Hills v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 76 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Hills v State of Queensland [2006] QSC 244

PARTIES:

CHRISTOPHER HILLS
(plaintiff)
v

STATE OF QUEENSLAND
(defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS 5440 of 2002

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Trial

ORIGINATING COURT: Supreme Court of Queensland

DELIVERED ON:

4 September 2006

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

18-21, 24, 26-28 April and 2-5, 8, 11-12 May 2006

JUDGE:

McMurdo J

ORDER:

Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $5,502,793.

CATCHWORDS:

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – where the plaintiff’s birth involved an emergency caesarean in the circumstance of a foetal cardiac arrest – where the plaintiff suffered brain damage resulting in a type of cerebral palsy known as choreo-athetoid – where the plaintiff claims damages for negligence against the State of Queensland – where the State of Queensland has admitted negligence ­– where the plaintiff was later diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes mellitus – where differing expert evidence on probable lifespan of plaintiff – where assessment of probable lifespan of plaintiff relevant to measure of damages

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL EXPENSES – where the plaintiff is entirely dependent upon the assistance of others for every day activities – where the plaintiff requires the attendance of carers on a twenty-four hour basis – where the cost of care varies according to the length of the carer’s shift – whether appropriate for carers to work 8, 12 or 24 hour shift arrangements – whether market cost of care appropriate for past and future gratuitous care and past and future paid care – whether the cost of future care should be discounted for contingencies ­­– whether the plaintiff’s claim for expenses and maintenance of future therapeutic aids, appliances and equipment appropriate and reasonable – whether plaintiff entitled to costs arising from future medical treatment, paramedical treatment and pharmaceutical costs

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – LOSS OF EARNINGS AND EARNING CAPACITY – PROSPECTIVE EARNING CAPACITY OF YOUNG CHILD – where the plaintiff has no earning capacity as a result of cerebral palsy ­– where calculations were performed on three alternative levels of income including solicitors, human resources managers and average weekly earnings ­­– whether assessment of earnings should be based on the weekly earnings of solicitors, human resources managers or average weekly earnings ­– whether the plaintiff is entitled to an allowance for long service leave – whether the plaintiff is entitled to an allowance for superannuation

DAMAGES – MEASURE AND REMOTENESS OF DAMAGES IN ACTIONS FOR TORT – MEASURE OF DAMAGES – PERSONAL INJURIES – OTHER PECUNIARY DAMAGE – whether plaintiff entitled to costs of house modifications for the parental home and the additional capital cost of modifying a house when the plaintiff lives independently from his parents – whether plaintiff entitled to costs of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hills v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] QSC 244
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hills v State of Queensland, the plaintiff sought damages for injuries sustained at birth due to an emergency caesarean under the circumstances of foetal cardiac arrest, resulting in brain damage and a form of cerebral palsy known as choreo-athetoid. The State of Queensland admitted negligence, and the primary issue was the assessment of damages, including the plaintiff's probable lifespan, care costs, future medical expenses, loss of earnings, and other pecuniary and non-pecuniary damages. The court had to determine the appropriate method to calculate the plaintiff's future care costs, whether the market rate for care should apply, and if there should be a discount for contingencies. It also had to decide on the appropriate weekly earnings level to base the plaintiff's loss of future earning capacity on, and whether allowances for long service leave and superannuation were justified.

The court addressed these issues by examining expert evidence on the plaintiff's probable lifespan, which varied significantly. It concluded that the plaintiff's care costs should be based on market rates, with appropriate adjustments for shift lengths and contingencies. Regarding loss of future earnings, the court decided that the plaintiff's earning capacity should be assessed based on the weekly earnings of solicitors, given the plaintiff's intellectual capacity. The court also ruled that the plaintiff was not entitled to allowances for long service leave or superannuation, as these benefits were not applicable given the plaintiff's circumstances. Furthermore, the court assessed the plaintiff's entitlement to various costs, including house modifications, hydrotherapy pool costs, housekeeping, technological aids, and additional educational, motor vehicle, and holiday expenses.

The judgment resulted in a total award of $5,502,793 to the plaintiff, encompassing all assessed damages and costs. This comprehensive award reflects the court's detailed consideration of the plaintiff's unique needs and the extensive nature of the injuries sustained.

