Hills v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read

[2009] QDC 75

DISTRICT COURT
APPELLATE JURISDICTION

JUDGE DEARDEN

LEVINA ROXANNE HILLS Appellant
and
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE Respondent
MOUNT ISA
..DATE 10/02/2009
ORDER

1-1

HIS HONOUR: This is an appeal against the sentence of the learned Magistrate sitting in the Mornington Island Magistrates Court on 15 April 2008 in respect of the appellant, Levina Roxanne Hills.

The appellant was on that day before the Court in respect of 11 offences to which she pleaded guilty. Seven of those were in respect of contraventions of the Liquor Act (1992); one offence related to a breach of the Bail Act (1980), and the three offences which are the subject of this appeal were contraventions of the Summary Offences Act (2005). With one exception, a possession of liquor in a restricted area, the offences occurred over a two month period between 20 February and 15 April 2008.

The three breaches of the Summary Offences Act were offences of commit a public nuisance, and they occurred relevantly on 27 March, 28 March and 15 April 2008.

In respect of each of those offences, the Magistrate imposed
sentences respectively of one month, two months and four
months imprisonment but then (and this is ultimately the
sentencing disposition which is the subject of the appeal),
the learned sentencing Magistrate ordered that all terms of
imprisonment be served cumulatively and set a parole release
date of 14 July 2008 which equates essentially to seven
months' imprisonment to serve, if I understand it correctly,
three months.
The grounds on which the applicant appeals are (1) that the
sentences were manifestly excessive, and (2) that the
Magistrate took into account irrelevant issues.
1-2 ORDER

There has been a difficulty in progressing the appeal in this matter because of the absence of a transcript. Ultimately the transcript of the sentencing submissions was able to be located and transcribed. There is, however, no transcript of the learned sentencing Magistrate's sentencing remarks. However, the legal representatives of both the applicant and the respondent are satisfied that this Court can deal with the appeal based on the record as it stands (including helpful affidavits from the Police Prosecutor who appeared on the sentence, Senior Constable Walter Brewer, and the solicitor from the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Legal Service who appeared, Ms Fiona McAdam), and I thank both of them for assisting the interests of justice by providing an affidavit as to their recollection of the relevant part of the proceedings.

Each of the first two public nuisance offences involved the applicant being involved in a fight; the first on the 27th of March at about 10 p.m., the second on the 28th of March at about midnight, and the third offence also involved intoxication of the appellant (as did the previous two offences), but on that case the appellant was intoxicated lying on a road and was swearing at other members of the public and at the police officers who took her into custody. She was, it seems, also in breach of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hills v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] QDC 75
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Levina Roxanne Hills appealed against the sentence imposed by the Mornington Island Magistrates Court on 15 April 2008, following her conviction on 11 offences. The appellant pleaded guilty to seven contraventions of the Liquor Act (1992), one breach of the Bail Act (1980), and three contraventions of the Summary Offences Act (2005). The three breaches of the Summary Offences Act, which involved committing a public nuisance, were the subject of the appeal. The Magistrate sentenced the appellant to one month, two months, and four months imprisonment, respectively, for each offence, with all terms to be served cumulatively, resulting in a total of seven months' imprisonment. The appellant argued that the sentences were manifestly excessive and that the Magistrate took into account irrelevant issues.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the cumulative sentence imposed by the Magistrate was manifestly excessive and whether the Magistrate took into account irrelevant matters. The court considered the circumstances surrounding the appellant's criminal history, her age, and her role as a mother of two children. The court also examined the submissions made by the local Community Justice Group and the effect they had on the Magistrate's sentencing decision.

The court found that while the Magistrate was entitled to consider the recommendations of the Community Justice Group, the responsibility for determining the appropriate sentence ultimately lay with the Magistrate. The court held that the Magistrate had erred in imposing cumulative sentences, effectively doubling the total sentence, which was manifestly excessive. The court concluded that the appropriate sentence for the last of the three offences of public nuisance was four months, and the cumulative sentencing had effectively doubled this head sentence. Therefore, the appeal was granted, and the court varied the sentence by ordering that the prison sentences be served concurrently instead of cumulatively.

The court ordered that the appellant report to a Probation and Parole Office between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. on the next business day, with a parole release date set for 10 February 2009. The court noted that the provisions of section 200 under the Corrective Services Act could be brought to the attention of the appellant by the Corrective Services officer with whom she deals in reporting within the relevant timeframe set out by section 160G of the Penalties and Sentences Act. The appellant's legal representative, Mr. Pennell, confirmed that he would undertake this obligation. There was no application for costs, and the court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established