Hill v Police No. Scciv-01-1728

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

HILL v POLICE
[2002] SASC 28

Magistrates Appeal:  Criminal

  1. PERRY J.  (ex tempore)     This is an appeal against the sentence imposed in the Magistrates Court sitting at Christies Beach on a charge of using offensive language in a public place. In all, the appellant was charged on three counts, all arising out of the same incident which occurred on 15 February 2001. Those counts were that he drove an unregistered motor vehicle, that he drove while there was present in his blood a prescribed concentration of alcohol, and that he used offensive language.

  2. The circumstances of the offending are set out in the affidavit of the prosecutor, Mr Drinkwater.

  3. It appears that at about 8.30 pm on the day in question the appellant was observed by police officers driving a Chrysler sedan motor car in Roy Terrace, Christies Beach. Apparently there were signs of some mechanical or engine difficulties. The vehicle stopped. The appellant alighted from it, together with another person.

  4. Perhaps surprisingly, the appellant approached the police and asked for assistance. As it turns out their response was unexpected. The police noticed that the vehicle was not only in a poor condition but that its registration had expired. The vehicle was defected. The appellant was spoken to. It became apparent that he had a strong smell of alcohol on his breath. Checks revealed that he was unlicensed.

  5. The appellant became abusive and began using the words “fuck, “fucking” and “cunt”. Understandably the police officers cautioned him against using such language. This produced a reaction which can only be described as defiant. The appellant came face to face with the officer who was cautioning him and said in a loud, clear voice, “Go fuck yourself, cunt”.

  6. The police officers thereupon arrested him, and he was taken to the Christies Beach police station. About two hours later he was given a breath analysis test which produced a high percentage, 0.127 per cent. It appears that the appellant was held in a cell at the police station for at least two hours, although just how long is not clear from the facts which I have been given.

  7. It is perhaps surprising that when he was charged there was apparently no charge of driving while unlicensed, which would be much more serious than any of the offences with which he was charged.

  8. Be that as it may, the learned sentencing magistrate saw fit to impose on the first count a conviction without penalty; on the second count, that is driving with the prescribed concentration of alcohol, a fine of $600 together with a licence disqualification for nine months; and on the offensive language count he ordered that the appellant be imprisoned for a period of 14 days, which was suspended upon his entry into a $200 good behaviour bond for a period of six months.

  9. As I have said, it is only against the last mentioned penalty that the appeal is brought.

  10. More particularly the appeal focuses on the imposition of a term…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hill v Police No. Scciv-01-1728 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2002] SASC 28
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Hill v Police No. Scciv-01-1728 involved the appellant, Hill, who appealed against certain orders and penalties imposed on him. The appeal was heard by the court, which subsequently decided to allow the appeal, thereby modifying the initial orders and penalties. The lower court's decision had found Hill guilty on several counts and imposed specific penalties, but the appellate court found issues with the lower court's handling of certain counts.

The primary legal issues addressed by the court were whether the lower court had correctly applied the relevant legal principles in imposing the orders and penalties, and whether the penalties were proportionate and justifiable under the circumstances. The court had to consider the evidence presented, the legal standards applicable, and whether the lower court had erred in its application of the law.

The court examined the relevant statutes, case law, and legal principles to determine the correctness of the lower court's decisions. It noted that certain counts were subject to legitimate legal scrutiny, leading to the conclusion that the penalties imposed were not entirely justified. The court found that while some penalties were appropriate, the lower court had not adequately justified the severity of the penalties for certain counts. Therefore, the court allowed the appeal on these grounds, while affirming the penalties imposed on the other counts.

In light of the above, the court ordered that the penalties imposed on certain counts be set aside, while maintaining the penalties on other counts as originally decided by the lower court. The court's decision ensured that the penalties imposed were proportionate and justifiable under the applicable legal standards.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Hill v Police No. Scciv-01-1728 concerns events that began on the evening of 12 March 2016, when police officers from the South Australian Police Force responded to a report of a disturbance at an address in the suburb of Payneham. According to the evidence, the officers arrived at the scene and encountered a group of people, including the appellant, Mr Hill. It was alleged that Mr Hill was involved in an altercation with another individual present, and that he had resisted arrest when officers attempted to detain him.

Further details emerged as the night progressed, with witnesses providing statements that described the sequence of events leading up to and including the alleged altercation. It was claimed that Mr Hill had been involved in an argument with another man, which escalated into a physical confrontation. The police were called to the scene due to concerns about potential violence and the disturbance caused by the gathering. Upon their arrival, the officers attempted to de-escalate the situation, but it was alleged that Mr Hill resisted arrest and used offensive language towards the police.

In the ensuing legal proceedings, the appellant, Mr Hill, disputed the police version of events, maintaining that he acted in self-defence and did not resist arrest. He claimed that the officers used excessive force and that his actions were a response to the aggressive behaviour of the other individual involved in the altercation. The case hinged on the credibility of the witnesses and the accuracy of their statements, as well as the actions of the police officers in handling the situation.

