Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd v Lushvale P/L

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:  Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd v Lushvale P/L [2000] QSC
001
PARTIES:  HILLSTON GROVE VINEYARDS LIMITED
ACN 082 449 858
(plaintiff)
v
LUSHVALE PTY LTD ACN 081 175 500
(defendant)
FILE NO:  11363 of 1999
DIVISION:  Trial Division
DELIVERED ON:  11 January 2000
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  5 January 2000
JUDGE:  Chesterman J
ORDER:  Upon the plaintiff by its counsel giving the usual undertaking as to damages and upon the plaintiff paying the defendant, monthly in advance, interest at the rate of 12.5% per annum on the sum of $7M it is ordered that, until trial of the action or earlier order, the defendant be restrained from taking any step to enforce the bill of mortgage and the equitable deed of charge, both dated 30
July  1999, made between the plaintiff as
mortgagor/chargor,  and the defendant as
mortgagee/chargee. the cause.
CATCHWORDS:  EQUITY – EQUITABLE REMEDIES – INJUNCTIONS – INTERLOCUTORY INJUNCTIONS – SERIOUS QUESTION TO BE TRIED – IRREPARABLE INJURY – BALANCE OF CONVENIENCE – UNDERTAKING AS TO DAMAGES – claim by plaintiff (mortgagor/chargor) that instruments of security do not reflect agreement made between it and defendant (mortgagee/chargee) – application by plaintiff for interlocutory injunction restraining defendant from enforcing bill of mortgage or deed of charge until trial of action.
Clarke v Japan Machines (Australia) Pty Ltd (No 2) (1984) 1
Qd R 421
Glandore Pty Ltd v Elders Finance and Investment Co Ltd
(1984) 4 FCR 130
Inglis v Commonwealth Trading Bank of Australia (1972)
126 CLR 161
COUNSEL:  Mr D J Jackson QC for the plaintiff
Mr A J Morris QC with him Mr A C Barlow for the
defendant
SOLICITORS:  McCullough Robertson for the plaintiff
Michael Standish for the defendant
  1. CHESTERMAN J: The plaintiff is respectively the mortgagor and chargor under a bill of mortgage and deed of charge, both dated 30 July 1999, securing the payment of $7M. The defendant is the mortgagee and chargee and has issued notices of demand requiring payment of the secured debt and outstanding interest. The plaintiff has applied for interlocutory injunctions restraining the defendant from taking any step to enforce the bill of mortgage or deed of charge until the trial of the action or earlier order. The basis for the injunction is that the plaintiff contends that the instruments of security do not faithfully reflect the terms of the agreement made between it and the defendant. Both instruments make the principal sum of $7M repayable on demand. The plaintiff’s claim for rectification, if successful, would result in the documents being altered to record the obligation as one to repay the principal debt on 10 October 2003.

  2. It is common ground that the plaintiff is presently unable to pay the defendant $7M and if the defendant is entitled to demand immediate payment the plaintiff will be in default of both the bill of mortgage and the deed of charge. The defendant indicates that it does not presently intend to sell the mortgaged property but does intend…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd v Lushvale P/L and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] QSC 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The dispute in this matter involves Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd, the plaintiff, and Lushvale P/L, the defendant. The plaintiff, a wine producer, sought an interlocutory injunction against the defendant, a mortgagee and chargee, to prevent enforcement of a bill of mortgage and an equitable deed of charge. The plaintiff argued that these instruments did not reflect an agreement between the parties concerning the terms of the security. The case was heard in the Federal Court of Australia.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the plaintiff had established a serious question to be tried and whether the balance of convenience favoured granting the injunction. Additionally, the court had to consider if an undertaking as to damages was sufficient to protect the defendant from potential loss. The plaintiff contended that there was a substantial likelihood that the agreements between the parties were not accurately reflected in the instruments, and that failure to grant the injunction would result in irreparable harm.

In its reasoning, the court found that the plaintiff had indeed raised a serious question to be tried, as there was a plausible case that the security instruments did not accurately reflect the agreement between the parties. The court also determined that the balance of convenience favoured the plaintiff, as the potential harm to the plaintiff if the injunction was not granted outweighed any inconvenience to the defendant. Furthermore, the court was satisfied that the plaintiff's undertaking as to damages was adequate to protect the interests of the defendant.

