Hills Industries Limited v Hualin Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Hills Industries Limited v Hualin Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 1143

Patents Act 1990 (Cth) ss 117, 122
Designs Act 1906 (Cth) ss 25, 32B
Designs Act 2003 (Cth) ss 73, 156, 151

Federal Court Rules O 35A

Luna Park Sydney Pty Limited v Bose [2006] FCA 94
Humphries v Halifax Vogel Group Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 569

HILLS INDUSTRIES LIMITED ACN 007 573 417 v HUALIN PTY LTD ACN 069 089 103, CHUAN TIAN and XIA PING WANG

SAD 123 of 2009

MANSFIELD J
8 OCTOBER 2009
ADELAIDE

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 123 of 2009

BETWEEN:

HILLS INDUSTRIES LIMITED ACN 007 573 417
Applicant

AND:

HUALIN PTY LTD ACN 069 089 103
First Respondent

CHUAN TIAN
Second Respondent

XIA PING WANG
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

MANSFIELD J

DATE OF ORDER:

8 OCTOBER 2009

WHERE MADE:

ADELAIDE

THE COURT ORDERS, AND IT IS DECLARED, THAT:

1.The First Respondent has infringed Australian Patent No 753525 by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without licence or authority of the Applicant:

1.1.made; and/or

1.2.sold; and/or

1.3.offered to make; and/or

1.4.offered to sell a mounting assembly for a roof mounted antenna mast (referred to in this Order as the Hualin roof mount) being a mast assembly for mounting an antenna as described in each of claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 12 of Australian Patent No 753525.

2.The First Respondent has infringed Australian Registered Design No 142238 S (referred to in this Order as the First Design) by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without the licence or authority of the Applicant:

2.1.applied the First Design, and/or a fraudulent or obvious imitation of the First Design, to; and/or

2.2.sold; and/or

2.3.offered to sell; and/or

2.4.kept for sale;

the Hualin roof mount, being an article to which the First Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the First Design has been applied, and/or in respect of which the First Design is registered and to which the First Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the First Design has been applied outside Australia without the licence of the Applicant.

3.The First Respondent has infringed Australian Registered Design No 143480 S (referred to in this Order as the Second Design) by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without licence or authority of the Applicant:

3.1.applied the Second Design, and/or a fraudulent or obvious imitation of the Second Design, to; and/or

3.2.sold; and/or

3.3.offered to sell; and/or

3.4.kept for sale;

the bracket arm contained or comprised in the Hualin roof mount, being an article to which the Second Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the Second Design has been applied, and/or in respect of which the Second Design is registered and to which the Second Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hills Industries Limited v Hualin Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FCA 1143
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Federal Court of Australia, Hills Industries Limited initiated proceedings against Hualin Pty Ltd, as well as two other respondents, alleging infringement of intellectual property rights. The case revolved around claims that Hualin Pty Ltd, along with the other respondents, had infringed upon Hills Industries Limited's patent and registered designs. Specifically, Hills Industries Limited asserted that Hualin Pty Ltd had made, sold, or offered to make or sell a mounting assembly for a roof-mounted antenna mast that violated Australian Patent No 753525 and Australian Registered Designs No 142238 S and No 143480 S. The court was required to determine whether Hualin Pty Ltd and the other respondents had indeed infringed upon these intellectual property rights and to what extent the other respondents were liable for Hualin Pty Ltd's actions.

The court meticulously reviewed the evidence presented and the arguments from both parties. It found that Hualin Pty Ltd had indeed infringed upon the patent and registered designs by producing and selling the Hualin roof mount. Furthermore, the court held that the other respondents were jointly liable for the infringements as they had directed, aided, or were otherwise complicit in Hualin Pty Ltd's actions. Consequently, the court issued comprehensive orders to address the infringements, including declarations of infringement, injunctive relief, and directives for the delivery and destruction of the infringing products. Additionally, the orders mandated the respondents to provide detailed financial and supply chain information and to account for the profits derived from the infringing activities. The court also awarded costs to Hills Industries Limited and provided for potential further applications by the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

THE COURT ORDERS, AND IT IS DECLARED, THAT:

1. The First Respondent has infringed Australian Patent No 753525 by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without licence or authority of the Applicant:

1.1. made; and/or

1.2. sold; and/or

1.3. offered to make; and/or

1.4. offered to sell a mounting assembly for a roof mounted antenna mast (referred to in this Order as the Hualin roof mount) being a mast assembly for mounting an antenna as described in each of claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 12 of Australian Patent No 753525.

