Hirehood Pty Ltd and VentureCrowd Pty Ltd [2025] ARTA 881 (1 July 2025)
Applicant:Hirehood Pty Ltd
Interested Party: VentureCrowd Pty Ltd
Respondent: Australian Securities & Investments Commission
Tribunal Number: 2024/7713
Tribunal:General Member Darian-Smith
Place:Sydney
Date:1 July 2025
Decision:The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.
.................[SGD]...............................
General Member M. Darian-Smith
Catchwords
CORPORATIONS – Crowd-sourced Funding – securities under offer – fully-paid ordinary shares - whether offer of beneficial interest in securities is an eligible offer under Part 6D.3A of the Act – decision to make stopping order affirmed
Legislation
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss. 92, 700, 738A, 738G, 738K, 738L, 738U, 738Y, 739, 912AH
Corporations Regulations 2001 Volume 1, reg. 6D.3A.01(1)
Cases
Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (Northern Territory) (2009) 239 CLR 27
Master Education Services Pty Ltd v Ketchell (2008) 236 CLR 101SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 262 CLR 362
Secondary Materials
ASIC Corporations (Nominee and Custody Services) Instrument 2016/1156
ASIC Regulatory Guide 148: Platforms that are managed investment schemes and nominee and custody servicesASIC Regulatory Guide 262: Crowd-sourced funding: Guide for intermediaries
STATEMENT OF REASONS
This application for review is concerned with aspects of the operation of Part 6D.3A of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) (Crowd-Sourced Funding or CSF) which establishes “a disclosure regime that can be used for certain offers of securities for issue in small unlisted companies, instead of complying with the requirements of Part 6D.2.”[1]
[1] Act s. 738A.
The Applicant (Hirehood) wishes to raise funds under the CSF. The Interested Party (VentureCrowd) is a licensed intermediary of Hirehood and has had the general carriage of the application for review on behalf of Hirehood. Where reference is made collectively to Hirehood and VentureCrowd, they are referred to as the Applicant Parties.
The Applicant Parties seek to utilise the services of a custodian company, Guardian Services Limited (GSL), which would provide nominee services to facilitate Hirehood making a CSF offer on VentureCrowd’s CSF platform. The nominee services are an arrangement whereby legal title to a security (for example, a share) is acquired by a custodian and held for the sole benefit of an investor. It was contemplated by the Applicant Parties that GSL would be recorded as a single shareholder, for the shares offered and acquired under the CSF offer, on Hirehood’s register of shareholders.
The relevant facts are detailed below, and the decisions under review are:
(a) the interim stop order made on 11 June 2024 by the Respondent (ASIC),[2] preventing an offer or issue of shares under the Hirehood CSF Offer Document dated 9 May 2024 (June Reviewable Decision). and
(b) the final stop order made by ASIC on 9 September 2024,[3] (September Reviewable Decision). (collectively the Reviewable Decisions).
[2] T3.
[3] T2.2.
The Applicant Parties have filed and rely upon the Interested Party’s Statement of Facts Issues and Contentions dated…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hirehood Pty Ltd and VentureCrowd Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2025] ARTA 881
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether the offer of beneficial interests in fully-paid ordinary shares, where the legal title to the shares is held by a custodian, constituted an eligible offer under Part 6D.3A of the Act. The Tribunal needed to determine if such an offer was permissible and whether ASIC’s interpretation of the CSF regime was correct. Specifically, the Tribunal examined whether the offer of beneficial interests complied with the statutory requirements outlined in section 738G of the Act.
The Tribunal found that ASIC's interpretation of the CSF regime was consistent with the legislative framework and the policy intent behind the Act. The Tribunal held that the offer in question was misleading and defective as it did not comply with the statutory requirement that the securities offered must be of a class specified in the regulations and must be fully-paid ordinary shares. The Tribunal concluded that ASIC's decision to issue a stop order was justified, as any delay in doing so would be prejudicial to the public interest. Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed ASIC's decision, holding that the stop order was correctly issued.