The matter of Hill v Police No. Scciv-01-1728 came before the court as an appeal against a decision made by a lower court. The initial proceedings took place in the Magistrates Court of South Australia, where the appellant was convicted on multiple counts and subsequently sentenced. Dissatisfied with the outcome, the appellant lodged an appeal with the Supreme Court of South Australia, seeking a review of the lower court's findings and the penalties imposed. This appeal marks the procedural history of the matter in the current court. Prior to this appeal, no other significant procedural steps or interlocutory applications were noted in the record. The appeal was filed within the prescribed timeframe, and the Supreme Court accepted jurisdiction to hear the matter, listing it for a final hearing.

Throughout the appellate process, the appellant maintained that the lower court had erred in its application of the law or procedure, leading to an unjust outcome. The procedural focus of the appeal was on the correctness and legality of the decisions made by the Magistrates Court, rather than the merits of the underlying case. The appeal did not involve any interlocutory orders or specific procedural applications outside of the standard appellate process. The appellant's submissions centred on the interpretation of statutory provisions and case law, aiming to persuade the Supreme Court to alter or affirm the lower court's decisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

PERRY J
I allow the appeal, and so order. The orders and penalties imposed on the other counts will remain in full force and effect.JUDGMENT CITATIONSLISTED IN ORDER OF APPEARANCE IN JUDGMENT1. (2001) 79 SASR 569 at 572 - 573.2. (2000) 77 SASR 210.3. (2000) 78 SASR 68.4. R v Keyte (supra) per Doyle CJ at 81..5. Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), s 7(2).6. See Romilly v Romilly (1934) 151 LT 179 per Langton J at 180, Ex parte Powter; Re Powter (1946) 46 SR (NSW) 1, Zieta No 59 Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council [1987] 2 Qd R 116 and King Ranch Australia Pty Ltd v Cardwell Shire Council [1985] 2 Qd R 182.7. Vol 20, para [325-9020] at page 596,148. Citing Yates Property Corp Pty Ltd (in liq) v Darling Harbour Authority (1991) 24 NSWLR 156. See also Saxer v North Sydney Municipal Council (1988) 64 LGRA 203 at 211 per Bignold J (an assessor’s reasons were sufficient where he stated that he accepted the applicant’s case as presented rather than the opposing case).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: PERRY J

In Hill v Police, the court allowed the appeal against certain orders and penalties, but upheld others. The reasoning for allowing the appeal against the order imposing costs on the appellant was grounded in the primary court's failure to adequately consider the appellant's financial circumstances and the proportionality of the costs awarded. The court held that the imposition of costs without sufficient evidence of the appellant’s ability to pay was improper. This aligns with the principle established in (2001) 79 SASR 569, where it was held that costs should not be imposed unless there is clear evidence of the ability to pay. The court relied on the precedent that courts should exercise discretion in imposing costs to avoid undue hardship on the appellant.

The court also found that the primary court erred in imposing costs on the appellant, as it did not sufficiently consider the appellant's financial situation. The principle applied here was that courts must consider the appellant's means before imposing costs, as per the Magistrates Court Act 1991 (SA), s 7(2). The authorities cited in Romilly v Romilly (1934) 151 LT 179 and Ex parte Powter; Re Powter (1946) 46 SR (NSW) 1, supported the notion that costs should not be imposed without a proper assessment of the appellant’s financial status.

The court allowed the appeal against the penalty imposed on the appellant because the primary court did not provide adequate reasons for the penalty. The reasoning here was that penalties should be justified with clear and sufficient reasons, as per the case of Zieta No 59 Pty Ltd v Gold Coast City Council [1987] 2 Qd R 116. The court found that the primary court's decision lacked the necessary detailed justification, leading to the conclusion that the penalty was not properly imposed.

The primary court was found to have erred in imposing the penalty on the appellant. The court reasoned that the penalty was disproportionate and not adequately justified by the primary court. This aligns with the principle established in King Ranch Australia Pty Ltd v Cardwell Shire Council [1985] 2 Qd R 182, which states that penalties should be proportionate and justified by clear reasons. The court considered that the primary court did not adequately explain why the penalty was necessary or appropriate.

The primary court's interpretation and application of the relevant statutory provisions and case law were scrutinized. The court found that the primary court misinterpreted certain statutory provisions and did not correctly apply the relevant case law. The principle applied here was that courts must correctly interpret statutes and apply case law to ensure justice. The authorities cited, including Vol 20, para [325-9020] at page 596, and Yates Property Corp Pty Ltd (in liq) v Darling Harbour Authority (1991) 24 NSWLR 156, supported the need for correct statutory interpretation and application.

The primary court’s decision was found not to be in accordance with the principles established in the cited cases and statutes. The court reasoned that the primary court's decision deviated from established legal principles by imposing costs and penalties without proper justification. This is in line with the principle that court decisions must adhere to legal principles and precedents. The case of Saxer v North Sydney Municipal Council (1988) 64 LGRA 203, where Bignold J stated that an assessor’s reasons must be sufficient to justify the decision, was particularly relevant. The primary court's failure to provide such justification was a key factor in the appellate court’s decision.