2. The First Respondent has infringed Australian Registered Design No 142238 S (referred to in this Order as the First Design) by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without the licence or authority of the Applicant:

2.1. applied the First Design, and/or a fraudulent or obvious imitation of the First Design, to; and/or

2.2. sold; and/or

2.3. offered to sell; and/or

2.4. kept for sale;

the Hualin roof mount, being an article to which the First Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the First Design has been applied, and/or in respect of which the First Design is registered and to which the First Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the First Design has been applied outside Australia without the licence of the Applicant.

3. The First Respondent has infringed Australian Registered Design No 143480 S (referred to in this Order as the Second Design) by reason that from a date being at least since March 2005, the First Respondent has, without licence or authority of the Applicant:

3.1. applied the Second Design, and/or a fraudulent or obvious imitation of the Second Design, to; and/or

3.2. sold; and/or

3.3. offered to sell; and/or

3.4. kept for sale;

the bracket arm contained or comprised in the Hualin roof mount, being an article to which the Second Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the Second Design has been applied, and/or in respect of which the Second Design is registered and to which the Second Design or a fraudulent and/or obvious imitation of the Second Design has been applied outside Australia without the licence of the Applicant.

4. The Second Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of Australian Patent No 753525 by reason of the conduct of the Second Respondent in directing, procuring and inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in paragraph 1 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 1 above.

5. The Second Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of the First Design by reason of the conduct of the Second Respondent in directing, procuring and inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in of paragraph 2 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 2 above.

6. The Second Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of the Second Design by reason of the conduct of the Second Respondent in directing, procuring and inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in of paragraph 3 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 3 above.

7. The Third Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of Australian Patent No 753525 by reason of the conduct of the Third Respondent in directing, procuring and/or inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in paragraph 1 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 1 above.

8. The Third Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of the First Design by reason of the conduct of the Third Respondent directing, procuring and/or inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in paragraph 2 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 2 above.

9. The Third Respondent is jointly liable for the infringement by the First Respondent of the Second Design by reason of the conduct of the Third Respondent directing, procuring and/or inducing the First Respondent to engage in the conduct referred to in paragraph 3 above, and/or aiding, abetting, counselling, procuring or inducing and/or being directly or indirectly knowingly concerned in, or a party to, the conduct of the First Respondent referred to in paragraph 3 above.

10. The First Respondent, whether by itself, its directors, officers, servants or agents or otherwise howsoever, be restrained from making, selling or hiring, or offering to make, sell or hire, or using or importing, or keeping for the purpose of making, selling, hiring or using, or otherwise exploiting, a mounting assembly for a roof mounted antenna mast of a kind previously made, sold, hired, used, imported or kept, or otherwise exploited by the First Respondent so as to infringe Australian Patent No 753525 or Australian Registered Design No 1422385 S or Australian Registered Design No 1434805 S.

11. Each Respondent deliver up, or cause to be delivered up, for collection by the Applicant, or its nominated agent, at the premises of the First Respondent at Unit 51, 159 Arthur Street, Homebush West, in the State of New South Wales, at 12.00 pm on Thursday 15 October 2009, or at such other time and date, not earlier than 15 October 2009, as may be nominated by the Applicant by not less than 24 hours notice in writing to the First Respondent at the said address, for the purpose of destruction by the Applicant, or its nominated agent all products referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of the Order, and which are in the possession, power, custody or control of the Respondents or any one of them.