Orders

Orders of the court

Judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $5,502,793.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a plaintiff who suffered brain damage during an emergency caesarean due to a foetal cardiac arrest, resulting in a type of cerebral palsy known as choreo-athetoid. The plaintiff's mother brought an action against the State of Queensland for negligence in the care provided during the birth. The State admitted negligence. The plaintiff, who is entirely dependent on others for daily activities and requires 24-hour care, was later diagnosed with Type 1 diabetes mellitus. There was differing expert evidence on the probable lifespan of the plaintiff, which is relevant to the measure of damages. The plaintiff sought damages for various pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses, including costs of care, therapeutic aids, house modifications, educational costs, and general damages for pain, suffering, and loss of amenities.

This case came before the court following an admission of negligence by the State of Queensland. The matter proceeded to a trial where the court assessed the quantum of damages. The trial involved extensive evidence and expert testimony regarding the plaintiff's injuries, care needs, and the various costs associated with his condition. The court also heard arguments regarding the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's future care and the various other claims for pecuniary and non-pecuniary losses. The case concluded with the court making a judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $5,502,793.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. What is the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's personal injuries, taking into account the differing expert evidence on his probable lifespan?
2. What is the appropriate cost for the plaintiff's future care, including whether to use 8, 12, or 24-hour shift arrangements, and whether market costs are suitable for past and future gratuitous and paid care?
3. Are the plaintiff's claims for expenses and maintenance of future therapeutic aids, appliances, and equipment appropriate and reasonable?
4. Is the plaintiff entitled to costs arising from future medical treatment, paramedical treatment, and pharmaceutical costs?
5. What is the appropriate assessment of the plaintiff's prospective earning capacity, and should this be based on the weekly earnings of solicitors, human resources managers, or average weekly earnings?
6. Is the plaintiff entitled to an allowance for long service leave and superannuation?
7. Are the plaintiff's claims for other pecuniary damages, such as house modifications, hydrotherapy pool costs, housekeeping, technological aids, educational costs, motor vehicle costs, holiday costs, and out-of-pocket expenses, appropriate and reasonable?
8. Should a public trustee or funds manager be appointed for the plaintiff?
9. Is the plaintiff's claim for general damages, including pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and loss of expectation of life, appropriate and reasonable?

Held
1. The court held that the appropriate measure of damages for the plaintiff's personal injuries, considering differing expert evidence on his probable lifespan, was determined by calculating the present value of future care costs based on the most probable lifespan.
2. The court decided that the appropriate cost for the plaintiff's future care should be calculated based on 24-hour shift arrangements, and that market costs were suitable for both past and future gratuitous and paid care.
3. The court held that the plaintiff's claims for expenses and maintenance of future therapeutic aids, appliances, and equipment were appropriate and reasonable.
4. The court held that the plaintiff was entitled to costs arising from future medical treatment, paramedical treatment, and pharmaceutical costs.
5. The court held that the appropriate assessment of the plaintiff's prospective earning capacity should be based on the weekly earnings of solicitors, but it was not entitled to an allowance for long service leave or superannuation.
6. The court held that the plaintiff's claims for other pecuniary damages, such as house modifications, hydrotherapy pool costs, housekeeping, technological aids, educational costs, motor vehicle costs, holiday costs, and out-of-pocket expenses, were appropriate and reasonable.
7. The court held that a public trustee or funds manager should be appointed for the plaintiff.
8. The court held that the plaintiff's claim for general damages, including pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and loss of expectation of life, was appropriate and reasonable.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the differing expert evidence on the probable lifespan of the plaintiff and determined that the appropriate measure of damages for his personal injuries was calculated based on the present value of future care costs using the most probable lifespan. The court examined the nature of the plaintiff's disability and the need for 24-hour care, and concluded that market costs were suitable for both past and future gratuitous and paid care. Regarding the plaintiff's claims for expenses and maintenance of future therapeutic aids, appliances, and equipment, the court found these claims to be appropriate and reasonable. The court also held that the plaintiff was entitled to costs arising from future medical treatment, paramedical treatment, and pharmaceutical costs. In assessing the plaintiff's prospective earning capacity, the court found that the weekly earnings of solicitors provided an appropriate basis for the calculation but determined that the plaintiff was not entitled to an allowance for long service leave or superannuation. The court held that the plaintiff's claims for other pecuniary damages, such as house modifications, hydrotherapy pool costs, housekeeping, technological aids, educational costs, motor vehicle costs, holiday costs, and out-of-pocket expenses, were appropriate and reasonable. The court ordered the appointment of a public trustee or funds manager to manage the plaintiff's damages. Finally, the court held that the plaintiff's claim for general damages, including pain and suffering, loss of amenities, and loss of expectation of life, was appropriate and reasonable. The ratio decidendi of this decision is the appropriate measure of damages for personal injuries, taking into account differing expert evidence on probable lifespan, and the suitability of market costs for past and future gratuitous and paid care.