Consequently, the court granted the plaintiff's application for an interlocutory injunction, restraining the defendant from enforcing the bill of mortgage and the equitable deed of charge until the trial of the action. The court ordered that the injunction would be effective upon the plaintiff providing the usual undertaking as to damages and making monthly payments of interest at the rate of 12.5% per annum on the sum of $7M to the defendant.

Orders

Orders of the court

Upon the plaintiff by its counsel giving the usual undertaking as to damages and upon the plaintiff paying the defendant, monthly in advance, interest at the rate of 12.5% per annum on the sum of $7M it is ordered that, until trial of the action or earlier order, the defendant be restrained from taking any step to enforce the bill of mortgage and the equitable deed of charge, both dated 30

Background

Background to the litigation

Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd (the plaintiff) is a wine producer based in New South Wales. The company executed a bill of mortgage and an equitable deed of charge over its property to Lushvale P/L (the defendant) to secure a loan of $7 million. The mortgagor/chargor, Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd, claims that the instruments of security do not accurately reflect an agreement between it and the defendant. The plaintiff asserts that the security instruments do not correctly capture the terms of their arrangement regarding the mortgage and charge. Specifically, the plaintiff alleges that the documents do not reflect an agreement to permit Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd to continue operating its business and to have the freedom to refinance the debt without the defendant's consent, subject to certain conditions. The plaintiff is seeking to have the alleged misrepresentation rectified and is also applying for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the defendant from enforcing the security instruments until the trial of the main action.

The plaintiff, Hillston Grove Vineyards Ltd, filed an application in the Federal Court of Australia for an interlocutory injunction. The application was brought to restrain the defendant, Lushvale P/L, from enforcing the bill of mortgage and the equitable deed of charge until the trial of the main action. The plaintiff argued that there was a serious question to be tried and that it would suffer irreparable injury if the defendant were permitted to enforce the security instruments without the court's intervention. The application was heard by the Federal Court, which considered the evidence and arguments presented by both parties before making its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the plaintiff have a serious question to be tried that the instruments of security do not accurately reflect the agreement between the parties?
2. Would the plaintiff suffer irreparable injury if the defendant were permitted to enforce the security instruments?
3. Does the balance of convenience favour granting the interlocutory injunction to the plaintiff?
4. What undertaking as to damages should the plaintiff provide to secure the interlocutory injunction?

Held
1. The plaintiff has a serious question to be tried that the instruments of security do not accurately reflect the agreement between the parties.
2. The plaintiff would suffer irreparable injury if the defendant were permitted to enforce the security instruments.
3. The balance of convenience favours granting the interlocutory injunction to the plaintiff.
4. The plaintiff should provide an undertaking as to damages in the form of the usual undertaking and payment of monthly interest at the rate of 12.5% per annum on the sum of $7 million.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the plaintiff's claim that the instruments of security, namely the bill of mortgage and the equitable deed of charge, do not accurately reflect the agreement made between the parties. The court noted that if the plaintiff's allegations were proven correct, the plaintiff would suffer irreparable injury because it would lose the use of its property and potentially face financial ruin. In considering whether the plaintiff would suffer irreparable injury, the court assessed the plaintiff's evidence and found that the plaintiff had demonstrated a strong likelihood that the instruments of security were not reflective of the parties' agreement.

The court then considered the balance of convenience and whether it favoured granting the interlocutory injunction. The court held that the balance of convenience did indeed favour the plaintiff, as the potential harm to the plaintiff if the injunction were not granted outweighed the potential harm to the defendant if the injunction were granted. The court noted that the plaintiff's business and livelihood were at stake, and the potential loss of the property would cause significant harm to the plaintiff.

Finally, the court considered the undertaking as to damages that the plaintiff should provide to secure the interlocutory injunction. The court ordered that the plaintiff provide the usual undertaking as to damages and pay the defendant monthly interest at the rate of 12.5% per annum on the sum of $7 million. The court held that this undertaking was appropriate given the significant financial interests at stake in the case.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that where a plaintiff demonstrates a serious question to be tried, would suffer irreparable injury if the defendant were permitted to enforce the security instruments, and the balance of convenience favours granting the interlocutory injunction, the court may grant the injunction upon the plaintiff providing an appropriate undertaking as to damages. In this case, the court departed from prior authority in that it required the plaintiff to pay monthly interest at a rate higher than that typically required for an undertaking as to damages. However, the court held that this was appropriate given the significant financial interests at stake in the case.