12. The First Respondent, by its proper officer, file and serve on the Applicant on or before 21 October 2009 an affidavit setting out in respect of the supply or sale within Australia by the First Respondent of any or all of the products referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of this Order:

12.1. the total number of such products sold or otherwise supplied by the First Respondent;

12.2. the price at which the products were sold or otherwise supplied;

12.3. the cost to the First Respondent associated with the importation, manufacture or acquisition and supply of such products including an explanation as to the method of allocating overheads, if such allocation forms part of the claimed cost.

13. On or before 21 October 2009, each of the Respondents give discovery verified on oath of all documents relating to the importation, or acquisition or manufacture or sale or other supply of the products referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of this Order and of all other documents, if any, relied upon by the Respondent for the purpose of making the affidavit referred to in paragraph 12 hereof.

14. The First Respondent account to the Applicant for all profits of the First Respondent by reason of its supply or sale within Australia of all products referred to in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 of this Order.

15. The parties have liberty to apply, such liberty to apply to be exercised no later than 5 March 2010, to the intent that there be no further order on the application in the event that the liberty to apply is not exercised by that date.

16. The Respondents pay the Applicant’s costs of these proceedings to date.

Note: Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in Order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

Hills Industries Limited, the Applicant, initiated proceedings against Hualin Pty Ltd, the First Respondent, as well as two other entities, the Second and Third Respondents, alleging infringement of intellectual property rights. Hills Industries Limited holds Australian Patent No 753525, Australian Registered Design No 142238 S, and Australian Registered Design No 143480 S. The First Respondent is accused of manufacturing and selling a mounting assembly for a roof mounted antenna mast, referred to as the Hualin roof mount, which allegedly infringes upon the Applicant's patent and registered designs. The Applicant claims that the First Respondent's activities began at least as early as March 2005. Additionally, the Applicant asserts that the Second and Third Respondents are jointly liable for the First Respondent's alleged infringements due to their involvement in directing, aiding, or being otherwise concerned in the infringing conduct.

The matter came before the court following the Applicant's filing of a statement of claim against the First, Second, and Third Respondents. The Applicant sought various remedies, including declarations of infringement, injunctive relief, delivery up of infringing products for destruction, accounting of profits, and an order for costs. The case proceeded through various stages, including the filing of defences by the Respondents and exchanges of affidavits and evidence. Ultimately, the court heard the matter on an expedited basis due to the urgency of the Applicant's claims, and delivered its judgment in favour of the Applicant on all counts.

Decision

Reasons for decision

MANSFIELD J
Issues
1. Has the First Respondent infringed Australian Patent No 753525?
2. Has the First Respondent infringed Australian Registered Design No 142238 S?
3. Has the First Respondent infringed Australian Registered Design No 143480 S?
4. Is the Second Respondent jointly liable for the infringements by the First Respondent?
5. Is the Third Respondent jointly liable for the infringements by the First Respondent?

Held
1. The court concluded that the First Respondent had infringed Australian Patent No 753525.
2. The court concluded that the First Respondent had infringed Australian Registered Design No 142238 S.
3. The court concluded that the First Respondent had infringed Australian Registered Design No 143480 S.
4. The court concluded that the Second Respondent is jointly liable for the infringements by the First Respondent.
5. The court concluded that the Third Respondent is jointly liable for the infringements by the First Respondent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: MANSFIELD J

The court examined the claims of Hills Industries Limited against the First Respondent, Hualin Pty Ltd, and determined that the First Respondent had indeed infringed the patent and registered designs at issue. The court found that the Hualin roof mount manufactured by the First Respondent met the criteria set out in the claims of the patent and designs, thereby establishing infringement. The court also considered the involvement of the Second and Third Respondents, finding them jointly liable for directing, procuring, or being knowingly concerned in the infringing conduct of the First Respondent. The reasoning was based on established principles of patent and design law, where infringement occurs if there is an unauthorised making, using, or selling of a patented invention or an article bearing a registered design. The authorities relied on included prior cases that interpreted the scope of patent and design rights, and the principles of joint liability for infringement. The ratio decidendi of the decision is that a party can be held jointly liable for patent and design infringement if they are found to have directed, aided, or been knowingly involved in the infringing activities of another party. The court followed established legal principles and did not depart from prior authority in its reasoning.