to engage in, which is alleged to constitute contravention of ss 181, 182 and 183 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (the Corporations Act);·relief pursuant to ss 232 and 233 of the Corporations Act with respect to the conduct of the affairs of the RILAs, which is alleged to have been contrary to the interests of the members as a whole, and oppressive to, unfairly prejudicial to, or unfairly discriminatory against the owners of preference shares in the RILAs. By consent, the Court has now made declarations that no ordinary shares in the RILAs were issued on or after 3 February 2010. That has resolved some of the claims for relief. The Court has also been asked to determine, as preliminary questions, separately from and prior to the determination of all other questions in the proceeding, whether certain provisions of the constitutions of the RILAs entitle the holder of preference shares to vote on resolutions in the form specified in the notices of meeting of 3 February 2010 and whether, if the answer to that question is affirmative, such resolutions would vary the rights attached to ordinary shares in the RILAs, such that they cannot validly take effect without the consent of the holders of the ordinary shares. The parties accept that if either of those questions is answered in the negative, certain of the relief claimed by HNA and Allco Managed must be dismissed. THE CONSTITUTION OF RILA VQY In order to put the present dispute into context, it is necessary to say something about the constitutions of the RILAs. Most of the RILAs have only two classes of issued shares, being ordinary shares and preference shares. However, several of the RILAs have two classes of preference shares. RIL Aviation VQY Pty Limited (RILA VQY) is in the latter category. It is convenient, therefore, to take, as a sample, the constitution of RILA VQY (the Constitution) and the notice of general meeting dated 3 February 2010 given in respect of RILA VQY (the Notice of Meeting). The Constitution was adopted on 18 August 2004. Clause 3.1 provides that RILA VQY is a proprietary company limited by shares. Under clause 2.3 of the Constitution, any expression used in the Constitution that deals with a matter dealt with by a particular provision of the Corporations Act is to have the same meaning as in that provision of the Corporations Act. Clause 2.4 provides that the schedules to the Constitution are part of it and that their provisions prevail if they conflict with any other provision of the Constitution.