Hill v The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 84 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Hill v The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd [2025] NSWPIC 460
APPLICANT: Graham Hill    
RESPONDENT: The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd
MEMBER: Jane Peacock
DATE OF DECISION: 5 September 2025

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; psychological injury; allegation of a primary psychological injury disputed; applicant has an accepted physical injury and secondary psychological condition for which he is receiving weekly benefits on the basis of no current work capacity (total incapacity); dispute about date of injury; dispute about lateness of notice of injury and claim for compensation; evidence weighed in the balance and applicant found to have suffered a primary psychological injury; not precluded from recovery because of “lateness” because deemed date of injury of the primary psychological injury so found is the date of incapacity as a result of the primary psychological injury; Held – award for the applicant on the basis of no current work capacity (total incapacity); reduced under section 46 by the amounts paid or being paid by the respondent for weekly compensation on the basis of no current work capacity (total incapacity) for the accepted physical injury and secondary psychological condition.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     The respondent pay the applicant as a result of primary psychological injury deemed to have occurred on 12 September 2024 at the rate of $1,282.33 from 12 September 2024 to
12 December 2024 and thereafter at the rate of $1,079.86 per week as indexed from
13 December 2024 to date and continuing.

2. Under s 46 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 the weekly compensation payable to the applicant is reduced by the amounts already paid or being paid by the respondent to the applicant for weekly compensation as a result of total incapacity in respect of the accepted physical injury and secondary psychological condition.

3.     The respondent pay the applicant’s section 60 expenses as a result of primary psychological injury on production of accounts, receipts and/or Medicare Notice of Charge.

A brief statement is attached setting out the Commission’s reasons for the determination.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. By Application to Resolve a Dispute (Application), Mr Graham Hill (the applicant), as amended, seeks weekly compensation and compensation for medical expenses as a result of allegation of a primary psychological injury in the course of or arising out of his employment as a machine operator.

  2. The respondent is The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd (the respondent). The respondent was insured at the relevant time for the purposes of workers compensation by Employers Mutual Limited (the insurer).

  3. The respondent denied liability for the claim.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. The applicant was employed by the respondent as a machine operator since about
    6 January 2020.

  2. On 5 March 2022 he suffered an injury to his right shoulder. There is no dispute about liability for his physical injury on 5 March 2022. Furthermore, the respondent concedes that the applicant suffered a secondary psychological condition as a result of his physical…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hill v The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] NSWPIC 460
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Hill v The A2 Milk Company (Australia) Pty Ltd, the applicant, Mr Hill, sought compensation for a psychological injury sustained during his employment with the respondent. Mr Hill had an accepted physical injury and a secondary psychological condition for which he was receiving weekly compensation benefits based on total incapacity. The primary dispute centred on whether Mr Hill had suffered a primary psychological injury, the date of the injury, and the timeliness of his notice and claim for compensation. The court was required to determine the validity of Mr Hill's claim for a primary psychological injury, assess the timeliness of the notice and claim, and decide whether the lateness of the notice and claim precluded his recovery.

The court evaluated the evidence presented and concluded that Mr Hill had indeed suffered a primary psychological injury. The court found that the date of injury for the primary psychological condition was the date when Mr Hill became totally incapacitated due to the condition. The court held that the lateness of the notice and claim did not bar recovery, as the primary psychological injury was deemed to have occurred on the date of incapacity. Consequently, Mr Hill was awarded compensation for his primary psychological injury based on total incapacity, with the award reduced by the amounts already paid or payable for his accepted physical injury and secondary psychological condition.