The Tribunal's decision was based on the interpretation that the offer of beneficial interests in shares, where the legal title was held by a custodian, did not meet the statutory definition of securities under the Act. The Tribunal rejected the applicants' argument that the definition of "securities" under section 92(5) should not apply once the class of securities was specified in the regulations. The Tribunal held that the statutory definition remained relevant and necessary to ensure compliance with the Act. The Tribunal's affirmation of ASIC's decision was based on the conclusion that the offer was not an eligible offer under Part 6D.3A of the Act.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In relation to Issue 3, ASIC does not engage with the Applicant Parties SFIC paragraphs [68] – [72] because ASIC is not contending that section 738G of the Act prohibits a custodian from acquiring securities issued under a CSF offer.[57][57] ASIC’s Response, [49].CONSIDERATION OF THE ISSUES The parties agree that section 912AH of the Act permits a custodian such as GSL to acquire securities under a CSF offer on behalf of an investor. The parties do not agree as to what then flows from that outcome. The Applicant Parties argue that if the custodian can legitimately acquire the shares which are to be the subject of a CSF offer, it follows that the Offer must be an eligible offer under the Act. ASIC says that section 912AH does not assist in determining what Hirehood is permitted to offer for sale on VentureCrowd’s platform under Part 6D.2 of the Act. If what is offered for sale by Hirehood to investors under the Offer is no more than the beneficial interest in shares where the legal title to the shares is held by GSL, ASIC’s position is that section 738G of the Act has not been complied with. Contrasting approaches to the question of whether an equitable interest in fully-paid ordinary shares can be offered or issued by Hirehood on VentureCrowd’s CSF platform are urged upon the Tribunal by the parties. The Applicant Parties say:… the correct approach is to construe: a. a ‘class’ of securities in a way that serves the purpose and context of the CSF Regime; b. which is in concordance with surrounding material which is probative in identifying policymakers’ intent; and c. an interpretation which is simpler and does not involve additive features to the legislation.[58] A key element of this approach is the proposition that section 92(5) of the Act is not relevant to defining the meaning of “securities of a class specified in the regulations” in subsection 738G(1)(c). The Applicant Parties accordingly answer “no” to the question posed under Issue 2 at (b)(iii). Once reg 6D.3A.01 specifies the class of securities as “fully-paid ordinary shares”, that class is to be treated in accordance with this approach and without further reference to section 92(5) of the Act.[59][58] Applicant Parties’ Reply, [8].[59] Applicant Parties’ Reply, [5] – [7]. ASIC say that the question can be resolved by an orthodox application of statutory interpretation principle involving the following steps: (a) Section 92 of the Act defines “securities” differently in different Chapters of the Act. The Tribunal must adopt the definition of securities which is prescribed for Part 6D of the Act.(b) Subsection 92(5) of the Act, when read with section 700 (by reason of subsection 92(4)), defines “securities” for the purposes of Chapter 6 as meaning “a share in a body” (s. 92(5)(a)) or “a legal or equitable right or interest” in a share in a body (s.92(5)(c)). (c) An eligible offer under Part 6D, is an offer for the issue of securities of the company (s.738G(1)(a)) and the securities are of a class specified in the regulations (s.738G(1)(c)). (d) Reg. 6D.3A.01 specifies “fully-paid ordinary shares” as a class of securities for the purpose of s.738G(1)(c). (e) The class of securities (fully-paid ordinary shares) referred to in Reg. 6D.3A.01 must be treated in a manner which is consistent with subsections 92(5)(a) and (c) of the Act and subsection 92(5)(c) must be given work to do. It follows that ASIC answers “yes” to the question posed under Issue 2 at (b)(iii).(f) It follows that a share in a body is to be a fully-paid ordinary share and if anything other than legal ownership of the fully-paid ordinary shares was contemplated by the Legislature that would have been expressly provided for in the Act or Regulations. Under this approach, subsection 92(5) of the Act does not cease to be of any relevance once the class of securities has been specified in the regulations and remains relevant as part of the statutory context.