The court's decision affirmed Mr Hill's entitlement to compensation for his primary psychological injury, notwithstanding the issues surrounding the timeliness of his notice and claim. The court's reasoning was grounded in the statutory provisions of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, which allow for recovery despite late notice if special circumstances exist. The final orders of the court were to award Mr Hill compensation for his primary psychological injury, reduced by the amounts already compensated for his other conditions.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The relevant legislation also includes ss 78, 254, 261, and 289A of the 1998 Act as follows:“78 Insurer to give notice of decisions(1) An insurer must give notice in accordance with this Division of any decision of the insurer—(a) to dispute liability in respect of a claim or any aspect of a claim, or(b) to discontinue payment to a worker of weekly payments of compensation, or reduce the amount of the compensation.(2) Notice of a decision of an insurer involving both a liability dispute and a discontinuation or reduction of weekly compensation may be combined into a single notice (subject to any provision of the Workers Compensation Guidelines requiring separate notices to be given).(3)The requirement to give notice of a decision to discontinue payment to a worker of weekly payments of compensation does not affect any limitation on weekly payments of compensation under Division 2 of Part 3 of the 1987 Act.254 Notice of injury must be given to employer(1) Neither compensation nor work injury damages are recoverable by an injured worker unless notice of the injury is given to the employer as soon as possible after the injury happened and before the worker has voluntarily left the employment in which the worker was at the time of the injury.(2) The failure to give notice of injury as required by this section (or any defect or inaccuracy in a notice of injury) is not a bar to the recovery of compensation or work injury damages if in proceedings to recover the compensation or damages it is found that there are special circumstances as provided by this section.(3) Each of the following constitutes special circumstances—(a) the person against whom the proceedings are taken has not been prejudiced in respect of the proceedings by the failure to give notice of injury or by the defect or inaccuracy in the notice,(b) the failure to give notice of injury, or the defect or inaccuracy in the notice, was occasioned by ignorance, mistake, absence from the State or other reasonable cause,(c) the person against whom the proceedings are taken had knowledge of the injury from any source at or about the time when the injury happened,(d) the injury has been reported by the employer to the Nominal Insurer in accordance with this Act,(e) the employer has contravened section 231,(f) the injury has been treated in a first aid room at the place of work,(g) if the employer is the owner of a mine—the injury has been reported by or on behalf of the employer to an inspector of mines or an inspector under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011.(4) In addition, if the employer is the owner of a mine or quarry, or the occupier of a factory, workshop, office or shop, each of the following constitutes special circumstances—(a) the summary referred to in section 231 has not been posted up in accordance with that section or the employer has otherwise contravened that section,(b) the injury has been reported by or on behalf of the employer to an inspector of mines or an inspector under the Work Health and Safety Act 2011,(c) the injury has been treated in a first aid room at the mine, quarry, factory, workshop, office or shop.261 Time within which claim for compensation must be made(1) Compensation cannot be recovered unless a claim for the compensation has been made within 6 months after the injury or accident happened or, in the case of death, within 6 months after the date of death.(2) If a claim for compensation was made by an injured worker within the period required by this section, this section does not apply to a claim for compensation in respect of the death of the worker resulting from the injury to which the worker’s claim related.(3) For the purposes of this section, a person is considered to have made a claim for compensation when the person makes any claim for compensation in respect of the injury or death concerned, even if the person’s claim did not relate to the particular compensation in question.(4) The failure to make a claim within the period required by this section is not a bar to the recovery of compensation if it is found that the failure was occasioned by ignorance, mistake, absence from the State or other reasonable cause, and either—(a) the claim is made within 3 years after the injury or accident happened or, in the case of death, within 3 years after the date of death, or(b) the claim is not made within that 3 years but the claim is in respect of an injury resulting in the death or serious and permanent disablement of a worker.(5) The failure to make a claim within the period required by this section is not a bar to the recovery of compensation if the insurer concerned determines to accept the claim outside that period. An insurer cannot determine to accept a claim made more than 3 years after the injury or accident happened or after the date of death (as appropriate) except with the approval of the Authority.(6) If an injured worker first becomes aware that he or she has received an injury after the injury was received, the injury is for the purposes of this section taken to have been received when the worker first became so aware.(7) If death results from an injury and a person who is entitled to claim compensation in respect of the death first becomes aware after the death that the death resulted or is likely to have resulted from the injury, the date of death is, for the purposes of the application of this section to a claim by that person, taken to be the date that the person became so aware.(8) In a case where 2 or more persons are liable or partly liable in respect of compensation (whether or not that liability arises from the same or from different injuries), a claim is for the purposes of this section taken to have been made when a claim is made on any one of those persons.(9) When particulars of any injury received by a worker are entered in a register of injuries kept by the employer under this Act, the making of that entry suffices for the purposes of this section as the making of a claim for compensation in respect of the injury.289A Further restrictions as to when a dispute can be referred to Commission(1) A dispute cannot be referred for determination by the Commission unless it concerns only matters previously notified as disputed.(2) A matter is taken to have been previously notified as disputed if—(a) it was notified in a notice of dispute under this Act or the 1987 Act after a claim was made or a claim was reviewed, or(b) it concerns matters, raised in writing between the parties before the dispute is referred to the President for determination by the Commission, concerning an offer of settlement of a claim for lump sum compensation.(3) The Commission may not hear or otherwise deal with any dispute if this section provides that the dispute cannot be referred for determination by the Commission. However, the Commission may hear or otherwise deal with a matter subsequently arising out of such a dispute.(4) Despite subsection (3), a dispute relating to previously unnotified matters may be heard or otherwise dealt with by the Commission if the Commission is of the opinion that it is in the interests of justice to do so.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established